arXiv++ Combinatorics

An ordered graph $G$ is a graph together with a specified linear ordering on the vertices, and its interval chromatic number is the minimum number of independent sets consisting of consecutive vertices that are needed to partition the vertex set. The $t$-color Ramsey number $R_t(G)$ of an ordered graph $G$ is the minimum number of vertices of an ordered complete graph such that every edge-coloring from a set of $t$ colors contains a monochromatic copy of $G$ such that the copy of $G$ preserves the original ordering on $G$. An ordered graph is $k$-ichromatic if it has interval chromatic number $k$. We obtain lower bounds linear in the number of vertices for the Ramsey numbers of certain classes of 2-ichromatic ordered graphs. We also determine the exact value of the $t$-color Ramsey number for two families of 2-ichromatic ordered graphs, and we prove a linear upper bound for a class of 2-ichromatic ordered graphs.

The \emph{slow-coloring game} is played by Lister and Painter on a graph $G$. Initially, all vertices of $G$ are uncolored. In each round, Lister marks a nonempty set $M$ of uncolored vertices, and Painter colors a subset of $M$ that is independent in $G$. The game ends when all vertices are colored. The score of the game is the sum of the sizes of all sets marked by Lister. The goal of Painter is to minimize the score, while Lister tries to maximize it. We provide strategies for Painter on various classes of graphs whose vertices can be partitioned into a bounded number of sets inducing forests, including $k$-degenerate, acyclically $k$-colorable, planar, and outerplanar graphs. For example, we show that on an $n$-vertex graph $G$, Painter can keep the score to at most $\frac{3k+4}4n$ when $G$ is $k$-degenerate, $3.9857n$ when $G$ is acyclically $5$-colorable, $3n$ when $G$ is planar with a Hamiltonian dual, $\frac{8n+3m}5$ when $G$ is $4$-colorable with $m$ edges (hence $3.4n$ when $G$ is planar), and $\frac73n$ when $G$ is outerplanar.

Let $G$ be a graph with nonnegative integer weights. A {\it unit acquisition move} transfers one unit of weight from a vertex to a neighbor that has at least as much weight. The {\it unit acquisition number} of a graph $G$, denoted $a_u(G)$, is the minimum size that the set of vertices with positive weight can be reduced to via successive unit acquisition moves when starting from the configuration in which every vertex has weight $1$. For a graph $G$ with $n$ vertices and minimum degree $k$, we prove $a_u(G)\le (n-1)/k$, with equality for complete graphs and $C_5$. Also $a_u(G)$ is at most the minimum size of a maximal matching in $G$, with equality on an infinite family of graphs. Furthermore, $a_u(G)$ is bounded by the maximum degree and by $\sqrt{n-1}$ when $G$ is an $n$-vertex tree with diameter at most $4$. We also construct arbitrarily large trees with maximum degree $5$ having unit acquisition number $1$, obtain a linear-time algorithm to compute the acquisition number of a caterpillar, and show that graphs with diameter $2$ have unit acquisition number $1$ except for $C_5$ and the Petersen graph.

Let $\mathcal{F}$ be a family of graphs. A graph $G$ is $\mathcal{F}$-saturated if $G$ contains no member of $\mathcal{F}$ as a subgraph but $G+e$ contains some member of $\mathcal{F}$ whenever $e\in E(\overline{G})$. The saturation number and extremal number of $\mathcal{F}$, denoted $sat(n,\mathcal{F})$ and $ex(n,\mathcal{F})$ respectively, are the minimum and maximum numbers of edges among $n$-vertex $\mathcal{F}$-saturated graphs. For $k\in\mathbb{N}$, let $\mathcal{F}_k$ and $\mathcal{F}'_k$ be the families of $k$-connected and $k$-edge-connected graphs, respectively. Wenger proved $sat(n,\mathcal{F}_k)=(k-1)n-{k\choose2}$, we prove $sat(n,\mathcal{F}'_k)=(k-1)(n-1)-\lfloor{\frac {n}{k+1}}\rfloor{k-1 \choose 2}$. We also prove $ex(n,\mathcal{F}'_k)=(k-1)n-{k\choose2}$ and characterize when equality holds. Finally, we give a lower bound on the spectral radius for $\mathcal{F}_k$-saturated and $\mathcal{F}'_k$-saturated graphs.

