arXiv++ Combinatorics

We study the loopy polynomial L_G, a multivariate graph invariant arising from bizonotopal graph algebras and defined by a deletion-loopy-contraction recursion, in which the contracted edge becomes a loop. We show that L_G contains the Tutte polynomial and admits a similar spanning-forest activity expansion. It also determines Stanley's chromatic symmetric function, the degree sequence, the induced edge count profile, and the independence polynomial for loopless graphs, and the clique and matching polynomials for simple graphs. Separating the size and the external activity of each forest component leads to a refined loopy polynomial, which we show to be equivalent to the extended U-polynomial of Noble and Welsh and to the extended polychromate. Different specializations of this common refinement give the ordinary U-polynomial, Tutte's universal V-function, and Stanley's Tutte symmetric function, placing these invariants into a single framework. We conjecture that L_G and the U-polynomial have the same distinguishing power on simple graphs, and verify this for all graphs on at most 11 vertices. Simplicity is essential: we found two loopless multigraphs with equal U-polynomials but distinct loopy polynomials. They also have distinct extended U-polynomials, so the ordinary U-polynomial does not determine the extended one on loopless multigraphs. This solves an open problem by Merino and Noble. For the score polytope P_G of the external bizonotopal algebra, loopy deletion-contraction lifts from the lattice-point enumerator to the polytope itself. This gives forest-indexed geometric parking complexes whose lattice points partition those of P_G, and which are piecewise-linearly parametrized by products of intervals whose lengths are the component weights in the forest expansion of L_G.

We prove a Schur alpha-omega lemma for chromatic symmetric functions. It bounds the partitions indexing nonzero Schur coefficients in terms of higher independence numbers, higher clique numbers, and the chromatic number. We then establish three equivalent dominance-matching criteria: matrix, Hall, and order-ideal, that certify Schur positivity from a fixed signed $e_I$-expansion. As applications, we obtain complete classifications of $e$-positivity and Schur positivity for four basic families of $3$-clique-spiders. Here $S^{ghk}_{rst}$ is formed by joining a common center to one vertex of each of $K_r$, $K_s$, and $K_t$ by internally disjoint paths of lengths $g$, $h$, and $k$, respectively. As a result, $S^{000}_{rst}$ is Schur positive exactly when $r\ge st-1$, and every graph $S^{100}_{rst}$ and $S^{010}_{rst}$ is Schur positive. When $s=t$, the graph $S^{001}_{rst}$ is Schur positive; when $s>t$, its Schur-positive members fall into four explicit parameter regimes. We also introduce a path-clique bootstrap and use it to prove that every spider $S(a,b,2)$ is Schur positive. Finally, we prove that the spider $S(a,b,2)$ for $a\ge b\ge2$ with $3\nmid b$ is $e$-positive if and only if $(a,b)\in\{(6,4),(12,4),(9,7)\}$, which advances the study of Tom's conjecture concerning the $e$-positivity of spiders $S(a,b,2)$.

Stanley's tree-isomorphism conjecture asks whether the chromatic symmetric function distinguishes nonisomorphic trees. We give a reconstruction criterion that permits repeated leaf-component orders. For a proper tree, collapse each leaf component to its center and record its order as a vertex weight. We prove that the chromatic symmetric function reconstructs the tree whenever every nonleaf vertex of this weighted core has a weight that occurs nowhere else in the core. Repetitions among core leaves are unrestricted. The proof uses only the leading star-basis partition and the coefficients immediately above it. As a consequence, the conjecture holds for an infinite class of diameter-six trees not covered by the condition that all leaf-component orders are distinct. We also give a canonical integer-partition model for arbitrary diameter-six trees and an exact cut-partition implementation intended for further work. The unrestricted diameter-six case remains open.

The classical bond lattice of a graph was used in a formula of Whitney to compute the chromatic polynomial. In this paper, we use weighted versions of the bond lattice, to introduce and study a new polynomial and a new symmetric function invariant of a graph. Examples of the new polynomial invariant include the classical Narayana polynomials (for the path graph), the tree-Eulerian polynomials (for the complete graph), and the binomial-Eulerian polynomials (for the star graph). These examples suggest an interesting connection to $h$-polynomials of general graph-associahedra. We prove that for any chordal graph, our polynomial graph invariant is $γ$-positive. Multiweighted bond posets yield a symmetric function graph invariant that is an analog of the chromatic polynomial. The highest degree homogeneous component of this symmetric function is of particular interest. The parking function symmetric function introduced by Haiman arises as an example, as do symmetric functions studied by the first author in connection with multibracketed Lie algebras and with colored exterior algebras. The $γ$-positivity result mentioned above is a specialization of an $e$-positivity result for the highest degree homogeneous component, which we prove for any chordal graph using the theory of lexicographic shellability. We conjecture that this symmetric function is Schur-log-concave, which specializes to Huh's log-concavity theorem for the chromatic polynomial.

