arXiv++ Combinatorics

In 2006 Bonato and Tardif posed the Tree Alternative Conjecture (TAC): the equivalence class of a tree under the embeddability relation is, up to isomorphism, either trivial or infinite. In 2022 LaFlamme, et al. provided a rigorous exposition of a conter-example to TAC developed by Tetano in his 2008 PhD thesis. Also in 2022, the present author provided a positive answer to TAC for the topological minor relation. Along with embeddability and the topological minor, the graph minor relation completes the triad of the most widely studied graph relations. In this paper we provide a positive answer to TAC for the the graph minor.

We prove the Tree Alternative Conjecture for the topological minor relation: letting $[T]$ denote the equivalence class of $T$ under the topological minor relation we show that: $|[T]| = 1$ or $|[T]|\geq \aleph_0$ and $\forall r\in V(T)$, $|[(T,r)]| = 1$ or $|[(T,r)]|\geq \aleph_0$. In particular, by means of curtailing trees, we show that for any tree $T$ with at least one not eventually bare ray: $|[T]| \geq 2^{\aleph_0}$.

A well-known theorem of Nash-Williams shows that the collection of locally finite trees under the topological minor relation results in a BQO. Set theoretically, two very natural questions arise: (1) What is the number $λ$ of topological types of locally finite trees? (2) What are the possible sizes of an equivalence class of locally finite trees? For (1), clearly, $ω\leq λ\leq \mathfrak{c}$ and Matthiesen refined it to $ω_1 \leq λ\leq \mathfrak{c}$. Thus, this question becomes non-trivial when the Continuum Hypothesis is not assumed. In this paper we address both questions by showing that - entirely within ZFC - for a large collection of locally finite trees that includes those with countably many rays: the answer for (1) is $λ= ω_1$, and that for (2) the size of an equivalence class can only be either $1$ or $\mathfrak{c}$.

Motivated by an error-correcting generalization of Bachet's weights problem, we define and classify relaxed complete partitions. We show that these partitions enjoy a succinct description in terms of lattice points in polyhedra, with adjustments in the error being commensurate with translations in the defining hyperplanes. Our main result is that the enumeration of the minimal such partitions (those with fewest possible parts) is achieved via Brion's formula. This generalizes work of Park on classifying complete partitions and that of Rødseth on enumerating minimal complete partitions.