arXiv++ Combinatorics

In this brief note, we prove a min-min equality for a clean tangled clutter, that the rainbow covering number is equal to the connectivity of its setcore.

A set-system $S\subseteq \{0,1\}^n$ is cube-ideal if its convex hull can be described by capacity and generalized set covering inequalities. In this paper, we use combinatorics, convex geometry, and polyhedral theory to give exponential lower bounds on the size of cube-ideal set-systems, and linear lower bounds on their VC dimension. We then provide applications to graph theory and combinatorial optimization, specifically to strong orientations, perfect matchings, dijoins, and ideal clutters.

In a digraph, a dicut is a cut where all the arcs cross in one direction. A dijoin is a subset of arcs that intersects every dicut. Edmonds and Giles conjectured that in a weighted digraph, the minimum weight of a dicut is equal to the maximum size of a packing of dijoins. This has been disproved. However, the unweighted version conjectured by Woodall remains open. We prove that the Edmonds-Giles conjecture is true if the underlying undirected graph is chordal. We also give a strongly polynomial time algorithm to construct such a packing.

Let $D=(V,A)$ be a digraph whose underlying graph is $2$-edge-connected, and let $P$ be the polytope whose vertices are the incidence vectors of arc sets whose reversal makes $D$ strongly connected. We study the lattice theoretic properties of the integer points contained in a proper face $F$ of $P$ not contained in $\{x:x_a=i\}$ for any $a\in A,i\in \{0,1\}$. We prove under a mild necessary condition that $F\cap \{0,1\}^A$ contains an integral basis $B$, i.e., $B$ is linearly independent, and any integral vector in the linear hull of $F$ is an integral linear combination of $B$. This result is surprising as the integer points in $F$ do not necessarily form a Hilbert basis. In proving the result, we develop a theory similar to Matching Theory for degree-constrained dijoins in bipartite digraphs. Our result has consequences for head-disjoint strong orientations in hypergraphs, and also to a famous conjecture by Woodall that the minimum size of a dicut of $D$, say $τ$, is equal to the maximum number of disjoint dijoins. We prove a relaxation of this conjecture, by finding for any prime number $p\geq 2$, a $p$-adic packing of dijoins of value $τ$ and of support size at most $2|A|$. We also prove that the all-ones vector belongs to the lattice generated by $F\cap \{0,1\}^A$, where $F$ is the face of $P$ satisfying $x(δ^+(U))=1$ for every minimum dicut $δ^+(U)$.

In a digraph, a dicut is a cut where all the arcs cross in one direction. A dijoin is a subset of arcs that intersects each dicut. Woodall conjectured in 1976 that in every digraph, the minimum size of a dicut equals to the maximum number of disjoint dijoins. However, prior to our work, it was not even known whether at least $3$ disjoint dijoins exist in an arbitrary digraph whose minimum dicut size is sufficiently large. By building connections with nowhere-zero (circular) $k$-flows, we prove that every digraph with minimum dicut size $τ$ contains $\left\lfloor\fracτ{k}\right\rfloor$ disjoint dijoins if the underlying undirected graph admits a nowhere-zero (circular) $k$-flow. The existence of nowhere-zero $6$-flows in $2$-edge-connected graphs (Seymour 1981) directly leads to the existence of $\left\lfloor\fracτ{6}\right\rfloor$ disjoint dijoins in a digraph with minimum dicut size $τ$, which can be found in polynomial time as well. The existence of nowhere-zero circular $\frac{2p+1}{p}$-flows in $6p$-edge-connected graphs (Lovász et al. 2013) directly leads to the existence of $\left\lfloor\frac{τp}{2p+1}\right\rfloor$ disjoint dijoins in a digraph with minimum dicut size $τ$ whose underlying undirected graph is $6p$-edge-connected. We also discuss reformulations of Woodall's conjecture into packing strongly connected orientations.

Let $D=(V,A)$ be a digraph. For an integer $k\geq 1$, a $k$-arc-connected flip is an arc subset of $D$ such that after reversing the arcs in it the digraph becomes (strongly) $k$-arc-connected. The first main result of this paper introduces a sufficient condition for the existence of a $k$-arc-connected flip that is also a submodular flow for a crossing submodular function. More specifically, given some integer $τ\geq 1$, suppose $d_A^+(U)+(\fracτ{k}-1)d_A^-(U)\geq τ$ for all $U\subsetneq V, U\neq \emptyset$, where $d_A^+(U)$ and $d_A^-(U)$ denote the number of arcs in $A$ leaving and entering $U$, respectively. Let $\mathcal{C}$ be a crossing family over ground set $V$, and let $f:\mathcal{C}\to \mathbb{Z}$ be a crossing submodular function such that $f(U)\geq \frac{k}τ(d_A^+(U)-d_A^-(U))$ for all $U\in \mathcal{C}$. Then $D$ has a $k$-arc-connected flip $J$ such that $f(U)\geq d_J^+(U)-d_J^-(U)$ for all $U\in \mathcal{C}$. The result has several applications to Graph Orientations and Combinatorial Optimization. In particular, it strengthens Nash-Williams' so-called weak orientation theorem, and proves a weaker variant of Woodall's conjecture on digraphs whose underlying undirected graph is $τ$-edge-connected. The second main result of this paper is even more general. It introduces a sufficient condition for the existence of capacitated integral solutions to the intersection of two submodular flow systems. This sufficient condition implies the classic result of Edmonds and Giles on the box-total dual integrality of a submodular flow system. It also has the consequence that in a weakly connected digraph, the intersection of two submodular flow systems is totally dual integral.

