arXiv++ Combinatorics

We compute the logarithmic asymptotics of the non-existence probability (and more generally the lower-tail probability) for a wide variety of combinatorial problems for a range of parameters in the `critical regime' between the regime amenable to hypergraph container methods and that amenable to Janson's inequality. Examples include lower tails and non-existence probabilities for subgraphs of random graphs and for $k$-term arithmetic progressions in random sets of integers. Our methods apply in the general framework of estimating the probability that a $p$-random subset of vertices in a $k$-uniform hypergraph induces significantly fewer hyperedges than expected. We show that under some simple structural conditions on the hypergraph and an upper bound on $p$ determined by a phase transition in the hard-core model on the infinite $k$-uniform, $Δ$-regular, linear hypertree, this probability can be accurately approximated by the Bethe free energy evaluated at the unique fixed point of a Belief Propagation operator on the hypergraph.

We prove that with high probability $G(n,p)$ with $p \geq n^{-4/11 + o(1)}$ admits a fractional triangle decomposition (FTD), i.e., a nonnegative weighting of its triangles such that for each edge, the total weight of the triangles containing it equals one. This improves on the state of the art, due to Delcourt, Kelly, and Postle, that $p \geq n^{-1/3+o(1)}$ suffices. The proof is algorithmic: Given $G \sim G(n,p)$, we first construct an approximate FTD by taking a uniform weighting of the triangles. We then use specialized gadgets to iteratively shift weights and obtain successively better approximations of an FTD.

We study the probability that the random graph $G(n,p)$ is triangle-free. When $p =o(n^{-1/2})$ or $p = ω(n^{-1/2})$ the asymptotics of the logarithm of this probability are known via Janson's inequality in the former case and via regularity or hypergraph container methods in the latter case. We prove for the first time an asymptotic formula for the logarithm of this probability when $p = c n^{-1/2}$ for $c$ a sufficiently small constant. More generally, we study lower-tail large deviations for triangles in random graphs: the probability that $G(n,p)$ has at most $η$ times its expected number of triangles, when $p = c n^{-1/2}$ for $c$ and $η\in [0,1)$ constant. Our results apply for all $c$ if $η\ge .4993$ and for $c$ small enough otherwise. For $η$ small (including the case of triangle-freeness), we prove that a phase transition occurs as $c$ varies, in the sense of a non-analyticity of the rate function, while for $η\ge .4993$ we prove that no phase transition occurs. On the other hand for the random graph $G(n,m)$, with $m = b n^{3/2}$, we show that a phase transition occurs in the lower-tail problem for triangles as $b$ varies for \emph{every} $η\in [0,1)$. Our method involves ingredients from algorithms and statistical physics including the cluster expansion and concentration inequalities for contractive Markov chains.

We study the following combinatorial counting and sampling problems: can we efficiently sample from the Erdős-Rényi random graph $G(n,p)$ conditioned on triangle-freeness? Can we efficiently approximate the probability that $G(n,p)$ is triangle-free? These are prototypical instances of forbidden substructure problems ubiquitous in combinatorics. The algorithmic questions are instances of approximate counting and sampling for a hypergraph hard-core model. Estimating the probability that $G(n,p)$ has no triangles is a fundamental question in probabilistic combinatorics and one that has led to the development of many important tools in the field. Through the work of several authors, the asymptotics of the logarithm of this probability are known if $p =o( n^{-1/2})$ or if $p =ω( n^{-1/2})$. The regime $p = Θ(n^{-1/2})$ is more mysterious, as this range witnesses a dramatic change in the the typical structural properties of $G(n,p)$ conditioned on triangle-freeness. As we show, this change in structure has a profound impact on the performance of sampling algorithms. We give two different efficient sampling algorithms for triangle-free graphs (and complementary algorithms to approximate the triangle-freeness large deviation probability), one that is efficient when $p < c/\sqrt{n}$ and one that is efficient when $p > C/\sqrt{n}$ for constants $c, C>0$. The latter algorithm involves a new approach for dealing with large defects in the setting of sampling from low-temperature spin models.

