arXiv++ Combinatorics

We study deterministic approximation algorithms for the permanent of a nonnegative matrix through the Bethe permanent, an approximation computable in polynomial time. The tight analysis of Anari and Rezaei gives a universal comparison between the permanent and the Bethe permanent within a factor $(\sqrt 2)^n$. The simple example of the unweighted $4$-cycle $C_4$ (or a union of disjoint $C_4$'s) shows that this bound is tight. We show that such $4$-cycle obstructions can be identified and exploited algorithmically. Given a Bethe optimizer, our algorithm identifies nearly isolated weighted $2\times2$ blocks and peels off a vertex-disjoint family of them. If the total weighted correction is large, we can improve the Bethe approximation; if it is small, we show that the Bethe permanent is within a factor of $(\sqrt2 - \varepsilon)^n$ of the truth. Combining these facts, we obtain a deterministic polynomial time $(\sqrt2-\varepsilon)^n$-approximation algorithm for the permanent of an arbitrary nonnegative $n\times n$ matrix, where $\varepsilon>0$ is some absolute constant.

We compute the logarithmic asymptotics of the non-existence probability (and more generally the lower-tail probability) for a wide variety of combinatorial problems for a range of parameters in the `critical regime' between the regime amenable to hypergraph container methods and that amenable to Janson's inequality. Examples include lower tails and non-existence probabilities for subgraphs of random graphs and for $k$-term arithmetic progressions in random sets of integers. Our methods apply in the general framework of estimating the probability that a $p$-random subset of vertices in a $k$-uniform hypergraph induces significantly fewer hyperedges than expected. We show that under some simple structural conditions on the hypergraph and an upper bound on $p$ determined by a phase transition in the hard-core model on the infinite $k$-uniform, $Δ$-regular, linear hypertree, this probability can be accurately approximated by the Bethe free energy evaluated at the unique fixed point of a Belief Propagation operator on the hypergraph.

In 1970 Hajnal and Szemerédi proved a conjecture of Erdös that for a graph with maximum degree $Δ$, there exists an equitable $Δ+1$ coloring; that is a coloring where color class sizes differ by at most $1$. In 2007 Kierstand and Kostochka reproved their result and provided a polynomial-time algorithm which produces such a coloring. In this paper we study the problem of approximately sampling uniformly random equitable colorings. A series of works gives polynomial-time sampling algorithms for colorings without the color class constraint, the latest improvement being by Carlson and Vigoda for $q\geq 1.809 Δ$. In this paper we give a polynomial-time sampling algorithm for equitable colorings when $q> 2Δ$. Moreover, our results extend to colorings with small deviations from equitable (and as a corollary, establishing their existence). The proof uses the framework of the geometry of polynomials for multivariate polynomials, and as a consequence establishes a multivariate local Central Limit Theorem for color class sizes of uniform random colorings.

We study the chromatic number of typical triangle-free graphs with $Θ\left( n^{3/2} (\log n)^{1/2} \right)$ edges and establish the width of the scaling window for the transitions from $χ= 3$ to $χ= 4$ and from $χ= 4$ to $χ= 5$. The transition from $3$- to $4$-colorability has scaling window of width $Θ(n^{4/3} (\log n)^{-1/3})$. To prove this, we show a high probability equivalence of the $3$-colorability of a random triangle-free graph at this density and the satisfiability of an instance of bipartite random $2$-SAT, for which we establish the width of the scaling window following the techniques of Bollob{á}s, Borgs, Chayes, Kim, and Wilson. The transition from $4$- to $5$-colorability has scaling window of width $Θ(n^{3/2} (\log n)^{-1/2})$. To prove this, we show a high probability equivalence of the $4$-colorability of a random triangle-free graph at this density and the simultaneous $2$-colorability of two independent Erdős--Rényi random graphs. For this transition, we also establish the limiting probability of $4$-colorability inside the scaling window.

