arXiv++ Combinatorics

In this paper, we study the $α$-Ricci curvature and the Lin-Lu-Yau Ricci curvature on simple, connected, and locally finite graphs. For regular graphs, we introduce a combinatorial construction of optimal transport plans realizing the 1-Wasserstein distance and use it to derive exact formulas for the $α$-Ricci curvature and the Lin-Lu-Yau Ricci curvature. This yields a combinatorial proof of the known curvature formulas. Furthermore, for non-regular graphs, we characterize conditions on the size of common neighborhoods that guarantee either non-negative or vanishing Lin-Lu-Yau Ricci curvature.

In this paper, we study the Lin--Lu--Yau Ricci curvature of strongly connected locally finite digraphs through an explicit optimal-coupling construction. For an arc of a digraph, we derive a computable curvature formula by constructing a coupling between the probability measures at its tail and head, and by proving its optimality using a suitable $1$-Lipschitz function. The formula is not only effective for direct computation, but also unifies several known results: in particular, it recovers the Lin--Lu--Yau Ricci curvature formula for Cayley graphs of Right-Angled Artin--Coxeter Hybrid groups as a special case and gives shorter proofs of curvature results arising from matching-type conditions. We then characterize arcs with zero Ricci curvature through perfect distance matching and perfect distance partitions. We further prove that, under suitable assumptions, such arc curvature in directed Cayley graphs increases when an inverse generator or a new generator is added to the generating set. As applications, we compute the curvature of directed Cayley graphs of dihedral groups and generalized quaternion groups, including $Γ(D_n,\{a,b\})$, $Γ(Q_{4m},\{a,b\})$, $Γ(Q_{4m},\{a,a^{-1},b\})$ and $Γ(Q_{4m},\{a,b,b^{-1}\})$. Finally, we provide an algorithm for computing the Lin--Lu--Yau Ricci curvature of Cayley graphs of finitely generated groups with prescribed generating sets, together with complete curvature tables for several important families of finite groups.

Consider a symmetric function $\mathcal{C}(x,y)$ on $[0,1]\times[0,1]$ which is twice continuously differentiable up to the boundary, and which satisfies $ \mathcal{C}(x,y)=\mathcal{C}(1-x,1-y)$. Let $A^{(n)} = \big(a^{(n)}_{i,j}\, :\, i,j \in [n]\big)$ be the matrix with entries $a^{(n)}_{i,j}\, =\, \exp(-\mathcal{C}(i/n,j/n))$. Soumik Pal conjectured the asymptotics $$\operatorname{perm}\big(A^{(n)}\big)/n!\sim \exp\big(n Λ[\mathcal{C}]\big)/ \sqrt{\mathcal{D}[\mathcal{C}]}$$ as $n \to \infty$ for known functionals that arise naturally in the context of entropy regularized optimal transport. The functional $Λ[\mathcal{C}]$ is the known large deviation rate function, already proved rigorously by Sumit Mukherjee. It is $\int_{0}^1 \int_0^{1} (α(x)+β(y))\, dx\, dy$ where $α(x)+β(y)$ is chosen such that $ρ(x,y) := \exp(-\mathcal{C}(x,y)-α(x)-β(y))$ has uniform marginals. The algebraic term $\mathcal{D}[c]$ is given by Peter McCullagh's formula for doubly stochastic matrices: $\operatorname{det}_F(I+J-T^*T)$, the Fredholm determinant, where $I$ is the identity on $L^2([0,1])$, $Jf(x) \equiv \int_{0}^1 f(z)\, dz$ (for all $x$) and $Tf(x) = \int_0^1 ρ(x,y) f(y)\, dy$. We prove the conjecture for functions $\mathcal C$ that are constant on blocks, exploiting a well-known Ross Pinsky's combinatorial decomposition of permutations in blocks.

Let $\Sym{n}$ denote the set of all permutations on $n$ labels. Let $c:[0, 1]^2\to [0, \infty)$ be a twice continuously differentiable function. A subfamily of the Mallows model is the Gibbs probability measures on $\Sym{n}$ such that $\mathbb{P}(X=σ)=L_n^{-1} \prod_{i=1}^{n}\exp(-c(i/n, σ(i)/n))$. Mukherjee [Ann. Stat., Vol. 44(2), pp 853--875 (2016)] computed the limit of the log partition function and showed that $\lim_{n\to \infty}\frac{1}{n}\log L_n=-Γ_0$ where $Γ_0$ is the optimal cost associated with an entropy regularized optimal transport problem. In the KRP Memorial Volume of the Indian Journal of Pure and Applied Math, Pal conjectured an exact value for the limit $\lim_{n\to \infty} e^{-nΓ_0}L_n$ in terms of the Fredholm determinant of an integral operator and provided a partial proof. We give a complete proof of Pal's conjecture.

