arXiv++ Combinatorics

A simplicial complex is said to be {\em critical} (or {\em forbidden}) for the 3-sphere $S^3$ if it cannot be embedded in $S^3$, but becomes embeddable upon removing the open star of any simplex in its second barycentric subdivision. We show that if a regular multibranched surface cannot be embedded in $S^3$, then it contains a critical complex consisting of a multibranched surface and, possibly, a graph. We classify all critical complexes for $S^3$ that are contained in the $K_5 \times S^1$ and $K_{3,3} \times S^1$ families. Additionally, we classify all critical complexes for $S^3$ that decompose as $(G \times S^1) \cup H$, where $G$ and $H$ are graphs whose intersection $G \cap H$ consists solely of vertices of $H$. Nevertheless, some complexes cannot be embedded in $S^3$ and yet do not contain any critical subcomplex. Motivated by such examples, we define an equivalence relation on the set of simplicial complexes $\mathcal{C}$, leading to a partially ordered set $(\mathcal{C}/\mathord\sim; \subseteqq)$, and refine the definition of critical. According to the refined definition of criticality, we prove that if a 2-dimensional complex $X$ cannot be embedded in $S^3$, then there exists $[X']\subseteqq [X]$ such that $[X']$ is critical for $[S^3]$.

In this paper, we give a lower bound for the maximum and minimum genus of a multibranched surface by the first Betti number and the minimum and maximum genus of the boundary of the neighborhood of it, respectively. As its application, we show that the maximum and minimum genus of $G\times S^1$ is equal to twice of the maximum and minimum genus of $G$ for a graph $G$, respectively. This provides an interplay between graph theory and 3-manifold theory.