arXiv++ Combinatorics

Richmond and Richmond (American Mathematical Monthly 104 (1997), 713--719) proved the following theorem: If, in a metric space with at least five points, all triangles are degenerate, then the space is isometric to a subset of the real line. We prove that the hypothesis is unnecessarily strong: In a metric space on $n$ points, fewer than $7n^2/6$ suitably placed degenerate triangles suffice. However, fewer than $n(n-1)/2$ degenerate triangles, no matter how cleverly placed, never suffice.

Given a metric space $(X, ρ)$, we say $y$ is between $x$ and $z$ if $ρ(x,z) = ρ(x,y) + ρ(y,z)$. A metric space gives rise to a 3-uniform hypergraph that has as hyperedges those triples $\{ x,y,z \}$ where $y$ is between $x$ and $z$. Such hypergraphs are called metric and understanding them is key to the study of metric spaces. In this paper, we prove that hypergraphs where small subsets of vertices induce few edges are metric. Additionally, we adapt the notion of sparsity with respect to monotone increasing functions, classify hypergraphs that exhibit this version of sparsity and prove that they are metric.

In a metric space $M=(X,d)$, we say that $v$ is between $u$ and $w$ if $d(u,w)=d(u,v)+d(v,w)$. Taking all triples $\{u,v,w\}$ such that $v$ is between $u$ and $w$, one can associate a 3-uniform hypergraph with each finite metric space $M$. An effort to solve some basic open questions regarding finite metric spaces has motivated an endeavor to better understand these associated hypergraphs. In answer to a question posed in arXiv:1112.0376, we present an infinite family of hypergraphs that are non-metric, i.e., they don't arise from any metric space. Another basic structure associated with a metric space is a binary equivalence on the vertex set, where two pairs are in the same class if they induce the same line. An equivalence that comes from some metric space is a metric-line equivalence. We present an infinite family of so called obstacles, that is, binary equivalences that prevent an equivalence from being a metric-line equivalence.

A set of $n$ points in the Euclidean plane determines at least $n$ distinct lines unless these $n$ points are collinear. In 2006, Chen and Chvátal asked whether the same statement holds true in general metric spaces, where the line determined by points $x$ and $y$ is defined as the set consisting of $x$, $y$, and all points $z$ such that one of the three points $x,y,z$ lies between the other two. The conjecture that it does hold true remains unresolved even in the special case where the metric space arises from a connected undirected graph with unit lengths assigned to edges. We trace its curriculum vitae and point out twenty-nine related open problems plus three additional conjectures.

Chen and Chvátal introduced the notion of lines in hypergraphs; they proved that every 3-uniform hypergraph with $n$ vertices either has a line that consists of all $n$ vertices or else has at least $\log_2 n$ distinct lines. We improve this lower bound by a factor of $2-o(1)$.

A special case of a combinatorial theorem of De Bruijn and Erdos asserts that every noncollinear set of n points in the plane determines at least n distinct lines. Chen and Chvatal suggested a possible generalization of this assertion in metric spaces with appropriately defined lines. We prove this generalization in all metric spaces where each nonzero distance equals 1 or 2.

A special case of a combinatorial theorem of De Bruijn and Erdos asserts that every noncollinear set of n points in the plane determines at least n distinct lines. Chen and Chvatal suggested a possible generalization of this assertion in metric spaces with appropriately defined lines. We prove this generalization in all metric spaces induced by connected chordal graphs.

One of the De Bruijn - Erdos theorems deals with finite hypergraphs where every two vertices belong to precisely one hyperedge. It asserts that, except in the perverse case where a single hyperedge equals the whole vertex set, the number of hyperedges is at least the number of vertices and the two numbers are equal if and only if the hypergraph belongs to one of simply described families, near-pencils and finite projective planes. Chen and Chvatal proposed to define the line uv in a 3-uniform hypergraph as the set of vertices that consists of u, v, and all w such that {u,v,w} is a hyperedge. With this definition, the De Bruijn - Erdos theorem is easily seen to be equivalent to the following statement: If no four vertices in a 3-uniform hypergraph carry two or three hyperedges, then, except in the perverse case where one of the lines equals the whole vertex set, the number of lines is at least the number of vertices and the two numbers are equal if and only if the hypergraph belongs to one of two simply described families. Our main result eneralizes this statement by allowing any four vertices to carry three hyperedges (but keeping two forbidden): the conclusion remains the same except that a third simply described family, complements of Steiner triple systems, appears in the extremal case.

We provide a proof of Sholander's claim (Trees, lattices, order, and betweenness, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 3, 369-381 (1952)) concerning the representability of collections of so-called segments by trees, which yields a characterization of the interval function of a tree. Furthermore, we streamline Burigana's characterization (Tree representations of betweenness relations defined by intersection and inclusion, Mathematics and Social Sciences 185, 5-36 (2009)) of tree betweenness and provide a relatively short proof.

We show that the method of counting closed walks in strongly regular graphs rules out no parameter sets other than those ruled out by the method of counting eigenvalue multiplicities.

De Bruijn and Erdős proved that every noncollinear set of n points in the plane determines at least n distinct lines. Chen and Chvátal suggested a possible generalization of this theorem in the framework of metric spaces. We provide partial results in this direction.

We characterize, by easily verifiable properties, abstract ternary relations isomorphic to the causal betweenness introduced by Hans Reichenbach.

A transversal in a rooted tree is any set of nodes that meets every path from the root to a leaf. We let c(T,k) denote the number of transversals of size k in a rooted tree T. We define a partial order on the set of all rooted trees with n nodes by saying that a tree T succeeds a tree T' if c(T,k) is at least c(T',k) for all k and strictly greater than c(T',k) for at least one k. We prove that, for every choice of positive integers d and n, the set of all rooted trees on n nodes where each node has at most d children has a unique minimal element with respect to this partial order and we describe this tree.

De Bruijn and Erdős proved that every noncollinear set of n points in the plane determines at least n distinct lines. We suggest a possible generalization of this theorem in the framework of metric spaces and provide partial results on related extremal combinatorial problems.