Quantifying the degree of dissimilarity between two probability distributions on a finite metric space is a fundamental task in Computer Science and Computer Vision. A natural dissimilarity measure based on optimal transport is the Earth Mover's Distance (EMD). A key technique for analyzing this metric, pioneered by Charikar (2002) and Indyk and Thaper (2003), involves constructing low-distortion embeddings of EMD(X) into the Lebesgue space $L_1$. It became a key problem to investigate whether the upper bound of $O(\log n)$ can be improved for important classes of metric spaces known to admit low-distortion embeddings into $L_1$. In the context of Computer Vision, grid graphs, especially planar grids, are among the most fundamental. Indyk posed the related problem of estimating the $L_1$-distortion of the space of uniform distributions on $n$-point subsets of $R^2$. The Progress Report, last updated in August 2011, highlighted two key results: first, the work of Khot and Naor (2006) on Hamming cubes, which showed that the $L_1$-distortion for Hamming cubes meets the described above upper estimate, and second, the result of Naor and Schechtman (2007) for planar grids, which established that the $L_1$-distortion of for a planar $n$ by $n$ grid is $Ω(\sqrt{\log n})$. Our first result is the improvement of the lower bound on the $L_1$-distortion for grids to $Ω(\log n)$, matching the universal upper bound up to multiplicative constants. The key ingredient allowing us to obtain these sharp estimates is a new Sobolev-type inequality for scalar-valued functions on the grid graphs. Our method is also applicable to many recursive families of graphs, such as diamond and Laakso graphs. We obtain the sharp distortion estimates of $\log n$ in these cases as well.

We introduce an optimal transport based approach for comparing undirected graphs with non-negative edge weights and general vertex labels, and we study connections between the resulting linear program and the graph isomorphism problem. Our approach is based on the notion of a joining of two graphs $G$ and $H$, which is a product graph that preserves their marginal structure. Given $G$ and $H$ and a vertex-based cost function $c$, the optimal graph joining (OGJ) problem finds a joining of $G$ and $H$ minimizing degree weighted cost. The OGJ problem can be written as a linear program with a convex polyhedral solution set. We establish several basic properties of the OGJ problem, and present theoretical results connecting the OGJ problem to the graph isomorphism problem. In particular, we examine a variety of conditions on graph families that are sufficient to ensure that for every pair of graphs $G$ and $H$ in the family (i) $G$ and $H$ are isomorphic if and only if their optimal joining cost is zero, and (ii) if $G$ and $H$ are isomorphic, the the extreme points of the solution set of the OGJ problem are deterministic joinings corresponding to the isomorphisms from $G$ to $H$.

We study a non-exchangeable multi-agent system and rigorously derive a strong form of the mean-field limit. The convergence of the connection weights and the initial data implies convergence of large-scale dynamics toward a deterministic limit given by the corresponding extended Vlasov PDE, at any later time and any realization of randomness. This is established on what we call a bi-coupling distance defined through a convex optimization problem, which is an interpolation of the optimal transport between measures and the fractional overlay between graphs. The proof relies on a quantitative stability estimate of the so-called observables, which are tensorizations of agent laws and graph homomorphism densities. This reveals a profound relationship between mean-field theory and graph limiting theory, intersecting in the study of non-exchangeable systems.

In 2010, Vershik proposed a new combinatorial invariant of metric spaces given by a class of polytopes that arise in the theory of optimal transport and are called ``Wasserstein polytopes'' or ``Kantorovich-Rubinstein polytopes'' in the literature. Answering a question posed by Vershik, we describe the stratification of the metric cone induced by the combinatorial type of these polytopes through a hyperplane arrangement. Moreover, we study its relationships with the stratification by combinatorial type of the injective hull (i.e., the tight span) and, in particular, with certain types of metrics arising in phylogenetic analysis. We also compute enumerative invariants in the case of metrics on up to six points.

In optimal transport, quadratic regularization is a sparse alternative to entropic regularization: the solution measure tends to have small support. Computational experience suggests that the support decreases monotonically to the unregularized counterpart as the regularization parameter is relaxed. We find it useful to investigate this monotonicity more abstractly for linear programs over polytopes, regularized with the squared norm. Here, monotonicity can be stated as an invariance property of the curve mapping the regularization parameter to the solution: once the curve enters a face of the polytope, does it remain in that face forever? We show that this invariance is equivalent to a geometric property of the polytope, namely that each face contains the minimum norm point of its affine hull. Returning to the optimal transport problem and its associated Birkhoff polytope, we verify this property for low dimensions, but show that it fails for marginals with five or more point masses. As a consequence, the conjectured monotonicity of the support fails in general, even if experiments suggest that monotonicity holds for many cost matrices. Separately, we apply our geometric point of view to a problem of Erdős, namely to characterize the doubly stochastic matrices whose maximal trace equals their squared norm.

