arXiv++ Combinatorics

Let $M$ be a matroid and let $\Tutte_M(x,y)$ be its Tutte polynomial. The multiplicative Merino--Welsh inequality \[ \Tutte_M(2,0)\Tutte_M(0,2)\geq \Tutte_M(1,1)^2 \] was proved to be false for matroids by Beke, Csáji, Csikvári, and Pituk (\emph{Adv. Math.} \textbf{446} (2024), 109674). Let $U_{n,r}$ denote the rank-$r$ uniform matroid on $n$ elements, where $0<r<n$, and let $U_{n,r}^{(q)}$ denote the matroid obtained by replacing each element of $U_{n,r}$ with $q$ parallel copies. They constructed an infinite family of counterexamples of the form $U_{n,r}^{(2)}$, including $U_{33,22}^{(2)}$. In this paper, we prove that every $U_{n,r}^{(q)}$ with $q\geq3$ satisfies the inequality. For $q=2$, we prove that the minimum number of elements in such a counterexample is $62$, attained by $U_{31,21}^{(2)}$. For loopless and bridgeless graphs, Noble and Royle (\emph{Eur. J. Comb.} \textbf{38} (2014), 24--35) showed that every edge of a minimum-size counterexample to the multiplicative Merino--Welsh conjecture lies in a series or parallel class of size two or three. For matroids, we further prove that every element of a minimum-size loopless and coloopless counterexample lies in exactly one series or parallel class of size two.

We study the loopy polynomial L_G, a multivariate graph invariant arising from bizonotopal graphical algebras and defined by deletion and loopy contraction, in which the contracted edge is retained as a loop. It determines the Tutte polynomial and admits a spanning-forest expansion recording external activity componentwise. It also determines Stanley's chromatic symmetric function for every graph; the degree sequence, induced edge count profile, and independence polynomial for loopless graphs; and the clique and matching polynomials for simple graphs. Separating component size from external activity gives a refinement that is equivalent to the extended U-polynomial and the extended polychromate. The ordinary U-polynomial, Tutte's universal $V$-function, and Stanley's Tutte symmetric function are specializations of this refinement. We conjecture that L_G and U_G have the same distinguishing power on simple graphs, and verify this through eleven vertices. We exhibit five-vertex loopless multigraphs with equal U-polynomials but distinct loopy and extended U-polynomials, solving a problem of Merino and Noble. We also disprove Loebl's conjecture for chordal graphs and its restriction to split graphs, with counterexamples on eleven and fourteen vertices, respectively. For the score polytope P_G of the external bizonotopal algebra, we give a geometric realization of loopy deletion-contraction. The resulting forest-indexed geometric parking complexes partition the lattice points of P_G and are piecewise integral-affinely parametrized by boxes whose interval lengths are the component indices in the forest expansion.

Let $\mathcal{M}$ be a simple matroid of rank $r$ on the ground set $[n]=\{1,\ldots,n\}$, let $T_{\mathcal{M}}(x,y)$ denote its Tutte polynomial, and let $\mathrm{OS}(\mathcal{M})$ denote its Orlik-Solomon $\mathbb{C}$-algebra. We say that $\mathrm{OS}(\mathcal{M})$ determines $T_{\mathcal{M}}(x,y)$ if, for every simple matroid $\mathcal{N}$, an isomorphism $\mathrm{OS}(\mathcal{M})\cong\mathrm{OS}(\mathcal{N})$ of $\mathbb{C}$-algebras, without regard to the grading, implies $T_{\mathcal{M}}(x,y)=T_{\mathcal{N}}(x,y)$. Falk conjectured that the Orlik-Solomon $\mathbb{C}$-algebra of every simple matroid of rank three determines its Tutte polynomial. We prove that this holds for every simple matroid of rank at most three, thereby resolving Falk's conjecture.

