arXiv++ Combinatorics

We prove that the product of chains $\mathbf m\times\mathbf n$ is not Schur positive whenever $n\ge4$ and $m\ge3n-1$. Writing $m=n+k$, we exhibit a negative Schur coefficient indexed by $(2n+k-1,2n+k-3,\ldots,k+5,k,k,4)$ and evaluate it explicitly as $(n-2)!$ times a polynomial of degree three in $k$. Together with earlier results, this establishes the two-case interpretation of the conjecture of Li, Qiu, Yang, and Zhang: these products are not Schur positive when $n=2$ and $m\ge8$, or when $n\ge3$ and $m\ge n+5$.

Bergeron, Garsia, Haiman, and Tesler conjectured that $(-1)^{n-\ell(μ)}\nabla\widetilde H_μ[X;0,t]$ and $\nablaω\widetilde H_μ[X;0,t^{-1}]$ are Schur positive, and that $\nablaω\widetilde H_μ[X;0,t^{-1}]-\nablaω\widetilde H_ν[X;0,t^{-1}]$ is Schur positive when $μ$ dominates $ν$. The first statement follows from the compositional shuffle conjecture of Haglund, Morse, and Zabrocki, proved by Carlsson and Mellit. We prove the other two statements. All three statements also hold for $\nabla^r$ with $r\geq1$. The main new step is an identity: when $μ$ covers $ν$, the difference $ω\widetilde H_μ[X;0,t^{-1}]-ω\widetilde H_ν[X;0,t^{-1}]$ is minus a power of $t$ times one LLT polynomial. Using the Catalanimals and the Cauchy identity of Blasiak, Haiman, Morse, Pun, and Seelinger, we show that $\nabla^r$ of this LLT polynomial is, up to sign, a positive sum of LLT polynomials. We also extend the main results to the Schiffmann algebra setting.

Determining when the chromatic symmetric function of a graph is Schur positive is a central problem in algebraic combinatorics. Elementary expansions can help answer this question, but negative coefficients obstruct a direct positivity argument. We develop methods for proving Schur positivity from signed elementary expansions and apply them to chromatic symmetric functions of clique-spiders and three-legged spiders. We first give the Schur alpha-omega lemma, which bounds Schur support. We then give four equivalent sufficient criteria for Schur positivity from a fixed composition-indexed elementary expansion. The matrix, order-ideal, negative Hall, and positive Hall formulations treat positive coefficients as capacities and negative coefficients as demands, with admissible assignments governed by dominance order. These criteria provide certificates of Schur positivity especially when elementary coefficients are negative. For the four basic families of $3$-clique-spiders with total leg length at most one, we obtain complete classifications of both $e$-positivity and Schur positivity. These classifications show how the position of a single leg edge changes positivity. Using selected clique-spider cases and a path-clique bootstrap, we prove that all spiders of the form $S(a,b,2)$ are Schur positive.

We give a complete classification of Schur positivity for three-legged spiders. Every spider with at least two even legs is Schur positive, whereas every spider with three odd legs has a negative Schur coefficient. If $a$ is even and $b,c$ are odd, then the spider $S(a,b,c)$ is Schur positive if and only if $a\le 5b+5c+2$. Whenever Schur positivity fails, there is exactly one negative Schur coefficient, whose value we determine explicitly. These results extend those of Thibon and Wang for the families $S(a,2,1)$ and $S(a,4,1)$, and those of Wang and Wang for $S(a,b,2)$. The proof combines known Schur-positivity results for clique-spiders with Pieri's rule and simultaneous induction.

The $k$-Schur functions (resp., $K$-$k$-Schur functions) are the symmetric function representatives of Schubert classes in the homology (resp., $K$-homology) of the affine Grassmannian of type $A$. We prove that every $K$-$k$-Schur function is a nonnegative integer linear combination in the basis of $k$-Schur functions. This settles a conjecture by Lam, Schilling and Shimozono. The proof relies on realizations of $k$-Schur and $K$-$k$-Schur functions as Catalan and Katalan functions, respectively.

We prove that the spider graphs $S(a,2,1)$ and $S(a,4,1)$ are Schur positive for all integers $a\ge1$. Together with the known $e$-positivity results, this completes the $e$- and Schur-positivity classification of both families. Our approach uses noncommutative symmetric functions, including a particularly simple ribbon expansion for the path lift with coefficients given by powers of two. We give a new proof of the Shareshian--Wachs path formula at $t=1$ and construct corresponding lifts for spiders. The Littlewood--Richardson rule converts their ribbon expansions into a general Schur-coefficient formula in terms of weighted Yamanouchi words. Mass-preserving multi-injections and a reduction to finitely many inequalities in degree $10$ then prove the required positivity; exact computer verification of these inequalities completes the proof in full generality.