A filter oracle for a clutter consists of a finite set $V$ along with an oracle which, given any set $X\subseteq V$, decides in unit time whether or not $X$ contains a member of the clutter. Let $\mathfrak{A}_{2n}$ be an algorithm that, given any clutter $\mathcal{C}$ over $2n$ elements via a filter oracle, decides whether or not $\mathcal{C}$ is ideal. We prove that in the worst case, $\mathfrak{A}_{2n}$ must make at least $2^n$ calls to the filter oracle. Our proof uses the theory of cuboids.

Let $D=(V,A)$ be a digraph. A dicut is a cut $δ^+(U)\subseteq A$ for some nonempty proper vertex subset $U$ such that $δ^-(U)=\emptyset$, a dijoin is an arc subset that intersects every dicut at least once, and more generally a $k$-dijoin is an arc subset that intersects every dicut at least $k$ times. Our first result is that $A$ can be partitioned into a dijoin and a $(τ-1)$-dijoin where $τ$ denotes the smallest size of a dicut. Woodall conjectured the stronger statement that $A$ can be partitioned into $τ$ dijoins. Let $w\in \mathbb{Z}^A_{\geq 0}$ and suppose every dicut has weight at least $τ$, for some integer $τ\geq 2$. Let $ρ(τ,D,w):=\frac{1}τ\sum_{v\in V} m_v$, where each $m_v$ is the integer in $\{0,1,\ldots,τ-1\}$ equal to $w(δ^+(v))-w(δ^-(v))$ mod $τ$. We prove the following results: (i) If $ρ(τ,D,w)\in \{0,1\}$, then there is an equitable $w$-weighted packing of dijoins of size $τ$. (ii) If $ρ(τ,D,w)= 2$, then there is a $w$-weighted packing of dijoins of size $τ$. (iii) If $ρ(τ,D,w)=3$, $τ=3$, and $w={\bf 1}$, then $A$ can be partitioned into three dijoins. Each result is best possible: (i) does not hold for $ρ(τ,D,w)=2$ even if $w=\1$, (ii) does not hold for $ρ(τ,D,w)=3$, and (iii) do not hold for general $w$.

A vector is \emph{dyadic} if each of its entries is a dyadic rational number, i.e. of the form $\frac{a}{2^k}$ for some integers $a,k$ with $k\geq 0$. A linear system $Ax\leq b$ with integral data is \emph{totally dual dyadic} if whenever $\min\{b^\top y:A^\top y=w,y\geq {\bf 0}\}$ for $w$ integral, has an optimal solution, it has a dyadic optimal solution. In this paper, we study total dual dyadicness, and give a co-NP characterization of it in terms of \emph{dyadic generating sets for cones and subspaces}, the former being the dyadic analogue of \emph{Hilbert bases}, and the latter a polynomial-time recognizable relaxation of the former. Along the way, we see some surprising turn of events when compared to total dual integrality, primarily led by the \emph{density} of the dyadic rationals. Our study ultimately leads to a better understanding of total dual integrality and polyhedral integrality. We see examples from dyadic matrices, $T$-joins, cycles, and perfect matchings of a graph.

A clutter is \emph{$k$-wise intersecting} if every $k$ members have a common element, yet no element belongs to all members. We conjecture that, for some integer $k\geq 4$, every $k$-wise intersecting clutter is non-ideal. As evidence for our conjecture, we prove it for $k=4$ for the class of binary clutters. Two key ingredients for our proof are Jaeger's $8$-flow theorem for graphs, and Seymour's characterization of the binary matroids with the sums of circuits property. As further evidence for our conjecture, we also note that it follows from an unpublished conjecture of Seymour from 1975. We also discuss connections to the chromatic number of a clutter, projective geometries over the two-element field, uniform cycle covers in graphs, and quarter-integral packings of value two in ideal clutters.

A clutter is \emph{clean} if it has no delta or the blocker of an extended odd hole minor, and it is \emph{tangled} if its covering number is two and every element appears in a minimum cover. Clean tangled clutters have been instrumental in progress towards several open problems on ideal clutters, including the $τ=2$ Conjecture. Let $\mathcal{C}$ be a clean tangled clutter. It was recently proved that $\mathcal{C}$ has a fractional packing of value two. Collecting the supports of all such fractional packings, we obtain what is called the {\it core} of $\mathcal{C}$. The core is a duplication of the cuboid of a set of $0-1$ points, called the {\it setcore} of $\mathcal{C}$. In this paper, we prove three results about the setcore. First, the convex hull of the setcore is a full-dimensional polytope containing the center point of the hypercube in its interior. Secondly, this polytope is a simplex if, and only if, the setcore is the cocycle space of a projective geometry over the two-element field. Finally, if this polytope is a simplex of dimension more than three, then $\mathcal{C}$ has the clutter of the lines of the Fano plane as a minor. Our results expose a fascinating interplay between the combinatorics and the geometry of clean tangled clutters.

A graph is {\em perfect} if, in all its induced subgraphs, the size of a largest clique is equal to the chromatic number. Examples of perfect graphs include bipartite graphs, line graphs of bipartite graphs and the complements of such graphs. These four classes of perfect graphs will be called {\em basic}. In 1960, Berge formulated two conjectures about perfect graphs, one stronger than the other. The weak perfect graph conjecture, which states that a graph is perfect if and only if its complement is perfect, was proved in 1972 by Lovász. This result is now known as the perfect graph theorem. The strong perfect graph conjecture (SPGC) states that a graph is perfect if and only if it does not contain an odd hole or its complement. The SPGC has attracted a lot of attention. It was proved recently (May 2002) in a remarkable sequence of results by Chudnovsky, Robertson, Seymour and Thomas. The proof is difficult and, as of this writing, they are still checking the details. Here we give a flavor of the proof.