arXiv++ Combinatorics

Homology generators in a relation offer individuals the ability to delay identification, by guiding the order via which the individuals reveal their attributes (see arXiv:1712.04130). This perspective applies as well to the identification of goal-attaining strategies in systems with errorful control, since the strategy complex of a fully controllable nondeterministic or stochastic graph is homotopic to a sphere. Specifically, such a graph contains for each state $v$ a maximal strategy $σ_v$ that converges to state $v$ from all other states in the graph and whose identity may be shrouded in the following sense: One may reveal certain actions of $σ_v$ in a particular order so that the full strategy becomes known only after at least $n-1$ of these actions have been revealed, with none of the actions revealed definitively inferable from those previously revealed. Here $n$ is the number of states in the graph. Moreover, the strategy contains at least $(n-1)!$ such informative action release sequences, each of length at least $n-1$. The earlier work described above sketched a proof that every maximal strategy in a pure nondeterministic or pure stochastic graph contains at least one informative action release sequence of length at least $n-1$. The primary purpose of the current report is to fill in the details of that sketch. To build intuition, the report first discusses several simpler examples. These examples suggest an underlying structure for hiding capabilities or bluffing capabilities, as well as for detecting such deceit.

Information has intrinsic geometric and topological structure, arising from relative relationships beyond absolute values or types. For instance, the fact that two people share a meal describes a relationship independent of the meal's ingredients. Multiple such relationships give rise to relations and their lattices. Lattices have topology. That topology informs the ways in which information may be observed, hidden, inferred, and dissembled. Dowker's Theorem establishes a homotopy equivalence between two simplicial complexes derived from a relation. From a privacy perspective, one complex describes individuals with common attributes, the other describes attributes shared by individuals. The homotopy equivalence produces a lattice. An element in the lattice consists of two components, one being a set of individuals, the other being a set of attributes. The lattice operations join and meet each amount to set intersection in one component and set union followed by a potentially privacy-puncturing inference in the other component. Privacy loss appears as simplicial collapse of free faces. Such collapse is local, but the property of fully preserving both attribute and association privacy requires a global condition: a particular kind of spherical hole. By looking at the link of an identifiable individual in its encompassing Dowker complex, one can characterize that individual's attribute privacy via another sphere condition. Even when long-term attribute privacy is impossible, homology provides lower bounds on how an individual may defer identification, when that individual has control over how to reveal attributes. Intuitively, the idea is to first reveal information that could otherwise be inferred. This last result highlights privacy as a dynamic process. Privacy loss may be cast as gradient flow. Harmonic flow for privacy preservation may be fertile ground for future research.