We analyze the asymptotic number and typical structure of claw-free graphs at constant edge densities. The first of our main results is a formula for the asymptotics of the logarithm of the number of claw-free graphs of edge density $γ\in (0,1)$. We show that the problem exhibits a second-order phase transition at edge density $γ^\ast=\frac{5-\sqrt{5}}{4}$. The asymptotic formula arises by solving a variational problem over graphons. For $γ\geqγ^\ast$ there is a unique optimal graphon, while for $γ<γ^\ast$ there is an infinite set of optimal graphons. By analyzing more detailed structure, we prove that for $γ<γ^\ast$, there is in fact a unique graphon $W$ such that almost all claw-free graphs at edge density $γ$ are close in cut metric to $W$. We also analyze the probability of claw-freeness in the Erdős-Rényi random graph $G(n,p)$ for constant $p$, obtaining a formula for the large-deviation rate function for claw-freeness. In this case, the problem exhibits a first-order phase transition at $p^\ast=\frac{3-\sqrt{5}}{2}$, separating distinct structural regimes. At the critical point $p^\ast$, the corresponding graphon variational problem has infinitely many solutions, and we again pinpoint a unique optimal graphon that describes the typical structure of $G(n,p^\ast)$ conditioned on being claw-free.

We study the probability that the random graph $G(n,p)$ is triangle-free. When $p =o(n^{-1/2})$ or $p = ω(n^{-1/2})$ the asymptotics of the logarithm of this probability are known via Janson's inequality in the former case and via regularity or hypergraph container methods in the latter case. We prove for the first time an asymptotic formula for the logarithm of this probability when $p = c n^{-1/2}$ for $c$ a sufficiently small constant. More generally, we study lower-tail large deviations for triangles in random graphs: the probability that $G(n,p)$ has at most $η$ times its expected number of triangles, when $p = c n^{-1/2}$ for $c$ and $η\in [0,1)$ constant. Our results apply for all $c$ if $η\ge .4993$ and for $c$ small enough otherwise. For $η$ small (including the case of triangle-freeness), we prove that a phase transition occurs as $c$ varies, in the sense of a non-analyticity of the rate function, while for $η\ge .4993$ we prove that no phase transition occurs. On the other hand for the random graph $G(n,m)$, with $m = b n^{3/2}$, we show that a phase transition occurs in the lower-tail problem for triangles as $b$ varies for \emph{every} $η\in [0,1)$. Our method involves ingredients from algorithms and statistical physics including the cluster expansion and concentration inequalities for contractive Markov chains.

We study the following combinatorial counting and sampling problems: can we efficiently sample from the Erdős-Rényi random graph $G(n,p)$ conditioned on triangle-freeness? Can we efficiently approximate the probability that $G(n,p)$ is triangle-free? These are prototypical instances of forbidden substructure problems ubiquitous in combinatorics. The algorithmic questions are instances of approximate counting and sampling for a hypergraph hard-core model. Estimating the probability that $G(n,p)$ has no triangles is a fundamental question in probabilistic combinatorics and one that has led to the development of many important tools in the field. Through the work of several authors, the asymptotics of the logarithm of this probability are known if $p =o( n^{-1/2})$ or if $p =ω( n^{-1/2})$. The regime $p = Θ(n^{-1/2})$ is more mysterious, as this range witnesses a dramatic change in the the typical structural properties of $G(n,p)$ conditioned on triangle-freeness. As we show, this change in structure has a profound impact on the performance of sampling algorithms. We give two different efficient sampling algorithms for triangle-free graphs (and complementary algorithms to approximate the triangle-freeness large deviation probability), one that is efficient when $p < c/\sqrt{n}$ and one that is efficient when $p > C/\sqrt{n}$ for constants $c, C>0$. The latter algorithm involves a new approach for dealing with large defects in the setting of sampling from low-temperature spin models.

We study the worst-case mixing time of the global Kawasaki dynamics for the fixed-magnetization Ising model on the class of graphs of maximum degree $Δ$. Proving a conjecture of Carlson, Davies, Kolla, and Perkins, we show that below the tree uniqueness threshold, the Kawasaki dynamics mix rapidly for all magnetizations. Disproving a conjecture of Carlson, Davies, Kolla, and Perkins, we show that the regime of fast mixing does not extend throughout the regime of tractability for this model: there is a range of parameters for which there exist efficient sampling algorithms for the fixed-magnetization Ising model on max-degree $Δ$ graphs, but the Kawasaki dynamics can take exponential time to mix. Our techniques involve showing spectral independence in the fixed-magnetization Ising model and proving a sharp threshold for the existence of multiple metastable states in the Ising model with external field on random regular graphs.