For a graph $G$, Schur positivity of $X_G$ implies that $G$ is strongly nice, and every strongly nice graph is nice. We construct three infinite families separating these properties. We first give a connected family $F_t$, $t\ge6$, that is strongly nice but not Schur positive. We then prove that homogeneous strongly nice symmetric functions with nonnegative monomial coefficients are closed under multiplication, and hence that strongly nice graphs are closed under disjoint union. As an application, for $H=K_{3,3}-e$, the graphs \[ M_t=H\sqcup K_t,\qquad t\ge3, \] form a disconnected family that is strongly nice but not Schur positive. Finally, we define \[ N_r=K_r\vee(K_2\sqcup2K_1),\qquad r\ge2, \] and prove that every $N_r$ is connected and nice but not strongly nice. We also introduce the level-$k$ nice property and show that the level depth of $N_r$ is $4r!$.

Chromatic symmetric functions are well-studied symmetric functions in algebraic combinatorics that generalize chromatic polynomials of graphs. In 1995, Stanley introduced these symmetric functions and conjectured that they are Schur positive for claw-free graphs. We give examples of a line graphs, which are thus claw-free, whose chromatic symmetric function have a negative coefficient in its Schur expansion. We also give a counterexample to the 2018 conjecture of Monical that Schur positive chromatic symmetric functions have saturated Newton polytope when expanded in any finite number of variables. Both of these examples were found using ChatGPT-5.6 Sol Pro.

The immanants of combinatorial matrices have many significant properties, including m-positivity and Schur positivity. While the immanants of Jacobi-Trudi matrices are known to be both m-positive and Schur positive, those of Giambelli matrices have only been proven to be m-positive, with Schur positivity remaining a conjecture. These positivity properties rely heavily on lattice path interpretations. In this paper, we study the Newton polytopes of immanants for these two classes of matrices. Using the lattice path method, we verify the saturation property for the Newton polytopes of Jacobi-Trudi matrices in special cases. For Giambelli matrices, we prove that this property holds for all immanants. To achieve this, we obtain the explicit coefficients of the largest monomial (in the dominance order) in the monomial expansion of the immanants of Giambelli matrices.

We study positivity properties of Hadamard products of Jacobi-Trudi matrices. Maló proved that the Hadamard (entrywise) product of two totally positive upper-triangular Toeplitz matrices whose Toeplitz sequences are the coefficient sequences of real-rooted polynomials with nonpositive zeros is again totally positive. Sokal conjectured that this result can be strengthened to total monomial positivity for the Hadamard product of Jacobi-Trudi matrices. In this paper we show that Temperley-Lieb immanants are Schur positive for Hadamard products of Jacobi-Trudi matrices given by ribbon-like skew shapes. In particular, we affirm Sokal's conjecture for minors given by ribbon-like skew shapes. Moreover, we provide a manifestly positive Schur expansion for Temperley-Lieb immanants evaluated on the Hadamard product of Jacobi-Trudi matrices indexed by ribbons. In addition, for the ribbon case, we construct a corresponding representation, offering a representation-theoretic proof of the Schur positivity.

We prove that the lattices $\textbf m\times\textbf 2$ and $\textbf m\times\textbf 3$ are not Schur positive for $m\ge 8$. This confirms a conjecture of Li, Qiu, Yang, and Zhang, as an extension of counterexamples to a comment of Stanley on the universal Schur positivity of distributive lattices. Our main tools include Pieri's rules, and Wang and Wang's combinatorial formula for computing any Schur coefficient of the chromatic symmetric function of a graph in terms of special ribbon tabloids. We further show that the lattice $\textbf m\times\textbf 3$ is not strongly nice for $m\ge 44$.

We say a sequence $f_0, f_1, f_2, \ldots$ of symmetric functions is Schur log-concave if $f_n^2 - f_{n-1}f_{n+1}$ is Schur positive for all $n\ge1$. We conjecture that a very general class of sequences of Schur functions satisfies this property, and show it for sequences of Schur functions indexed by partitions with growing first part and column. Our findings are related to work of Lam, Postnikov and Pylyavskyy on Schur positivity, and of Butler, Sagan, and the second author on $q$-log-concavity.

We establish a strong link between two open problems: determining the Reidemeister spectrum of free nilpotent groups and determining the coefficients in the Schur expansion of plethysms of Schur functions. Specifically, we show that the expressions occurring in the computations for the Reidemeister spectrum are sums of plethysms of the form $s_{1^{i}}[g]$, where $g$ is a Schur function or a Schur positive function.

