arXiv++ Combinatorics

For a graph $G$, denote by $a(G)$ the number of vertices in the largest induced forest in $G$. The Albertson-Berman conjecture, which had been open since 1979, states that $a(G) \geq \frac{n}{2}$ for every simple planar graph $G$ on $n$ vertices. Although the Albertson-Berman conjecture was recently resolved in the negative by constructing a counterexample with the help of AI, we independently found a counterexample to the Albertson-Berman conjecture without AI and present it in this article. Our counterexample is on $39$ vertices with $a(G)=19$. Finally, we indicate, without a full proof, a variant of this construction with a larger number of vertices, but with a slightly smaller ratio $\frac{a(G)}{n}=\frac{37}{76}$.

For a graph $G$ on $n$ vertices, denote by $a(G)$ the number of vertices in the largest induced forest in $G$. The Albertson-Berman conjecture, which is open since 1979, states that $a(G) \geq \frac{n}{2}$ for all simple planar graphs $G$. We show that the version of this problem for multigraphs (allowing parallel edges) is easily reduced to the problem about the independence number of simple planar graphs. Specifically, we prove that $a(M) \geq \frac{n}{4}$ for all planar multigraphs $M$ and that this lower bound is tight. Then, we study the case when the number of pairs of vertices with parallel edges, which we denote by $k$, is small. In particular, we prove the lower bound $a(M) \geq \frac{2}{5}n-\frac{k}{10}$ and that the Albertson-Berman conjecture for simple planar graphs, assuming that it holds, would imply the lower bound $a(M) \geq \frac{n-k}{2}$ for planar multigraphs, which would be better than the general lower bound when $k$ is small. Finally, we study the variant of the problem where the plane multigraphs are prohibited from having $2$-faces, which is the main non-trivial problem that we introduce in this article. For that variant without $2$-faces, we prove the lower bound $a(M) \geq \frac{3}{10}n+\frac{7}{30}$ and give a construction of an infinite sequence of multigraphs with $a(M)=\frac{3}{7}n+\frac{4}{7}$.

We define a set $P$ to be a branching $k$-path vertex cover of an undirected forest $F$ if all leaves and isolated vertices (vertices of degree at most $1$) of $F$ belong to $P$ and every path on $k$ vertices (of length $k-1$) contains either a branching vertex (a vertex of degree at least $3$) or a vertex belonging to $P$. We define the branching $k$-path vertex cover number of an undirected forest $F$, denoted by $ψ_b(F,k)$, to be the number of vertices in the smallest branching $k$-path vertex cover of $F$. These notions for a rooted directed forest are defined similarly, with natural adjustments. We prove the lower bound $ψ_b(F,k) \geq \frac{n+3k-1}{2k}$ for undirected forests, the lower bound $ψ_b(F,k) \geq \frac{n+k}{2k}$ for rooted directed forests, and that both of them are tight.