The theory of combinatorial Hopf algebras (CHA) is a powerful framework for studying algebraic invariants of combinatorial objects. For instance, Stanley's chromatic symmetric function and the chromatic polynomial arise naturally from the CHA of graphs. In this paper, we define a CHA of signed graphs in order to study, in the same spirit, invariants of signed graphs such as the signed chromatic polynomial. The key ingredient of our construction is a well-chosen character, from which the signed chromatic invariants are obtained. Via the antipode, we obtain new proofs of combinatorial reciprocity results for these invariants. Moreover, by deforming the character with an additional parameter, we incorporate bivariate invariants into this framework, both for classical and signed graphs. In the classical case, this technique recovers the Tutte polynomial.

We present a "myopic" Tutte polynomial for graphs on $\mathbb{R}P^2$ which takes only nullhomologous spanning subgraphs as input. It recovers the generalized Krushkal polynomial and Drobotukhina's analogue of the Jones polynomial for alternating, nullhomologous links in $\mathbb{R}P^3$. We use this myopic Tutte polynomial to prove an analogue of the Kauffman-Murasugi-Thistlethwaite Theorem, relating the Jones polynomial of an alternating link to certain refinements of the crossing number. Finally, we construct a spanning tree model for the Khovanov homology of nullhomologous links, mirroring work by Champanerkar-Kofman and Wehrli for links in $S^3$. For alternating links, we use our model to prove that the Khovanov homology in $\mathbb{Z}/2\mathbb{Z}$ coefficients is determined entirely by the Jones polynomial and signatures of the link.

We derive new formulas for the Jones polynomial and the Kauffman bracket polynomial of a rational link represented by a standard diagram that is not necessarily alternating. These formulas generalize the results of Qazaqzeh, Yasein, and Abu-Qamar for the Tutte polynomial of the Tait graph of an alternating diagram of a rational link, as well as the matrix formulas of Lawrence and Rosenstein for the Jones polynomial of a rational link. Our approach uses the colored version of Brylawski's tensor product formula for Tutte polynomials of colored graphs, due to Diao, Hetyei, and Hinson. Furthermore, generalizing the formulas of Qazaqzeh, Yasein, and Abu-Qamar, we present a finite automaton that computes the crossing signs, thereby enabling the calculation of the writhe of a standard diagram of a rational link.

The Tutte polynomial is a bivariate polynomial that has been extensively studied in graph and matroid theory. Gordon was the first to study the Tutte polynomial $T(P;x,y)$ of the greedoid induced by a poset $P$, including the special case of series-parallel posets. In particular, Gordon and McMahon conjectured that, for any two series-parallel posets $P$ and $Q$, the equality $T(P;x,y)=T(Q;x,y)$ holds if and only if $P\cong Q$. In studying this conjecture, Gordon introduced a subclass $\mathcal{P}$ of series-parallel posets and proved that this equivalence holds for all $P,Q\in\mathcal{P}$. In this paper, we introduce a new subclass $\mathrm H$ of series-parallel posets and prove that $\mathcal P\subseteq\mathrm H$. Moreover, we show that, for every $P\in\mathrm H$ and every $Q\in\mathrm{SP}$, the equality $T(P;x,y)=T(Q;x,y)$ holds if and only if $P\cong Q$, thereby extending Gordon's result.

Hall algebras can be associated with a broad class of combinatorial structures through the theory of 2-Segal sets. In this paper, we study the Hall algebras arising from the 2-Segal sets of rooted trees, undirected graphs, and directed graphs. In each case, we establish an analogue of Green's theorem giving a twisted bialgebra structure to the Hall algebra, describe the primitive elements, and derive a presentation by generators and relations. As an application, we realize the Hall algebra of an undirected graph as the cohomology ring of a topological space. In the case of directed graphs, we introduce the Hall polynomial, defined as the Poincar{é} polynomial of the space of primitive elements. The Hall polynomial is an invariant of the underlying undirected graph which we show to be closely related to the Tutte polynomial. We furthermore give examples of graphs with equal Tutte polynomials but distinct Hall polynomials showing thus that the Hall polynomial encodes different information from that of the Tutte polynomial.

