arXiv++ Combinatorics

We give the first deterministic polynomial time algorithm that approximates the permanent of arbitrary nonnegative rational matrices within a subexponential factor. For a matrix of order $n$, the approximation factor is \[ \exp\!\left(O\!\left(\frac{n(\log\log n)^2}{\log n}\right)\right)=\exp(o(n)). \] All previously known deterministic polynomial time guarantees for unrestricted inputs had approximation factors $\exp(Ω(n))$. Our proof uses convex optimization to tighten an upper bound on the permanent. The bound is based on weighted sums over all matchings in a bipartite graph representing the matrix, and correlations between unmatched vertices control its error. We approximate these sums deterministically using correlation decay and a bound on the effect of vertex deletion.

We give deterministic FPTASes for two dense counting problems on which the known deterministic algorithms, based on zero-free interpolation, run in quasipolynomial time. For fixed $0<γ<1/2$ and $0<θ\leq1$, the first approximates $\mathrm{haf}(A)$ for a symmetric matrix $A$ when its support graph $G$ has minimum degree at least $(1/2+γ)n$ and its nonzero entries lie in $[θ,1]$. It also approximates permanents under the analogous bipartite condition, including full-support matrices in $[θ,1]$. For fixed $β>0$ and $0<κ\leq1$, the second approximates the zero-field Ising partition function $Z(J)$ for zero-diagonal real symmetric matrices $J$ satisfying $\max_{i,j}|J_{ij}|\leqβ/n$ and $λ_{\max}(J)\leq1-κ$. No separate lower-eigenvalue condition is imposed. We further prove $\log\mathrm{haf}(A)=h_A(G)-n/2+O_{γ,θ}(1)$ and $Z(J)=2^n\det(I-J)^{-1/2}(1+O_{β,κ}(1/n))$. Here $h_A(G)$ is the maximum weighted fractional-matching entropy. For unweighted graphs, the first formula improves the Cuckler--Kahn error from $o(n)$ to $O_γ(1)$ on the fixed-margin class and extends it to weights in $[θ,1]$. Both algorithms use a common Gaussian truncation principle. Each problem becomes an integral of a product of a fixed entire function over Gaussian coordinates, with possibly indefinite moment matrix entries of order $1/n$. Cancelling the linear term and exactly resumming the quadratic term leaves a coordinate remainder vanishing to order at least three. Complex dilation handles small supports. For large supports, we bound the recombined tail by a large-deviation rate that beats the entropy of the subsets. The truncation error is at most $(CR/n)^{R/2}+e^{-cn}$. This faster-than-geometric decay permits $R\log(en/R)=O(\log n+\log(1/ε))$ and hence polynomial enumeration.

For an $n\times n$ nonnegative matrix $A$, the Bethe permanent, which is computable in deterministic polynomial time, satisfies the tight universal comparison \[\operatorname{Bethe}(A) \leq \operatorname{per}(A) \leq 2^{n/2}\operatorname{Bethe}(A).\] The lower bound, due to Gurvits, is attained on forests. The upper bound, due to Anari and Rezaei, is attained by the adjacency matrix of a disjoint union of $4$-cycles. Confirming a conjecture of Anari, we provide an optimal girth-dependent refinement of the above comparison. More precisely, we show that if the bipartite support graph of $A$ has girth at least an even integer $g \geq 4$, then \[\operatorname{Bethe}(A) \leq \operatorname{per}(A) \leq 2^{2n/g}\operatorname{Bethe}(A).\] The upper bound is attained by the adjacency matrix of a disjoint union of $g$-cycles.

We study deterministic approximation algorithms for the permanent of a nonnegative matrix through the Bethe permanent, an approximation computable in polynomial time. The tight analysis of Anari and Rezaei gives a universal comparison between the permanent and the Bethe permanent within a factor $(\sqrt 2)^n$. The simple example of the unweighted $4$-cycle $C_4$ (or a union of disjoint $C_4$'s) shows that this bound is tight. We show that such $4$-cycle obstructions can be identified and exploited algorithmically. Given a Bethe optimizer, our algorithm identifies nearly isolated weighted $2\times2$ blocks and peels off a vertex-disjoint family of them. If the total weighted correction is large, we can improve the Bethe approximation; if it is small, we show that the Bethe permanent is within a factor of $(\sqrt2 - \varepsilon)^n$ of the truth. Combining these facts, we obtain a deterministic polynomial time $(\sqrt2-\varepsilon)^n$-approximation algorithm for the permanent of an arbitrary nonnegative $n\times n$ matrix, where $\varepsilon>0$ is some absolute constant.