The claw-free Schur-positivity conjecture, recorded by Stanley (1998) and credited there to Gasharov, asserts that the chromatic symmetric function of every claw-free graph is Schur-positive. We give a counterexample on 12 vertices: the line graph $G$ of the graph obtained from a 4-cycle by attaching triangles at two opposite vertices and pendant edges at the other two satisfies $[s_{(3,3,3,3)}]X_G = -64$. The coefficient follows from a short computation by hand and is also reproduced by three exact implementations. An exhaustive computation over all 216,777 connected claw-free graphs on at most 11 vertices shows that every one is Schur-positive, so 12 vertices is the minimum order of any counterexample. A complete census of the 1,728,404 connected claw-free graphs on 12 vertices finds exactly two non-Schur-positive isomorphism classes; the other has graph6 code K?`CR@`bAbRB and coefficient $[s_{(3,3,3,3)}] = -40$.

The Stanley--Gasharov conjecture asserts that the chromatic symmetric function of every claw-free graph is Schur-positive. Prajapati, and independently Matherne and Morales, found counterexamples, and the latter asked for an infinite family of counterexamples. Combining Prajapati's complete census through order~$12$ with an exact census of the $144{,}492$ previously untreated connected claw-free graphs on~$n$ vertices and~$m$ edges with $13\le n\le 21$ and $n-1\le m\le 20$, we show that their counterexample graph~$G_2$ with $12$ vertices and $21$ edges is the unique minimum counterexample under the edge-first, vertex-second order. We also construct an infinite family of connected line graphs whose chromatic symmetric functions are not Schur-positive. This yields an infinite family of counterexamples to the Stanley--Gasharov conjecture.

Chromatic symmetric functions are well-studied symmetric functions in algebraic combinatorics that generalize chromatic polynomials of graphs. In 1995, Stanley introduced these symmetric functions and conjectured that they are Schur positive for claw-free graphs. We give examples of a line graphs, which are thus claw-free, whose chromatic symmetric function have a negative coefficient in its Schur expansion. We also give a counterexample to the 2018 conjecture of Monical that Schur positive chromatic symmetric functions have saturated Newton polytope when expanded in any finite number of variables. Both of these examples were found using ChatGPT-5.6 Sol Pro.

An open question asks whether the chromatic symmetric function (CSF) of a graph distinguishes non-isomorphic trees. While it is known that the CSF does not distinguish unicyclic graphs, examples of pairs of unicyclic graphs with the same CSF and girth larger than 3 were not known until very recently. This manuscript exhibits a sequence of pairs of non-isomorphic, connected, unicyclic graphs with increasing girth and which share the same CSF. This also provides the first infinite family of bipartite graphs with the same CSF. Our main technique is to apply a version of the "triple deletion" modular relation, due independently to Guay-Paquet and Orellana--Scott.

We show that the partitions that always appear with nonnegative $e$-coefficients in chromatic symmetric functions of finite graphs are precisely the hook partitions.

A long-standing question is whether chromatic symmetric functions can distinguish non-isomorphic trees. Campbell introduced chromatic noncommutative symmetric functions for digraphs, which lift chromatic symmetric functions to NSym, and asked to what extent they can distinguish non-isomorphic oriented trees. In this article, we prove that chromatic noncommutative symmetric functions can reconstruct oriented stars, oriented double stars, some oriented caterpillars, and some oriented paths.

A \emph{sprout sequence} is a sequence $\frakr=(R_0=1,R_1,R_2,\dots)$ of symmetric functions in the variables $\bmx=(x_1,x_2,\dots)$ over a field $K$ generated from a power series $F(t)=1+a_1t+a_2t^2+\cdots$ by the rule $\sum_{n\geq 0}R_nt^n = \prod_{i\geq 1} F(x_it)$. The power series $F(t)$ is called the \emph{seed} of $\frakr$. This concept originated in the work of Littlewood and Richardson (though not with the name ``sprout sequence''), and numerous examples of sprout sequences have appeared in the literature. They are related to chromatic Tutte polynomials of complete graphs and complete hypergraphs, binomial posets, upper homogeneous (upho) posets, topological genera, etc. We first develop the basic theory of sprout sequences and then look at the special case $F(t)=\sec(\sqrt{t})$. We give five characterizations of sprout sequences and consider the expansion of sprout symmetric functions in terms of well-known symmetric function bases. The Schur positivity, elementary symmetric function positivity, and complete homogeneous symmetric function positivity of $R_n$ for all $n$ are completely characterized using the Edrei-Thoma theorem from the theory of total positivity. The seed $F(t)=\sec(\sqrt{t})$ is especially interesting. The expansion of $R_n$ in the power sum or monomial basis is related to alternating permutations. The Schur function expansion is related to standard Young skew tableaux. The expansion in terms of the complete symmetric functions has nonnegative integer coefficients, but we don't know a combinatorial interpretation. Finally we give a formula for $R_n$ as a sum of chromatic symmetric functions of interval orders.

