arXiv++ Combinatorics

In this article, we show that for any bridgeless graph $G$, if its flow polynomial $F(G,x)$ has real zeros only, then $G$ is the dual of a chordal plane graph and each zero of $F(G,x)$ is an integer in the set $\{1,2,3\}$.

We consider the encoding of graph problems as Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO) problems, which are solvable by either quantum or classical annealers. Yet, the class of problems encoded as QUBO problems has not previously included nowhere-zero flows. Nowhere-zero flows are related to Tutte's $5$-flow conjecture and appear in many contexts in graph theory. We provide an encoding of nowhere-zero flows as a QUBO Hamiltonian and prove the correctness of the construction. Our construction yields a Hamiltonian $H_{\mathrm{mod},k}$ whose ground state has zero energy if and only if the graph $G$ has a nowhere-zero $\mathbb Z_k$-flow. By Tutte's equivalence theorem, zero ground energy is equivalent to $\varphi(G)\le k$, and the zero-energy degeneracy is given by the flow polynomial $F(G;k)$. In particular, when the ground-state energy is zero, this is also the ground-state degeneracy. The construction uses one-hot variables to represent the edge flow residues modulo $k$ and auxiliary variables to represent the per-vertex modular quotient. We prove that the correctness of the construction is independent of the choice of orientation, root vertex, and positive penalty weights. We verify the construction on $59$ examples of graphs and values of $k$ that include both yes-instances and no-instances. We exhaustively sweep orientations and root choices on selected robustness instances and test a finite suite of positive penalty weights. The resulting Hamiltonian is implemented using the dimod.BinaryQuadraticModel class, which is compatible with the D-Wave Ocean SDK. Quantum-hardware runs and claims about potential speedup using these devices are left to follow-up work.

We introduce a partition-selection method to generalize the flow, chromatic, and Tutte polynomials of a graph by restricting the standard edge subgraph expansions to subgraphs given by prescribed connected vertex partitions. We establish similar deletion-contraction formulas and specialization relations for these polynomials, recovering all classical polynomial invariants when the selection is the set of all partitions. Next we study a relation between Jaeger et al.'s nonhomogeneous flows and a special class of partition-selected flow polynomials (called affine flow polynomials). Specifically, we give a geometric realization of nowhere-zero nonhomogeneous flows by restricting the edge-coordinate arrangement to affine flow spaces. The resulting characteristic polynomials coincide with Kochol's admissible assigning polynomials and with affine flow polynomials, which enumerate nowhere-zero nonhomogeneous flows over finite fields. To see the key role of the partition-selection framework, we further introduce boundary arrangements determined by the bond structure of a graph. Using the intersection posets of boundary arrangements, we obtain the classification of all restricted arrangements mentioned above, the comparison of unsigned coefficients of affine flow polynomials, and the decomposition formulas for affine flow polynomials.

Around 10 years ago, Agol and Krushkal showed that the number of chromatic polynomials $P_{G}$ arising from graphs $G$ on $n$ vertices grows exponentially with $n$, by establishing that the (dual) flow polynomial $F_{G}\left(\frac{3+\sqrt{5}}{2}\right)$ already takes on exponentially many values, if one varies $G$ over all planar cubic graphs $G$ on $n$ vertices. We show, more generally, that the size of the set $\{P_G(q): |V(G)|=n\}$ is exponential in $n$, for every fixed real number $q \neq 0,1,2$. In fact, our approach can also be pushed to show that $P_{G}(q)$ already takes on exponentially many values, if we only vary $G$ over all planar graphs on $n$ vertices. The case $q=3$ confirms a conjecture of Agol, which was initially motivated by the $\mathsf{NP}$-completeness of planar $3$-colorability.

This paper studies signed graphs with possible outer-edges. We introduce and investigate the chain group, the boundary operator, the co-boundary operator, the flow group, the tension group, the homology group, the cohomology group, with coefficients in an abelian group. We also introduce and investigate the bivariate flow polynomial for signed graphs. The guiding principle is the correspondence between representable matroids over $\mathbb{R}$ on a ground set $E$ of edges and the subspaces of the vector space of real-valued chains on the same ground set. The frame matroid of signed graph emerges naturally by defining circuits as minimal supports of nonzero flows, rather than listing circuit patterns abruptly. Likewise, bonds, or co-circuits, can be obtained as minimal supports of nonzero tensions. In addition to standardizing the concepts and their meanings of signed graphs, we update the following results: (1) Characterization of cuts and bonds of signed graph with outer-edges. (2) The structures of flow group, boundary group, and homology group, with coefficients in an arbitrary abelian group. (3) Introduction of bivariate flow polynomial of signed graph, revealing the mystery of inexistence of univariate flow polynomial of signed graph in the literature.

