arXiv++ Combinatorics

Given a multigraph $G$, the all-terminal reliability $R(G,p)$ is the probability that $G$ remains connected under percolation with parameter $p$. Fixing the number of vertices $n$ and edges $m$, we investigate which graphs maximize $R(G,p)$ -- such graphs are called optimal -- paying particular attention to uniqueness and to whether the answer depends upon $p$. We generalize the concept of a distillation and build a framework with which we identify all optimal graphs for which $m-n\in\{1,2,3\}$. These graphs are uniformly optimal in $p$. Most have been previously identified, but with serious problems, especially when $m-n=3$. We obtain partial results for $m-n\in\{4,5\}$. For $m-n=3$, the optimal graphs were incorrectly identified by Wang in 1994, in the infinite number of cases where $m\equiv5\pmod{9}$ and $m\geq14$. This erroneous result concerns subdivisions of $K_{3,3}$ and has been cited extensively, without any mistake being detected. While the optimal graphs were correctly described for other $m$, the proof is fundamentally flawed. Our proof of the rectified statement is self-contained. For $m-n=4$, the optimal graphs were recently shown to depend upon $p$ for infinitely many $m$. We find a new such set of $m$-values, which gives a different perspective on why this phenomenon occurs and leads us to conjecture that uniformly optimal graphs exist only for finitely many $m$. However, for $m-n=5$, we conjecture that there are again infinitely many uniformly optimal graphs.

Consider a monotone Boolean function $f:\{0,1\}^n\to\{0,1\}$ and the canonical monotone coupling $\{η_p:p\in[0,1]\}$ of an element in $\{0,1\}^n$ chosen according to product measure with intensity $p\in[0,1]$. The random point $p\in[0,1]$ where $f(η_p)$ flips from $0$ to $1$ is often concentrated near a particular point, thus exhibiting a threshold phenomenon. For a sequence of such Boolean functions, we peer closely into this threshold window and consider, for large $n$, the limiting distribution (properly normalized to be nondegenerate) of this random point where the Boolean function switches from being 0 to 1. We determine this distribution for a number of the Boolean functions which are typically studied and pay particular attention to the functions corresponding to iterated majority and percolation crossings. It turns out that these limiting distributions have quite varying behavior. In fact, we show that any nondegenerate probability measure on $\mathbb{R}$ arises in this way for some sequence of Boolean functions.

The noise sensitivity of a Boolean function describes its likelihood to flip under small perturbations of its input. Introduced in the seminal work of Benjamini, Kalai and Schramm [Inst. Hautes Études Sci. Publ. Math. 90 (1999) 5-43], it was there shown to be governed by the first level of Fourier coefficients in the central case of monotone functions at a constant critical probability $p_c$. Here we study noise sensitivity and a natural stronger version of it, addressing the effect of noise given a specific witness in the original input. Our main context is the Erdős-Rényi random graph, where already the property of containing a given graph is sufficiently rich to separate these notions. In particular, our analysis implies (strong) noise sensitivity in settings where the BKS criterion involving the first Fourier level does not apply, for example, when $p_c\to0$ polynomially fast in the number of variables.