The canonical Bethe approximation gives a deterministic approximation to the permanent of every nonnegative matrix within a factor of $(\sqrt{2})^n$. We improve the base of this exponential factor: for some absolute constant $c<\sqrt{2}$, there is a deterministic polynomial-time $c^n$-approximation for the permanent of every nonnegative matrix. This shows that the canonical Bethe guarantee is not a barrier for deterministic approximation of the permanent. The proof augments the Bethe lower bound with a new certificate tailored to matrices on which that lower bound loses nearly the full factor. The author supplied the high-level plan of attack, and the proof was developed in an interaction with ChatGPT 5.6 Sol Pro. The author subsequently verified the results. Codex assisted with proof checking, manuscript assembly, and typesetting.

Bang (1976) proved the inequality for matrix permanents $\mathrm{per}^2(A) \geq 2^{-2n}\mathrm{per}(A \otimes J_2)$, where $J_2$ is the $2 \times 2$ all-ones matrix and $A$ is any $n \times n$ matrix with non-negative entries. We show that, if $A$ is any $n \times n$ real-valued matrix with rank at most two (possibly having negative entries), this inequality can be sharpened, replacing the constant $2^{-2n}$ by $1 / \binom{2n}{n} = (n!)^2 / (2n)! > 2^{-2n}$. We then show that this sharpened inequality also implies new inequalities for finite free convolutions of polynomials: if $p$ and $q$ are monic real-rooted polynomials of degree $n$, then $(p \boxplus_n q)(x)^2 \geq (p^2 \boxplus_{2n} q^2)(x)$ and $(p \boxtimes_n q)(x)^2 \geq (p^2 \boxtimes_{2n} q^2)(x)$ for all $x \in \mathbb{R}$, for $\boxplus_n$ and $\boxtimes_n$ the finite free additive and multiplicative convolution operations, respectively, on polynomials of degree $n$.

Let $G$ be a simple graph of order $n$ with adjacency matrix $A= (a_{ij})$. The \emph{determinant} and the \emph{permanen}t of the matrix $A$ are defined as \[\mathrm{det}A= \sum_{σ\in S_n}\mathrm{sgn}(σ) \prod_{i=1}^n a_{iσ(i)}\quad\text{and}\quad\mathrm{per}A= \sum_{σ\in S_n} \prod_{i=1}^n a_{iσ(i)},\]respectively. The polynomials $φ(G;x) =\mathrm{det}(xI-A(G))$ and $π(G;x) =\mathrm{per}(xI-A(G))$ are called the \emph{characteristic polynomial} and the \emph{permanental polynomial} of $G$, respectively. Two graphs are said to be \emph{nearly cospectral} with respect to the determinant (resp. permanent) if the difference of their characteristic (resp. permanental) polynomials is a constant. Lv et al. introduced the nearly cospectral graphs problem with respect to the determinant, and provided partial results in the case modulo 4. In this paper, we mainly prove that the corresponding results also hold for the nearly cospectral graphs problem with respect to the permanent. The determinant and permanent are the immanants corresponding to the irreducible characters $(1^n)$ and $(n)$ of the symmetric group $ S_n $, respectively. Here, the \emph{immanant} $d_λ(A)$ of $A$ is defined as \[d_λ(A) = \sum_{σ\in S_n} χ_λ(σ) \prod_{i=1}^n a_{iσ(i)},\] where $χ_λ$ is the irreducible character of $ S_n $ indexed by the partition $ λ$. The immanantal polynomial of $G$ associated with $ χ_λ$ is given by $ φ_λ(G;x)=d_λ(xI-A) $. In this paper, we also establish a similar result for nearly immanantal cospectral graphs in $\mathbb{F}_2[x]$ for all irreducible characters $χ_λ$.

