arXiv++ Combinatorics

We study variants of Sidorenko's conjecture in tournaments, where new phenomena arise that do not have clear analogues in the setting of undirected graphs. We first consider oriented graphs that are systematically under-represented in tournaments (called tournament anti-Sidorenko). We prove that such oriented graphs must be quite sparse; specifically, the maximum number of edges of a $k$-vertex oriented graph which is tournament anti-Sidorenko is $(1+o(1))k\log_2 k$. We also give several novel constructions of oriented graphs that are systematically over-represented in tournaments (tournament Sidorenko); as a representative example, we show that most ways to delete an edge from a transitive tournament yield a tournament Sidorenko oriented graph. As an illustration of our methods, we characterize which orientations of stars are tournament Sidorenko and which are tournament anti-Sidorenko.

We study analogues of Sidorenko's conjecture and the forcing conjecture in oriented graphs, showing that natural variants of these conjectures in directed graphs are equivalent to the asymmetric, undirected analogues of the conjectures.

Given a graph sequence $\{G_n\}_{n\ge1}$ and a simple connected subgraph $H$, we denote by $T(H,G_n)$ the number of monochromatic copies of $H$ in a uniformly random vertex coloring of $G_n$ with $c \ge 2$ colors. In this article, we prove a central limit theorem for $T(H,G_n)$ with explicit error rates. The error rates arise from graph counts of collections formed by joining copies of $H$ that we call good joins. Counts of good joins are closely related to the fourth moment of a normalized version of $T(H,G_{n})$, and that connection allows us to show a fourth moment phenomenon for the central limit theorem. Precisely, for $c\ge 30$, we show that $T(H,G_n)$ (appropriately centered and rescaled) converges in distribution to $\mathcal{N}(0,1)$ whenever its fourth moment converges to 3 (the fourth moment of the standard normal distribution). We show the convergence of the fourth moment is necessary to obtain a normal limit when $c\ge 2$. The combination of these results implies that the fourth moment condition characterizes the limiting normal distribution of $T(H,G_n)$ for all subgraphs $H$, whenever $c\ge 30$.

A directed graph is oriented if it can be obtained by orienting the edges of a simple, undirected graph. For an oriented graph $G$, let $β(G)$ denote the size of a minimum feedback arc set, a smallest subset of edges whose deletion leaves an acyclic subgraph. A simple consequence of a result of Berger and Shor is that any oriented graph $G$ with $m$ edges satisfies $β(G) = m/2 - Ω(m^{3/4})$. We observe that if an oriented graph $G$ has a fixed forbidden subgraph $B$, the upper bound of $β(G) = m/2 - Ω(m^{3/4})$ is best possible as a function of the number of edges if $B$ is not bipartite, but the exponent $3/4$ in the lower order term can be improved if $B$ is bipartite. We also show that for every rational number $r$ between $3/4$ and $1$, there is a finite collection of digraphs $\mathcal{B}$ such that every $\mathcal{B}$-free digraph $G$ with $m$ edges satisfies $β(G) = m/2 - Ω(m^r)$, and this bound is best possible up to the implied constant factor. The proof uses a connection to Turán numbers and a result of Bukh and Conlon. Both of our upper bounds come equipped with randomized linear-time algorithms that construct feedback arc sets achieving those bounds. Finally, we give a characterization of quasirandom directed graphs via minimum feedback arc sets.

We study the following question: how few edges can we delete from any $H$-free graph on $n$ vertices in order to make the resulting graph $k$-colorable? It turns out that various classical problems in extremal graph theory are special cases of this question. For $H$ any fixed odd cycle, we determine the answer up to a constant factor when $n$ is sufficiently large. We also prove an upper bound when $H$ is a fixed clique that we conjecture is tight up to a constant factor, and prove upper bounds for more general families of graphs. We apply our results to get a new bound on the maximum cut of graphs with a forbidden odd cycle in terms of the number of edges.