arXiv++ Combinatorics

In 1967, Gerencsér and Gyárfás proved a result which is considered the starting point of graph-Ramsey theory: In every 2-coloring of $K_n$ there is a monochromatic path on $\lceil(2n+1)/3\rceil$ vertices, and this is best possible. There have since been hundreds of papers on graph-Ramsey theory with some of the most important results being motivated by a series of conjectures of Burr and Erd\H os regarding the Ramsey numbers of trees, graphs with bounded maximum degree, and graphs with bounded degeneracy. In 1993, Erd\H os and Galvin \cite{EG} began the investigation of a countably infinite analogue of the Gerencsér and Gyárfás result: What is the largest $d$ such that in every $2$-coloring of $K_\mathbb{N}$ there is a monochromatic infinite path with upper density at least $d$. Erd\H os and Galvin showed that $2/3\leq d\leq 8/9$, and after a series of recent improvements, it was finally shown that $d={(12+\sqrt{8})}/{17}$. This paper begins a systematic study of quantitative countably infinite graph-Ramsey theory, focusing on infinite analogues of the Burr-Erdős conjectures. We obtain some results which are analogous to what is known in finite case, and other (unexpected) results which have no analogue in the finite case.

For any countably infinite graph $G$, Ramsey's theorem guarantees an infinite monochromatic copy of $G$ in any $r$-coloring of the edges of the countably infinite complete graph $K_\mathbb{N}$. Taking this a step further, it is natural to wonder how "large" of a monochromatic copy of $G$ we can find with respect to some measure -- for instance, the density (or upper density) of the vertex set of $G$ in the positive integers. Unlike finite Ramsey theory, where this question has been studied extensively, the analogous problem for infinite graphs has been mostly overlooked. In one of the few results in the area, Erdős and Galvin proved that in every 2-coloring of $K_\mathbb{N}$, there exists a monochromatic path whose vertex set has upper density at least $2/3$, but it is not possible to do better than $8/9$. They also showed that for some sequence $ε_n\to 0$, there exists a monochromatic path $P$ such that for infinitely many $n$, the set $\{1,2,...,n\}$ contains the first $(\frac{1}{3+\sqrt{3}}-ε_n)n$ vertices of $P$, but it is not possible to do better than $2n/3$. We improve both results, in the former case achieving an upper density at least $3/4$ and in the latter case obtaining a tight bound of $2/3$. We also consider related problems for directed paths, trees (connected subgraphs), and a more general result which includes locally finite graphs for instance.