The q-state Potts model is a fundamental framework in statistical physics and graph theory, with its partition function encoding rich information about spin configurations. The multivariate Tutte polynomial (known as the partition function of the Potts model) can be defined on an arbitrary finite graph $G$ and encodes a lot of important combinatorial information about the graph. As a special case, it contains the familiar Tutte polynomial with two variables and, consequently, its specialization with one variable, such as the chromatic polynomial, the flow polynomial and the reliability polynomial. The main goal of this paper is to present an efficient algorithm for computing the Potts model partition function on SP-graphs (series-parallel graphs) with arbitrary weights. The algorithm for SP-graphs is based on simplifying the graph by replacing several edges with a single edge of equivalent weight, which significantly reduces computational complexity. In this paper, we present a linear-time algorithm for exactly computing the Potts model partition function on series-parallel graphs (SP-graphs).

We prove relations between the number of $k$-connected components of a graph, Crapo's invariant $β(M)$ of a matroid, and Speyer's polynomial $g_M(t)$. These yield a simple interpretation of $g_M'(-1)$ when $M$ is graphic or cographic. Furthermore, we improve Ferroni's algorithm to compute $g_M(t)$ and provide an implementation and an extensive data set. These calculations reveal a large number of graph theoretic constraints on the second derivative $g_M''(-1)$, which we thus advertise as an intriguing new invariant of graphs. We also propose a relation between the flow polynomial and $g_M''(0)$ for cubic graphs.

Consider a finite field $\mathbb F_q$, $q=p^d$, where $p$ is an odd number. Let $M=(E,r)$ be a regular matroid; denote by ${\mathcal B}$ the family of its bases, $\bar s(M;α)=\sum_{B\in {\mathcal B}}\prod_{e\not\in B} α_e$, where ${α_e\in \mathbb F_q}$, $α_e\neq 0$. Let a subset $A\equiv A(α)$ in $E$ have the maximal cardinality and satisfy the condition $\bar s(M|A;α)\neq 0$, while ${r^*}(α)=|A|-r(E)$. Let us represent the value of the characteristic polynomial of the matroid $M$ at the point $q$ as the linear combination of Legendre symbols with respect to $\bar s(M|A;α)$, whose coefficients are modulo equal to $1/q^{r^*(α)/2}$. This representation generalizes the formula for a flow polynomial of a graph which was obtained by us earlier. The latter formula is an analog of the so-called $α$-representation of vacuum Feynman amplitudes in the case of a finite field, which has inspired the Kontsevich conjecture (1997). The $α$-representation technique is also applicable for expressing the number of Tait colorings for a cubic biconnected planar graph in terms of principal minors of the matrix of faces of this graph.

Let $G$ be a connected bridgeless $(n,m)$-graph which may have loops and multiedges, and let $F(G,t)$ denote the flow polynomial of $G$. Dong and Koh \cite{Dong1} established an upper bound for the absolute value of coefficient $c_{i}$ of $t^{i}$ in the expansion of $F(G,t)$, where $0\leqslant i \leqslant m-n+1$. In this paper, we refine the aforementioned bound. Specifically, we demonstrate that when $n \leqslant m \leqslant n+3$, $|c_{i}|\leqslant d_{i}$, where $d_{i}$ is the coefficient of $t^{i}$ in the expansion $\prod\limits_{j=1}^{m-n+1}(t+j)$; and when $m\geqslant n+4$, $|c_{i}|\leqslant d_{i}$, with $d_{i}$ being the coefficient of $t^{i}$ in the expansion $(t+1)(t+2)(t+3)^{2}(t+4)^{m-n-3}$. Furthermore, we prove that if $G$ is a connected bridgeless cubic graph having only real flow roots, then $b_{i}\leqslant |c_{i}|$, where $b_{i}$ is the coefficient of $t^{i}$ in the expansion $(t+1)(t+2)^{\frac{n}{2}}$. Notably, if $G$ is simple connected bridgeless cubic graph with only real flow roots, then $b_{i}$ is the coefficient of $t^{i}$ in the expansion $(t+1)(t+2)^{\frac{n}{2}-2}(t+3)^{2}$.

Boesch, Li, and Suffel were the first to identify the existence of uniformly optimally reliable graphs (UOR graphs), graphs which maximize all-terminal reliability over all graphs with $n$ vertices and $m$ edges. The all-terminal reliability of a graph, and more generally a graph's all-terminal reliability polynomial $R(G;p)$, may both be obtained via the Tutte polynomial $T(G;x,y)$ of the graph $G$. Here we show that the UOR graphs found earlier are in fact maximum graphs for the Tutte polynomial itself, in the sense that they are maximum not just for all-terminal reliability but for a vast array of other parameters and polynomials that may be obtained from $T(G;x,y)$ as well. These parameters include, but are not limited to, enumerations of a wide variety of well-known orientations, partial orientations, and fourientations of $G$; the magnitudes of the coefficients of the chromatic and flow polynomials of $G$; and a wide variety of generating functions, such as generating functions enumerating spanning forests and spanning connected subgraphs of $G$. The maximality of all of these parameters is done in a unified way through the use of $(n,m)$ Tutte polynomial posets.

