arXiv++ Combinatorics

Let $I$ and $O$ denote two sets of vertices, where $I\cap O =\emptyset$, $|I| = n$, $|O| = r$, and $B_u(n,r)$ denote the set of unlabeled graphs whose edges connect vertices in $I$ and $O$. Recently, it was established in\cite{atmacaoruc2018} that the following two-sided equality holds, \begin{equation} \label{mainResult} \displaystyle \frac{\binom{r+2^{n}-1}{r}}{n!}\, \le\, |B_u(n,r)|\, \le\, 2\frac{\binom{r+2^{n}-1}{r}}{n!},\, n < r.\nonumber \end{equation} and exact formulas were provided in~\cite{atmaca2017size} for $|B_u(2,r)|$ and $|B_u(3,r)|.$ In this paper, these results are extended to various families of labeled bipartite graphs.

This paper solves a problem that was stated by M. A. Harrison in 1973~\cite{harrison1973number}. This problem, that has remained open since then is concerned with counting equivalence classes of $n\times r$ binary matrices under row and column permutations. Let $I$ and $O$ denote two sets of vertices, where $I\cap O =Φ$, $|I| = n$, $|O| = r$, and $B_u(n,r)$ denote the set of unlabeled graphs whose edges connect vertices in $I$ and $O$. Harrison established that the number of equivalence classes of $n\times r$ binary matrices is equal to the number of unlabeled graphs in $B_u(n,r).$ He also computed the number of such matrices (hence such graphs) for small values of $n$ and $r$ without providing an asymptotic formula $|B_u(n,r)|.$ Here, such an asymptotic formula is provided by proving the following two-sided equality using Polya's Counting Theorem.