In 2010, N. Lichiardopol conjectured for $q \geq 3$ and $k \geq 1$ that any tournament with minimum out-degree at least $(q-1)k-1$ contains $k$ disjoint cycles of length $q$. We prove this conjecture for $q \geq 5$. Since it is already known to hold for $q\le4$, this completes the proof of the conjecture.

The slow-coloring game is played by Lister and Painter on a graph $G$. On each round, Lister marks a nonempty subset $M$ of the remaining vertices, scoring $|M|$ points. Painter then gives a color to a subset of $M$ that is independent in $G$. The game ends when all vertices are colored. Painter's goal is to minimize the total score; Lister seeks to maximize it. The score that each player can guarantee doing no worse than is the sum-color cost of $G$, written $\mathring{\rm s}(G)$. We develop a linear-time algorithm to compute $\mathring{\rm s}(G)$ when $G$ is a tree, enabling us to characterize the $n$-vertex trees with the largest and smallest values. Our algorithm also computes on trees the interactive sum choice number, a parameter recently introduced by Bonamy and Meeks.

The separation dimension of a graph $G$, written $π(G)$, is the minimum number of linear orderings of $V(G)$ such that every two nonincident edges are "separated" in some ordering, meaning that both endpoints of one edge appear before both endpoints of the other. We introduce the fractional separation dimension $π_f(G)$, which is the minimum of $a/b$ such that some $a$ linear orderings (repetition allowed) separate every two nonincident edges at least $b$ times. In contrast to separation dimension, fractional separation dimension is bounded: always $π_f(G)\le 3$, with equality if and only if $G$ contains $K_4$. There is no stronger bound even for bipartite graphs, since $π_f(K_{m,m})=π_f(K_{m+1,m})=\frac{3m}{m+1}$. We also compute $π_f(G)$ for cycles and some complete tripartite graphs. We show that $π_f(G)<\sqrt 2$ when $G$ is a tree and present a sequence of trees on which the value tends to $4/3$. Finally, we consider analogous problems for circular orderings, where pairs of nonincident edges are separated unless their endpoints alternate. Let $π^\circ(G)$ be the number of circular orderings needed to separate all pairs and $π_f^\circ(G)$ be the fractional version. Among our results: (1) $π^\circ(G)=1$ if and only $G$ is outerplanar. (2) $π^\circ(G)\le2$ when $G$ is bipartite. (3) $π^\circ(K_n)\ge\log_2\log_3(n-1)$. (4) $π_f^\circ(G)\le\frac{3}{2}$, with equality if and only if $K_4\subseteq G$. (5) $π_f^\circ(K_{m,m})=\frac{3m-3}{2m-1}$.

The $k$-deck of a graph is its multiset of induced subgraphs on $k$ vertices. We prove that $n$-vertex graphs with maximum degree $2$ have the same $k$-decks if each cycle has at least $k+1$ vertices, each path component has at least $k-1$ vertices, and the number of edges is the same. Using this for lower bounds, we obtain for each graph with maximum degree at most $2$ the least $k$ such that it is determined by its $k$-deck. For the $n$-vertex cycle this value is $\lfloor n/2 \rfloor$, and for the $n$-vertex path it is $\lfloor n/2 \rfloor+1$. Also, the least $k$ such that the $k$-deck of an $n$-vertex graph always determines whether it is connected is at least $\lfloor n/2 \rfloor +1$.

For an interconnection network $G$, the {\it $ω$-wide diameter} $d_ω(G)$ is the least $\ell$ such that any two vertices are joined by $ω$ internally-disjoint paths of length at most $\ell$, and the {\it $(ω-1)$-fault diameter} $D_ω(G)$ is the maximum diameter of a subgraph obtained by deleting fewer than $ω$ vertices of $G$. The enhanced hypercube $Q_{n,k}$ is a variant of the well-known hypercube. Yang, Chang, Pai, and Chan gave an upper bound for $d_{n+1}(Q_{n,k})$ and $D_{n+1}(Q_{n,k})$ and posed the problem of finding the wide diameters and fault diameters of $Q_{n,k}$. By constructing internally disjoint paths between any two vertices in the enhanced hypercube, for $n\ge3$ and $2\le k\le n$ we prove $$ D_ω(Q_{n,k})=d_ω(Q_{n,k})=\begin{cases} d(Q_{n,k}) & \textrm{for $1 \leq ω< n-\lfloor\frac{k}{2}\rfloor$;}\\ d(Q_{n,k})+1 & \textrm{for $n-\lfloor\frac{k}{2}\rfloor \leq ω\leq n+1$.} \end{cases} $$ where $d(Q_{n,k})$ is the diameter of $Q_{n,k}$. These results mean that interconnection networks modelled by enhanced hypercubes are extremely robust.

