arXiv++ Combinatorics

Granville and Ono proved that there is an $e$-core partition of $n$ for every $n\in\mathbb{N}$ if and only if $e\geq 4$, which translates to a statement about the existence of defect $0$ blocks for symmetric groups in positive characteristic and defect $0$ unipotent blocks of finite general linear groups in positive, non-defining characteristic. Motivated by analogous applications to the block theory of finite classical groups, imprimitive spetses, and cyclotomic Hecke algebras, we prove similar positivity statements about different variants of $e$-cores for charged multipartitions.

It is well known that the Young lattice is the Bratelli diagram of the symmetric groups, expressing how irreducible representations restrict from $\mathfrak{S}_{N}$ to $\mathfrak{S}_{N-1}$. In 1975, Stanley discovered a similar lattice called the Young-Fibonacci lattice which was identified as the Bratelli diagram of a family of algebras $\{\mathbf{O}_N(X,Y)\}_{N \geq 0}$ by Okada in 1994. In this paper, we first realize the Okada algebra $\mathbf{O}_N(X,Y)$ and the associated monoid $\mathbf{O}_N$ using a labelled version of non-crossing arc-diagrams appearing in the description of the Temperley-Lieb algebra and Jones monoid. We establish, for general parameters $(X,Y)$, that the dimension of the Okada algebra $\mathbf{O}_N(X,Y)$ is $N!$, noting that Okada proved this result only in the semisimple case. We interpret a natural bijection between permutations and labelled arc-diagrams as an incarnation of Fomin's version of the Robinson-Schensted correspondence associated to the Young-Fibonacci lattice. The arc-diagram formalism allow us to probe the structure of the Okada monoid and algebra. In particular we prove that the Okada monoid is a regular, aperiodic $*$-monoid and we describe its Green relations and order. These results allow us to construct a cellular basis of the Okada algebra and to show that $\{\mathbf{O}_N(X,Y)\}_{N \geq 0}$ forms a coherent tower of cellular algebras in the sense of Goodman and Graber. We present some conjectures expressing the Gram determinant of the invariant bilinear form attached to each cell module in terms of Okada's clone Schur functions. We conclude the paper by presenting two follow-up, ongoing projects along with a series of questions pushing further the analogy between the symmetric groups and the Okada algebras.

In a preceding article, we introduced stable symmetric series encoding simultaneously the normalized conjugacy classes of all symmetric groups. The same rational series remain stable for the Jack-deformed Goulden--Jackson product. We investigate their two-parameter Macdonald analogue. Starting from the $(q,t)$-deformed class product (dual to the coproduct diagonal on the $J$-basis), we construct the unique infinite series whose multiplication realizes any shifted Macdonald eigenvalue. In contrast with the classical and Jack cases, this transform is no longer multiplication by a fixed explicit series. We identify it with a composition of a Cauchy multiplication, the integral nabla operator, and a simple diagonal operator. We then determine the series realizing the Nazarov--Sklyanin operators $A^{(k)}$, derive a single generating series for all column partitions, and compare our construction with the Macdonald characters and Theta operators of Ben Dali and D'Adderio.

Let $W$ be an affine Coxeter group of type $\widetilde{A}_n$, that is, the affine symmetric group $\widetilde{S}_N$ with $N=n+1$, let $T$ be its set of reflections, and let $\mathrm{Red}_T(w)$ be the set of reduced reflection factorizations of an element $w\in W$. The braid group acts on $\mathrm{Red}_T(w)$ by the Hurwitz action. For finite Coxeter groups it is known exactly when this action is transitive, namely precisely for the parabolic quasi-Coxeter elements. We address this problem for the affine type $\widetilde{A}_n$ by determining all orbits of $\mathrm{Red}_T(w)$.

For a set of $n$ alternatives, the best--worst choice polytope is the convex hull of the deterministic best--worst choice vectors induced by all linear rankings of the alternatives. The question of determining the dimension of this polytope as a function of $n$ has been raised by Doignon \cite{Doignon2023}. In this paper we answer this question by finding an explicit formula for this dimension. Our proof is motivated by a representation-theoretic interpretation of the relevant rank problem for the symmetric group, but is presented entirely in elementary linear-algebraic terms. The connection with representation theory will be explored elsewhere.

We introduce stable symmetric series which encode normalized conjugacy classes and their multiplication operators simultaneously for all symmetric groups. This gives a direct route from the Ivanov--Kerov algebra to shifted symmetric functions and to differential operators in $U(\mathcal W_{1+\infty})$. Using the Goulden--Jackson product, we extend the construction to Jack polynomials, recover shifted Jack eigenvalues and Pieri-type relations, and obtain explicit candidate operators in degrees three and four. Their real and quaternionic specializations to zonal polynomials are verified by Gaussian matrix integrals and exhaustive Wick enumeration.