We establish two expansions of the Potts model partition function of a graph. One is along the deletions of a graph, a rewritten formula given in Biggs (1977). The other is along the contractions of a graph. Then, we specialize the partition function to the chromatic or flow polynomial by the Möbius inversion formula, and prove two known equations of the two polynomials. One expresses the chromatic polynomial as a weighted sum of flow polynomials of deletions, the other expresses the flow polynomial as a weighted sum of chromatic polynomials of contractions. The proof of the former by Biggs formula is due to Bychkov et al. (2021). The two expressions are considered to be dual in the sense of their forms, and transfer to each other with plane duality. This relation also holds in our expansions of the Potts model partition function. We clarify this duality by using matroid duality. Partition functions can be extended to matroids, and the two expansions can also be extended. The two expansions transfer to each other with matroid duality, so in addition to an elementary combinatorial proof of the two, we give another proof by the "duality" relation between them.

In 1977, Yu. V. Matiyasevich proposed a formula expressing the chromatic polynomial of an arbitrary graph as a linear combination of flow polynomials of subgraphs of the original graph. In this paper, we prove that this representation is a particular case of one (easily verifiable) formula, namely, the representation of the characteristic polynomial of an arbitrary matroid as a linear combination of characteristic polynomials of dual matroids. As an application, we represent the flow polynomial of a complete graph with $n$ vertices as the sum of elementary terms with respect to all partitions of positive integer $n$. Since the growth rate of the number of all partitions is less than exponential, this technique allows us to evaluate the flow polynomial for values of $n\approx 50$. We also get an explicit expression for the characteristic polynomial of the matroid dual to the matroid of the projective geometry over a finite field. We prove, in particular, that major coefficients of all these polynomials coincide with the beginning of the row in the Pascal triangle, whose number equals the quantity of elements in the corresponding matroid. At the end part of the paper, we consider one more approach, which allows us to obtain the same results of application of our main theoren by using properties of the Tutte polynomial and the classical Rota formula for coefficients of the characteristic polynomial of a matroid. In addition, we describe the connection between the matroid variant of the Matiyasevich formula and convolution formulas for Tutte polynomials.

For a bridgeless graph $G$, its flow polynomial is defined to be the function $F(G,q)$ which counts the number of nonwhere-zero $Γ$-flows on an orientation of $G$ whenever $q$ is a positive integer and $Γ$ is an additive Abelian group of order $q$. It was introduced by Tutte in 1950 and the locations of zeros of this polynomial have been studied by many researchers. This article gives a survey on the results and problems on the study of real zeros of flow polynomials.

We extend the duality between acyclic orientations and totally cyclic orientations on planar graphs to dualities on graphs on orientable surfaces by introducing boundary acyclic orientations and totally bi-walkable orientations. In addition, we provide a reciprocity theorem connecting local tensions and boundary acyclic orientations. Furthermore, we define the balanced flow polynomial which is connected with tension polynomial by duality and with totally bi-walkable orientations by reciprocity.

We introduce the ``trivariate Tutte polynomial" of a signed graph as an invariant of signed graphs up to vertex switching that contains among its evaluations the number of proper colorings and the number of nowhere-zero flows. In this, it parallels the Tutte polynomial of a graph, which contains the chromatic polynomial and flow polynomial as specializations. The number of nowhere-zero tensions (for signed graphs they are not simply related to proper colorings as they are for graphs) is given in terms of evaluations of the trivariate Tutte polynomial at two distinct points. Interestingly, the bivariate dichromatic polynomial of a biased graph, shown by Zaslavsky to share many similar properties with the Tutte polynomial of a graph, does not in general yield the number of nowhere-zero flows of a signed graph. Therefore the ``dichromate" for signed graphs (our trivariate Tutte polynomial) differs from the dichromatic polynomial (the rank-size generating function). The trivariate Tutte polynomial of a signed graph can be extended to an invariant of ordered pairs of matroids on a common ground set -- for a signed graph, the cycle matroid of its underlying graph and its frame matroid form the relevant pair of matroids. This invariant is the canonically defined Tutte polynomial of matroid pairs on a common ground set in the sense of a recent paper of Krajewski, Moffatt and Tanasa, and was first studied by Welsh and Kayibi as a four-variable linking polynomial of a matroid pair on a common ground set.

