arXiv++ Combinatorics

The $k$-Opt heuristic is a simple improvement heuristic for the Traveling Salesman Problem. It starts with an arbitrary tour and then repeatedly replaces $k$ edges of the tour by $k$ other edges, as long as this yields a shorter tour. We will prove that for 2-dimensional Euclidean Traveling Salesman Problems with $n$ cities the approximation ratio of the $k$-Opt heuristic is $Θ(\log n / \log \log n)$. This improves the upper bound of $O(\log n)$ given by Chandra, Karloff, and Tovey in 1999 and provides for the first time a non-trivial lower bound for the case $k\ge 3$. Our results not only hold for the Euclidean norm but extend to arbitrary $p$-norms with $1 \le p < \infty$.

The (1,2)-TSP is a special case of the TSP where each edge has cost either 1 or 2. In this paper we give a lower bound of $\frac{3}{2}$ for the approximation ratio of the 2-Opt algorithm for the (1,2)-TSP. Moreover, we show that the 3-Opt algorithm has an exact approximation ratio of $\frac{11}{8}$ for the (1,2)-TSP. Furthermore, we introduce the 3-Opt++-algorithm, an improved version of the 3-Opt algorithm for the (1-2)-TSP with an exact approximation ratio of $\frac{4}{3}$.

In this paper we investigate instances with high integrality ratio of the subtour LP. We develop a procedure to generate families of Euclidean TSP instances whose integrality ratios converge to $\frac{4}{3}$ and may have a different structure than the instances currently known from the literature. Moreover, we compute the instances maximizing the integrality ratio for Rectilinear TSP with up to 10 vertices. Based on these instances we give families of instances whose integrality ratio converge to $\frac{4}{3}$ for Rectilinear, Multidimensional Rectilinear and Euclidean TSP that have similar structures. We show that our instances for Multidimensional Rectilinear TSP and the known instances for Metric TSP maximize the integrality ratio under certain assumptions. We also investigate the concept of local optimality with respect to integrality ratio and develop several algorithms to find instances with high integrality ratio. Furthermore, we describe a family of instances that are hard to solve in practice. The currently fastest TSP solver Concorde needs more than two days to solve an instance from the family with 52 vertices.

In this paper we investigate the integrality ratio of the standard LP relaxation for the metric $s-t$ Path TSP. We make a near-optimal choice for an auxiliary function used in the analysis of Traub and Vygen which leads to an improved upper bound on the integrality ratio of 1.5273.

The $k$-Opt and Lin-Kernighan algorithm are two of the most important local search approaches for the Metric TSP. Both start with an arbitrary tour and make local improvements in each step to get a shorter tour. We show that for any fixed $k\geq 3$ the approximation ratio of the $k$-Opt algorithm for Metric TSP is $O(\sqrt[k]{n})$. Assuming the Erdős girth conjecture, we prove a matching lower bound of $Ω(\sqrt[k]{n})$. Unconditionally, we obtain matching bounds for $k=3,4,6$ and a lower bound of $Ω(n^{\frac{2}{3k-3}})$. Our most general bounds depend on the values of a function from extremal graph theory and are tight up to a factor logarithmic in the number of vertices unconditionally. Moreover, all the upper bounds also apply to a parameterized generalization of the Lin-Kernighan algorithm with appropriate parameters. We also show that the approximation ratio of $k$-Opt for Graph TSP is $Ω\left(\frac{\log(n)}{\log\log(n)}\right)$ and $O\left(\left(\frac{\log(n)}{\log\log(n)}\right)^{\log_2(9)+ε}\right)$ for all $ε>0$. For the (1,2)-TSP we give a lower bound of $\frac{11}{10}$ on the approximation ratio of the $k$-improv and $k$-Opt algorithm for arbitrary fixed $k$.

The 2-Opt heuristic is one of the simplest algorithms for finding good solutions to the metric Traveling Salesman Problem. It is the key ingredient to the well-known Lin-Kernighan algorithm and often used in practice. So far, only upper and lower bounds on the approximation ratio of the 2-Opt heuristic for the metric TSP were known. We prove that for the metric TSP with $n$ cities, the approximation ratio of the 2-Opt heuristic is $\sqrt{n/2}$ and that this bound is tight.

One way to speed up the calculation of optimal TSP tours in practice is eliminating edges that are certainly not in the optimal tour as a preprocessing step. In order to do so several edge elimination approaches have been proposed in the past. In this work we investigate two of them in the scenario where the input consists of $n$ independently distributed random points in the 2-dimensional unit square with bounded density function from above and below by arbitrary positive constants. We show that after the edge elimination procedure of Hougardy and Schroeder the expected number of remaining edges is $Θ(n)$, while after that the non-recursive part of Jonker and Volgenant the expected number of remaining edges is $Θ(n^2)$.

The well known $4/3$ conjecture states that the integrality ratio of the subtour LP is at most $4/3$ for metric Traveling Salesman instances. We present a family of Euclidean Traveling Salesman instances for which we prove that the integrality ratio of the subtour LP converges to $4/3$. These instances (using the rounded Euclidean norm) turn out to be hard to solve exactly with Concorde, the fastest existing exact TSP solver. For a 200 vertex instance from our family of Euclidean Traveling Salesman instances Concorde needs several days of CPU time. This is more than 1,000,000 times the runtime for a TSPLIB instance of similar size. Thus our new family of Euclidean Traveling Salesman instances may serve as new benchmark instances for TSP algorithms.