We study fairness in social influence maximization, whereby one seeks to select seeds that spread a given information throughout a network, ensuring balanced outreach among different communities (e.g. demographic groups). In the literature, fairness is often quantified in terms of the expected outreach within individual communities. In this paper, we demonstrate that such fairness metrics can be misleading since they overlook the stochastic nature of information diffusion processes. When information diffusion occurs in a probabilistic manner, multiple outreach scenarios can occur. As such, outcomes such as ``In 50% of the cases, no one in group 1 gets the information, while everyone in group 2 does, and in the other 50%, it is the opposite'', which always results in largely unfair outcomes, are classified as fair by a variety of fairness metrics in the literature. We tackle this problem by designing a new fairness metric, mutual fairness, that captures variability in outreach through optimal transport theory. We propose a new seed-selection algorithm that optimizes both outreach and mutual fairness, and we show its efficacy on several real datasets. We find that our algorithm increases fairness with only a minor decrease (and at times, even an increase) in efficiency.

We investigate the random bipartite optimal matching problem on a flat torus in two-dimensions, considering general strictly convex power costs of the distance. We extend the successful ansatz first introduced by Caracciolo et al. for the quadratic case, involving a linear Poisson equation, to a non-linear equation of $q$-Poisson type, allowing for a more comprehensive analysis of the optimal transport cost. Our results establish new asymptotic connections between the energy of the solution to the PDE and the optimal transport cost, providing insights on their asymptotic behavior.

We prove a sharp bound for the minimal doubling of a small measurable subset of a compact connected Lie group. Namely, let $G$ be a compact connected Lie group of dimension $d_G$, we show that for for all measurable subsets $A$, we have $$μ_G(A^2) \geq \left(2^{d_G-d_H} - Cμ_G(A)^{\frac{2}{d_G-d_H}}\right)μ_G(A)$$ where $d_H$ is the maximal dimension of a proper closed subgroup $H$ and $C > 0$ is a dimensional constant. This settles a conjecture of Breuillard and Green, and recovers and improves - with completely different methods - a recent result of Jing--Tran--Zhang corresponding to the case $G=SO_3(\mathbb{R})$. As is often the case, the above doubling inequality stems from a special case of general product-set estimates. We prove that for all $ε>0$ and for any pair of sufficiently small measurable subsets $A,B$ a Brunn--Minkowski-type inequality holds: $$ μ_G(AB)^{\frac{1}{d_G-d_H}} \geq (1-ε)\left( μ_G(A)^{\frac{1}{d_G-d_H}} + μ_G(B)^{\frac{1}{d_G-d_H}}\right).$$ Going beyond the scope of the Breuillard--Green conjecture, we prove a stability result asserting that the only subsets with close to minimal doubling are essentially neighbourhoods of proper subgroups i.e. of the form $$H_δ:=\{g \in G: d(g,H)<δ\}$$ where $H$ denotes a proper closed subgroup of maximal dimension, $d$ denotes a bi-invariant distance on $G$ and $δ>0$. Our approach relies on a combination of two toolsets: optimal transports and its recent applications to the Brunn--Minkowski inequality, and the structure theory of compact approximate subgroups.

A result of Hohloch links the theory of integer partitions with the Monge formulation of the optimal transport problem, giving the optimal transport map between (Young diagrams of) integer partitions and their corresponding symmetric partitions. Our aim is to extend Hohloch's result to the higher dimensional case. In doing so, we show the Kantorovich formulation of the optimal transport problem provides the tool to study the matching of higher dimensional partitions with their corresponding symmetric partitions.

Softassign is a pivotal method in graph matching and other learning tasks. Many softassign-based algorithms exhibit performance sensitivity to a parameter in the softassign. However, tuning the parameter is challenging and almost done empirically. This paper proposes an adaptive softassign method for graph matching by analyzing the relationship between the objective score and the parameter. This method can automatically tune the parameter based on a given error bound to guarantee accuracy. The Hadamard-Equipped Sinkhorn formulas introduced in this study significantly enhance the efficiency and stability of the adaptive softassign. Moreover, these formulas can also be used in optimal transport problems. The resulting adaptive softassign graph matching algorithm enjoys significantly higher accuracy than previous state-of-the-art large graph matching algorithms while maintaining comparable efficiency.