Let $G$ be a bridgeless graph. In 2011 Kung and Royle showed that all roots of the flow polynomial $F(G,λ)$ of $G$ are integers if and only if $G$ is the dual of a chordal and plane graph. In this article, we study whether a bridgeless graph $G$ for which $F(G,λ)$ has real roots only must be the dual of some chordal and plane graph. We conclude that the answer of this problem for $G$ is positive if and only if $F(G,λ)$ does not have any real root in the interval $(1,2)$. We also prove that for any non-separable and $3$-edge connected $G$, if $G-e$ is also non-separable for each edge $e$ in $G$ and every $3$-edge-cut of $G$ consists of edges incident with some vertex of $G$, then all roots of $P(G,λ)$ are real if and only if either $G\in \{L,Z_3,K_4\}$ or $F(G,λ)$ contains at least $9$ real roots in the interval $(1,2)$, where $L$ is the graph with one vertex and one loop and $Z_3$ is the graph with two vertices and three parallel edges joining these two vertices.

In contrast to ordinary graphs, the number of the nowhere-zero group-flows in a signed graph may vary with different groups, even if the groups have the same order. In fact, for a signed graph $G$ and non-negative integer $d$, it was shown that there exists a polynomial $F_d(G,x)$ such that the number of the nowhere-zero $Γ$-flows in $G$ equals $F_d(G,x)$ evaluated at $k$ for every Abelian group $Γ$ of order $k$ with $ε(Γ)=d$, where $ε(Γ)$ is the largest integer $d$ for which $Γ$ has a subgroup isomorphic to $\mathbb{Z}^d_2$. We focus on the combinatorial structure of $Γ$-flows in a signed graph and the coefficients in $F_d(G,x)$. We first define the fundamental directed circuits for a signed graph $G$ and show that all $Γ$-flows (not necessarily nowhere-zero) in $G$ can be generated by these circuits. It turns out that all $Γ$-flows in $G$ can be evenly classified into $2^{ε(Γ)}$-classes specified by the elements of order 2 in $Γ$, each class of which consists of the same number of flows depending only on the order of the group. This gives an explanation for why the number of $Γ$-flows in a signed graph varies with different $ε(Γ)$, and also gives an answer to a problem posed by Beck and Zaslavsky. Secondly, using an extension of Whitney's broken circuit theory we give a combinatorial interpretation of the coefficients in $F_d(G,x)$ for $d=0$, in terms of the broken bonds. As an example, we give an analytic expression of $F_0(G,x)$ for a class of the signed graphs that contain no balanced circuit. Finally, we show that the sets of edges in a signed graph that contain no broken bond form a homogeneous simplicial complex.

In order to apply quantum topology methods to nonplanar graphs, we define a planar diagram category that describes the local topology of embeddings of graphs into surfaces. These \emph{virtual graphs} are a categorical interpretation of ribbon graphs. We describe an extension of the flow polynomial to virtual graphs, the $S$-polynomial, and formulate the $\mathfrak{sl}(N)$ Penrose polynomial for non-cubic graphs, giving contraction-deletion relations. The $S$-polynomial is used to define an extension of the Yamada polynomial to virtual spatial graphs, and with it we obtain a sufficient condition for non-classicality of virtual spatial graphs. We conjecture the existence of local relations for the $S$-polynomial at squares of integers.

We establish a quadratic identity for the Yamada polynomial of ribbon cubic graphs in 3-space, extending the Tutte golden identity for planar cubic graphs. An application is given to the structure of the flow polynomial of cubic graphs at zero. The golden identity for the flow polynomial is conjectured to characterize planarity of cubic graphs, and we prove this conjecture for a certain infinite family of non-planar graphs. Further, we establish exponential growth of the number of chromatic polynomials of planar triangulations, answering a question of D. Treumann and E. Zaslow. The structure underlying these results is the chromatic algebra, and more generally the SO(3) topological quantum field theory.

Let $t_{i,j}$ be the coefficient of $x^iy^j$ in the Tutte polynomial $T(G;x,y)$ of a connected bridgeless and loopless graph $G$ with order $n$ and size $m$. It is trivial that $t_{0,m-n+1}=1$ and $t_{n-1,0}=1$. In this paper, we obtain expressions of another eight extreme coefficients $t_{i,j}$'s with $(i,j)=(0,m-n)$,$(0,m-n-1)$,$(n-2,0)$,$(n-3,0)$,$(1,m-n)$,$(1,m-n-1)$,$(n-2,1)$ and $(n-3,1)$ in terms of small substructures of $G$. Among them, the former four can be obtained by using coefficients of the highest, second highest and third highest terms of chromatic or flow polynomials, and vice versa. We also discuss their duality property and their specializations to extreme coefficients of the Jones polynomial.