arXiv++ Combinatorics

Let $G$ be a finite abelian group, let $0 < α< 1$, and let $A \subseteq G$ be a random set of size $|G|^α$. We let $$ μ(A) = \max_{B,C:|B|=|C|=|A|}|\{(a,b,c) \in A \times B \times C : a = b + c \}|. $$ The issue is to determine upper bounds on $μ(A)$ that hold with high probability over the random choice of $A$. Mennink and Preneel \cite{BM} conjecture that $μ(A)$ should be close to $|A|$ (up to possible logarithmic factors in $|G|$) for $α\leq 1/2$ and that $μ(A)$ should not much exceed $|A|^{3/2}$ for $α\leq 2/3$. We prove the second half of this conjecture by showing that $$ μ(A) \leq |A|^3/|G| + 4|A|^{3/2}\ln(|G|)^{1/2} $$ with high probability, for all $0 < α< 1$. We note that $3α- 1 \leq (3/2)α$ for $α\leq 2/3$. In previous work, Alon et al$.$ have shown that $μ(A) \leq O(1)|A|^3/|G|$ with high probability for $α\geq 2/3$ while Kiltz, Pietrzak and Szegedy show that $μ(A) \leq |A|^{1 + 2α}$ with high probability for $α\leq 1/4$. Current bounds on $μ(A)$ are essentially sharp for the range $2/3 \leq α\leq 1$. Finding better bounds remains an open problem for the range $0 < α< 2/3$ and especially for the range $1/4 < α< 2/3$ in which the bound of Kiltz et al$.$ doesn't improve on the bound given in this paper (even if that bound applied). Moreover the conjecture of Mennink and Preneel for $α\leq 1/2$ remains open.