Immanants are a class of generalized matrix functions associated with the irreducible characters of the symmetric group. Bürgisser [SIAM J. Comput., 30 (2000), pp. 1023--1040] proved that the computation of hook immanants and immanants corresponding to rectangular Young diagrams of polynomially growing width is VNP-complete under $p$-projections. And he posed an open problem: whether the family of immanants corresponding to rectangular Young diagrams of width $2$ is VNP-complete under $p$-projections. This paper gives a solution to this problem. We prove that, over any field of characteristic zero, the immanant families associated with rectangular Young diagrams of width $2$ and of length $2$ are both VNP-complete under $p$-projections.

A $t$-wise balanced design on the edge set of a complete graph is graphical if its block multiset is invariant under the induced action of the symmetric group on the vertices. Chouinard conjectured that, for each fixed index $λ$, there are only finitely many nontrivial simple graphical $t$-wise balanced designs with $t>1$. We prove the conjecture for $t$-designs, which are the $t$-wise balanced designs whose blocks all have the same size. Our theorem does not require simplicity, and we bound all parameters of the designs by explicit polynomials in $λ$.

Let $G$ be a simple graph of order $n$ with adjacency matrix $A= (a_{ij})$. The \emph{determinant} and the \emph{permanen}t of the matrix $A$ are defined as \[\mathrm{det}A= \sum_{σ\in S_n}\mathrm{sgn}(σ) \prod_{i=1}^n a_{iσ(i)}\quad\text{and}\quad\mathrm{per}A= \sum_{σ\in S_n} \prod_{i=1}^n a_{iσ(i)},\]respectively. The polynomials $φ(G;x) =\mathrm{det}(xI-A(G))$ and $π(G;x) =\mathrm{per}(xI-A(G))$ are called the \emph{characteristic polynomial} and the \emph{permanental polynomial} of $G$, respectively. Two graphs are said to be \emph{nearly cospectral} with respect to the determinant (resp. permanent) if the difference of their characteristic (resp. permanental) polynomials is a constant. Lv et al. introduced the nearly cospectral graphs problem with respect to the determinant, and provided partial results in the case modulo 4. In this paper, we mainly prove that the corresponding results also hold for the nearly cospectral graphs problem with respect to the permanent. The determinant and permanent are the immanants corresponding to the irreducible characters $(1^n)$ and $(n)$ of the symmetric group $ S_n $, respectively. Here, the \emph{immanant} $d_λ(A)$ of $A$ is defined as \[d_λ(A) = \sum_{σ\in S_n} χ_λ(σ) \prod_{i=1}^n a_{iσ(i)},\] where $χ_λ$ is the irreducible character of $ S_n $ indexed by the partition $ λ$. The immanantal polynomial of $G$ associated with $ χ_λ$ is given by $ φ_λ(G;x)=d_λ(xI-A) $. In this paper, we also establish a similar result for nearly immanantal cospectral graphs in $\mathbb{F}_2[x]$ for all irreducible characters $χ_λ$.

Let $μ_t$ be the full set of $t$-th roots of unity and $(z,z^{-1})$ a free reciprocal pair. We determine how much of a partition $s_λ(μ_t,z,z^{-1})$ can see: a multiset of three integers and a sign, and nothing else, so partitions of any sizes agreeing on it share the value. The evaluation, for every $t\ge2$ and every $λ$ with no hypothesis on its shape, is a signed product of exactly three factors over a fixed denominator, or zero, the three arguments read off the $t$-quotient. The proof is a Laplace expansion along the $t$ frozen rows of the bialternant with one cancellation lemma in the symmetric group, and delivers the sign, the one already in Littlewood's evaluation at $μ_t$. Three consequences follow. A vanishing criterion: it vanishes exactly when a residue class modulo $t$ is empty, or two distinguished classes are concentric as intervals, the second only for $t$ even. An extension of a recent independence criterion of Ayyer-Kumari: for two-row shapes on the reciprocal locus it acquires exactly one further family, classified by core and quotient. And an enumerative reading: at $t=2$ a $(-1)$-enumeration of plane partitions in a box refined by a parameter that stays free. The factorization is isolated: it fails under each of four deformations of the alphabet, for one reason. A last section treats the zero locus, which survives further pairs. Two conditions make $Ψ_r=s_λ(1,-1,z_1^{\pm1},\dots,z_r^{\pm1})$ vanish: the beta set having constant parity, and $λ$ being self-complementary of odd width. That direction is a corollary of the complementation identity over an index family Ayyer and Behrend single out. The new content is the converse, that nothing else vanishes, proved for one pair, for every $r$ inside Littlewood's range, and for every $r$ when $|λ|\le2r+2$. The rest is conjectural, verified over every shape in the tabulated ranges.

