arXiv++ Combinatorics

Zarankiewicz's long standing conjecture states that the crossing number $cr(K_{m,n})$ of the complete bipartite graph is \[ Z(m,n):=\bigg\lfloor{\frac{m}{2}}\bigg\rfloor \bigg\lfloor{\frac{m-1}{2}}\bigg\rfloor \bigg\lfloor{\frac{n}{2}}\bigg\rfloor \bigg\lfloor{\frac{n-1}{2}}\bigg\rfloor. \] Using flag algebras, we show that $cr(K_{n,n}) \geq 0.96936 \cdot Z(n,n) + o(n^4)$. We also show that the rectilinear crossing number $\overline{cr}(K_{n,n})$ of $K_{n,n}$ is at least $0.987\cdot Z(n,n) + o(n^4)$. Additionally, we prove the following for complete bipartite graphs: if a drawing of $K_{n,n}$ contains no induced subdrawing of $K_{3,4}$ with exactly two crossings whose endpoints intersect in exactly one vertex, then it has at least $Z(n,n)+o(n^4)$ crossings. This is a local restriction inspired by Turán-type problems that gives an asymptotically tight result. A closely related conjecture is Hill's conjecture stating that the crossing number $cr(K_{n})$ of the complete graph $K_n$ is \[ H(n):= \frac14 \left\lfloor \frac{n}{2} \right\rfloor \left\lfloor \frac{n-1}{2} \right\rfloor \left\lfloor \frac{n-2}{2} \right\rfloor \left\lfloor \frac{n-3}{2} \right\rfloor \] for all $n \geq 3$. By an averaging argument, the asymptotic Zarankiewicz conjecture implies the asymptotic Hill conjecture. We improve the lower bound on $cr(K_{n})$ from $(0.985+o(1)) H(n)$ to $(0.9899+o(1)) H(n)$. Both conjectures were claimed to be true in manuscripts by OpenAI dated Sep 23, 2026 and made public on Oct 6, 2026. This paper represents the state of knowledge before those publications and shows how far we can push the flag algebra method.

This paper studies crossing numbers of $d$-dimensional simplicial complexes drawn in $\mathbb R^{2d}$ or $\mathbb S^{2d}$. We clarify and generalize a number of known results and conjectures from the graph case to higher dimensions: the crossing lemma (including the exceptional case of two-dimensional complexes drawn in dimension $4$), a generalized Harary-Hill conjecture (and evidence for it), existence of a midrange crossing constant (in a weak sense), and upper bound constructions based on stochastic geometry (related to Sylvester's problem) and the cyclic polytope. Some of our results are new even in the case of graphs: we give a simple proof of the Harary-Hill conjecture for antipodal drawings, and sharpen the threshold above which the rectilinear and spherical crossing numbers of the Erdős-Rényi random graph behave like those of the complete graph.

Albertson's conjecture states that every graph of chromatic number r has crossing number at least that of the complete graph K_r. We prove the conjecture for all r. The proof combines new clique-sensitive edge bounds for critical graphs, maximum-clique sampling, and a reserved immersion construction. For graphs of order close to r, we construct edge-disjoint routes while preserving a complete bipartite subgraph whose forced crossings compensate for those introduced when the immersion is smoothed into a drawing. For larger orders, we derive explicit edge bounds using independent-triple deletion and structural properties of critical graphs, then combine them with sampling inequalities that account for crossings within a maximum clique. The remaining numerical inequalities are certified using exact rational arithmetic, with a reproducible certificate and standalone Python verifier.

We present a "myopic" Tutte polynomial for graphs on $\mathbb{R}P^2$ which takes only nullhomologous spanning subgraphs as input. It recovers the generalized Krushkal polynomial and Drobotukhina's analogue of the Jones polynomial for alternating, nullhomologous links in $\mathbb{R}P^3$. We use this myopic Tutte polynomial to prove an analogue of the Kauffman-Murasugi-Thistlethwaite Theorem, relating the Jones polynomial of an alternating link to certain refinements of the crossing number. Finally, we construct a spanning tree model for the Khovanov homology of nullhomologous links, mirroring work by Champanerkar-Kofman and Wehrli for links in $S^3$. For alternating links, we use our model to prove that the Khovanov homology in $\mathbb{Z}/2\mathbb{Z}$ coefficients is determined entirely by the Jones polynomial and signatures of the link.

We present a procedure that, given a pair of coprime integers, produces a one-vertex triangulation of the three-sphere containing the corresponding torus knot as an edge. The construction is canonical, and produces a three-sphere triangulation from a pair of minimal layered triangulations of the solid torus. The size of the triangulation is, in the worst case, linear, but can be as small as logarithmic in the crossing number of the knot, motivating this triangulation size as an organising principle for knots, alternative to the crossing number.

