arXiv++ Combinatorics

A graph $G$ is minimal Ramsey for a graph $H$ if every $2$-colouring of the edges of $G$ contains a monochromatic copy of $H$, but for every proper subgraph of $G$, there is a $2$-colouring that does not contain such a monochromatic copy. Characterizing minimal Ramsey graphs is a widely studied problem. Recent research in this field includes the characterization of the size of the set $\mathcal{M}_2(H)$ of all minimal Ramsey graphs for $H$, or finding the smallest minimum degree among all graphs in $\mathcal{M}_2(H)$. In this paper, we introduce a game theoretic analogue of the above concept by considering the Maker-Breaker $H$-game on a graph $G$. In this game, two players, Maker and Breaker, alternately claim unclaimed edges of $G$, and Maker wins if in the end of the game the graph spanned by Maker's edges contains a copy of $H$. Otherwise, Breaker wins the game. We call a graph $G$ winnable for $H$ if Maker has a winning strategy for the Maker-Breaker $H$-game on $G$, and we call it minimal winnable if additionally Breaker wins the $H$-game on every proper subgraph of $G$. Along the lines of minimal-Ramsey theory, we characterize all graphs $H$ for which there exist infinitely many minimal winnable graphs, and we prove tight bounds for the smallest minimum degree among all these minimal winnable graphs. Amongst others, we obtain precise results for trees, cycles, cliques, and complete bipartite graphs. In general, we find many similarities between the Ramsey setting and the Maker-Breaker setting, but we also show substantial differences.

We study biased Maker-Breaker games on a graph system $\{G_1,\ldots,G_s\}$, in which Maker's goal is to claim certain rainbow structures, i.e., specified subgraphs consisting of at most one edge from each graph $G_i$. We consider the rainbow-connectivity game, in which Maker wants to claim a rainbow path between every pair of vertices. We analyse this game in detail, essentially determining the threshold bias when played on the system of complete graphs, and observing that whether the random graph intuition holds depends on the size of $s$. The key ingredient of our result is the analysis of a Maker's strategy that combines several randomized strategies with an appropriately designed balancing game. As a byproduct, we find the order of the threshold bias for the Maker-Breaker diameter game, and disprove a conjecture by Balogh, Martin and Pluhár. Another natural and general way to analyse Maker-Breaker games that are played on a colored board is to require Maker to occupy a rainbow winning set of a given positional game. In the case of the connectivity game, Maker's goal is to claim a rainbow spanning tree. For this game played on the system of complete graphs, we establish matching upper and lower bounds on the threshold bias, up to constant factors.

We initiate the study of a new variant of the Maker-Breaker positional game, which we call multistage game. Given a hypergraph $\mathcal{H}=(\mathcal{X},\mathcal{F})$ and a bias $b \ge 1$, the $(1:b)$ multistage Maker-Breaker game on $\mathcal{H}$ is played in several stages as follows. Each stage is played as a usual $(1:b)$ Maker-Breaker game, until all the elements of the board get claimed by one of the players, with the first stage being played on $\mathcal{H}$. In every subsequent stage, the game is played on the board reduced to the elements that Maker claimed in the previous stage, and with the winning sets reduced to those fully contained in the new board. The game proceeds until no winning sets remain, and the goal of Maker is to prolong the duration of the game for as many stages as possible. In this paper we estimate the maximum duration of the $(1:b)$ multistage Maker-Breaker game, for biases $b$ subpolynomial in $n$, for some standard graph games played on the edge set of $K_n$: the connectivity game, the Hamilton cycle game, the non-$k$-colorability game, the pancyclicity game and the $H$-game. While the first three games exhibit a probabilistic intuition, it turns out that the last two games fail to do so.