Let $Γ$ be a finite group of order $k\ge2$, and label the edges of a simple loopless $d$-regular digraph $D$ by elements of $Γ$. A directed cycle is zero-sum if the ordered product of its labels is the identity of $Γ$. We prove that a zero-sum cycle exists whenever $d\ge e^3(k-1)$. We also prove that every labelled $d$-regular digraph contains $Ω(d/k)$ pairwise vertex-disjoint zero-sum cycles. When $d\ge50k$, it contains $Ω(d^2/k)$ pairwise edge-disjoint zero-sum cycles. All three results are asymptotically optimal. The existence and packing results extend to Eulerian digraphs whose minimum and maximum common degrees $δ$ and $Δ$ satisfy $δ^3/Δ^2=Ω(k)$. The techniques extend a determinant--permanent argument of Friedland for even directed cycles.

The Foregger-Sinkhorn tie-point conjecture asserts that if a nearly decomposable doubly stochastic matrix minimizes the permanent on a face and the permanental cofactor at a prescribed zero is larger than its permanent, then that zero is a tie point. We give a counterexample in dimension eight.

Dittert's conjecture asserts that, among nonnegative $n\times n$ matrices whose entries sum to $n$, the functional $φ(A)=\prod_{i=1}^n r_i+\prod_{j=1}^n c_j-\operatorname{per}(A)$ is uniquely maximized by the uniform matrix $J_n/n$. This paper proves the conjecture for $n=16$. The key observation is that, for a near-maximizer, the deficits of the row-sum and column-sum products satisfy a single joint constraint rather than two independent bounds. Combining this joint-deficit estimate with a Pinsker-type subset-sum bound yields a sharper scalar dilation to a doubly superstochastic matrix. The Knopp-Sinkhorn boundary lower bound for permanents then excludes maximizers with a zero entry, and Hwang's positive-support theorem identifies the unique maximizer. Together with Pang's result for $n\ge 17$ (arXiv:2606.01531), this establishes Dittert's conjecture for every $n\ge 16$.

We investigate the combinatorial structure of the tropical characteristic polynomial of symmetric matrices using the tropical permanents of their principal submatrices. We establish new inequalities for the leading coefficients of the tropical characteristic polynomial, revealing concavity properties of the coefficient sequence and yielding necessary conditions for a sequence to arise as the coefficient sequence of the tropical characteristic polynomial of a symmetric matrix. These results provide a deeper understanding of the structure of tropical characteristic polynomials associated with symmetric matrices.

Fix $n \ge 2$. A set $A = \{a_0 < a_1 < \dots < a_{n-1}\}$ of $n$ residues in $\Z_N$ is \emph{valid mod $N$} if the all-ones multiset is the \emph{only} size-$n$ multiset drawn from $A$ whose sum is $p := \sum_i a_i \pmod N$. For the super-increasing set $A = \{2^k - 1 : 0 \le k \le n-1\}$ we determine the least valid modulus exactly: $\Nmin(n) = 2^{\,n} - 2^{\lfloor \log_2 n \rfloor}$ for all $n \ge 2$. Both directions of the proof are elementary, resting on a sharp minimal-digit-sum estimate for representations by binary coins, and the full theorem has been machine-checked in Lean~4/Mathlib for all $n$ (https://github.com/jarfo/min-modulus). We conjecture that no size-$n$ residue set admits a smaller valid modulus. This validity condition is exactly what makes the permanent of an $n \times n$ matrix equal to a single coefficient of a row-product polynomial modulo $x^N - 1$, extractable by a size-$N$ discrete Fourier (or number-theoretic) transform; the theorem thus identifies the smallest transform, $N \approx 2^n$, for which this evaluation is exact. That application -- and the resulting common framework for the classical formulas of Ryser and Glynn and this transform -- is developed in a companion paper [2].

We study the number $\Nu(\Per(G_λ))$ of distinct monomials with nonzero coefficients in the group permanent of an abelian $p$-group $G_λ$ associated with a partition $λ$ of a positive integer $N$. First, we derive an explicit formula for $\Nu(\Per(G_λ))$ in terms of the partial column sums of the Young diagram of $λ$. Next, we show that the relative order of the values $\Nu(\Per(G_λ))$ is determined by a lexicographic comparison of the conjugate Young diagrams. Finally, we investigate congruence properties of $\Nu(\Per(G_λ))$ for abelian $p$-groups and establish a criterion involving Wolstenholme primes.