The Hamming graph H(d,3)=K_3^{box d} (n=3^d vertices) is the graph of single-symbol errors of ternary codes, yet we ask a geometric question of it: can it be drawn in the plane with every edge exactly one unit long and no two non-adjacent vertices a unit apart? It can, for every d, joining two problems into one. Where does it live? As a Minkowski sum of unit triangles, each H(d,3) has a hidden flexibility carrying its coordinates up the constructibility ladder (compass, origami, and beyond), so one graph is realizable over many number fields at once, in the plane and in R^3 (edim(H(d,q))=q-1). Yet almost every faithful realization is transcendental: the Galois picture is a measure-zero shadow of a vast transcendental continuum, matching the exists-R hardness of unit-distance recognition. How crowded must a unit drawing be? We separate the ordinary crossing number from a unit-distance crossing number (absent from Schaefer's survey), and one recursion H(d,3)=H(d-1,3) box K_3 controls both. We prove cr(H)=Theta(n^2), with sharp one-page constant 7/6; and Omega(n^2) <= udcr(H) <= O(n^2 log n) by concentration, plus a closed-form majorant (3/2)n^2(L^2-L+1), L=log_3 n. The least-crossing drawing we find is constructible (origami): field and crossings are two readings of one geometry. All claims are verified computationally; the lower bound udcr=Omega(n^2 log n) is the central open problem.

A rotation system on $n$ elements assigns to each element a cyclic order of the other $n-1$ elements. A four-element subset is non-planar if its induced rotation system cannot be realized by a crossing-free drawing of $K_4$. As a combinatorial strengthening of Hill's conjecture on the crossing number of the complete graph, Archdeacon conjectured that every rotation system on $n$ elements has at least $H(n)=\frac{1}{4} \lfloor\frac {n}{2}\rfloor \lfloor\frac{n-1}{2}\rfloor \lfloor\frac{n-2}{2}\rfloor \lfloor\frac{n-3}{2}\rfloor$ non-planar four-element subsets. We computationally verify Archdeacon's conjecture for $n\leq 10$ and show that every extremal rotation system in these orders is realizable by a simple drawing. With computer assistance, we prove that every rotation system on $n$ elements has at least $(8/9 - o(1)) H(n)$ non-planar four-element subsets. We also present a proof by hand for a weaker lower bound of $(2/3-o(1)) H(n)$. Finally, extending recent work of Felsner on antipodal pairs in drawings, we show that Archdeacon's conjecture holds for antipodally shellable rotation systems.

We study two inverse problems for shortest-path metrics of Okamura-Seymour instances: recognizing metrics realizable by outerplanar graphs, and computing minimum-edge Okamura-Seymour realizations. We introduce the notion of \emph{repelling pairs}, a metric certificate that the shortest paths corresponding to two terminal pairs must be vertex-disjoint in every realization. Our central structural result is that, for an Okamura-Seymour metric with a prescribed cyclic order, a terminal path structure in an Okamura-Seymour instance can be realized by nonnegative edge lengths if and only if the paths assigned to every repelling pair are vertex-disjoint. Building on the notion of repelling pairs, we give algorithmic answers to the inverse problems. First, we design an algorithm that, given a metric, decides in polynomial time whether or it admits an outerplanar realization and constructs one when one exists. Second, given an Okamura-Seymour metric, we efficiently compute a canonical medial template whose crossing number equals the minimum number of edges in any Okamura-Seymour realization. The minimum-edge graph structures are exactly the primal graphs of arrangements of this template, and each can be assigned realizing edge lengths in polynomial time.

The enumeration of planar maps with control on the boundary metric, i.e. the pseudometric induced on the outer face of the map by its bulk graph distance metric, is a difficult problem in general. However, we show that for a family of bipartite planar map models with special q-deformed face weights that arise in the physics context of the double-scaled Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model (DSSYK) the enumeration admits a very simple answer. Encoding the boundary metric of a bipartite planar map by its so-called geodesic chord diagram, we prove that the weighted enumeration depends only on the crossing number of the chord diagram. At fixed perimeter, the induced law of the geodesic chord diagram in these planar map models coincides exactly with the chord diagram representation of the DSSYK model.

Using the concepts of Eulerian-spanning set and coboundary operator, we generalize Hadlock's conversion of the maxcut problem on planar graphs to one on general graphs with non-negative weights. Using our conversion, we can explore algorithms for maxcut beyond the class of planar graphs. We obtain a Fixed-Parameter Tractable algorithm for $k$-contraction apex graphs. Specifically, our algorithm can be applied to graphs with crossing number $k$, giving an $O(2^k(n+k)^{3/2}\log (n+k))$-time algorithm that matches the best known results when restricted to non-negative weights.

We study the existence of plane substructures in drawings of the $d$-dimensional hypercube graph $Q_d$. We construct drawings of $Q_d$ which contain no plane subgraph with more than $2d-2$ edges, no plane path with more than $2d-3$ edges, and no plane matching of size more than $2d-4$. On the other hand, we prove that every rectilinear drawing of $Q_d$ with vertices in convex position contains a plane path of length $d$ (if $d$ is odd) or $d-1$ (if $d$ is even). We also prove that if a graph $G$ is a plane subgraph of every drawing of $Q_d$ for a sufficiently large $d$, then $G$ is necessarily a forest of caterpillars. Lastly, we give a short proof of a generalization of a result by Alpert et al. [Cong. Numerantium, 2009] on the maximum rectilinear crossing number of $Q_d$.