We give a new proof of the theorem of Boesch-Tindell and Farzad-Mahdian-Mahmoodian-Saberi-Sadri that a directed graph extends to a strongly connected digraph on the same vertex set if and only if it has no complete directed cut. Our proof bounds the number of edges needed for such an extension; we give examples to demonstrate sharpness. We apply the characterization to a problem on non-transitive dice.

The slow-coloring game is played by Lister and Painter on a graph $G$. On each round, Lister marks a nonempty subset $M$ of the uncolored vertices, scoring $|M|$ points. Painter then gives a color to a subset of $M$ that is independent in $G$. The game ends when all vertices are colored. Painter and Lister want to minimize and maximize the total score, respectively. The best score that each player can guarantee is the sum-color cost of $G$, written $\mathring{\mathrm{s}}(G)$. The game is an online variant of online sum list coloring. We proe $\frac{|V(G)|}{2α(G)} + \frac{1}{2} \leq \frac{\mathring{\mathrm{s}}(G)}{|V(G)|} \leq \max\left\{ \frac{|V(H)|}{α(H)} : H \subset G\right\}$, where $α(G)$ is the independence number, and we study when equality holds in the bounds. We compute $\mathring{\mathrm{s}}(G)$ for graphs with $α(G) = 2$. Among $n$-vertex graphs, we prove that $\mathring{\mathrm{s}}$ is minimized by the star and maximized by the path. We also obtain good bounds on $\mathring{\mathrm{s}}(K_{r,s})$.

Given a graph $F$, a graph $G$ is {\it uniquely $F$-saturated} if $F$ is not a subgraph of $G$ and adding any edge of the complement to $G$ completes exactly one copy of $F$. In this paper we study uniquely $C_t$-saturated graphs. We prove the following: (1) a graph is uniquely $C_5$-saturated if and only if it is a friendship graph. (2) There are no uniquely $C_6$-saturated graphs or uniquely $C_7$-saturated graphs. (3) For $t\ge6$, there are only finitely many uniquely $C_t$-saturated graphs (we conjecture that in fact there are none).

For a loopless multigraph $G$, the fractional arboricity $Arb(G)$ is the maximum of $\frac{|E(H)|}{|V(H)|-1}$ over all subgraphs $H$ with at least two vertices. Generalizing the Nash-Williams Arboricity Theorem, the Nine Dragon Tree Conjecture asserts that if $Arb(G)\le k+\frac{d}{k+d+1}$, then $G$ decomposes into $k+1$ forests with one having maximum degree at most $d$. The conjecture was previously proved for $d=k+1$ and for $k=1$ when $d \le 6$. We prove it for all $d$ when $k \le 2$, except for $(k,d)=(2,1)$.

An $r$-augmented tree is a rooted tree plus $r$ edges added from each leaf to ancestors. For $d,g,r\in\mathbb{N}$, we construct a bipartite $r$-augmented complete $d$-ary tree having girth at least $g$. The height of such trees must grow extremely rapidly in terms of the girth. Using the resulting graphs, we construct sparse non-$k$-choosable bipartite graphs, showing that maximum average degree at most $2(k-1)$ is a sharp sufficient condition for $k$-choosability in bipartite graphs, even when requiring large girth. We also give a new simple construction of non-$k$-colorable graphs and hypergraphs with any girth $g$.

