arXiv++ Combinatorics

Let $F$ denote the Fano plane, the $3$-uniform hypergraph with $7$ vertices and $7$ edges. Frankl and Füredi, and independently Keevash and Sudakov, proved that the largest $F$-free subhypergraph of $K_n^{(3)}$ is bipartite. In this paper, we determine the sharp threshold for this property in the random setting. We show that for $\hat{p} = Θ_F \cdot n^{-2/3} \left(\log n\right)^{1/6}$, where $Θ_F$ is an explicit constant depending on $F$, we have: (i) if $(1+ε) \hat{p} \le p = o(1)$, then with high probability every largest $F$-free subhypergraph of $G_{n,p}^{(3)}$ is bipartite; and (ii) if $\frac{1}{n^2} \ll p \le (1-ε) \hat{p}$, then with high probability every largest $F$-free subhypergraph of $G_{n,p}^{(3)}$ is not bipartite. To the best of our knowledge, this work provides the first sharp threshold result obtained for a Turán-type problem in random hypergraphs.

We study the coupon collector's problem in a generalized setting where each draw reveals a fixed number of coupons and the sampling mechanism is required to be \emph{fair}, meaning that every coupon appears with the same frequency among the admissible draws. Grunbaum and Yaakobi conjectured that, among all fair mechanisms with fixed parameters, the fully random model maximizes the expected time to complete coverage. We disprove this conjecture by exhibiting explicit counterexamples arising from finite geometry. In particular, we show that the line set of the Fano plane yields a fair mechanism whose expected coverage time exceeds that of the full model. Further exact and computational results are obtained for projective planes of higher order. In addition, we analyze a simple infinite family of fair mechanisms, the star mechanism, for which the expected coverage time admits a closed form. Depending on the scaling regime, this mechanism can be asymptotically slower or faster than the full model, showing that no universal extremality principle holds for fair mechanisms without additional structural assumptions.

We use perfect matchings and labelled Fano planes to construct and study the $2025$ orthogonal bases of positive roots in the $E_8$ root system. The set of these bases forms a highly structured, Bruhat-like graded poset $(Ω, \leq_Q)$ whose rank function can be computed from the cardinalities of so-called generalized Rothe diagrams. We give combinatorial characterizations of these diagrams in terms of matchings and Fano planes, and we explain how to compute the ranks of the elements of $Ω$ using suitable combinatorial statistics such as the weights of perfect matchings. We establish simple formulas for the rank generating functions of $Ω$ and of its 50 congruence classes under a natural order congruence relation. Our derivation of the generating functions contains some intermediate results on general perfect matchings and labelled Fano planes that can be stated without mentioning root systems and may be of independent interest.

Our paper shows that if a matroid contains the Fano plane or its dual as a minor, then its toric ideal does not have any quadratic Gröbner basis. More than 25 years ago, Hibi, Herzog, and Sturmfels established a direct connection between the existence of quadratic Gröbner bases and regular unimodular flag triangulations. Our paper solves a famous question posed by Herzog and Hibi on a polyhedral reformulation for the existence of quadratic Gröbner bases: we show that the base polytopes of the Fano plane and its dual do not have regular unimodular flag triangulations which implies the main result on Gröbner bases. Our proof relies on several novel tools: a lemma that connects the $1$-skeleton of a lattice polytope to the lattice points in its dilations, an encoding with Boolean formulas and SAT solvers, and symmetry-breaking arguments.

Recently, Alon and Frankl (JCTB, 2024) determined the maximum number of edges in $K_{\ell+1}$-free $n$-vertex graphs with bounded matching number. For integers $\ell\ge r \ge 2$, the family $\mathcal{K}_{\ell+1}^{r}$ consists of all $r$-graphs $F$ with at most $\binom{\ell+1}{2}$ edges such that, for some $(\ell+1)$-set $K$, every pair $\{x,y\} \subseteq K$ is covered by an edge in $F$. In this paper, we study the maximum number of edges in $\mathcal{K}_{\ell+1}^r$-free $r$-uniform hypergraphs that have the matching number at most $s$, that is, $\mathrm{ex}_r(n, \{\mathcal{K}_{\ell+1}^r, M^r_{s+1}\})$, and obtain the exact value for sufficiently large $n$, along with the corresponding extremal hypergraph. This result can be viewed as a hypergraph extension of the work of Alon and Frankl. In addition, for the $3$-uniform Fano plane $\mathbb{F}$, we determine the exact value of $\mathrm{ex}_3(n, \{\mathbb{F}, M^3_{s+1}\})$, and characterize the corresponding extremal hypergraph.