We survey the current state of affairs in the study of thresholds and sharp thresholds in random structures on the occasion of the recent proof of the Kahn--Kalai Conjecture by Park and Pham and the fairly recent proof of the satisfiability conjecture for large $k$ by Ding, Sly, and Sun. Random discrete structures appear as fundamental objects of study in many scientific and mathematical fields including statistical physics, combinatorics, algorithms and complexity, social choice theory, coding theory, and statistics. While the models and properties of interest in these fields vary widely, much progress has been made through the development of general tools applicable to large families of models and properties all at once. Historically these tools originated to solve or make progress on specific, difficult conjectures in the areas mentioned above. We will survey recent progress on some of these hard problems and describe some challenges for the future.

We study the typical structure and the number of triangle-free graphs with $n$ vertices and $m$ edges where $m$ is large enough so that a typical triangle-free graph has a cut containing nearly all of its edges, but may not be bipartite. Erdős, Kleitman, and Rothschild showed that almost every triangle-free graph is bipartite. Osthus, Prömel, and Taraz later showed that for $m \ge (1+ε)\frac{\sqrt{3}}{4}n^{3/2}\sqrt{\log n}$, almost every triangle-free graph on $n$ vertices and $m$ edges is bipartite. Here we give a precise characterization of the distribution of edges within each part of the max cut of a uniformly chosen triangle-free graph $G$ on $n$ vertices and $m$ edges, for a larger range of densities with $m=Θ(n^{3/2} \sqrt{\log n})$. Using this characterization, we describe the evolution of the structure of typical triangle-free graphs as the density changes. We show that as the number of edges decreases below $\frac{\sqrt{3}}{4} n^{3/2}\sqrt{\log n}$, the following structural changes occur in $G$: -Isolated edges, then trees, then more complex subgraphs emerge as `defect edges', edges within parts of a max cut of $G$. The distribution of defect edges is first that of independent Erdős-Rényi random graphs, then that of independent exponential random graphs, conditioned on a small maximum degree and no triangles. -There is a sharp threshold for $3$-colorability at $m \sim \frac{\sqrt{2}}{4} n^{3/2}\sqrt{\log n}$ and a sharp threshold between $4$-colorability and unbounded chromatic number at $m\sim\frac{1}{4}n^{3/2}\sqrt{\log n}$. -Giant components emerge in the defect edges at $m\sim\frac{1}{4} n^{3/2}\sqrt{\log n}$. We use these results to prove asymptotic formulas for the number of triangle-free graphs at these densities. We likewise prove analogous results for the random graph $G(n,p)$ conditioned on triangle-freeness.

We consider the algorithmic problem of finding large \textit{balanced} independent sets in sparse random bipartite graphs, and more generally the problem of finding independent sets with specified proportions of vertices on each side of the bipartition. In a bipartite graph it is trivial to find an independent set of density at least half (take one of the partition classes). In contrast, in a random bipartite graph of average degree $d$, the largest balanced independent sets (containing equal number of vertices from each class) are typically of density $(2+o_d(1)) \frac{\log d}{d}$. Can we find such large balanced independent sets in these graphs efficiently? By utilizing the overlap gap property and the low-degree algorithmic framework, we prove that local and low-degree algorithms (even those that know the bipartition) cannot find balanced independent sets of density greater than $(1+ε) \frac{\log d}{d}$ for any $ε>0$ fixed and $d$ large but constant. This factor $2$ statistical--computational gap between what exists and what local algorithms can achieve is analogous to the gap for finding large independent sets in (non-bipartite) random graphs. Our results therefor suggest that this gap is pervasive in many models, and that hard computational problems can lurk inside otherwise tractable ones. A particularly striking aspect of the gap in bipartite graphs is that the algorithm achieving the lower bound is extremely simple and can be implemented as a $1$-local algorithm and a degree-$1$ polynomial (a linear function).

