arXiv++ Combinatorics

In a previous submission, we established a fundamental relation between tone networks and configurations. It was shown that the Eulerian tonnetz can be represented by a $\{12_3\}$ of Daublebsky von Sterneck type D222. We also constructed a tonnetz for Tristan-genus chords (dominant sevenths and half-diminished sevenths) and we showed that this tonnetz can be represented by a $\{12_3\}$ of type D228. In both of these constructions the associated Levi graphs play an important role. Here we look at the tonnetze associated with some other musical systems, thereby offering several concrete examples of an abstract view of music as combinatorial geometry. First, we look at the tonal harmonies typical of the classical period. In the case of diatonic triads, we show the existence of a bipartite graph of type $\{7_3\}$ and girth four that represents the well-known relations between the seven diatonic degrees and their pitch classes. In the case of diatonic seventh chords, we obtain a Fano configuration $\{7_3\}$ which gives a complete characterization of the voice-leading relations that hold between such chords. Next, we construct a tonnetz for pentatonic music based on the Desargues configuration $\{10_3\}$ and we construct a tonnetz for the 12-tone system based on the Cremona-Richmond configuration $\{15_3\}$. Both can be used as a resource for musical compositions. Finally, we show that the relation between the chromatic pitch class set and the major triad set is also represented by a D222. The minor triads are in one-to-one correspondence with the members of a certain class of hexacycles in the Levi graph of this configuration. In this way, the characteristic duality between major and minor triads in the tonnetz can be broken.

The Eulerian tonnetz, which associates three minor chords to each major chord and three major chords to each minor chord, can be represented by a bipartite graph with twelve white vertices denoting major chords and twelve black vertices denoting minor chords. This so-called Levi graph determines a configuration of twelve points and twelve lines in $\mathbb R^2$ with the property that three points lie on each line and three lines pass through each point. Interesting features of the tonnetz, such as the existence of the four hexatonic cycles and the three octatonic cycles, crucial for the understanding of nineteenth-century harmony and voice leading, can be read off directly as properties of this configuration $\{12_3\}$ and its Levi graph. Analogous tone networks together with their Levi graphs and configurations can be constructed for pentatonic music and twelve-tone music. These and other new tonnetze offer the promise of new methods of composition. If the constraints of the Eulerian tonnetz are relaxed so as to allow movements between major and minor triads with variations at exactly two tones, the resulting bipartite graph has two components, each generating a tessellation of the plane, of a type known to Kepler, based on hexagons, squares and dodecagons. When the same combinatorial idea is applied to tetrachords of the 'Tristan' genus (dominant sevenths and half-diminished sevenths) the cycles of the resulting bipartite graph are sufficiently ample in girth to ensure the existence of a second configuration $\{12_3\}$, distinct from the Eulerian tonnetz as an incidence geometry, which can be used for a new approach to the analysis of the rich tetradic harmonies of the nineteenth century common practice.