It has long been known that the most symmetrical solutions of Kirkman's Schoolgirl Problem can be constructed from the $240$ packings of the projective space $PG(3, 2)$, but it seems to have escaped notice that these packings have the structure of a partially ordered set. In this paper, we construct a shellable Bruhat-like graded partial order on the packings of $PG(3, 2)$ that refines the partial order on the product of four chains $[8]\times[5]\times[3]\times[2]$ and defines a Lehmer code on the packings. The partial order exists because the packings of $PG(3, 2)$ form a quasiparabolic set (in the sense of Rains--Vazirani) that is in bijective correspondence with a certain collection of maximal orthogonal subsets of the $E_8$ root system. The $E_8$ construction also induces transitive actions of the Weyl groups of type $D_n$ on the packings for $5 \leq n \leq 8$, and these actions are faithful for $n < 8$. It is possible to define both the signed permutation action and the partial order using the combinatorics of labelled Fano planes.

Let $U$ be a set of positive roots of type $ADE$, and let $Ω_U$ be the set of all maximum cardinality orthogonal subsets of $U$. For each element $R \in Ω_U$, we define a generalized Rothe diagram whose cardinality we call the level, $ρ(R)$, of $R$. We define the generalized quantum Hafnian of $U$ to be the generating function of $ρ$, regarded as a $q$-polynomial in $U$. Several widely studied algebraic and combinatorial objects arise as special cases of these constructions, and in many cases, $Ω_U$ has the structure of a graded partially ordered set with rank function $ρ$. A motivating example of the construction involves a certain set of $k^2$ roots in type $D_{2k}$, where the elements of $Ω_U$ correspond to permutations in $S_k$, the generalized Rothe diagrams are the traditional Rothe diagrams associated to permutations, the level of a permutation is its length, the generalized quantum Hafnian is the $q$-permanent, and the partial order is the Bruhat order. We exhibit many other natural examples of this construction, including one involving perfect matchings, two involving labelled Fano planes, and one involving the invariant cubic form in type $E_6$.

We introduce a semigroup framework for Laplacians on directed hypergraphs, extending the classical heat flow models on graphs and establishing hypergraphs as prototypical models for non-Markovian diffusion. We apply spectral surgery methods to derive eigenvalue bounds, thus describing large-time behaviour of the heat flow. Unlike on standard graphs, heat flows on directed hypergraphs may lose positivity and/or $\infty$-contractivity, yet can recover them eventually or asymptotically under specific combinatorial configurations: examples based on duals of oriented graph and realisations of the Fano plane illustrate these phenomena. Our approach combines combinatorial, order-theoretic and linear-algebraic methods.

The "infamous upper tail problem" for $r$-uniform hypergraphs is to estimate the probability that the number of copies of a fixed hypergraph $H$ in a large binomial $r$-uniform hypergraph $\boldsymbol{G}$ exceeds its expectation by a constant factor. The problem was popularized by Janson and Ruciński and, particularly in the case of graphs ($r=2$), has been a driving example in the development of nonlinear large deviations theory. Recent work of the first author with Dembo and Pham has accomplished the \emph{naive mean-field reduction step}, reducing the upper tail problem to an entropic variational problem on a space of weighted graphs. The latter was resolved for counts of $r$-uniform cliques and a certain linear 3-uniform hypergraph by Liu and Zhao, who also conjectured a general formula. We confirm their conjecture for other classes of hypergraphs, including complete $r$-partite $r$-graphs, tight cycles, and the Fano plane. We also prove a general large deviation upper bound for counts of $r$-graphs $H$ satisfying certain edge covering properties.

We formulated a homological and computer-aided approach to study certain unions of symplectic surfaces, called symplectic configurations, in a rational $4$-manifold $X=CP^2\# N\overline{CP^2}$. We addressed several fundamental theoretical questions, and also as a technical device, developed a symplectic analog of the so-called quadratic Cremona transformations in complex algebraic geometry. As an application, we gave a new proof that a certain line arrangement in $CP^2$, called Fano planes, does not exist in the symplectic category. The nonexistence of Fano planes in the holomorphic category was due to Hirzebruch, and in the topological category, it was first proved by Ruberman and Starkston. Our proof in the symplectic category is independent to both.