An \textit{$r$-dynamic $k$-coloring} of a graph $G$ is a proper $k$-coloring of $G$ such that every vertex in $V(G)$ has neighbors in at least $\min\{d(v),r\}$ different color classes. The \textit{$r$-dynamic chromatic number} of a graph $G$, written $χ_r(G)$, is the least $k$ such that $G$ has such a coloring. Proving a conjecture of Jahanbekam, Kim, O, and West, we show that the $m$-by-$n$ grid has no $3$-dynamic $4$-coloring when $mn\equiv2\mod 4$. This completes the determination of the $r$-dynamic chromatic number of the $m$-by-$n$ grid for all $r,m,n$.

We consider a Cops-and-Robber game played on the subsets of an $n$-set. The robber starts at the full set; the cops start at the empty set. On each turn, the robber moves down one level by discarding an element, and each cop moves up one level by gaining an element. The question is how many cops are needed to ensure catching the robber when the robber reaches the middle level. Aaron Hill posed the problem and provided a lower bound of $2^{n/2}$ for even $n$ and $\binom{n}{\lceil n/2 \rceil}2^{-\lfloor n/2 \rfloor}$ for odd $n$. We prove an upper bound (for all $n$) that is within a factor of $O(\ln n)$ times this lower bound.

Given a family ${\mathcal F}$ and a host graph $H$, a graph $G\subseteq H$ is ${\mathcal F}$-saturated relative to $H$ if no subgraph of $G$ lies in ${\mathcal F}$ but adding any edge from $E(H)-E(G)$ to $G$ creates such a subgraph. In the ${\mathcal F}$-saturation game on $H$, players Max and Min alternately add edges of $H$ to $G$, avoiding subgraphs in ${\mathcal F}$, until $G$ becomes ${\mathcal F}$-saturated relative to $H$. They aim to maximize or minimize the length of the game, respectively; $\textrm{sat}_g({\mathcal F};H)$ denotes the length under optimal play (when Max starts). Let ${\mathcal O}$ denote the family of all odd cycles and ${\mathcal T}$ the family of $n$-vertex trees, and write $F$ for ${\mathcal F}$ when ${\mathcal F}=\{F\}$. Our results include $\textrm{sat}_g({\mathcal O};K_{2k})=k^2$, $\textrm{sat}_g({\mathcal T};K_n)=\binom{n-2}{2}+1$ for $n\ge6$, $\textrm{sat}_g(K_{1,3};K_n)=2\lfloor n/2 \rfloor$ for $n\ge8$, $\textrm{sat}_g(K_{1,r+1};K_n)=\frac{rn}{2}-\frac{r^2}{8}+O(1)$, and $|\textrm{sat}_g(P_4;K_n)-(4n-1)/5|\le 1$. We also determine $\textrm{sat}_g(P_4;K_{m,n})$; with $m\ge n$, it is $n$ when $n$ is even, $m$ when $n$ is odd and $m$ is even, and $m+\lfloor n/2 \rfloor$ when $mn$ is odd. Finally, we prove the lower bound $\textrm{sat}_g(C_4;K_{n,n})\ge\frac{1}{10.4}n^{13/12}-O(n^{35/36})$. The results are very similar when Min plays first, except for the $P_4$-saturation game on $K_{m,n}$.

Let $\text{ch}(G)$ denote the choice number of a graph $G$ (also called "list chromatic number" or "choosability" of $G$). Noel, Reed, and Wu proved the conjecture of Ohba that $\text{ch}(G)=χ(G)$ when $|V(G)|\le 2χ(G)+1$. We extend this to a general upper bound: $\text{ch}(G)\le \max\{χ(G),\lceil({|V(G)|+χ(G)-1})/{3}\rceil\}$. Our result is sharp for $|V(G)|\le 3χ(G)$ using Ohba's examples, and it improves the best-known upper bound for $\text{ch}(K_{4,\dots,4})$.

We provide a "how-to" guide to the use and application of the Discharging Method. Our aim is not to exhaustively survey results proved by this technique, but rather to demystify the technique and facilitate its wider use, using applications in graph coloring as examples. Along the way, we present some new proofs and new problems.

We apply the Discharging Method to prove the 1,2,3-Conjecture and the 1,2-Conjecture for graphs with maximum average degree less than 8/3. Stronger results on these conjectures have been proved, but this is the first application of discharging to them, and the structure theorems and reducibility results are of independent interest.