Motivated by Kuratowski's theorem, a Kuratowski subgraph of a graph is a subgraph that is a subdivided $K_5$ or a subdivided $K_{3,3}$. An edge is crossing-critical if the crossing number decreases after removing the edge. In this note, we present the following examples: a graph with an edge that is crossed in every optimal drawing of the graph, but the edge is not in any Kuratowski subgraph of the graph; a graph with an edge that is in every Kuratowski subgraph but is not crossed in any optimal drawing of the graph; and a graph with a crossing-critical edge that is not present in any Kuratowski subgraph and is not crossed in any optimal drawing of the graph.

Grid diagrams are special representations of knots in the three-sphere that are used to define a combinatorial version of knot Floer homology. Paolo Ghiggini and Yi Ni showed that knot Floer homology detects fibered knots. Their results imply, in particular, that grid diagrams with a unique grid state whose Alexander grading is maximal only exist for fibered knots. Whether every fibered knot admits such a diagram remains an open question. Here, we investigate the existence of such special grid diagrams for fibered knots. We develop an efficient method for deciding whether a given grid diagram meets the even stricter condition of having a unique grid state that realizes an upper bound for the Alexander function. By implementing this method in a Python package, we find suitable grid diagrams for 5385 of the 5397 fibered prime knots with crossing number at most 13.

We develop a purely combinatorial framework for the systematic enumeration of knot and link diagrams supported on the thickened torus $T^2\times I$. Using the theory of maps on surfaces, cellular $4$--regular torus projections are encoded by permutation pairs $(α,σ)$, and unsensed projection classes are enumerated completely and without duplication via canonical representatives. For a fixed projection, crossing assignments are encoded by bit data, and an immediate Reidemeister~II reduction supported by a bigon face is characterized directly in terms of these bits. The genus-one generalized Kauffman-type bracket is then evaluated as a state sum entirely within the permutation model, without drawing diagrams in a fundamental polygon. The implementation is validated against published genus-one classifications for $N\le 5$ under explicit comparison conventions, with remaining discrepancies explained at the level of global conventions. Beyond the published range, we compute projection and diagram data for crossing numbers up to $N=8$ and provide a public reference implementation together with machine-readable datasets. Via the standard correspondence between virtual knots and knots in thickened surfaces, this yields a canonical and fully reproducible genus-one framework for virtual knot tabulation.

We show that the 3-symmetric rectilinear and the 3-symmetric pseudolinear crossing numbers of $K_{33}$ are equal. Specifically, we prove that $\operatorname{sym}-\overline{\operatorname{cr}}_3(K_{33}) = 14 634 = \operatorname{sym}-\widetilde{\operatorname{cr}}_3(K_{33})$.

Albertson conjectured that every graph with chromatic number $r$ has crossing number at least the crossing number of the complete graph $K_r$. This conjecture was proved for $r\le 12$ by Albertson, Cranston, and Fox; for $r\le 16$ by Barát and Tóth; and for $r\le 18$ by Ackerman. Here we verify it for $r\le 24$; we also greatly restrict the possibilities for counterexamples when $r\in\{25,26\}$. In addition, we strengthen earlier work bounding the order of a minimum counterexample for each choice of $r$: we exclude the possibility that $|G|\ge 2.82r$ and exclude the possibility that $1.228r\le |G|\le 1.768r$. Finally, as $r$ grows, we extend the lower end of this range of excluded orders for a minimum counterexample. In particular: if $r\ge 125{,}000$, then we exclude the possibility that $1.10r\le |G|\le 1.768r$; and if $r\ge 825{,}000$, then we exclude the possibility that $1.05r\le |G|\le 1.768r$.

We define a set of restricted Reidemeister moves and show that if $K$ is obtained from $K_0\,\#\,K_1$ using those moves, then the crossing number of $K$ is at least $c(K_0)+c(K_1)$. We also explore topological interpretations of this result.

We prove that all $1$-vertex spatial graphs with adequate diagrams have minimal crossing number, and that spatial graph diagrams obtained by replacing vertices and edges of a planar embedded graph by minimal crossing link or spatial graph diagrams have minimal crossing number. Finally, we give an example in answer to a question of Adams et al. about minimal crossing diagrams of rigid vertex graphs.

The crossing number of a graph is the minimum number of crossings over all of its drawings on the plane. The Crossing Lemma, proved more than 40 years ago, is a tight lower bound on the crossing number of a graph in terms of the number of vertices and edges. It is definitely the most important inequality on crossing numbers. We review some generalizations and applications of the Crossing Lemma.

We study crossing numbers for systoles of congruence surfaces. Taken as a family of curves on a family of surfaces, we show that the growth rate of their intersection is optimally small among all sets of curves of the same cardinality lying on the same topological surface.