A classical object in hypergraph Turán theory is the Fano plane $\mathbb{F}$, the unique linear $3$-graph on seven vertices with seven edges. The Turán density and exact Turán number of $\mathbb{F}$, first proposed as a problem by Sós \cite{Sos76} in the 1970s, were determined through a sequence of works by De Caen-Füredi \cite{DCF00}, Füredi-Simonovits \cite{FS05}, Keevash-Sudakov \cite{KS05}, and Bellmann-Reiher \cite{BR19}. Addressing a conjecture of Balogh-Clemen-Lidický \cite[Conjecture 3.1]{BCL22a}, we establish an Andrásfai-Erdős-Sós-type stability theorem for $\mathbb{F}$ in the $\ell_2$-norm: there exists a positive constant $\varepsilon$ such that for large $n$, every $\mathbb{F}$-free $3$-graph on $n$ vertices with minimum $\ell_2$-norm degree at least $(5/4 - \varepsilon)n^3$ must be bipartite. As a consequence, for large $n$, the balanced complete bipartite $3$-graph is the unique extremal construction for the $\ell_{2}$-norm Turán problem of $\mathbb{F}$, thereby confirming the conjecture of Balogh-Clemen-Lidický. Our proof includes a refinement of a classical result by Ahlswede-Katona \cite{AK78} on counting stars, and the establishment of an Andrásfai-Erdős-Sós-type theorem for a multigraph Turán problem studied by Bellmann-Reiher \cite{BR19}, both of which are of independent interest.

In this paper we introduce a $q$-analogue of the single-element extensions of matroids for $q$-matroids, which we call one-dimensional extensions. To enumerate such extensions, we define a $q$-analogue of modular cuts and define a certain function which we call a modular cut selector. It assigns each newly appearing one-dimensional subspace to a modular cut. By using these notion, we prove the one-to-one correspondence between the one-dimensional extensions and the modular cut selectors. Furthermore, we define the canonnical representatives of the isomorphic class of the $q$-matroids, which enable us to enumerate non-isomorphic $q$-matroids without the paiwise isomorphism testing. As an application, we develop a classification algorithm for $q$-matroids, and classify all the $q$-matroids on ground spaces over $\mathbb{F}_2$ and $\mathbb{F}_3$ of dimension $4$ and $5$ respectively. We also determine some $5$-dimensional $q$-matroids related to the $q$-Fano plane, which is the $q$-analogue of the Fano plane, over $\mathbb{F}_2$.

The Ruzsa-Szemerédi $(6,3)$-problem can be equivalently stated as determining the maximum number of edge-disjoint triangles on $n$ vertices such that no triangle is formed by edges from three distinct triangle-copies. Gowers and Janzer extended this problem by establishing an analogous result for complete graphs. A natural generalization of the two results, first introduced by Imolay, Karl, Nazy and Váli, asks for the maximum number of edge-disjoint copies of a graph $F$ on $n$ vertices such that no copy of $G$ is formed by edges originating from distinct $F$-copies. This maximum number, denoted by $ex_F(n,G)$, is called the {\em $F$-multicolor Turán number} of $G$. This paper focuses on the setting of uniform hypergraphs. We first prove that for $k$-uniform hypergraphs $\mathcal{G}$ and $\mathcal{F}$, $ex_{\mathcal{F}}(n,\mathcal{G})=o(n^k)$ if and only if there exists a homomorphism from $\mathcal{G}$ to $\mathcal{F}$. For degenerate case, we show that $ex_{\mathcal{F}}(n,\mathcal{G})=n^{k-o(1)}$ whenever $\mathcal{G}$ contains a $k$-uniform tight triangle. These results extend previous results. We further establish corresponding supersaturation and blowup statements. In the non-degenerate setting, we derive matching lower and upper bounds for $ex_{\mathcal{F}}(n,\mathcal{G})$. We give a necessary and sufficient condition for $ex_{\mathcal{F}}(n,\mathcal{G})$ to fail to attain the upper bound, under the assumption that the extremal graphs for $\mathcal{G}$ are stable. As an application, we refine a result due to Imolay, Karl, Nazy and Váli. Furthermore, we completely characterize $\mathcal{F}$ for which $ex_{\mathcal{F}}(n,\mathcal{G})$ does not attain the upper bound when $\mathcal{G}$ is one of the three special intersecting graphs: Fano plane, extended triangle and $r$-book of $r$-edges with $r=3,4$.

We consider seven fundamental properties of cellular embeddings of graphs in compact surfaces, and show that each property can be associated with a point of the Fano plane $F$, in such a way that allowable combinations of properties correspond to projective subspaces of $F$. This Fano framework allows us to deduce a number of implications involving the seven properties, providing new results and unifying existing ones. For each property, we provide a correspondence between embeddings with that property and an associated structure for $4$-regular graphs, using the medial graph of the graph embedding. We apply this to characterize when a graph embedding has a twisted dual with one of the properties. For each allowable combination of properties, we show that a graph embedding with these properties exists. We investigate connections between the seven properties and three weaker `Eulerian' properties. Our proofs involve parity conditions on closed walks in an extended version of the `gem' (graph-encoded map) representation of a graph embedding.