In this paper we solve an open problem on distributive lattices, which was proposed by Stanley in 1998. This problem was motivated by a conjecture due to Griggs, which equivalently states that the incomparability graph of the boolean algebra $B_n$ is nice. Stanley introduced the idea of studying the nice property of a graph by investigating the Schur positivity of its corresponding chromatic symmetric functions. Since the boolean algebras form a special class of distributive lattices, Stanley raised the question of whether the incomparability graph of any distributive lattice is Schur positive. Stanley further noted that this seems quite unlikely. In this paper, we construct a family of distributive lattices which are not nice and hence not Schur positive. We also provide a family of distributive lattices which are nice but not Schur positive.

To any Schur polynomial $s_λ$ one can associated its derived polynomials $s_λ{(i)}$ $i=0,\ldots,|λ|$ by the rule $$s_λ(x_1+t,\ldots,x_n+t) = \sum_i s_λ^{(i)}(x_1,\ldots,x_n) t^i.$$ We conjecture that $$(s_λ^{(i)})^2 - s_λ^{(i-1)} s_λ^{(i+1)}$$ is always Schur positive and prove this when $i=1$ for rectangles $λ= (k^\ell)$, for hooks $λ= (k, 1^{\ell -1})$, and when $λ= (k,k,1)$ or $λ= (3,2^{k-1})$.

Haglund, Morse, and Zabrocki introduced a family of creation operators of Hall-Littlewood polynomials, $\{C_{a}\}$ for any $a\in \mathbb{Z}$, in their compositional refinement of the shuffle (ex-)conjecture. For any $α\vDash n$, the combinatorial formula for $\nabla C_α$ is a weighted sum of parking functions. These summations can be converted to a weighted sum of certain LLT polynomials. Thus $\nabla C_α$ is Schur positive since Grojnowski and Haiman proved that all LLT polynomials are Schur positive. In this paper, we obtain a recursion that implies the $C$-positivity of $(-1)^{k} m_{2^{k}1^{l}}$, and hence prove the Schur positivity of $(-1)^{k}\nabla m_{2^{k}1^{l}}$. As a corollary, a parking function interpretation for $(-1)^{k}\nabla m_{2^{k}1^{l}}$ is obtained by using the compositional shuffle theorem of Carlsson and Mellit.

Chern plethysm (introduced by Billey, Rhoades, and Tewari) is a geometric way to produce Schur positive symmetric polynomials. We present combinatorial interpretations for the Schur expansions of special cases of Chern plethysm. We also exhibit a symmetric group module whose Frobenius characteristic is (a symmetric function analog of) one of these cases, generalizing a result of Reiner and Webb.

We define monotone links on a torus, obtained as projections of curves in the plane whose coordinates are monotone increasing. Using the work of Morton-Samuelson, to each monotone link we associate elements in the double affine Hecke algebra and the elliptic Hall algebra. In the case of torus knots (when the curve is a straight line), we recover symmetric function operators appearing in the rational shuffle conjecture. We show that the class of monotone links viewed as links in $\mathbb R^3$ coincides with the class of Coxeter links, studied by Oblomkov-Rozansky in the setting of the flag Hilbert scheme. When the curve satisfies a convexity condition, we recover positroid links that we previously studied. In the convex case, we conjecture that the associated symmetric functions are Schur positive, extending a recent conjecture of Blasiak-Haiman-Morse-Pun-Seelinger, and we speculate on the relation to Khovanov-Rozansky homology. Our constructions satisfy a skein recurrence where the base case consists of piecewise almost linear curves. We show that convex piecewise almost linear curves give rise to algebraic links.

For a partition $ν$, let $λ,μ\subseteq ν$ be two distinct partitions such that $|ν/λ|=|ν/μ|=1$. Butler conjectured that the divided difference $\operatorname{I}_{λ,μ}[X;q,t]=(T_λ\widetilde{H}_μ[X;q,t]-T_μ\widetilde{H}_λ[X;q,t])/(T_λ-T_μ)$ of modified Macdonald polynomials of two partitions $λ$ and $μ$ is Schur positive. By introducing a new LLT equivalence called column exchange rule, we give a combinatorial formula for $\operatorname{I}_{λ,μ}[X;q,t]$, which is a positive monomial expansion. We also prove Butler's conjecture for some special cases.

The machinery of noncommutative Schur functions is a general approach to Schur positivity of symmetric functions initiated by Fomin-Greene. Hwang recently adapted this theory to posets to give a new approach to the Stanley-Stembridge conjecture. We further develop this theory to prove that the symmetric function associated to any $P$-Knuth equivalence graph is Schur positive. This settles a conjecture of Kim and the third author, and refines results of Gasharov, Shareshian-Wachs, and Hwang on the Schur positivity of chromatic symmetric functions.