Given a square matrix, the permanent is a determinant-like function without signs. In this paper, we study inequalities involving permanents of certain submatrices. We first focus on a family of zero-one totally nonnegative matrices that arise as anti-adjacency matrices of unit interval orders. For these matrices, we prove a collection of inequalities comparing products of permanents of consecutive principal submatrices with products of permanents of parity-selected principal submatrices. We also study a related combinatorial problem involving two families of permutations: a Young subgroup and a set of parity alternating permutations. We construct a bijective map from the first family to the second family, and verify computationally for n at most 13 that each permutation is below its image in Bruhat order. We conjecture that this property holds for all n. If true, this would imply one of the main permanent inequalities for all totally nonnegative matrices in the balanced case. More broadly, we conjecture that the full family of inequalities holds for all totally nonnegative matrices.

Consider a symmetric function $\mathcal{C}(x,y)$ on $[0,1]\times[0,1]$ which is twice continuously differentiable up to the boundary, and which satisfies $ \mathcal{C}(x,y)=\mathcal{C}(1-x,1-y)$. Let $A^{(n)} = \big(a^{(n)}_{i,j}\, :\, i,j \in [n]\big)$ be the matrix with entries $a^{(n)}_{i,j}\, =\, \exp(-\mathcal{C}(i/n,j/n))$. Soumik Pal conjectured the asymptotics $$\operatorname{perm}\big(A^{(n)}\big)/n!\sim \exp\big(n Λ[\mathcal{C}]\big)/ \sqrt{\mathcal{D}[\mathcal{C}]}$$ as $n \to \infty$ for known functionals that arise naturally in the context of entropy regularized optimal transport. The functional $Λ[\mathcal{C}]$ is the known large deviation rate function, already proved rigorously by Sumit Mukherjee. It is $\int_{0}^1 \int_0^{1} (α(x)+β(y))\, dx\, dy$ where $α(x)+β(y)$ is chosen such that $ρ(x,y) := \exp(-\mathcal{C}(x,y)-α(x)-β(y))$ has uniform marginals. The algebraic term $\mathcal{D}[c]$ is given by Peter McCullagh's formula for doubly stochastic matrices: $\operatorname{det}_F(I+J-T^*T)$, the Fredholm determinant, where $I$ is the identity on $L^2([0,1])$, $Jf(x) \equiv \int_{0}^1 f(z)\, dz$ (for all $x$) and $Tf(x) = \int_0^1 ρ(x,y) f(y)\, dy$. We prove the conjecture for functions $\mathcal C$ that are constant on blocks, exploiting a well-known Ross Pinsky's combinatorial decomposition of permutations in blocks.

This paper studies generalized Pólya conversion problems for the $q$-permanent \[ \operatorname{P}_q(A)=\sum_{σ\in S_n} q^{\ell(σ)} a_{1,σ(1)} \cdots a_{n,σ(n)}, \] where $q\in\mathbb{C}^*$ and $\ell(σ)$ is the permutation length. We show that for $n\geq 3$ and $q\neq \pm1$, the $q$-permanent is not linearly convertible to the determinant or the permanent, and we completely classify and give a geometric interpretation of the special case $n=2$. Focusing on Schur multiplier transformations, we characterize the space of Schur multiplier preservers. For $|q|\neq1$, the preserver exponents is a $(2n-2)$-dimensional vector space consisting of additive matrices satisfying a discrete Monge relation. In contrast, for $q$ on the unit circle, the solution space becomes a countable union of affine lattices. For lower Hessenberg matrices, we prove that the rigidity phenomenon disappears, yielding an explicit determinantal reduction of the $q$-permanent and an $O(n^3)$ evaluation algorithm. The central results of this paper establish sharp rigidity thresholds governing permutational symmetries and mixed conversion identities. First, we classify permutational converter exponents and show that, for $n\geq4$, the admissible symmetries are precisely the elements of the dihedral group. Second, we solve a mixed conversion problem that expresses the $q$-permanent as a linear combination of the determinant and the permanent, and prove that the corresponding solution space is nonempty if and only if $n\leq4$, in which case it decomposes into finitely many affine components modeled on the preserver exponent space. This mixed formulation yields a direct algebraic characterization of the $q$-permanent's zero locus for $n \le 4$ via a generalized Pólya identity.

