arXiv++ Combinatorics

We prove a range of new sum-product type growth estimates over a general field $\mathbb{F}$, in particular the special case $\mathbb{F}=\mathbb{F}_p$. They are unified by the theme of "breaking the $3/2$ threshold", epitomising the previous state of the art. These estimates stem from specially suited applications of incidence bounds over $\mathbb{F}$, which apply to higher moments of representation functions. We establish the estimate $|R[A]| \gtrsim |A|^{8/5}$ for cardinality of the set $R[A]$ of distinct cross-ratios defined by triples of elements of a (sufficiently small if $\mathbb{F}$ has positive characteristic, similarly for the rest of the estimates) set $A\subset \mathbb{F}$, pinned at infinity. The cross-ratio naturally arises in various sum-product type questions of projective nature and is the unifying concept underlying most of our results. It enables one to take advantage of its symmetry properties as an onset of growth of, for instance, products of difference sets. The geometric nature of the cross-ratio enables us to break the version of the above threshold for the minimum number of distinct triangle areas $Ouu'$, defined by points $u,u'$ of a non-collinear point set $P\subset \mathbb{F}^2$. Another instance of breaking the threshold is showing that if $A$ is sufficiently small and has additive doubling constant $M$, then $|AA|\gtrsim M^{-2}|A|^{14/9}$. This result has a second moment version, which allows for new upper bounds for the number of collinear point triples in the set $A\times A\subset \mathbb{F}^2$, the quantity often arising in applications of geometric incidence estimates.

Let $R$ be a finite valuation ring of order $q^r.$ Using a point-plane incidence estimate in $R^3$, we obtain sum-product type estimates for subsets of $R$. In particular, we prove that for $A\subset R$, $$|AA+A|\gg \min\left\{q^{r}, \frac{|A|^3}{q^{2r-1}}\right\}.$$ We also show that if $|A+A||A|^{2}>q^{3r-1}$, then $$|A^2+A^2||A+A|\gg q^{\frac{r}{2}}|A|^{\frac{3}{2}}.$$

Let $F$ be a field of characteristic $p>2$ and $A\subset F$ have sufficiently small cardinality in terms of $p$. We improve the state of the art of a variety of sum-product type inequalities. In particular, we prove that $$ |AA|^2|A+A|^3 \gg |A|^6,\qquad |A(A+A)|\gg |A|^{3/2}. $$ We also prove several two-variable extractor estimates: ${\displaystyle |A(A+1)| \gg|A|^{9/8},}$ $$ |A+A^2|\gg |A|^{11/10},\; |A+A^3|\gg |A|^{29/28}, \; |A+1/A|\gg |A|^{31/30}.$$ Besides, we address questions of cardinalities $|A+A|$ vs $|f(A)+f(A)|$, for a polynomial $f$, where we establish the inequalities $$ \max(|A+A|,\, |A^2+A^2|)\gg |A|^{8/7}, \;\; \max(|A-A|,\, |A^3+A^3|)\gg |A|^{17/16}. $$ Szemerédi-Trotter type implications of the arithmetic estimates in question are that a Cartesian product point set $P=A\times B$ in $F^2$, of $n$ elements, with $|B|\leq |A|< p^{2/3}$ makes $O(n^{3/4}m^{2/3} + m + n)$ incidences with any set of $m$ lines. In particular, when $|A|=|B|$, there are $\ll n^{9/4}$ collinear triples of points in $P$, $\gg n^{3/2}$ distinct lines between pairs of its points, in $\gg n^{3/4}$ distinct directions. Besides, $P=A\times A$ determines $\gg n^{9/16}$ distinct pair-wise distances. These estimates are obtained on the basis of a new plane geometry interpretation of the incidence theorem between points and planes in three dimensions, which we call collisions of images.

This paper is an erratum to our paper, entitled "On an application of Guth-Katz theorem", Math. Res. Lett. 18 (2011), no. 4, 691-697. Let $F$ be the real or complex field and $ω$ a non-degenerate skew-symmetric bilinear form in the plane $F^2$. We prove that for finite a point set $P\subset F^2\setminus\{0\}$, the set $T_ω(P)$ of nonzero values of $ω$ in $P\times P$, if nonempty, has cardinality $Ω(N^{9/13}).$ A presumably near-sharp estimate $Ω(N/\log N)$ was claimed in the abovemnetioned paper over the reals for a symmetric or skew-symmetric form $ω$. However, the set-up for the proof was flawed. We discuss why we believe that justifying this claim in full strength is a major open problem. In the special case when $P=A\times A$, where $A$ is a set of at least two reals, we establish the following sum-product type estimates: $$ |AA+ AA|= Ω\left(|A|^{19/12}\right), $$ and $$|AA-AA|= Ω\left( \frac{|A|^{26/17}}{\log^{2/17}|A|}\right).$$

In recent years some near-optimal estimates have been established for certain sum-product type estimates. This paper gives some first extremal results which provide information about when these bounds may or may not be tight. The main tool is a new result which provides a nontrivial upper bound on the multiplicative energy of a sum set or difference set.