Degeneracy plays an important role in understanding Turán- and Ramsey-type properties of graphs. Unfortunately, the usual hypergraphical generalization of degeneracy fails to capture these properties. We define the skeletal degeneracy of a $k$-uniform hypergraph as the degeneracy of its $1$-skeleton (i.e., the graph formed by replacing every $k$-edge by a $k$-clique). We prove that skeletal degeneracy controls hypergraph Turán and Ramsey numbers in a similar manner to (graphical) degeneracy. Specifically, we show that $k$-uniform hypergraphs with bounded skeletal degeneracy have linear Ramsey number. This is the hypergraph analogue of the Burr-Erdős conjecture (proved by Lee). In addition, we give upper and lower bounds of the same shape for the Turán number of a $k$-uniform $k$-partite hypergraph in terms of its skeletal degeneracy. The proofs of both results use the technique of dependent random choice. In addition, the proof of our Ramsey result uses the `random greedy process' introduced by Lee in his resolution of the Burr-Erdős conjecture.

Consider a host hypergraph $G$ which contains a spanning structure due to minimum degree considerations. We collect three results proving that if the edges of $G$ are sampled at the appropriate rate then the spanning structure still appears with high probability in the sampled hypergraph. We prove such results for perfect matchings in hypergraphs above Dirac thresholds, for $K_r$-factors in graphs satisfying the Hajnal--Szemerédi minimum degree condition, and for bounded-degree spanning trees. In each case our proof is based on constructing a spread measure and then applying recent results on the (fractional) Kahn--Kalai conjecture connecting the existence of such measures with probabilistic thresholds. For our second result we give a shorter and more general proof of a recent theorem of Allen, Böttcher, Corsten, Davies, Jenssen, Morris, Roberts, and Skokan which handles the $r=3$ case with different techniques. In particular, we answer a question of theirs with regards to the number of $K_r$-factors in graphs satisfying the Hajnal--Szemerédi minimum degree condition.

We prove that with high probability $\mathbb{G}^{(3)}(n,n^{-1+o(1)})$ contains a spanning Steiner triple system for $n\equiv 1,3\pmod{6}$, establishing the exponent for the threshold probability for existence of a Steiner triple system. We also prove the analogous theorem for Latin squares. Our result follows from a novel bootstrapping scheme that utilizes iterative absorption as well as the connection between thresholds and fractional expectation-thresholds established by Frankston, Kahn, Narayanan, and Park.

We prove several results about substructures in Latin squares. First, we explain how to adapt our recent work on high-girth Steiner triple systems to the setting of Latin squares, resolving a conjecture of Linial that there exist Latin squares with arbitrarily high girth. As a consequence, we see that the number of order-$n$ Latin squares with no intercalate (i.e., no $2\times2$ Latin subsquare) is at least $(e^{-9/4}n-o(n))^{n^{2}}$. Equivalently, $\mathbb{P}\left[\mathbf{N}=0\right]\ge e^{-n^{2}/4-o(n^{2})}=e^{-(1+o(1))\mathbb{E}\mathbf{N}}$, where $\mathbf{N}$ is the number of intercalates in a uniformly random order-$n$ Latin square. In fact, extending recent work of Kwan, Sah, and Sawhney, we resolve the general large-deviation problem for intercalates in random Latin squares, up to constant factors in the exponent: for any constant $0<δ\le1$ we have $\mathbb{P}[\mathbf{N}\le(1-δ)\mathbb{E}\mathbf{N}]=\exp(-Θ(n^{2}))$ and for any constant $δ>0$ we have $\mathbb{P}[\mathbf{N}\ge(1+δ)\mathbb{E}\mathbf{N}]=\exp(-Θ(n^{4/3}\log n))$. Finally, as an application of some new general tools for studying substructures in random Latin squares, we show that in almost all order-$n$ Latin squares, the number of cuboctahedra (i.e., the number of pairs of possibly degenerate $2\times2$ submatrices with the same arrangement of symbols) is of order $n^{4}$, which is the minimum possible. As observed by Gowers and Long, this number can be interpreted as measuring ``how associative'' the quasigroup associated with the Latin square is.

We prove a 1973 conjecture due to Erdős on the existence of Steiner triple systems with arbitrarily high girth.

The $n$-queens problem is to determine $\mathcal{Q}(n)$, the number of ways to place $n$ mutually non-threatening queens on an $n \times n$ board. We show that there exists a constant $α= 1.942 \pm 3 \times 10^{-3}$ such that $\mathcal{Q}(n) = ((1 \pm o(1))ne^{-α})^n$. The constant $α$ is characterized as the solution to a convex optimization problem in $\mathcal{P}([-1/2,1/2]^2)$, the space of Borel probability measures on the square. The chief innovation is the introduction of limit objects for $n$-queens configurations, which we call queenons. These form a convex set in $\mathcal{P}([-1/2,1/2]^2)$. We define an entropy function that counts the number of $n$-queens configurations that approximate a given queenon. The upper bound uses the entropy method of Radhakrishnan and Linial--Luria. For the lower bound we describe a randomized algorithm that constructs a configuration near a prespecified queenon and whose entropy matches that found in the upper bound. The enumeration of $n$-queens configurations is then obtained by maximizing the (concave) entropy function in the space of queenons. Along the way we prove a large deviations principle for $n$-queens configurations that can be used to study their typical structure.

