arXiv++ Combinatorics

In this paper, we study the three-term nested recurrence relation $B(n)=B(n-B(n-1))+B(n-B(n-2))+B(n-B(n-3))$ subject to initial conditions where the first $N$ terms are the integers $1$ through $N$. This recurrence is the three-term analog of Hofstadter's famous $Q$-recurrence $Q(n)=Q(n-Q(n-1))+Q(n-Q(n-2))$. Nested recurrences are highly sensitive to their initial conditions. Some initial conditions lead to finite sequences, others lead to predictable sequences, and yet others lead to sequences that appear to be chaotic and infinite. A corresponding study to this one was previously carried out on the $Q$-recurrence. As with that work, we consider two families of sequences, one where terms with nonpositive indices are undefined and a second where terms with nonpositive indices are defined to be zero. We find similar results here as with the $Q$-recurrence, as we can completely characterize the sequences for sufficiently large $N$. The results here are, in a sense, simpler, as our sequences are all finite for sufficiently large $N$.

Genome rearrangement is a common model for molecular evolution. In this paper, we consider the Pairwise Rearrangement problem, which takes as input two genomes and asks for the number of minimum-length sequences of permissible operations transforming the first genome into the second. In the Single Cut-and-Join model (Bergeron, Medvedev, & Stoye, J. Comput. Biol. 2010), Pairwise Rearrangement is $\#\textsf{P}$-complete (Bailey, et. al., COCOON 2023), which implies that exact sampling is intractable. In order to cope with this intractability, we investigate the parameterized complexity of this problem. We exhibit a fixed-parameter tractable algorithm with respect to the number of components in the adjacency graph that are not cycles of length $2$ or paths of length $1$. As a consequence, we obtain that Pairwise Rearrangement in the Single Cut-and-Join model is fixed-parameter tractable by distance. Our results suggest that the number of nontrivial components in the adjacency graph serves as the key obstacle for efficient sampling.

In this paper, we examine the computational complexity of enumeration in certain genome rearrangement models. We first show that the Pairwise Rearrangement problem in the Single Cut-and-Join model (Bergeron, Medvedev, & Stoye, J. Comput. Biol. 2010) is $\#\textsf{P}$-complete under polynomial-time Turing reductions. Next, we show that in the Single Cut or Join model (Feijao & Meidanis, IEEE ACM Trans. Comp. Biol. Bioinf. 2011), the problem of enumerating all medians ($\#$Median) is logspace-computable ($\textsf{FL}$), improving upon the previous polynomial-time ($\textsf{FP}$) bound of Miklós & Smith (RECOMB 2015).

Labeled infinite trees provide combinatorial interpretations for many integer sequences generated by nested recurrence relations. Typically, such sequences are monotone increasing. Several of these sequences also have straightforward descriptions in terms of how often each value in the sequence occurs. In this paper, we generalize the most classical examples to a larger family of sequences parametrized by linear recurrence relations. Each of our sequences can be constructed in three different ways: via a nested recurrence relation, from labeled infinite trees, or by using Zeckendorf-like strings of digits to describe its frequency sequence. We conclude the paper by discussing the asymptotic behaviors of our sequences.

Generalized Geography is a combinatorial game played on a directed graph. Players take turns moving a token from vertex to vertex, deleting a vertex after moving the token away from it. A player unable to move loses. It is well known that the computational complexity of determining which player should win from a given position of Generalized Geography is PSPACE-complete. We introduce several rule variants to Generalized Geography, and we explore the computational complexity of determining the winner of positions of many resulting games. Among our results is a proof that determining the winner of a game known in the literature as Undirected Partizan Geography is PSPACE-complete, even when restricted to being played on a bipartite graph.

Nested recurrence relations are highly sensitive to their initial conditions. The best-known nested recurrence, the Hofstadter $Q$-recurrence, generates sequences displaying a wide variety of behaviors. Most famous among these is the Hofstadter $Q$-sequence, which appears to be structured at a macro level and chaotic at a micro level. Other choices of initial conditions can lead to more predictable solutions, frequently interleavings of simple sequences. Previous work has focused on the form of a desired solution and on describing an initial condition that generates such a solution. In this paper, we flip this paradigm around. We illustrate how focusing on the form of an initial condition and describing the resulting sequences can yield strange families of new solutions to nested recurrences.

Hofstadter's Q-sequence remains an enigma fifty years after its introduction. Initially, the terms of the sequence increase monotonically by 0 or 1 at a time. But, Q(12)=8 while Q(11)=6, and monotonicity fails shortly thereafter. In this paper, we add a third term to Hofstadter's recurrence, giving the recurrence B(n)=B(n-B(n-1))+B(n-B(n-2))+B(n-B(n-3)). We show that this recurrence, along with a suitable initial condition that naturally generalizes Hofstadter's initial condition, generates a sequence whose terms all increase monotonically by 0 or 1 at a time. Furthermore, we give a complete description of the resulting frequency sequence, which allows the nth term of our sequence to be efficiently computed. We conclude by showing that our sequence cannot be easily generalized.

The Hofstadter Q-sequence, with its simple definition, has defied all attempts at analyzing its behavior. Defined by a simple nested recurrence and an initial condition, the sequence looks approximately linear, though with a lot of noise. But, nobody even knows whether the sequence is infinite. In the years since Hofstadter published his sequence, various people have found variants with predictable behavior. Oftentimes, the resulting sequence looks complicated but provably grows linearly. Other times, the sequences are eventually linear recurrent. Proofs describing the behaviors of both types of sequence are inductive. In the first case, the inductive hypotheses are fairly ad-hoc, but the proofs in the second case are highly automatable. This suggests that a search for more sequences like these may be fruitful. In this paper, we develop a step-by-step symbolic algorithm to search for these sequences. Using this algorithm, we determine that such sequences come in infinite families that are themselves plentiful. In fact,there are hundreds of easy to describe families based on the Hofstadter Q-recurrence alone.

In 1991, Solomon Golomb discovered a quasilinear solution to Hofstadter's Q-recurrence. In this paper, we construct eventual quasipolynomial solutions of all positive degrees to Hofstadter's recurrence.

In a recent paper, Frank Ruskey asked whether every linear recurrent sequence can occur in some solution of a meta-Fibonacci sequence. In this paper, we answer his question in the affirmative for recurrences with positive coefficients.

Subtraction games are a class of impartial combinatorial games whose positions correspond to nonnegative integers and whose moves correspond to subtracting one of a fixed set of numbers from the current position. Though they are easy to define, sub- traction games have proven difficult to analyze. In particular, few general results about their Sprague-Grundy values are known. In this paper, we construct an example of a subtraction game whose sequence of Sprague-Grundy values is ternary and aperiodic, and we develop a theory that might lead to a generalization of our construction.