arXiv++ Combinatorics

In this paper, we study the so-called log-convergence of graphs defined by Balázs Szegedy (arXiv:1504.00858). We answer his Question 4 affirmatively: the sequence of incidence graphs of projective planes over finite fields log-converges, and the limit coincides with that of a particular random graph model.

We prove measurable analogues of Whitney's classical theorems on weak isomorphisms of finite graphs. In the setting of locally finite graphings, we introduce a notion of weak isomorphism as an edge-measure-preserving Borel bijection that preserves cycles and hyperfinite subgraphs, modulo null sets. We first show a rigidity theorem, proving that for weakly 3-connected infinitely-ended graphings, every weak isomorphism is induced by an isomorphism of graphings. To our knowledge, this gives the first general sufficient condition in measurable combinatorics for the existence of an isomorphism between two given graphings. Next, we give a full measurable version of Whitney's theorem, showing that every weak isomorphism between graphings can be implemented by countably many measurable Whitney operations, which we introduce in this setting. The proofs require new measurable-combinatorial tools, including a careful analysis of infinitely-ended subforests. This work further develops the limit theory of matroids recently initiated by Lovász.

To illustrate that the notion of convergence of submodular function sequences fits reasonably into the limit theory of graphs, we describe several classes of matroids and other submodular setfunctions for which convergence of appropriate sequences can be proved. Some of the proofs are surprisingly nontrivial.

For a graph $G$ let $\varepsilon(G)$ denote the number of Eulerian orientations, and $v(G)$ denote the number of vertices of $G$. We show that if $(G_n)_n$ is a sequence of Eulerian graphs that are convergent in Benjamini--Schramm sense, then $\lim\limits_{n\to \infty}\frac{1}{v(G_n)}\ln \varepsilon(G_n)$ is convergent.

We introduce the concept of quotient-convergence for sequences of submodular set functions, providing, among others, a new framework for the study of convergence of matroids through their rank functions. Extending the limit theory of bounded degree graphs, which analyzes graph sequences via neighborhood sampling, we address the challenge posed by the absence of a neighborhood concept in matroids. We show that any bounded set function can be approximated by a sequence of finite set functions that quotient-converges to it. In addition, we explicitly construct such sequences for increasing, submodular, and upper continuous set functions, and prove the completeness of the space under quotient-convergence.

A recent line of research has concentrated on exploring the links between analytic and combinatorial theories of submodularity, uncovering several key connections between them. In this context, Lovász initiated the study of matroids from an analytic point of view and introduced the cycle matroid of a graphing. Motivated by the limit theory of graphs, the authors introduced a form of right-convergence, called quotient-convergence, for a sequence of submodular setfunctions, leading to a notion of convergence for matroids through their rank functions. In this paper, we study the connection between local-global convergence of graphs and quotient-convergence of their cycle matroids. We characterize the exposed points of associated convex sets, forming an analytic counterpart of matroid independence- and base-polytopes. Finally, we consider dual planar graphings and show that the cycle matroid of one is the cocycle matroid of its dual if and only if the underlying graphings are hyperfinite.

For a graph $G=(V,E)$ with $v(G)$ vertices the partition function of the random cluster model is defined by $$Z_G(q,w)=\sum_{A\subseteq E(G)}q^{k(A)}w^{|A|},$$ where $k(A)$ denotes the number of connected components of the graph $(V,A)$. Furthermore, let $g(G)$ denote the girth of the graph $G$, that is, the length of the shortest cycle. In this paper we show that if $(G_n)_n$ is a sequence of $d$-regular graphs such that the girth $g(G_n)\to \infty$, then the limit $$\lim_{n\to \infty} \frac{1}{v(G_n)}\ln Z_{G_n}(q,w)=\ln Φ_{d,q,w}$$ exists if $q\geq 2$ and $w\geq 0$. The quantity $Φ_{d,q,w}$ can be computed as follows. Let $$Φ_{d,q,w}(t):=\left(\sqrt{1+\frac{w}{q}}\cos(t)+\sqrt{\frac{(q-1)w}{q}}\sin(t)\right)^{d}+(q-1)\left(\sqrt{1+\frac{w}{q}}\cos(t)-\sqrt{\frac{w}{q(q-1)}}\sin(t)\right)^{d},$$ then $$Φ_{d,q,w}:=\max_{t\in [-π,π]}Φ_{d,q,w}(t),$$ The same conclusion holds true for a sequence of random $d$-regular graphs with probability one. Our result extends the work of Dembo, Montanari, Sly and Sun for the Potts model (integer $q$), and we prove a conjecture of Helmuth, Jenssen and Perkins about the phase transition of the random cluster model with fixed $q$.

Let $G$ be the Cartesian product of a regular tree $T$ and a finite connected transitive graph $H$. It is shown in arXiv:2006.06387 that the Free Uniform Spanning Forest ($\mathsf{FSF}$) of this graph may not be connected, but the dependence of this connectedness on $H$ remains somewhat mysterious. We study the case when a positive weight $w$ is put on the edges of the $H$-copies in $G$, and conjecture that the connectedness of the $\mathsf{FSF}$ exhibits a phase transition. For large enough $w$ we show that the $\mathsf{FSF}$ is connected, while for a large family of $H$ and $T$, the $\mathsf{FSF}$ is disconnected when $w$ is small (relying on arXiv:2006.06387). Finally, we prove that when $H$ is the graph of one edge, then for any $w$, the $\mathsf{FSF}$ is a single tree, and we give an explicit formula for the distribution of the distance between two points within the tree.

For a graph $G$ on $v(G)$ vertices let $m_k(G)$ denote the number of matchings of size $k$, and consider the partition function $M_{G}(λ)=\sum_{k=0}^nm_k(G)λ^k$. In this paper we show that if $G$ is a $d$--regular graph and $0<λ<(4d)^{-2}$, then $$\frac{1}{v(G)}\ln M_G(λ)>\frac{1}{v(K_{d+1})}\ln M_{K_{d+1}}(λ).$$ The same inequality holds true if $d=3$ and $λ<0.3575$. More precise conjectures are also given.

Let $F(G)$ be the number of forests of a graph $G$. Similarly let $C(G)$ be the number of connected spanning subgraphs of a connected graph $G$. We bound $F(G)$ and $C(G)$ for regular graphs and for graphs with fixed average degree. Among many other things we study $f_d=\sup_{G\in \mathcal{G}_d}F(G)^{1/v(G)}$, where $\mathcal{G}_d$ is the family of $d$--regular graphs, and $v(G)$ denotes the number of vertices of a graph $G$. We show that $f_3=2^{3/2}$, and if $(G_n)_n$ is a sequence of $3$--regular graphs with length of the shortest cycle tending to infinity, then $\lim_{n\to \infty}F(G_n)^{1/v(G_n)}=2^{3/2}$. We also improve on the previous best bounds on $f_d$ for $4\leq d\leq 9$.

The goal of this short paper to advertise the method of gauge transformations (aka holographic reduction, reparametrization) that is well-known in statistical physics and computer science, but less known in combinatorics. As an application of it we give a new proof of a theorem of A. Schrijver asserting that the number of Eulerian orientations of a $d$--regular graph on $n$ vertices with even $d$ is at least $\left(\frac{\binom{d}{d/2}}{2^{d/2}}\right)^n$. We also show that a $d$--regular graph with even $d$ has always at least as many Eulerian orientations as $(d/2)$--regular subgraphs.