Introduced by Birkhoff in 1912 to study the four-color conjecture, the chromatic polynomial has become one of the most extensively studied graph polynomials. It is closely connected to the Tutte polynomial through specialization, to the characteristic polynomial of the associated graphic matroid, and to the flow polynomial through planar duality. It has also inspired several related polynomials, including the $σ$-polynomial, the $w$-polynomial, and the $τ$-polynomial. This survey examines these relationships, illustrated in Figure 1, and reviews the main results.

We prove a formula for the linear coefficient of the Ehrhart polynomial in terms of the Tutte polynomial. Furthermore, we characterize the matroids that extremize this Ehrhart coefficient, proving a conjecture of Ferroni.

The Tutte polynomial, through its rank-generating formula, provides a unified framework for describing various combinatorial structures of graphs and matroids, and serves as an important polynomial invariant connecting graph theory, matroid theory, and their related applications. Let $G=(V(G),E(G),r(G))$ be a simple rooted graph, where $V(G)$ is the vertex set, $E(G)$ is the edge set, and $r(G)$ is the root. Let $Γ(G)$ be the greedoid induced by the rooted graph $G$, and let its greedoid Tutte polynomial be denoted by $T(Γ(G);x,y)$. Let $r=r(G)$, $L_r(G)=\{v\in V(G)\setminus\{r\}: rv\in E(G),\ d_G(v)=1\}$, and $\ell_r(G)=|L_r(G)|$. Gordon and McMahon proposed the following conjecture: for rooted graphs, $\operatorname{ord}_{x}T(Γ(G);x,y)=\ell_r(G)$, where $\operatorname{ord}_{x}T(Γ(G);x,y)=\max\{a\in\mathbb Z_{\geq0}:x^a\mid T(Γ(G);x,y)\}$, that is, the highest power of $x$ dividing $T(Γ(G);x,y)$ is equal to the number of leaf vertices adjacent to the root. In this paper, we proved that this conjecture holds for all simple rooted graphs.

The factorisation of graph polynomials often reflects combinatorial decomposition. For a nonempty loopless graph $G$, we first prove that the two-variable interlace polynomial $q(G;x,y)$, introduced by Arratia, Bollobás and Sorkin, is irreducible over $\mathbb{C}[x,y]$ if and only if $G$ is connected, exactly paralleling the classical irreducibility theorem for the Tutte polynomial. The loopless hypothesis is essential: we construct an infinite family of connected looped graphs whose two-variable interlace polynomials are reducible. For a nonempty graph $G$, we prove that Courcelle's multivariate interlace polynomial $C_G(u,v;\mathbf{x},\mathbf{y})$ is irreducible over $\mathbb{C}[u,v,x_a,y_a:a\in V(G)]$ if and only if $G$ is connected.

DP-coloring (or correspondence coloring) is a generalization of list coloring that has been widely studied since its introduction by Dvořák and Postle in 2015. As the analogue of $P(G,q)$, the chromatic polynomial of a graph $G$, the DP color function of $G$, denoted by $P_{DP}(G,q)$, counts the minimum number of DP-colorings over all $q$-fold covers of $G$. It follows that $P_{DP}(G,q) \leq P(G,q)$. It is known that there are graphs for which $P_{DP}(G,q) < P(G,q)$ for all sufficiently large $q$; in fact, all bipartite graphs containing a cycle have this property. A fundamental open question about DP color functions asks whether, for every graph $G$, there exist $N \in \mathbb{N}$ and a polynomial $p$ such that $P_{DP}(G,q) = p(q)$ whenever $q \geq N$. In this paper we answer this question affirmatively for all bipartite graphs. Specifically, if $G$ is an $n$-vertex bipartite graph with $c$ components, then $P_{DP}(G,q) = (-1)^{n-c}q^c \;T_G(1-q,1)$ for all sufficiently large $q$, where $T_G(x,y)$ is the Tutte polynomial of $G$. The ideas we develop also yield an asymptotic formula for $P(G,q)-P_{DP}(G,q)$ whenever the girth of $G$ is even.