A graph is Schur-positive if its chromatic symmetric function expands non-negatively in the Schur basis. We determine a full Schur-positivity classification for complete multipartite graphs by showing that a complete multipartite graph $K_λ$ is Schur-positive if and only if either $λ_i\in \{1,2\}$ for all $i$ or $λ=(3,2^β)$ for some $β\ge 1$. These results extend earlier classifications for complete bipartite and complete tripartite graphs to full generality. Our proofs combine structural arguments ruling out most cases, with a combinatorial analysis of Schur coefficients for the remaining family $K_{(3,2^β)}$ via special rim hook $G$-tabloids. Along the way, we establish a simpler formula for Schur coefficients of incomparability graphs, which we then apply to compute the coefficients of interest in terms of non-increasing sequences.

We prove that the coefficient of the star $\mathfrak{st}_{21^{n-2}}$ in the chromatic symmetric function $X_G$ determines whether a connected graph $G$ is $2$-connected. We also prove new linear relations on other star coefficients of chromatic symmetric functions. This allows us to find new bases for certain spans of chromatic symmetric functions. Finally, we relate the coefficient of the star $\mathfrak{st}_n$ to acyclic orientations.

We study the $H$-chromatic symmetric functions $X_G^H$ (introduced in (arXiv:2011.06063) as a generalization of the chromatic symmetric function (CSF) $X_G$), which track homomorphisms from the graph $G$ to the graph $H$. We focus first on the case of self-chromatic symmetric functions (self-CSFs) $X_G^G$, making some progress toward a conjecture from (arXiv:2011.06063) that the self-CSF, like the normal CSF, is always different for different trees. In particular, we show that the self-CSF distinguishes trees from non-trees with just one exception, we check using Sage that it distinguishes all trees on up to 12 vertices, and we show that it determines the number of legs of a spider and the degree sequence of a caterpillar given its spine length. We also show that the self-CSF detects the number of connected components of a forest, again with just one exception. Then we prove some results about the power sum expansions for $H$-CSFs when $H$ is a complete bipartite graph, in particular proving that the conjecture from (arXiv:2011.06063) about $p$-monotonicity of $ω(X_G^H)$ for $H$ a star holds as long as $H$ is sufficiently large compared to $G$. We also show that the self-CSFs of complete multipartite graphs form a basis for the ring $Λ$ of symmetric functions, and we give some construction of bases for the vector space $Λ^n$ of degree $n$ symmetric functions using $H$-CSFs $X_G^H$ where $H$ is a fixed graph that is not a complete graph, answering a question from (arXiv:2011.06063) about whether such bases exist. However, we show that there generally do not exist such bases with $G$ fixed, even with loops, answering another question from (arXiv:2011.06063). We also define the $H$-chromatic polynomial as an analogue of the chromatic polynomial, and ask when it is the same for different graphs.

We prove that the lattices $\textbf m\times\textbf 2$ and $\textbf m\times\textbf 3$ are not Schur positive for $m\ge 8$. This confirms a conjecture of Li, Qiu, Yang, and Zhang, as an extension of counterexamples to a comment of Stanley on the universal Schur positivity of distributive lattices. Our main tools include Pieri's rules, and Wang and Wang's combinatorial formula for computing any Schur coefficient of the chromatic symmetric function of a graph in terms of special ribbon tabloids. We further show that the lattice $\textbf m\times\textbf 3$ is not strongly nice for $m\ge 44$.

