arXiv++ Combinatorics

The all-terminal reliability of a graph $G$ is the probability that $G$ remains connected when each edge fails independently with probability $p$. For fixed $n$ and $m$, the uniformly most reliable problem asks which graph with $n$ vertices and $m$ edges maximizes reliability for all $p \in [0,1]$. Although such graphs do not always exist, optimal graphs in the regime $p \to 0$ always do and are determined by the structure of their minimal cut sets. We establish a structural characterization of graphs that are most reliable near $p=0$. Our results partially resolve a conjecture of Bourel et al., showing that, under suitable conditions, regular graphs with maximal girth are optimal. Extending this analysis to graphs with fixed redundancy $r=m-(n-1)$ and sufficiently large $n$, we show that the most reliable graphs are obtained by subdividing the most reliable cubic graphs with $2(r-1)$ vertices. The general conjecture remains open. Unlike previous results, which resolved only small redundancy cases or very dense regimes, our approach yields a substantial extension of the known range. We determine the unique cubic candidates for uniformly most reliable graphs for all redundancy levels $m-n \le 19$, and prove the non-existence of uniformly most reliable graphs for several infinite families with fixed redundancy and asymptotically large $n$. These results significantly enlarge both the candidate class and the range of provable non-existence.

The need for reliable and low-cost infrastructure is crucial in today's world. However, achieving both at the same time is often challenging. Traditionally, infrastructure networks are designed with a radial topology lacking redundancy, which makes them vulnerable to disruptions. As a result, network topologies have evolved towards a ring topology with only one redundant edge and, from there, to more complex mesh networks. However, we prove that large rings are unreliable. Our research shows that a sparse mesh network with a small number of redundant edges that follow some design rules can significantly improve reliability while remaining cost-effective. Moreover, we have identified key areas where adding redundant edges can impact network reliability the most by using the SAIDI index, which measures the expected number of consumers disconnected from the source node. These findings offer network planners a valuable tool for quickly identifying and addressing reliability issues without the need for complex simulations. Properly planned sparse mesh networks can thus provide a reliable and a cost-effective solution to modern infrastructure challenges.