Ollivier and Lin--Lu--Yau established the theory of graph Ricci curvature (LLY curvature) via optimal transport on graphs. Ikeda--Kitabeppu--Takai--Uehara introduced a new distance called the Kantorovich difference on hypergraphs and generalized the LLY curvature to hypergraphs (IKTU curvature). As the LLY curvature can be represented by the graph Laplacian by Münch--Wojciechowski, Ikeda--Kitabeppu--Takai--Uehara conjectured that the IKTU curvature has a similar expression in terms of the hypergraph Laplacian. In this paper, we introduce a variant of the Kantorovich difference inspired by the above conjecture and study the Ricci curvature associated with this distance ($\mathsf{wIKTU}$ curvature). Moreover, for hypergraphs with a specific structure, we analyze a quantity $\mathcal{C}(x,y)$ at two distinct vertices $x,y$ defined by using the hypergraph Laplacian. If the resolvent operator converges uniformly to the identity, then $\mathcal{C}(x,y)$ coincides with the $\mathsf{wIKTU}$ curvature along $x,y$.

We investigate the one-dimensional random assignment problem in the concave case, i.e., the assignment cost is a concave power function, with exponent $0<p<1$, of the distance between $n$ source and $n$ target points, that are i.i.d. random variables with a common law on an interval. We prove that the limit of a suitable renormalization of the costs exists if the exponent $p$ is different than $1/2$. Our proof in the case $1/2<p<1$ makes use of a novel version of the Kantorovich optimal transport problem based on Young integration theory, where the difference between two measures is replaced by the weak derivative of a function with finite $q$-variation, which may be of independent interest. We also prove a similar result for the random bipartite Traveling Salesperson Problem.

A nonnegative integer matrix is said to be width-one if its nonzero entries lie along a path consisting of steps to the south and to the east. These matrices are important in optimal transport theory: the northwest corner algorithm, for example, takes supply and demand vectors and outputs a width-one matrix. The problem in this paper is to write down an explicit formula for the sum of all width-one matrices (with given dimensions $n \times n$ and given sum $d$ of the entries). We prove two strikingly different formulas. The first, a ${}_4 F_3$ hypergeometric series with unit argument, is obtained by applying the Robinson-Schensted-Knuth correspondence to the width-one matrices; the second is obtained via Stanley-Reisner theory. Computationally, our two formulas are complementary to each other: the first formula outperforms the second if $d$ is fixed and $n$ increases, while the second outperforms the first if $n$ is fixed and $d$ increases. We also show how our result yields a new non-recursive formula for the mean value of the discrete earth mover's distance (i.e., the solution to the transportation problem), whenever the cost matrix has the Monge property.

Branched Optimal Transport (BOT) is a generalization of optimal transport in which transportation costs along an edge are subadditive. This subadditivity models an increase in transport efficiency when shipping mass along the same route, favoring branched transportation networks. We here study the NP-hard optimization of BOT networks connecting a finite number of sources and sinks in $\mathbb{R}^2$. First, we show how to efficiently find the best geometry of a BOT network for many sources and sinks, given a topology. Second, we argue that a topology with more than three edges meeting at a branching point is never optimal. Third, we show that the results obtained for the Euclidean plane generalize directly to optimal transportation networks on two-dimensional Riemannian manifolds. Finally, we present a simple but effective approximate BOT solver combining geometric optimization with a combinatorial optimization of the network topology.

We investigate the minimum cost of a wide class of combinatorial optimization problems over random bipartite geometric graphs in $\mathbb{R}^d$ where the edge cost between two points is given by a $p$-th power of their Euclidean distance. This includes e.g.\ the travelling salesperson problem and the bounded degree minimum spanning tree. We establish in particular almost sure convergence, as $n$ grows, of a suitable renormalization of the random minimum cost, if the points are uniformly distributed and $d \ge 3$, $1\le p<d$. Previous results were limited to the range $p<d/2$. Our proofs are based on subadditivity methods and build upon new bounds for random instances of the Euclidean bipartite matching problem, obtained through its optimal transport relaxation and functional analytic techniques.

We discuss a phenomenon where Optimal Transport leads to a remarkable amount of combinatorial regularity. Consider infinite sequences $(x_k)_{k=1}^{\infty}$ in $[0,1]$ constructed in a greedy manner: given $x_1, \dots, x_n$, the new point $x_{n+1}$ is chosen so as to minimize the Wasserstein distance $W_2$ between the empirical measure of the $n+1$ points and the Lebesgue measure, $$x_{n+1} = \arg\min_x ~W_2\left( \frac{1}{n+1} \sum_{k=1}^{n} δ_{x_k} + \frac{δ_{x}}{n+1}, dx\right).$$ This leads to fascinating sequences (for example: $x_{n+1} = (2k+1)/(2n+2)$ for some $k \in \mathbb{Z}$) which coincide with sequences recently introduced by Ralph Kritzinger in a different setting. Numerically, the regularity of these sequences rival the best known constructions from Combinatorics or Number Theory. We prove a regularity result below the square root barrier.