arXiv++ Combinatorics

For the circulant graph $C_n(1,2)$ with $n\ge10$ even, the $\F_2$ system requiring every quadrilateral to be unbalanced is consistent and its solutions form exactly four switching classes. We show that the class containing the signing which is $+1$ on step-$1$ edges and $(-1)^i$ on step-$2$ edges has spectrum $\{\pm2\sqrt{\cos^2θ_k+\cos^2 2θ_k}\}$ and spectral radius exactly $2\sqrt2$, well below the Kesten bound $2\sqrt3$; that the quadrilateral system is equivalent to alternating triangle fluxes, so that the four classes are coordinatized by $(τ_0,α)$ and the spectral radius depends only on the Hamilton-cycle holonomy $α$; and that the two twisted classes attain $ρ_-(n)=2\sqrt{\cos^2(π/n)+\cos^2(2π/n)}<2\sqrt2$. Exhaustive enumeration of all $2^{n+1}$ switching classes for $n\in\{8,10,12,14,16,18\}$ shows that $ρ_-(n)$ is the global minimum in every case, and we conjecture this for all even $n$; the lower bound is a flux-minimization statement in the sense of Lieb's flux-phase theorem. For odd $n$ the quadrilateral system is inconsistent.

For a signing $σ$ of a $d$-regular graph, the spectrum of $A_σ$ depends only on the signs of cycles. We study the affine $\mathbb F_2$ family of signings making every short even cycle unbalanced, and show that averaging over it converts the sign problem of the Bilu-Linial conjecture into a counting problem: a master identity expresses the family-averaged trace as a parity-weighted sum over wrap classes confined to the span $W$ of the constraint cycles, and the family-averaged Ihara $L$-function diagonalizes so that every prime whose parity escapes $W$ contributes the Ramanujan rate $\sqrt{d-1}$ automatically. Uniform averaging over all signings, by contrast, provably cannot certify a spectral radius below the Kesten profile. We prove matched upper and lower bounds for the confined walk counts, a doubling injection from below, and from above an ear-decomposition encoding in which the number of fresh runs of a non-backtracking walk equals the cycle rank of its support, combined with a window lemma for bicycle-free graphs and a rank bound via the Moore bound for irregular graphs. Consequences include $\varepsilon$-versions of the Bilu-Linial conjecture: every $d$-regular graph that is subcritical at scale $\log n$, and every $d$-regular graph bicycle-free at radius $C\log\log n/δ$, admits a signing in the parity family with $ρ(A_σ)\le2\sqrt{d-1}(1+Cδ\log(1/δ))(1+o(1))$. We further identify the necessary hypotheses exactly ($K_d$-trapping; tree-burst gadgets), give an exact certificate on the hypercube, and record a decisive obstruction to two-sided interlacing: $\mathbb E_σ\det(xI-A_σ^2)$ is not real-rooted, already for the quadrilateral, where it equals $(x^2-4x+2)^2+4$.