arXiv++ Combinatorics

Tangles were originally introduced as a concept to formalize regions of high connectivity in graphs. In recent years, they have also been discovered as a link between structural graph theory and data science: when interpreting similarity in data sets as connectivity between points, finding clusters in the data essentially amounts to finding tangles in the underlying graphs. This paper further explores the potential of tangles in data sets as a means for a formal study of clusters. Real-world data often follow a normal distribution. Accounting for this, we develop a quantitative theory of tangles in data sets drawn from Gaussian mixtures. To this end, we equip the data with a graph structure that models similarity between the points and allows us to apply tangle theory to the data. We provide explicit conditions under which tangles associated with the marginal Gaussian distributions exist asymptotically almost surely. This can be considered as a sufficient formal criterion for the separabability of clusters in the data.

Representing graphs by their homomorphism counts has led to the beautiful theory of homomorphism indistinguishability in recent years. Moreover, homomorphism counts have promising applications in database theory and machine learning, where one would like to answer queries or classify graphs solely based on the representation of a graph $G$ as a finite vector of homomorphism counts from some fixed finite set of graphs to $G$. We study the computational complexity of the arguably most fundamental computational problem associated to these representations, the homomorphism reconstructability problem: given a finite sequence of graphs and a corresponding vector of natural numbers, decide whether there exists a graph $G$ that realises the given vector as the homomorphism counts from the given graphs. We show that this problem yields a natural example of an $\mathsf{NP}^{#\mathsf{P}}$-hard problem, which still can be $\mathsf{NP}$-hard when restricted to a fixed number of input graphs of bounded treewidth and a fixed input vector of natural numbers, or alternatively, when restricted to a finite input set of graphs. We further show that, when restricted to a finite input set of graphs and given an upper bound on the order of the graph $G$ as additional input, the problem cannot be $\mathsf{NP}$-hard unless $\mathsf{P} = \mathsf{NP}$. For this regime, we obtain partial positive results. We also investigate the problem's parameterised complexity and provide fpt-algorithms for the case that a single graph is given and that multiple graphs of the same order with subgraph instead of homomorphism counts are given.

A Dyck path with $2k$ steps and $e$ flaws is a path in the integer lattice that starts at the origin and consists of $k$ many $\nearrow$-steps and $k$ many $\searrow$-steps that change the current coordinate by $(1,1)$ or $(1,-1)$, respectively, and that has exactly $e$ many $\searrow$-steps below the line $y=0$. Denoting by $D_{2k}^e$ the set of Dyck paths with $2k$ steps and $e$ flaws, the Chung-Feller theorem asserts that the sets $D_{2k}^0,D_{2k}^1,\ldots,D_{2k}^k$ all have the same cardinality $\frac{1}{k+1}\binom{2k}{k}=C_k$, the $k$-th Catalan number. The standard combinatorial proof of this classical result establishes a bijection $f'$ between $D_{2k}^e$ and $D_{2k}^{e+1}$ that swaps certain parts of the given Dyck path $x$, with the effect that $x$ and $f'(x)$ may differ in many positions. In this paper we strengthen the Chung-Feller theorem by presenting a simple bijection $f$ between $D_{2k}^e$ and $D_{2k}^{e+1}$ which has the additional feature that $x$ and $f(x)$ differ in only two positions (the least possible number). We also present an algorithm that allows to compute a sequence of applications of $f$ in constant time per generated Dyck path. As an application, we use our minimum-change bijection $f$ to construct cycle-factors in the odd graph $O_{2k+1}$ and the middle levels graph $M_{2k+1}$ --- two intensively studied families of vertex-transitive graphs --- that consist of $C_k$ many cycles of the same length.