We prove tight bounds on the site percolation threshold for $k$-uniform hypergraphs of maximum degree $Δ$ and for $k$-uniform hypergraphs of maximum degree $Δ$ in which any pair of edges overlaps in at most $r$ vertices. The hypergraphs that achieve these bounds are hypertrees, but unlike in the case of graphs, there are many different $k$-uniform, $Δ$-regular hypertrees. Determining the extremal tree for a given $k, Δ, r$ involves an optimization problem, and our bounds arise from a convex relaxation of this problem. By combining our percolation bounds with the method of disagreement percolation we obtain improved bounds on the uniqueness threshold for the hard-core model on hypergraphs satisfying the same constraints. Our uniqueness conditions imply exponential weak spatial mixing, and go beyond the known bounds for rapid mixing of local Markov chains and existence of efficient approximate counting and sampling algorithms. Our results lead to natural conjectures regarding the aforementioned algorithmic tasks, based on the intuition that uniqueness thresholds for the extremal hypertrees for percolation determine computational thresholds.

We study the locations of complex zeroes of independence polynomials of bounded degree hypergraphs. For graphs, this is a long-studied subject with applications to statistical physics, algorithms, and combinatorics. Results on zero-free regions for bounded-degree graphs include Shearer's result on the optimal zero-free disk, along with several recent results on other zero-free regions. Much less is known for hypergraphs. We make some steps towards an understanding of zero-free regions for bounded-degree hypergaphs by proving that all hypergraphs of maximum degree $Δ$ have a zero-free disk almost as large as the optimal disk for graphs of maximum degree $Δ$ established by Shearer (of radius $\sim 1/(e Δ)$). Up to logarithmic factors in $Δ$ this is optimal, even for hypergraphs with all edge-sizes strictly greater than $2$. We conjecture that for $k\ge 3$, $k$-uniform linear hypergraphs have a much larger zero-free disk of radius $Ω(Δ^{- \frac{1}{k-1}} )$. We establish this in the case of linear hypertrees.

The ferromagnetic Ising model is a model of a magnetic material and a central topic in statistical physics. It also plays a starring role in the algorithmic study of approximate counting: approximating the partition function of the ferromagnetic Ising model with uniform external field is tractable at all temperatures and on all graphs, due to the randomized algorithm of Jerrum and Sinclair. Here we show that hidden inside the model are hard computational problems. For the class of bounded-degree graphs we find computational thresholds for the approximate counting and sampling problems for the ferromagnetic Ising model at fixed magnetization (that is, fixing the number of $+1$ and $-1$ spins). In particular, letting $β_c(Δ)$ denote the critical inverse temperature of the zero-field Ising model on the infinite $Δ$-regular tree, and $η_{Δ,β,1}^+$ denote the mean magnetization of the zero-field $+$ measure on the infinite $Δ$-regular tree at inverse temperature $β$, we prove, for the class of graphs of maximum degree $Δ$: 1. For $β< β_c(Δ)$ there is an FPRAS and efficient sampling scheme for the fixed-magnetization Ising model for all magnetizations $η$. 2. For $β> β_c(Δ)$, there is an FPRAS and efficient sampling scheme for the fixed-magnetization Ising model for magnetizations $η$ such that $|η| >η_{Δ,β,1}^+ $. 3. For $β> β_c(Δ)$, there is no FPRAS for the fixed-magnetization Ising model for magnetizations $η$ such that $|η| <η_{Δ,β,1}^+ $ unless NP=RP\@.