Let the symmetric group $S_n$ act on the space of $n \times r$ real matrices by permuting rows, so orbits are multisets of $n$ points in $\mathbb{R}^r$. The basic $r$-symmetric tropical polynomials form a family of $\binom{n+r}{r}-1$ nonconstant invariants of degree at most $n$ that separates orbits and embeds the orbit space bi-Lipschitzly. We prove that this family generates the semifield of all $r$-symmetric tropical rational functions, answering a question raised in [J. Pure Appl. Algebra 223 (2019) 72-85]. Derksen showed that the invariant semifield of any permutation group $G \le S_N$ is generated in degree at most $N p_1 \cdots p_{|G|}$ ($p_i$ the $i$th prime), which for the row action is $nr p_1 \cdots p_{n!}$; the present result replaces this by generators of degree at most $n$. The generating expression is a finite minimum over the ways of re-assembling a multiset from its sorted columns, with penalties from the basic values that, via the bi-Lipschitz inequality, dominate a wrong re-assembly. The same penalties describe the image of the basic coordinate map as the zero set of a single tropical rational function and yield an expression algorithm. Subfamilies of the basic family containing the single-column values generate if and only if they separate. For any permutation group $G \le S_N$ the same mechanism generates the invariant semifield in degree at most $\max\{N, \binom{N}{2}\}$, a quadratic bound independent of the group order; combined with a genericity theorem of Cahill, Iverson, Mixon, and Packer, it yields $2N+1$ invariant tropical polynomials that separate orbits and $3N$ that generate, with at least $N$ necessary for each task. The quadratic bound is optimal: every $A_N$-invariant tropical polynomial of degree less than $\binom{N}{2}$ is $S_N$-invariant, so every separating family for the alternating group $A_N$ contains a member of degree at least $\binom{N}{2}$.

The symmetric group $S_n$ is generated by transpositions, and problems of sorting permutations using transpositions are well studied. In recent work, Adin, Alon, and Roichman studied the related problem of sorting $n$ points on a circle, and gave a formula for the maximum number of adjacent swaps required. This is equivalent to the number of adjacent transpositions required to transform any permutation into a power of the cyclic permutation $(1,2,\ldots, n)$. The focus of this work is an analogous question in the alternating group $A_n$, which is generated by $3$-cycles. That is, using 3-cycles instead of transpositions, what is the maximum number of steps required to transform an even permutation into a power of $(1,2,\ldots, n)$ in the alternating group? We determine this number exactly for even $n$ and $n \equiv 1 \pmod{4}$. For $n \equiv 3 \pmod{4}$, we show that the sorting number can take one of two possible values and give explicit constructions demonstrating that the larger value occurs infinitely often.

Aldous' spectral gap conjecture states that the random walk and the interchange process on any connected graph have the same spectral gap, or, equivalently, the second largest eigenvalue of any connected Cayley graph on the symmetric group $S_n$ with respect to a set of transpositions is achieved by the standard representation of $S_n$. This celebrated conjecture, proved in its general form in 2010, has inspired much interest in searching for other Cayley graphs on $S_n$ possessing this property, now known as the Aldous property. In this paper, we first prove that for $n \ge 5$ at most one of a normal Cayley graph on $S_n$ and its complement can possess the Aldous property except when these two graphs are $2K_{n!/2}$ and $K_{n!/2,n!/2}$ respectively. We then determine, for sufficiently large $n$, all normal Cayley graphs $\mathrm{Cay}(S_n, S)$ that have the Aldous property, except for the case when $S$ contains a permutation with support size in $\{2, 3, \dots, n-2\}$ and a permutation with support size in $\{n-1, n\}$, but not all permutations with support size $n$ are contained in $S$. In particular, we show that a non-complete normal Cayley graph $\mathrm{Cay}(S_n, S)$ does not have the Aldous property if all permutations in $S$ have support size $n-1$ or $n$, or all permutations with support size $n$ are contained in $S$, thereby solving an open problem posed by Li, Xia and Zhou in 2023. Along the way we determine all normal Cayley graphs on $S_n$ that are line graphs, and classify all normal Cayley graphs on $S_n$ with the strictly second largest eigenvalue at most $1$.

We investigate a remarkable probability distribution on the symmetric group, due to Steck from the early 1970's, arising from a natural process that intertwines continuous and discrete selections for the values and positions, respectively, of a permutation. Steck used a matrix determinant to express his distribution, whereas we contribute new combinatorial formulas for it in terms of "bottom-to-top maxima" (that are simply the left-to-right maxima of the inverse) permutation statistics. These formulas specialize, in the case of the identity permutation, to a result of Pitman--Stanley from the late 1990's. We then use the Steck distribution to define a game of best choice (secretary problem variation) that incorporates a filtering process for the pool of candidates over time. We solve the model for the case where there is a single filtering step. It turns out that the probability of winning the game under optimal play is similar to the classical model ($1/e$, asymptotically), but that the interviewer must employ a different (non-positional) strategy in order to attain it. The optimal strategy depends on the relationship between interview position and the next bottom-to-top maximum value after the filtering step. Among other results, we prove that the optimal strategy always transitions from rejection to acceptance between positions $(1/e)$ and $(1/e) + (1 - 1/e)y$ as a proportion of the total candidates considered, where $y$ is the proportion of unfiltered candidates.

