arXiv++ Combinatorics

Let $G$ be a group and $A\subseteq G$ a non-empty subset. A right $s$-factor associated with $A$ is a maximal subset $U\subseteq G$ such that the product $AU$ is direct. The lower and upper $s$-indices $|G:A|^-$ and $|G:A|^+$ are defined as the minimum and the supremum of the cardinalities of such maximal sets $U$. The subset $A$ is called stable if $|G:A|^- = |G:A|^+$, and $G$ is called stable if every subset of $G$ is stable. Using a graph-theoretic reformulation in terms of Cayley graphs, we prove that every infinite group is unstable. Equivalently, for every infinite group $G$ there exists a subset $A\subseteq G$ for which maximal subsets $U$ with direct product $AU$ do not all have the same cardinality. This gives a negative answer to Question 21.58 of the Kourovka Notebook.

We study a combinatorial property of subsets in finite groups that is analogous to the notion of independence in graphs. Given a group $G$ and a non-empty subset $A\subset G$, we define a (right) $s$-factor as a subset $B\subset G$ satisfying the following conditions: (i) Every element of $AB$ can be written uniquely as $ab$ with $a\in A$ and $b\in B$. (ii) $B$ is maximal (with respect to inclusion) with this property. For a finite group $G$, the upper and lower indices of $A$ are the sizes of the largest and smallest $s$-factors associated with $A$. A subset is called stable if its upper and lower indices coincide. A group is called stable if all its subsets are stable. We then explore the connection between $s$-factors in groups and maximal independent sets in graphs. Specifically, we show that $s$-factors in $G$ associated with $A$ correspond to maximal independent sets in a Cayley graph Cay($G$, $S$), where $S=A^{-1}A\setminus\{e\}$. Consequently, the upper and lower indices of $A$ are equal to the independence number and the independent domination number of the associated Cayley graph. The concepts of $s$-factors, subset indices in groups, stable subsets, and stable groups (under different names) were introduced by Hooshmand in 2020. Later, Hooshmand and Yousefian-Arani classified stable groups using computer calculations. Using the connection with graphs, we compute the upper and lower indices for various groups and their subsets. Furthermore, we prove a classification theorem describing all stable groups without relying on computer calculations.

A planar graph $G$ is called a pentagulation of an $n$-gon ($n\geq$ is an integer) if all faces of $G$ are pentagons, except one, which is an $n$-gon. A $3$-connected pentagulation $G$ of an $n$-gon is called minimal if it has the smallest number of pentagons among all such $3$-connected pentagulations. It is known that minimal pentagulations of the $3$-gon and $4$-gon contain 15 and 14 pentagons, respectively. We determined all minimal pentagulations of $n$-gons for all $n$ such that $3\leq n\leq 12$ using computer calculations. The calculations employed the plantri package, which generates all planar triangulations for a given number of vertices. We also present several open questions on this topic.