By implementing algorithmic versions of Sapozhenko's graph container methods, we give new algorithms for approximating the number of independent sets in bipartite graphs. Our first algorithm applies to $d$-regular, bipartite graphs satisfying a weak expansion condition: when $d$ is constant, and the graph is a bipartite $Ω( \log^2 d/d)$-expander, we obtain an FPTAS for the number of independent sets. Previously such a result for $d>5$ was known only for graphs satisfying the much stronger expansion conditions of random bipartite graphs. The algorithm also applies to weighted independent sets: for a $d$-regular, bipartite $α$-expander, with $α>0$ fixed, we give an FPTAS for the hard-core model partition function at fugacity $λ=Ω(\log d / d^{1/4})$. Finally we present an algorithm that applies to all $d$-regular, bipartite graphs, runs in time $\exp\left( O\left( n \cdot \frac{ \log^3 d }{d } \right) \right)$, and outputs a $(1 + o(1))$-approximation to the number of independent sets.

We give an FPTAS for computing the number of matchings of size $k$ in a graph $G$ of maximum degree $Δ$ on $n$ vertices, for all $k \le (1-δ)m^*(G)$, where $δ>0$ is fixed and $m^*(G)$ is the matching number of $G$, and an FPTAS for the number of independent sets of size $k \le (1-δ) α_c(Δ) n$, where $α_c(Δ)$ is the NP-hardness threshold for this problem. We also provide quasi-linear time randomized algorithms to approximately sample from the uniform distribution on matchings of size $k \leq (1-δ)m^*(G)$ and independent sets of size $k \leq (1-δ)α_c(Δ)n$. Our results are based on a new framework for exploiting local central limit theorems as an algorithmic tool. We use a combination of Fourier inversion, probabilistic estimates, and the deterministic approximation of partition functions at complex activities to extract approximations of the coefficients of the partition function. For our results for independent sets, we prove a new local central limit theorem for the hard-core model that applies to all fugacities below $λ_c(Δ)$, the uniqueness threshold on the infinite $Δ$-regular tree.

We determine the asymptotics of the number of independent sets of size $\lfloor β2^{d-1} \rfloor$ in the discrete hypercube $Q_d = \{0,1\}^d$ for any fixed $β\in [0,1]$ as $d \to \infty$, extending a result of Galvin for $β\in [1-1/\sqrt{2},1]$. Moreover, we prove a multivariate local central limit theorem for structural features of independent sets in $Q_d$ drawn according to the hard core model at any fixed fugacity $λ>0$. In proving these results we develop several general tools for performing combinatorial enumeration using polymer models and the cluster expansion from statistical physics along with local central limit theorems.

We determine the computational complexity of approximately counting and sampling independent sets of a given size in bounded-degree graphs. That is, we identify a critical density $α_c(Δ)$ and provide (i) for $α< α_c(Δ)$ randomized polynomial-time algorithms for approximately sampling and counting independent sets of given size at most $αn$ in $n$-vertex graphs of maximum degree $Δ$; and (ii) a proof that unless NP=RP, no such algorithms exist for $α>α_c(Δ)$. The critical density is the occupancy fraction of the hard core model on the complete graph $K_{Δ+1}$ at the uniqueness threshold on the infinite $Δ$-regular tree, giving $α_c(Δ)\sim\frac{e}{1+e}\frac{1}Δ$ as $Δ\to\infty$. Our methods apply more generally to anti-ferromagnetic 2-spin systems and motivate new questions in extremal combinatorics.

We derive asymptotic formulas for the number of integer partitions with given sums of $j$th powers of the parts for $j$ belonging to a finite, non-empty set $J \subset \mathbb N$. The method we use is based on the `principle of maximum entropy' of Jaynes. This principle leads to an intuitive variational formula for the asymptotics of the logarithm of the number of constrained partitions as the solution to a convex optimization problem over real-valued functions.

We prove that the `Upper Matching Conjecture' of Friedland, Krop, and Markström and the analogous conjecture of Kahn for independent sets in regular graphs hold for all large enough graphs as a function of the degree. That is, for every $d$ and every large enough $n$ divisible by $2d$, a union of $n/(2d)$ copies of the complete $d$-regular bipartite graph maximizes the number of independent sets and matchings of size $k$ for each $k$ over all $d$-regular graphs on $n$ vertices. To prove this we utilize the cluster expansion for the canonical ensemble of a statistical physics spin model, and we give some further applications of this method to maximizing and minimizing the number of independent sets and matchings of a given size in regular graphs of a given minimum girth.