arXiv++ Combinatorics

Since the breakthrough superpolynomial multilinear formula lower bounds of Raz (Theory of Computing 2006), proving such lower bounds against multilinear algebraic branching programs (mABPs) has been a longstanding open problem in algebraic complexity theory. All known multilinear lower bounds rely on the min-partition rank method, and the best bounds against mABPs have remained quadratic (Alon, Kumar, and Volk, Combinatorica 2020). We show that the min-partition rank method cannot prove superpolynomial mABP lower bounds: there exists a full-rank multilinear polynomial computable by a polynomial-size mABP. This is an unconditional barrier: new techniques are needed to separate $\mathsf{mVBP}$ from higher classes in the multilinear hierarchy. Our proof resolves an open problem of Fabris, Limaye, Srinivasan, and Yehudayoff (ECCC 2026), who showed that the power of this method is governed by the minimum size $N(n)$ of a combinatorial object called a $1$-balanced-chain set system, and proved $N(n) \le n^{O(\log n/\log\log n)}$. We prove $N(n) = n^{O(1)}$ by giving the chain-builder a binary choice at each step, biasing what was a symmetric random walk into one where the imbalance increases with probability at most $1/4$; a supermartingale argument combined with a multi-scale recursion yields the polynomial bound.

For a fixed "pattern" graph $G$, the $\textit{colored $G$-subgraph isomorphism problem}$ (denoted $\mathrm{SUB}(G)$) asks, given an $n$-vertex graph $H$ and a coloring $V(H) \to V(G)$, whether $H$ contains a properly colored copy of $G$. The complexity of this problem is tied to parameterized versions of $\mathit{P}$ ${=}?$ $\mathit{NP}$ and $\mathit{L}$ ${=}?$ $\mathit{NL}$, among other questions. An overarching goal is to understand the complexity of $\mathrm{SUB}(G)$, under different computational models, in terms of natural invariants of the pattern graph $G$. In this paper, we establish a close relationship between the $\textit{formula complexity}$ of $\mathrm{SUB}$ and an invariant known as $\textit{tree-depth}$ (denoted $\mathrm{td}(G)$). $\mathrm{SUB}(G)$ is known to be solvable by monotone $\mathit{AC^0}$ formulas of size $O(n^{\mathrm{td}(G)})$. Our main result is an $n^{\tildeΩ(\mathrm{td}(G)^{1/3})}$ lower bound for formulas that are monotone $\textit{or}$ have sub-logarithmic depth. This complements a lower bound of Li, Razborov and Rossman (SICOMP 2017) relating tree-width and $\mathit{AC^0}$ circuit size. As a corollary, it implies a stronger homomorphism preservation theorem for first-order logic on finite structures (Rossman, ITCS 2017). The technical core of this result is an $n^{Ω(k)}$ lower bound in the special case where $G$ is a complete binary tree of height $k$, which we establish using the $\textit{pathset framework}$ introduced in (Rossman, SICOMP 2018). (The lower bound for general patterns follows via a recent excluded-minor characterization of tree-depth (Czerwiński et al, arXiv:1904.13077).) Additional results of this paper extend the pathset framework and improve upon both, the best known upper and lower bounds on the average-case formula size of $\mathrm{SUB}(G)$ when $G$ is a path.

A simple generalization of the Hall's condition in bipartite graphs, the Normalized Matching Property (NMP) in a graph $G(X,Y,E)$ with vertex partition $(X,Y)$ states that for any subset $S\subseteq X$, we have $\frac{|N(S)|}{|Y|}\ge\frac{|S|}{|X|}$. In this paper, we show the following results about having the Normalized Matching Property in random and pseudorandom graphs. 1. We establish $p=\frac{\log n}{k}$ as a sharp threshold for having NMP in $\mathbb{G}(k,n,p)$, which is the graph with $|X|=k,|Y|=n$ (assuming $k\le n\leq \exp(o(k))$), and in which each pair $(x,y)\in X\times Y$ is an edge independently with probability $p$. This generalizes a classic result of Erdős-Rényi on the $\frac{\log n}{n}$ threshold for having a perfect matching in $\mathbb{G}(n,n,p)$. 2. We also show that a pseudorandom bipartite graph - upon deletion of a vanishingly small fraction of vertices - admits NMP, provided it is not too sparse. More precisely, a bipartite graph $G(X,Y)$, with $k=|X|\le |Y|=n$, is said to be Thomason pseudorandom (following A. Thomason (Discrete Math., 1989)) with parameters $(p,\varepsilon)$ if each $x\in X$ has degree at least $pn$ and each pair of distinct $x, x'\in X$ has at most $(1+\varepsilon)p^2n$ common neighbors. We show that for any large enough $(p,\varepsilon)$-Thomason pseudorandom graph $G(X,Y)$, there are "tiny" subsets $\mathrm{Del}_X\subset X, \ \mathrm{Del}_Y\subset Y$ such that the subgraph $G(X\setminus \mathrm{Del}_X,Y\setminus \mathrm{Del}_Y)$ has NMP, provided $p \gg\tfrac{1}{k}$. En route, we prove an "almost" vertex decomposition theorem: Every such Thomason pseudorandom graph admits - excluding a negligible portion of its vertex set - a partition of its vertex set into graphs that we call Euclidean trees. These are trees that have NMP, and which arise organically through the Euclidean GCD algorithm.