arXiv++ Combinatorics

In 2021, motivated by graph limit theory Lovász extended most of the theory of flows to a measure theoretic setting. Using this framework, the first author constructed $d$-regular treeings that are measurably bipartite, and have no nonzero measurable circulations, that is, flows without sources or sinks. In particular, these treeings do not admit a measurable perfect matching. In this paper, we develop tools to build $d$-regular treeings where the space of circulations is exactly $k$-dimensional for any positive integer $k$. As applications, we construct 1) a treeing with a single balanced orientation, but no Schreier decoration; 2) a treeing with a single Schreier decoration; 3) and a treeing with a proper edge $d$-coloring, but no further perfect matchings. The first answers a question raised by Lovász, as this particular balanced orientation does not decompose as a linear combination of finite cycles and infinite paths.

Alon and Shapira proved that every monotone class (closed under taking subgraphs) of undirected graphs is strongly testable, that is, under the promise that a given graph is either in the class or $\varepsilon$-far from it, there is a test using a constant number of samples (depending on $\varepsilon$ only) that rejects every graph not in the class with probability at least one half, and always accepts a graph in the class. However, their bound on the number of samples is quite large since they heavily rely on Szemerédi's regularity lemma. We study the case of posets and show that every monotone class of posets is easily testable, that is, a polynomial (of $\varepsilon^{-1}$) number of samples is sufficient. We achieve this via proving a polynomial removal lemma for posets. We give a simple classification: for every monotone class of posets, there is an $h$ such that the class is indistinguishable (every large enough poset in one class is $\varepsilon$-close to a poset in the other class) from the class of $C_h$-free posets, where $C_h$ denotes the chain with $h$ elements. This allows us to test every monotone class of posets using $O(\varepsilon^{-1})$ samples. The test has a two-sided error, but it is almost complete: the probability of refuting a poset in the class is polynomially small in the size of the poset. The analogous results hold for comparability graphs, too.

We study groups which satisfy Gardner's equidecomposition conjecture for uniformly distributed sets. We prove that an amenable group has this property if and only if it does not admit $(\mathbb{Z}/2\mathbb{Z}) *(\mathbb{Z}/2\mathbb{Z})$ as a quotient by a finite subgroup. Our technical contribution is an algorithm for rounding Borel flows for actions of amenable groups.

The theory of limits of permutations leads to limit objects called permutons, which are certain Borel measures on the unit square. We prove that permutons avoiding a given permutation of order $k$ have a particularly simple structure. Namely, almost every fiber of the disintegration of the permuton (say, along the x-axis) consists only of atoms, at most $(k-1)$ many, and this bound is sharp. We use this to give a simple proof of the `permutation removal lemma'.

We characterize hyperfinite bipartite graphings that admit measurable perfect matchings. In particular, we prove that every regular hyperfinite bipartite graphing admits a measurable perfect matching if it is one-ended or the degree is odd. We give several applications of this result, answering various open questions in the field. For instance, we extend the Lyons--Nazarov theorem by characterizing bipartite Cayley graphs which admit a factor of iid perfect matching, answering the bipartite case of a well-known question of Lyons and Nazarov, popularized by Kechris and Marks. Moreover, we show how our results apply to measurable equidecompositions and, in particular, generalize the recent result of Grabowski, Máthé and Pikhurko on the measurable circle squaring. Our approach applies more generally to rounding measurable perfect fractional matchings.

We construct, for every $d \geq 3$, a $d$-regular acyclic measurably bipartite graphing that admits no measurable perfect matching, resolving a problem of Kechris and Marks. A dense variant of our construction yields a coupling of two standard Borel probability measure spaces whose support contains no deterministic coupling, though the conditional probabilities of the coupling measure are atomless. This refutes a conjecture of Gurel-Gurevich and Peled.

Gardner conjectured that if two bounded measurable sets $A,B \subset \mathbb{R}^n$ are equidecomposable by a set of isometries $Γ$ generating an amenable group then $A$ and $B$ admit a measurable equidecomposition by all isometries. Cieśla and Sabok asked if there is a measurable equidecomposition using isometries only in the group generated by $Γ$. We answer this question negatively.