A new combinatorial object, called generalised nice set, is classified up to collineations of the Fano plane. This classification is necessary to find the graded contractions of all the exceptional complex Lie algebras of dimension at least 52, endowed with $\mathbb Z_2^3$-gradings coming from the octonions. Our classification is of purely combinatorial nature.

This article describes our invention of a new poetic form based on projective geometry. In doing this we also explore the 'what ifs' in mathematics and poetry which spark the creative processes of poet and mathematician. In other words, throughout our collaboration we often asked one another, is this what it's like for you? Do you think in this way, too? How does your experience of creativity compare to mine? And often, as well, what exactly do you mean when you say...? We spent a fair amount of time and energy, for example, trying to understand one another's interpretation of 'a line'. This collaboration resulted in three poems in the new projective plane form. We also consider what might be interesting avenues for future research, such as the incorporation of octonions in poetic form.

In this paper we present some geometrical representations of the Frobenius group of order $21$ (henceforth, $F_{21}$). The main focus is on investigating the group of common automorphisms of two orthogonal Fano planes and the automorphism group of a suitably oriented Fano plane. We show that both groups are isomorphic to $F_{21},$ independently of the choice of the two orthogonal Fano planes and of the choice of the orientation. We show, moreover, that any triangular embedding of the complete graph $K_7$ into a surface is isomorphic to the classical toroidal biembedding and hence is face $2$-colorable, with the two color classes defining a pair of orthogonal Fano planes. As a consequence, we show that, for any triangular embedding of $K_7$ into a surface, the group of the automorphisms that preserve the color classes is the Frobenius group of order $21.$ This way we provide three geometrical representations of $F_{21}$. Also, we apply the representation in terms of two orthogonal Fano planes to give an alternative proof that $F_{21}$ is the automorphism group of the Kirkman triple system of order $15$ that is usually denoted as #61.

An O'Nan configuration in a unital is a set of four lines forming a quadrilateral, where the six intersections of pairs of lines are points of the unital. In 2019 Feng and Li elegantly construct O'Nan configurations in orthogonal and Tits Buekenhout-Metz unitals. We extend their work by extending their construction to a Fano plane embedded in the orthogonal Buekenhout-Metz unital of even order. We deduce that there exist O'Nan configurations in orthogonal Buekenhout-Metz unitals different to those of Feng and Li, and make a conjecture about Fano planes embedded in orthogonal Buekenhout-Metz unitals.

Given a pair of $k$-uniform hypergraphs $(G,H)$, the Ramsey number of $(G,H)$, denoted by $R(G,H)$, is the smallest integer $n$ such that in every red/blue-colouring of the edges of $K_n^{(k)}$ there exists a red copy of $G$ or a blue copy of $H$. Burr showed that, for any pair of graphs $(G,H)$, where $G$ is large and connected, $R(G,H) \geq (v(G)-1)(χ(H)-1)+σ(H)$, where $σ(H)$ stands for the minimum size of a colour class over all proper $χ(H)$-colourings of $H$. We say that $G$ is $H$-good if $R(G,H)$ is equal to the general lower bound. Burr showed that, for any graph~$H$, every sufficiently long path is $H$-good. Our goal is to explore the notion of Ramsey goodness in the setting of $k$-uniform hypergraphs. We demonstrate that, in stark contrast to the graph case, $k$-uniform $\ell$-paths are not $H$-good for a large class of $k$-graphs. On the other hand, we prove that long loose paths are always at least asymptotically $H$-good for every $H$ and derive lower and upper bounds that are best possible in a certain sense. In the 3-uniform setting, we complement our negative result with a positive one, in which we determine the Ramsey number asymptotically for pairs containing a long tight path and a 3-graph $H$ when $H$ belongs to a certain family of hypergraphs. This extends a result of Balogh, Clemen, Skokan, and Wagner for the Fano plane asymptotically to a much larger family of 3-graphs.

We study the open and closed embedding dimensions of a convex 3-sparse code $\mathcal{FP}$, which records the intersection pattern of lines in the Fano plane. We show that the closed embedding dimension of $\mathcal{FP}$ is three, and the open embedding dimension is between four and six, providing the first example of a 3-sparse code with closed embedding dimension three and differing open and closed embedding dimensions. We also investigate codes whose canonical form is quadratic, i.e. ``degree two" codes. We show that such codes are realizable by axis-parallel boxes, generalizing a recent result of Zhou on inductively pierced codes. We pose several open questions regarding sparse and low-degree codes. In particular, we conjecture that the open embedding dimension of certain 3-sparse codes derived from Steiner triple systems grows to infinity.