For a graph \(G\) with no isolated vertices, its Laplacian ratio is defined as \[ π(G)=\frac{\operatorname{per}(L(G))}{\prod_{v\in V(G)} d(v)}, \] where \(L(G)\) is the Laplacian matrix of \(G\), \(d(v)\) is the degree of \(v\), and \(\operatorname{per}\) denotes the permanent. Brualdi and Goldwasser asked for the maximum value of \(π(T)\) among trees \(T\) with a fixed number of vertices. Wu, Dong and Lai recently proposed a conjectural answer to this problem. We give infinite families of counterexamples to their conjecture.

Several graph decompositions that factorize the determinant of the adjacency matrix isolate a Kőnig-Egerváry part, such as the SD--KE decomposition and the critical independence decomposition of Larson. This suggests that the study of graph unimodularity can be approached, to a large extent, through the structure of Kőnig-Egerváry graphs. In this paper we advance this point of view by introducing a new determinant factorization inside the class of Kőnig-Egerváry graphs. More precisely, given a Kőnig-Egerváry graph $G$, we consider the partition of $V(G)$ into its perfect-flower part $PF(G)$ and its perfect-flower-free part $PFF(G)$, and prove that \[ \det(G)=\det(G[PF(G)])\det(G[PFF(G)]). \] We also obtain the analogous factorization for the permanent. This decomposition provides a new tool for the study of unimodularity, reducing the problem to two induced subgraphs of a very different nature: the graph $G[PF(G)]$, whose structure is closely related to Sterboul--Deming configurations with perfect matching, and the graph $G[PFF(G)]$, which is governed by the theory of critical independent sets. In this way, the paper gives a new structural framework for the study of unimodular graphs through Kőnig-Egerváry theory.

In 1982, Chollet conjectured that $\mathrm{per}(A\circ B)\le \mathrm{per}(A)\mathrm{per}(B)$ for Hermitian positive semidefinite matrices $A,B$, where $\circ$ denotes the Hadamard product, and observed that in the real symmetric case it suffices to prove $\mathrm{per}(A\circ A)\le \mathrm{per}(A)^2$. We prove $\mathrm{per}(A\circ A)\le \mathrm{per}(A)^2$ for symmetric $Z$-matrices with nonnegative diagonal whose support graph is bipartite. Motivated by this, we study the Laplacian inequality $\mathrm{per}(L_G\circ L_G)\le \mathrm{per}(L_G)^2$ for the graph Laplacian $L_G$. We introduce a compositional framework for permanental inequalities on graph Laplacians, showing that Chollet's inequality is preserved under vertex coalescence. This enables the extension of the inequality from basic graph classes to large structured families, revealing new tractable regimes for a fundamentally $\#P$-hard quantity.

The algebraic degree of a network game measures the complexity of its totally mixed Nash equilibria. For sparse multilinear network games, Datta's formula expresses this degree combinatorially in terms of a permanent, but the geometric origin of this formula has remained unclear. In this paper, we provide a tropical-geometric derivation of Datta's formula by identifying totally mixed equilibria with stable intersection points of tropical hypersurfaces associated with the indifference equations. We show that the mixed cells arising from the multilinear Newton polytope structure induce the cycle-cover combinatorics of the polynomial graph, so that the permanent appears as a tropical intersection count. This interpretation yields several structural consequences. We prove that the algebraic degree is multiplicative over strongly connected components, and we establish a sharp contrast between two basic multilayer coupling mechanisms: Cartesian-type couplings remain bounded through a transfer-matrix trace formula, whereas tensor-type couplings exhibit exponential growth governed by the permanent of a local gadget. These results show that algebraic degree provides a structural complexity invariant for network architecture. We further illustrate the theory on coupled cyclic games and networked energy-market models, and we support the theoretical predictions with numerical experiments based on homotopy continuation.