In this paper, we study the random walk on the symmetric group $\mathfrak{S}_n$ generated by the conjugacy class of $k$-cycles, where $2\le k=o(n/(\log n)^4)$. We prove that the walk exhibits hitting-time mixing: at the first time when every card has been touched, the distribution is already close to equilibrium. For odd $k$, the equilibrium measure is the uniform measure on $\mathfrak{A}_n$. For even $k$, the walk first mixes to the parity mixture determined by the hitting time, and in our range this mixture is asymptotically $U_{\mathfrak{S}_n}$. Our argument combines a refined fixed-time approximation for the random $k$-cycle walk near the cutoff window with an auxiliary marking scheme inspired by Jain-Sawhney's work (arXiv:2410.23944) on random transpositions. The main new feature is a parity-compatible coupling which handles both odd and even $k$-cycles in a unified framework. We also prove a hitting-time mixing result in the opposite regime $k\ge n-o(n^{1/2})$, and formulate a conjecture for all $2\le k\le n-1$.

We certify, exactly, the coordinate fields of a faithful planar realization of two neighbouring triangle-free Exoo-Ismailescu unit-distance graphs (UDGs), and show they realize the two opposite extremes of the constructibility hierarchy. The 17-vertex graph EI17 (House of Graphs 51375) is the smallest triangle-free UDG with chromatic number 4; the 19-vertex graph EI19 (HoG 51376) is its state-of-the-art origami neighbour. In both, fixing a rational base edge, the remaining vertices are intersections of unit circles -- each on the radical axis of its two neighbours, a tower of square roots over the free angles -- and a small closure system locks the realization. For EI19 the base lies in Q(sqrt 2, sqrt 5, sqrt 7) and a single free angle has an irreducible degree 12 = 2^2*3 minimal polynomial with Galois group the solvable transitive group 12T236 (order 2304 = 2^8*3^2): not ruler-and-compass, but origami-constructible (the cubic Beloch fold O6 necessary, in casus irreducibilis). For EI17 two free angles are locked by two closures, whose resultant is irreducible of degree 20 = 2^2*5 with Galois group the full symmetric group S20 (a Frobenius census exhibits a 17-cycle, forcing A20 by Jordan, and an odd 20-cycle, raising it to S20): non-solvable, so the coordinates are not expressible by radicals -- neither compass nor origami of any fold order. Thus the smallest triangle-free 4-chromatic UDG is the generic, maximally exotic case, the exact opposite of its origami neighbour. We give the full certification pipeline as explicit algorithms, record two methodological pitfalls, and read the pair through a conjectural bridge between the Laman number and the Galois group.

We consider permutations $q$ in the symmetric group $S_n$ whose Verma multiplicities in the principal block of $\mathcal{O}(\mathfrak{sl}_n)$ satisfy $[M(p):L(q)] \geq 2$. We present a construction along with a diagrammatic visualization, showing how permutations in $S_n$ with this property generate a family of permutations in $S_{n+1}$ that share the same multiplicity property. While the method does not recover all such permutations in $S_{n+1}$, it systematically generates many new examples. In addition, we present all permutations in $S_5$ with $[M(\mathrm{id}):L(q)] \geq 2$ in a Bruhat diagram and describe all permutations in $S_6$ and $S_7$ with non-simple Verma multiplicities.

We associate the Orlik--Solomon sheaf with a finite geometric lattice and compute its sheaf homology. We show that this homology concentrates in top degree, admitting a convolution-type decomposition into a principal ideal OS piece tensoring with a principal filter complement poset homology. Applications to uniform matroids provide interesting representations of symmetric groups.

Let $α(n)$ denote the length of the shortest non-trivial two-variable law for the symmetric group $S_n$. Buskin's quantitative subgroup-separability argument gives the classical lower bound $α(n)\geq 2n-O(1)$. In this short note we give an improvement by proving that $α(n)\geq \frac52 n-O(1)$.

The paper aims to provide a categorification of the Brenti--Welker identity involving Eulerian numbers in (Adv. Appl. Math. 42 (2009): 545--556) by lifting it from an enumerative equality to an isomorphism of symmetric group representations. To do so, we study the decomposition of the tensor product of $(\mathbb{C}^r)^{\otimes n}$ and modules affording Foulkes characters as modules of the symmetric group. The main ingredient of the proof is a combinatorial identity which may be of independent interest.