Let $F$ be a field with positive odd characteristic $p$. We prove a variety of new sum-product type estimates over $F$. They are derived from the theorem that the number of incidences between $m$ points and $n$ planes in the projective three-space $PG(3,F)$, with $m\geq n=O(p^2)$, is $$O( m\sqrt{n} + km ),$$ where $k$ denotes the maximum number of collinear planes. The main result is a significant improvement of the state-of-the-art sum-product inequality over fields with positive characteristic, namely that \begin{equation}\label{mres} |A\pm A|+|A\cdot A| =Ω\left(|A|^{1+\frac{1}{5}}\right), \end{equation} for any $A$ such that $|A|<p^{\frac{5}{8}}.$

In this paper we apply a group action approach to the study of Erd\H os-Falconer type problems in vector spaces over finite fields and use it to obtain non-trivial exponents for the distribution of simplices. We prove that there exists $s_0(d)<d$ such that if $E \subset {\mathbb F}_q^d$, $d \ge 2$, with $|E| \ge Cq^{s_0}$, then $|T^d_d(E)| \ge C'q^{d+1 \choose 2}$, where $T^d_k(E)$ denotes the set of congruence classes of $k$-dimensional simplices determined by $k+1$-tuples of points from $E$. Non-trivial exponents were previously obtained by Chapman, Erdogan, Hart, Iosevich and Koh (\cite{CEHIK12}) for $T^d_k(E)$ with $2 \leq k \leq d-1$. A non-trivial result for $T^2_2(E)$ in the plane was obtained by Bennett, Iosevich and Pakianathan (\cite{BIP12}). These results are significantly generalized and improved in this paper. In particular, we establish the Wolff exponent $\frac{4}{3}$, previously established in \cite{CEHIK12} for the $q\equiv3\mbox{ mod }4$ case to the case $q\equiv1\mbox{ mod }4$, and this results in a new sum-product type inequality. We also obtain non-trivial results for subsets of the sphere in ${\mathbb F}_q^d$, where previous methods have yielded nothing. The key to our approach is a group action perspective which quickly leads to natural and effective formulae in the style of the classical Mattila integral from geometric measure theory.

Let $G$ be a finite group acting transitively on a set $Ω$. We study what it means for this action to be {\it quasirandom}, thereby generalizing Gowers' study of quasirandomness in groups. We connect this notion of quasirandomness to an upper bound for the convolution of functions associated with the action of $G$ on $Ω$. This convolution bound allows us to give sufficient conditions such that sets $S,T\subset G$ and $Γ\subseteq Ω$ contain elements $s\in S, t\in T, γ\inΓ$ such that $s(γ)=t$. Other consequences include an analogue of `the Gowers trick' of Nikolov and Pyber for general group actions, a sum-product type theorem for large subsets of a finite field, as well as applications to expanders and to the study of the diameter and width of a finite simple group.

Given two points $p,q$ in the real plane, the signed area of the rectangle with the diagonal $[pq]$ equals the square of the Minkowski distance between the points $p,q$. We prove that $N>1$ points in the Minkowski plane $\R^{1,1}$ generate $Ω(\frac{N}{\log{N}})$ distinct distances, or all the distances are zero. The proof follows the lines of the Elekes/Sharir/Guth/Katz approach to the Erd\H os distance problem, analysing the 3D incidence problem, arising by considering the action of the Minkowski isometry group $ISO^*(1,1)$. The signature of the metric creates an obstacle to applying the Guth/Katz incidence theorem to the 3D problem at hand, since one may encounter a high count of congruent line intervals, lying on null lines, or "light cones", all these intervals having zero Minkowski length. In terms of the Guth/Katz theorem, its condition of the non-existence of "rich planes" generally gets violated. It turns out, however, that one can efficiently identify and discount incidences, corresponding to null intervals and devise a counting strategy, where the rich planes condition happens to be just ample enough for the strategy to succeed. As a corollary we establish the following near-optimal sum-product type estimate for finite sets $A,B\subset \R$, with more than one element: $$|(A\pm{B})\cdot{(A\pm{B})}|\gg{\frac{|A||B|}{\log{|A|}+\log{|B|}}}.$$

In this paper we further study the relationship between convexity and additive growth, building on the work of Schoen and Shkredov (\cite{SS}) to get some improvements to earlier results of Elekes, Nathanson and Ruzsa (\cite{ENR}). In particular, we show that for any finite set $A\subset{\mathbb{R}}$ and any strictly convex or concave function $f$, \[|A+f(A)|\gg{\frac{|A|^{24/19}}{(\log|A|)^{2/19}}}\] and \[\max\{|A-A|,\ |f(A)+f(A)|\}\gg{\frac{|A|^{14/11}}{(\log|A|)^{2/11}}}.\] For the latter of these inequalities, we go on to consider the consequences for a sum-product type problem.

New lower bounds involving sum, difference, product, and ratio sets for $A\subset \C$ are given.