We conjecture that finite graphs with positive Cheeger constant admit a spanning subgraph with positive Cheeger constant and girth proportional to the diameter. We prove this conjecture for regular expander graphs with large expansion. Our proof relies on the Local Lemma.

We prove Bowen's conjecture that every sequence of finite graphs that locally converges to the Cayley graph of a countably infinite group with Kazhdan Property (T) is essentially a vertex-disjoint union of expander graphs. We characterize graph sequences that are essentially a vertex-disjoint union of expander graphs in terms of the Markov operator.

We introduce the matching measure of a finite graph as the uniform distribution on the roots of the matching polynomial of the graph. We analyze the asymptotic behavior of the matching measure for graph sequences with bounded degree. A graph parameter is said to be estimable if it converges along every Benjamini-Schramm convergent sparse graph sequence. We prove that the normalized logarithm of the number of matchings is estimable. We also show that the analogous statement for perfect matchings already fails for d-regular bipartite graphs for any fixed d at least 3. The latter result relies on analyzing the probability that a randomly chosen perfect matching contains a particular edge. However, for any sequence of d-regular bipartite graphs converging to the d-regular tree, we prove that the normalized logarithm of the number of perfect matchings converges. This applies to random d-regular bipartite graphs. We show that the limit equals to the exponent in Schrijver's lower bound on the number of perfect matchings. Our analytic approach also yields a short proof for the Nguyen-Onak (also Elek--Lippner) theorem saying that the matching ratio is estimable. In fact, we prove the slightly stronger result that the independence ratio is estimable for claw-free graphs.

We consider the pursuit and evasion game on finite, connected, undirected graphs known as cops and robbers. Meyniel conjectured that for every graph on n vertices a rootish number of cops can win the game. We prove that this holds up to a log(n) factor for random graphs G(n,p) if p is not very small, and this is close to be tight unless the graph is very dense. We analyze the area-defending strategy (used by Aigner in case of planar graphs) and show examples where it can not be too efficient.

We show that every NP problem is polynomially equivalent to a simple combinatorial problem: the membership problem for a special class of digraphs. These classes are defined by means of shadows (projections) and by finitely many forbidden colored (lifted) subgraphs. Our characterization is motivated by the analysis of syntactical subclasses with the full computational power of NP, which were first studied by Feder and Vardi. Our approach applies to many combinatorial problems and it induces the characterization of coloring problems (CSP) defined by means of shadows. This turns out to be related to homomorphism dualities. We prove that a class of digraphs (relational structures) defined by finitely many forbidden colored subgraphs (i.e. lifted substructures) is a CSP class if and only if all the the forbidden structures are homomorphically equivalent to trees. We show a surprising richness of coloring problems when restricted to most frequent graph classes. Using results of Nešetřil and Ossona de Mendez for bounded expansion classes (which include bounded degree and proper minor closed classes) we prove that the restriction of every class defined as the shadow of finitely many colored subgraphs equals to the restriction of a coloring (CSP) class.

We give a poly-time construction for a combinatorial classic known as Sparse Incomparability Lemma, studied by Erdos, Lovasz, Nesetril, Rodl and others: We show that every Constraint Satisfaction Problem is poly-time equivalent to its restriction to structures with large girth. This implies that the complexity classes CSP and Monotone Monadic Strict NP introduced by Feder and Vardi are computationally equivalent. The technical novelty of the paper is a concept of expander relations and a new type of product for relational structures: a generalization of the zig-zag product, the twisted product.

We present a definition of the class NP in combinatorial context as the set of languages of structures defined by finitely many forbidden lifted substructures. We apply this to special syntactically defined subclasses and show how they correspond to naturally defined (and intensively studied) combinatorial problems. We show that some types of combinatorial problems like edge colorings and graph decompositions express the full computational power of the class NP. We then characterize Constraint Satisfaction Problems (i.e. H-coloring problems) which are expressible by finitely many forbidden lifted substructures. This greatly simplifies and generalizes the earlier attempts to characterize this problem. As a corollary of this approach we perhaps find a proper setting of Feder and Vardi analysis of CSP languages within the class MMSNP.