arXiv++ Combinatorics

The main purpose of this paper is to show the nonexistence of tight Euclidean 9-designs on 2 concentric spheres in $\mathbb R^n$ if $n\geq 3.$ This in turn implies the nonexistence of minimum cubature formulas of degree 9 (in the sense of Cools and Schmid) for any spherically symmetric integrals in $\mathbb R^n$ if $n\geq 3.$

We give a new example of Euclidean tight 6-design in $\mathbb R^{22}$.

In the previous paper, we studied the "Toy models for D. H. Lehmer's conjecture". Namely, we showed that the m-th Fourier coefficient of the weighted theta series of the $\mathbb{Z}^2$-lattice and the $A_{2}$-lattice does not vanish, when the shell of norm $m$ of those lattices is not the empty set. In other words, the spherical 4 (resp. 6)-design does not exist among the nonempty shells in the $\mathbb{Z}^2$-lattice (resp. $A_{2}$-lattice). This paper is the sequel to the previous paper. We take 2-dimensional lattices associated to the algebraic integers of imaginary quadratic fields whose class number is either 1 or 2, except for $\mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{-1})$ and $\mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{-3})$, then, show that the $m$-th Fourier coefficient of the weighted theta series of those lattices does not vanish, when the shell of norm $m$ of those lattices is not the empty set. Equivalently, we show that the corresponding spherical 2-design does not exist among the nonempty shells in those lattices.

In 1947, Lehmer conjectured that the Ramanujan's tau function $τ(m)$ never vanishes for all positive integers $m$, where $τ(m)$ is the $m$-th Fourier coefficient of the cusp form $Δ_{24}$ of weight 12. The theory of spherical $t$-design is closely related to Lehmer's conjecture because it is shown, by Venkov, de la Harpe, and Pache, that $τ(m)=0$ is equivalent to the fact that the shell of norm $2m$ of the $E_{8}$-lattice is a spherical 8-design. So, Lehmer's conjecture is reformulated in terms of spherical $t$-design. Lehmer's conjecture is difficult to prove, and still remains open. However, Bannai-Miezaki showed that none of the nonempty shells of the integer lattice $\ZZ^2$ in $\RR^2$ is a spherical 4-design, and that none of the nonempty shells of the hexagonal lattice $A_2$ is a spherical 6-design. Moreover, none of the nonempty shells of the integer lattices associated to the algebraic integers of imaginary quadratic fields whose class number is either 1 or 2, except for $\QQ(\sqrt{-1})$ and $\QQ(\sqrt{-3})$ is a spherical 2-design. In the proof, the theory of modular forms played an important role. Recently, Yudin found an elementary proof for the case of $\ZZ^{2}$-lattice which does not use the theory of modular forms but uses the recent results of Calcut. In this paper, we give the elementary (i.e., modular form free) proof and discuss the relation between Calcut's results and the theory of imaginary quadratic fields.

Let $L$ be any integral lattice in the 2-dimensional Euclidean space. Generalizing the earlier works of Hiroshi Maehara and others, we prove that for every integer $n>0$, there is a circle in the plane $\mathbb{R}^{2}$ that passes through exactly $n$ points of $L$.

The concept of spherical $t$-design, which is a finite subset of the unit sphere, was introduced by Delsarte-Goethals-Seidel (1977). The concept of Euclidean $t$-design, which is a two step generalization of spherical design in the sense that it is a finite weighted subset of Euclidean space, by Neumaier-Seidel (1988). We first review these two concepts, as well as the concept of tight $t$-design, i.e., the one whose cardinality reaches the natural lower bound. We are interested in $t$-designs (spherical or Euclidean) which are either tight or close to tight. As is well known by Delsarte-Goethals-Seidel (1977), in the study of spherical $t$-designs and in particular of those which are either tight or close to tight, association schemes play important roles. The main purpose of this paper is to show that in the study of Euclidean $t$-designs and in particular of those which are either tight or close to tight, coherent configurations play important roles. Here, coherent configuration is a purely combinatorial concept defined by D. G. Higman, and is obtained by axiomatizing the properties of general, not necessarily transitive, permutation groups, in the same way as association scheme was obtained by axiomatizing the properties of transitive permutation groups. The main purpose of this paper is to prove that Euclidean $t$-designs satisfying certain conditions give the structure of coherent configurations. Moreover we study the classification problems of Euclidean 4-designs on two concentric spheres with certain additional conditions.

In 1947, Lehmer conjectured that the Ramanujan $τ$-function $τ(m)$ never vanishes for all positive integers $m$, where the $τ(m)$ are the Fourier coefficients of the cusp form $Δ_{24}$ of weight 12. Lehmer verified the conjecture in 1947 for $m<214928639999$. In 1973, Serre verified up to $m<10^{15}$, and in 1999, Jordan and Kelly for $m<22689242781695999$. The theory of spherical $t$-design, and in particular those which are the shells of Euclidean lattices, is closely related to the theory of modular forms, as first shown by Venkov in 1984. In particular, Ramanujan's $τ$-function gives the coefficients of a weighted theta series of the $E_{8}$-lattice. It is shown, by Venkov, de la Harpe, and Pache, that $τ(m)=0$ is equivalent to the fact that the shell of norm $2m$ of the $E_{8}$-lattice is an 8-design. So, Lehmer's conjecture is reformulated in terms of spherical $t$-design. Lehmer's conjecture is difficult to prove, and still remains open. In this paper, we consider toy models of Lehmer's conjecture. Namely, we show that the $m$-th Fourier coefficient of the weighted theta series of the $\mathbb{Z}^2$-lattice and the $A_{2}$-lattice does not vanish, when the shell of norm $m$ of those lattices is not the empty set. In other words, the spherical 5 (resp. 7)-design does not exist among the shells in the $\mathbb{Z}^2$-lattice (resp. $A_{2}$-lattice).

We prove that if X is a spherical t-design and s-distance set with $t\geq 2s-3$, then X has the structure of Q-polynomial association scheme of class s. Also, we describe the parameters of the association scheme.

H. Cohn et. al. proposed an association scheme of 64 points in R^{14} which is conjectured to be a universally optimal code. We show that this scheme has a generalization in terms of Kerdock codes, as well as in terms of maximal real mutually unbiased bases. These schemes also related to extremal line-sets in Euclidean spaces and Barnes-Wall lattices. D. de Caen and E. R. van Dam constructed two infinite series of formally dual 3-class association schemes. We explain this formal duality by constructing two dual abelian schemes related to quaternary linear Kerdock and Preparata codes.