The $n$-queens puzzle is to place $n$ mutually non-attacking queens on an $n \times n$ chessboard. We present a simple two stage randomized algorithm to construct such configurations. In the first stage, a random greedy algorithm constructs an approximate \textit{toroidal} $n$-queens configuration. In this well-known variant the diagonals wrap around the board from left to right and from top to bottom. We show that with high probability this algorithm succeeds in placing $(1-o(1))n$ queens on the board. In the second stage, the method of absorbers is used to obtain a complete solution to the non-toroidal problem. By counting the number of choices available at each step of the random greedy algorithm we conclude that there are more than $\left( \left( 1 - o(1) \right) n e^{-3} \right)^n$ solutions to the $n$-queens problem. This proves a conjecture of Rivin, Vardi, and Zimmerman in a strong form.

We describe a new random greedy algorithm for generating regular graphs of high girth: Let $k\geq 3$ and $c \in (0,1)$ be fixed. Let $n \in \mathbb{N}$ be even and set $g = c \log_{k-1} (n)$. Begin with a Hamilton cycle $G$ on $n$ vertices. As long as the smallest degree $δ(G)<k$, choose, uniformly at random, two vertices $u,v \in V(G)$ of degree $δ(G)$ whose distance is at least $g-1$. If there are no such vertex pairs, abort. Otherwise, add the edge $uv$ to $E(G)$. We show that with high probability this algorithm yields a $k$-regular graph with girth at least $g$. Our analysis also implies that there are $\left( Ω(n) \right)^{kn/2}$ labeled $k$-regular $n$-vertex graphs with girth at least $g$.

Consider the random process in which the edges of a graph $G$ are added one by one in a random order. A classical result states that if $G$ is the complete graph $K_{2n}$ or the complete bipartite graph $K_{n,n}$, then typically a perfect matching appears at the moment at which the last isolated vertex disappears. We extend this result to arbitrary $k$-regular bipartite graphs $G$ on $2n$ vertices for all $k = ω\left( \frac{n}{\log^{1/3} n} \right)$. Surprisingly, this is not the case for smaller values of $k$. Using a construction due to Goel, Kapralov and Khanna, we show that there exist bipartite $k$-regular graphs in which the last isolated vertex disappears long before a perfect matching appears.

Let $m \leq n \leq k$. An $m \times n \times k$ 0-1 array is a Latin box if it contains exactly $mn$ ones, and has at most one $1$ in each line. As a special case, Latin boxes in which $m = n = k$ are equivalent to Latin squares. Let $\mathcal{M}(m,n,k;p)$ be the distribution on $m \times n \times k$ 0-1 arrays where each entry is $1$ with probability $p$, independently of the other entries. The threshold question for Latin squares asks when $\mathcal{M}(n,n,n;p)$ contains a Latin square with high probability. More generally, when does $\mathcal{M}(m,n,k;p)$ support a Latin box with high probability? Let $\varepsilon>0$. We give an asymptotically tight answer to this question in the special cases where $n=k$ and $m \leq \left(1-\varepsilon \right) n$, and where $n=m$ and $k \geq \left(1+\varepsilon \right) n$. In both cases, the threshold probability is $Θ\left( \log \left( n \right) / n \right)$. This implies threshold results for Latin rectangles and proper edge-colorings of $K_{n,n}$.

Let $H$ be a random $k$-uniform $n$-vertex hypergraph where every $k$-tuple belongs to $H$ independently with probability $p$. We show that for some $\varepsilon_k > 0$, if $p \geq n^{-\varepsilon_k}$, then asymptotically almost surely $H$ contains an $\left( n , k , k - 1 \right)$-Steiner System. Our main tool is Keevash's method of Randomized Algebraic Constructions.

This paper is part of the ongoing effort to study high-dimensional permutations. We prove the analogue to the Erdős-Szekeres theorem: For every $k\ge1$, every order-$n$ $k$-dimensional permutation contains a monotone subsequence of length $Ω_{k}\left(\sqrt{n}\right)$, and this is tight. On the other hand, and unlike the classical case, the longest monotone subsequence in a random $k$-dimensional permutation of order $n$ is asymptotically almost surely $Θ_{k}\left(n^{\frac{k}{k+1}}\right)$.