Place the vertices of a finite graph at projective points. Each edge defines a span map to $\mathrm{Gr}(2,n)$; the pulled-back Chern classes generate a graded algebra $A_G^{(n)}$. This assignment is a covariant graph functor, so the abstract graded-algebra type is a graph invariant. In ambient dimension four, the Hilbert series is incomparable with the chromatic and Tutte polynomials. On five vertices in dimension three, the $34$ graph classes yield $33$ algebra types, strictly refining both classical polynomials. For every tree $T$, we obtain a closed Hilbert-series formula depending only on $|V(T)|$ and $n$, while $A_T^{(3)}$ determines $T$ up to isomorphism. More precisely, its cubic relation data is a complete tree invariant of polynomial size. Finally, the graphical configuration space embeds as a dense open in the picture variety, and picture spaces with equal additive homology can have nonisomorphic edge-Chern algebras.

We establish a family of linear relations for the coefficients of the Tutte polynomial of a semimatroid. We also introduce ranked central sets, a mild generalization of semimatroids, and prove that the same identities hold in this broader setting. The proof relies on the specialization $x=\frac{z}{z-1}$, $y=z$ along the hyperbola $(x-1)(y-1)=1$; under this specialization, the edge subgraph expansion over central sets reduces to the $f$-polynomial of the central set complex. As applications, we obtain explicit formulas for Tutte polynomials of affine hyperplane arrangements and for balanced Tutte polynomials of biased graphs, whose central sets are central subarrangements and balanced edge sets, respectively. Our results recover the generalized Brylawski's identities for Tutte polynomials of ranked sets, matroids and graphs.

We introduce a partition-selection method to generalize the flow, chromatic, and Tutte polynomials of a graph by restricting the standard edge subgraph expansions to subgraphs given by prescribed connected vertex partitions. We establish similar deletion-contraction formulas and specialization relations for these polynomials, recovering all classical polynomial invariants when the selection is the set of all partitions. Next we study a relation between Jaeger et al.'s nonhomogeneous flows and a special class of partition-selected flow polynomials (called affine flow polynomials). Specifically, we give a geometric realization of nowhere-zero nonhomogeneous flows by restricting the edge-coordinate arrangement to affine flow spaces. The resulting characteristic polynomials coincide with Kochol's admissible assigning polynomials and with affine flow polynomials, which enumerate nowhere-zero nonhomogeneous flows over finite fields. To see the key role of the partition-selection framework, we further introduce boundary arrangements determined by the bond structure of a graph. Using the intersection posets of boundary arrangements, we obtain the classification of all restricted arrangements mentioned above, the comparison of unsigned coefficients of affine flow polynomials, and the decomposition formulas for affine flow polynomials.

In 1988, Las Vergnas conjectured that if $M$ is a binary matroid with bicycle dimension $d$, then for $0 \leq k \leq d$, the $k$th derivative of the diagonal Tutte polynomial $T(M;z,z)$ evaluated at $z=-1$ is an integer multiple of $2^{d-k}$. While this was rapidly disproved for binary matroids and for graphs in general, extensive computations strongly suggested that it might be true for planar graphs. In this paper we prove that this is indeed the case. To do this, we consider a stronger divisibility property that we call the LV property, and a larger class of graphs, namely the class of delta-wye-reducible graphs. By a detailed analysis of how a delta-wye exchange affects the coefficients of the diagonal Tutte polynomial, we show that delta-wye-reducible graphs have the LV property. That Las Vergnas' conjecture holds for planar graphs immediately follows because planar graphs are delta-wye reducible and the LV property is stronger than Las Vergnas' divisibility conditions.

