arXiv++ Combinatorics

Beiglboeck, Bergelson and Fish proved that if subsets A,B of a countable discrete amenable group G have positive Banach densities a and b respectively, then the product set AB is piecewise syndetic, i.e. there exists k such that the union of k-many left translates of AB is thick. Using nonstandard analysis we give a shorter alternative proof of this result that does not require G to be countable, and moreover yields the explicit bound that k is not greater than 1/ab. We also prove with similar methods that if $\{A_i\}$ are finitely many subsets of G having positive Banach densities $a_i$ and G is countable, then there exists a subset B whose Banach density is at least the product of the densities $a_i$ and such that the product $BB^{-1}$ is a subset of the intersection of the product sets $A_i A_i^{-1}$. In particular, the latter set is piecewise Bohr.

We present a short proof of Jin's theorem which is entirely elementary, in the sense that no use is made of nonstandard analysis, ergodic theory, measure theory, ultrafilters, or other advanced tools. The given proof provides the explicit bound 1/c where c=BD(A)*BD(B) to the number of shifts of A+B that are needed to cover a thick set.