arXiv++ Combinatorics

For a finite subset $X$ of the $d$-dimensional unit sphere, the harmonic strength $T(X)$ of $X$ is the set of $\ell\in \mathbb{N}$ such that $\sum_{x\in X} P(x)=0$ for all harmonic polynomials $P$ of homogeneous degree $\ell$. We will study three exceptional finite groups of unit quaternions, called the binary tetrahedral group $2T$ of order 24, the octahedral group $2O$ of order 48, and the icosahedral group $2I$ of order 120, which can be viewed as a subset of the 3-dimensional unit sphere. For these three groups, we determine the harmonic strength and show the minimality and the uniqueness as spherical designs. In particular, the group $2O$ is unique as a minimal subset $X$ of the 3-dimensional unit sphere with $T(X)=\{22,14,10,6,4,2 \}\cup \mathbb{O}^+$, where $\mathbb{O}^+$ denotes the set of all positive odd integers. This result provides the first characterization of $2O$ from the spherical design viewpoint. For $G\in \{2T,2O,2I\}$, we consider the lattice $\mathcal{O}_{G}$ generated by $G$ over $R_G$ on which the group $G$ acts on by multiplication, where $R_{2T}=\mathbb{Z},\ R_{2O}=\mathbb{Z}[\sqrt{2}],\ R_{2I}=\mathbb{Z}[(1+\sqrt{5})/2]$ are the ring of integers. We introduce the spherical theta function $θ_{G,P}(z)$ attached to the lattice $\mathcal{O}_G$ and a harmonic polynomial $P$ of degree $\ell$ and prove that they are modular forms. By applying our results on the characterization of $G$ as a spherical design, we determine the cases in which the $\mathbb{C}$-vector space spanned by all $θ_{G,P}(z)$ of harmonic polynomials $P$ of homogeneous degree $\ell$ has dimension zero--without relying on the theory of modular forms.

This is the write-up of a talk given in RIMS conference ``Analytic and arithmetic aspects of automorphic representations", where I outlined two kinds of different results related to the D4 lattice, obtained in a joint work with Hirao and Nozaki. In general, from the design theoretical viewpoints, we are interested in determining the harmonic strength of finite subsets on the unit sphere. When considering the shells of a lattice, this problem shifts to the non-vanishing problem of the Fourier coefficients of elliptic cusp forms. Various instances, mostly from root lattices, are listed in this note.

In this paper, we study shells of the $D_4$ lattice with a {slight generalization} of spherical $t$-designs due to Delsarte-Goethals-Seidel, namely, the spherical design of harmonic index $T$ (spherical $T$-design for short) introduced by Delsarte-Seidel. We first observe that{, for any positive integer $m$,} the $2m$-shell of $D_4$ is an antipodal spherical $\{10,4,2\}$-design on the three dimensional sphere. We then prove that the $2$-shell, which is the $D_4$ root system, is a tight $\{10,4,2\}$-design, using the linear programming method. The uniqueness of the $D_4$ root system as an antipodal spherical $\{10,4,2\}$-design with 24 points is shown. We give two applications of the uniqueness: a decomposition of the shells of the $D_4$ lattice in terms of orthogonal transformations of the $D_4$ root system, and the uniqueness of the $D_4$ lattice as an even integral lattice of level 2 in the four dimensional Euclidean space. We also reveal a connection between the harmonic strength of the shells of the $D_4$ lattice and non-vanishing of the Fourier coefficients of a certain newform of level 2. Motivated by this, congruence relations for the Fourier coefficients are discussed.