Let $G$ be a simple connected graph, and let $T_{G}(x,y)$ be the Tutte polynomial of $G$. Motivated by the works in \cite{Ma}, we, in this paper, introduce the even-left spanning forests of $G$ and odd $G$-partitionable permutations, and show that $T_{G}(2,-1)$ is equal to both the number of even-left spanning forests of $G$ and the number of odd $G$-partitionable permutations. In particular, for a complete graph $K_n$, we prove that $T_{K_{n}}(2,-1)$ is the number of alternating permutations on $\{1,2,\dots,n+1\}$, using two distinct techniques: a recurrence relation and an explicit bijection construction.

A \emph{sprout sequence} is a sequence $\frakr=(R_0=1,R_1,R_2,\dots)$ of symmetric functions in the variables $\bmx=(x_1,x_2,\dots)$ over a field $K$ generated from a power series $F(t)=1+a_1t+a_2t^2+\cdots$ by the rule $\sum_{n\geq 0}R_nt^n = \prod_{i\geq 1} F(x_it)$. The power series $F(t)$ is called the \emph{seed} of $\frakr$. This concept originated in the work of Littlewood and Richardson (though not with the name ``sprout sequence''), and numerous examples of sprout sequences have appeared in the literature. They are related to chromatic Tutte polynomials of complete graphs and complete hypergraphs, binomial posets, upper homogeneous (upho) posets, topological genera, etc. We first develop the basic theory of sprout sequences and then look at the special case $F(t)=\sec(\sqrt{t})$. We give five characterizations of sprout sequences and consider the expansion of sprout symmetric functions in terms of well-known symmetric function bases. The Schur positivity, elementary symmetric function positivity, and complete homogeneous symmetric function positivity of $R_n$ for all $n$ are completely characterized using the Edrei-Thoma theorem from the theory of total positivity. The seed $F(t)=\sec(\sqrt{t})$ is especially interesting. The expansion of $R_n$ in the power sum or monomial basis is related to alternating permutations. The Schur function expansion is related to standard Young skew tableaux. The expansion in terms of the complete symmetric functions has nonnegative integer coefficients, but we don't know a combinatorial interpretation. Finally we give a formula for $R_n$ as a sum of chromatic symmetric functions of interval orders.

We introduce the \emph{Morse ensemble polynomial} $\ME_K(z_0,\ldots,z_d)$ of a finite simplicial complex $K$, defined as the generating function $\ME_K = \sum_M \prod_i z_i^{c_i(M)}$ over all acyclic matchings $M$ on the face poset of $K$, where $c_i(M)$ counts critical $i$-simplices. This polynomial records the complete distribution of Morse vectors across all discrete Morse functions on $K$, and is an isomorphism invariant of simplicial complexes. Our main results are the following. \textbf{(I) The Laplacian Formula}: for any connected graph $G$, $\ME_G = z_1^{m-n}\det(z_0z_1\,I_n + L_G)$, identifying $\ME_G$ as a complete Laplacian spectral invariant and showing $\ME_G$ to be incomparable with the Tutte polynomial. \textbf{(II) The Top-Face Recursion}: adding a $d$-simplex $σ$ (with $\partialσ\subset K$) to a complex $K$ gives a recursion $\ME_{K\cup\{σ\}} = z_d\cdot\ME_K + \sum_{τ\precσ}(\ME_{P(K')\setminus\{σ,τ\}}-F(K,σ,τ))$. The correction term is controlled by the top incidence graph: an incidence-separation criterion detects exactly when $F=0$, and the incidence distance gives the leading obstruction term. As a topological application, this recursion gives exact coefficient recursions for perfect and optimal discrete Morse vectors. \textbf{(III) The independence ME polynomial} $Φ(G) := \ME_{\mathrm{Ind}(G)}$ is a fine graph invariant which strictly refines the graph-level Morse ensemble $\ME_G$, separates examples not distinguished by $T_G$ and $I(G;t)$, and records collapse-level information of $\mathrm{Ind}(G)$ through coefficients such as $[z_0]Φ(G)$.