Cho and van Willigenburg (arXiv:1508.07670) and Alinaeifard, Wang, and van Willgenburg (arXiv:2010.00147) introduce multiplicative chromatic bases for the ring $Λ$ of symmetric functions, consisting of the chromatic symmetric functions (CSFs) of a sequence of connected graphs $G_1,G_2,\dots$ such that $G_n$ has total weight $n$, together with the CSFs of their disjoint unions. In arXiv:1707.04058, Tsujie introduces an alternative ring structure $\widetildeΛ$ on the vector space $Λ$ that makes CSFs multiply over joins instead of over disjoint unions. The $\widetilde{m}_λ$ basis, consisting of all CSFs of weighted cliques, is a multiplicative basis for $\widetildeΛ$, as is the $r_λ$ basis of complete multipartite graphs studied by Penaguiao (arXiv:1803.08824) and Crew and Spirkl (arXiv:2009.14141). We show that one can get more of these "cochromatic bases" (where the starting graphs are combined by joins instead of disjoint unions, hence forming a multiplicative basis for $\widetildeΛ$ instead of $Λ$) if and only if the starting graphs are edgeless. We also show that $\widetildeΛ$ is a Hopf algebra with the same coproduct as $Λ$, and that many of the chromatic bases for $Λ$ generated by cliques can be taken to their corresponding cochromatic bases via Hopf algebra isomorphisms $Λ\to \widetildeΛ.$ We also show that there is a single Hopf algebra morphism taking the CSFs of all unweighted triangle-free graphs to the CSFs of their complements, and we give several more conditions and examples for when one can or cannot find Hopf algebra maps taking the CSFs of certain graphs to the CSFs of their complements. Finally, we show that $K$-analogues of many of the above statements also hold if one instead uses the Kromatic symmetric function (KSF) defined by Crew, Pechenik, and Spirkl (arXiv:2301.02177).

Tatsuyuki Hikita recently proved the Stanley--Stembridge conjecture using probabilistic methods, showing that the chromatic symmetric functions of unit interval graphs are $e$-positive. Finding a combinatorial interpretation for these $e$-coefficients remains a major open problem. Towards this goal, we introduce sets of strong and powerful $P$-tableaux and conjecture that these sets undercount and overcount the $e$-coefficients of the chromatic symmetric function $X_{inc(P)}(\mathbf{x}, q)$. We then use this framework to obtain combinatorial interpretations for various cases of $e$-expansion coefficients of chromatic symmetric functions of unit interval graphs. Additionally, we show that strong $P$-tableaux and the Shareshian--Wachs inversion statistic appear naturally in the proof of Hikita's result.

In 1995, Stanley introduced the chromatic symmetric function of a graph, which specializes to its chromatic polynomial, and which has been the focus of intense research. In 2017, Shareshian, Wachs, and Ellzey defined a refinement of this function for a directed graph, that appears to be in $QSym$, the algebra of quasisymmetric functions, which is of great interest in algebraic combinatorics. Our goal is to extend this work to signed graphs, taking into account the perspective of the hyperplane arrangement associated with a signed graph, developed by Zaslavsky. We introduce the signed chromatic quasisymmetric invariant, and obtain structural properties. As a consequence, we define and study $SQSym$, the algebra of signed quasisymmetric functions.

The Kromatic symmetric function (KSF) $\overline{X}_G$ of a graph $G$ is a $K$-analogue introduced by Crew, Pechenik, and Spirkl in arXiv:2301.02177 of Stanley's chromatic symmetric function (CSF) $X_G$. The KSF is known to distinguish some pairs of graphs with the same CSF. The first author showed in arXiv:2403.15929 and arXiv:2502.21285 that the number of copies in $G$ of certain induced subgraphs can be determined given $\overline{X}_G$, and conjectured that $\overline{X}_G$ distinguishes all graphs. We disprove that conjecture by finding four pairs of 8-vertex graphs with equal KSF, as well as giving several ways to use existing graph pairs with equal KSF to construct larger graph pairs that also have equal KSF. On the other hand, we show that many of the graph pairs from the constructions of Orellana and Scott in arXiv:1308.6005 and of Aliste-Prieto, Crew, Spirkl, and Zamora in arXiv:2007.11042 of graphs with the same CSF are distinguished by the KSF, thus also giving some new examples of cases where the KSF is a stronger invariant than the CSF.

A MacMahon symmetric function is an invariant of the diagonal action of the symmetric group on power series in multiple alphabets of variables. We introduce an analogue of the chromatic symmetric function for vertex-weighted graphs, taking values in the MacMahon symmetric functions on two sets of variables, recording information about both cardinalities and weights of vertex sets. We prove that the chromatic symmetric MacMahon function of a tree determines the generating function for its vertex subsets by cardinality, weight, and the numbers of internal and external edges. This result generalizes the one for the unweighted case, first conjectured by Crew and proved independently by Aliste-Prieto--Martin--Wagner--Zamora and Liu--Tang.