arXiv++ Combinatorics

Let $Γ$ be a straight-line crossing-free drawing of a tree $T$. A \emph{bad pair} in $Γ$ is a pair of non-adjacent vertices of $T$ whose Euclidean distance in $Γ$ is smaller than the length of the longest edge in the path connecting them in~$Γ$. When $Γ$ has no bad pairs, $Γ$ is a Euclidean Minimum Spanning Tree of its vertex set (or EMST-drawing for short). Deciding whether a tree of maximum degree at most six admits an EMST-drawing is known to be \NP-hard. In contrast, we characterize those caterpillars that admit an EMST-drawing. The characterization gives rise to a linear-time algorithm that decides if a caterpillar admits an EMST-drawing, and in the affirmative case, computes such a drawing. For caterpillars of maximum degree six, we further present a linear-time algorithm to compute a crossing-free straight-line drawing with the minimum number of bad pairs. For $n$-vertex trees with maximum vertex degree $Δ$, we prove the $Δ^2n\log n$ upper bound on the minimum number of bad pairs. In the special case of stars, we construct a drawing with the minimum number of bad pairs.

We study the problem of reconfiguring odd matchings, that is, matchings that cover all but a single vertex. Our reconfiguration operation is a so-called flip where the unmatched vertex of the first matching gets matched, while consequently another vertex becomes unmatched. We consider two distinct settings: the geometric setting, in which the vertices are points embedded in the plane and all occurring odd matchings are crossing-free, and a combinatorial setting, in which we consider odd matchings in general graphs. For the latter setting, we provide a complete polynomial time checkable characterization of graphs in which any two odd matchings can be reconfigured into each another. This complements the previously known result that the flip graph is always connected in the geometric setting [Aichholzer, Brötzner, Perz, and Schnider. Flips in odd matchings]. In the combinatorial setting, we prove that the diameter of the flip graph, if connected, is linear in the number of vertices. Furthermore, we establish that deciding whether there exists a flip sequence of length $k$ transforming one given matching into another is NP-complete in both the combinatorial and the geometric settings. To prove the latter, we introduce a framework that allows us to transform partial order types into general position with only polynomial overhead. Finally, we demonstrate that when parameterized by the flip distance $k$, the problem is fixed-parameter tractable (FPT) in the geometric setting when restricted to convex point sets.

Given a set $A$ of $n$ points (vertices) in general position in the plane, the \emph{complete geometric graph} $K_n[A]$ consists of all $\binom{n}{2}$ segments (edges) between the elements of $A$. It is known that the edge set of every complete geometric graph on $n$ vertices can be partitioned into $O(n^{3/2})$ crossing-free paths (or matchings). We strengthen this result under various additional assumptions on the point set. In particular, we prove that for a set $A$ of $n$ \emph{randomly} selected points, uniformly distributed in $[0,1]^2$, with probability tending to $1$ as $n\rightarrow\infty$, the edge set of $K_n[A]$ can be covered by $O(n\log n)$ crossing-free paths and by $O(n\sqrt{\log n})$ crossing-free matchings. On the other hand, we construct $n$-element point sets such that covering the edge set of $K_n[A]$ requires a quadratic number of monotone paths.

Generalizing pseudospherical drawings, we introduce a new class of simple drawings, which we call separable drawings. In a separable drawing, every edge can be closed to a simple curve that intersects each other edge at most once. Curves of different edges might interact arbitrarily. Most notably, we show that (1) every separable drawing of any graph on $n$ vertices in the plane can be extended to a simple drawing of the complete graph $K_{n}$, (2) every separable drawing of $K_{n}$ contains a crossing-free Hamiltonian cycle and is plane Hamiltonian connected, and (3) every generalized convex drawing and every 2-page book drawing is separable. Further, the class of separable drawings is a proper superclass of the union of generalized convex and 2-page book drawings. Hence, our results on plane Hamiltonicity extend recent work on generalized convex drawings by Bergold et al. (SoCG 2024).

A subset $S$ of vertices in a planar graph $G$ is a free set if, for every set $P$ of $|S|$ points in the plane, there exists a straight-line crossing-free drawing of $G$ in which vertices of $S$ are mapped to distinct points in $P$. In this survey, we review - several equivalent definitions of free sets, - results on the existence of large free sets in planar graphs and subclasses of planar graphs, - and applications of free sets in graph drawing. The survey concludes with a list of open problems in this still very active research area.

Simultaneous Geometric Embedding (SGE) asks whether, for a given collection of graphs on the same vertex set V, there is an embedding of V in the plane that admits a crossing-free drawing with straightline edges for each of the given graphs. It is known that SGE is $\exists\mathbb{R}$-complete, that is, the problem is polynomially equivalent to deciding whether a system of polynomial equations and inequalities with integer coefficients has a real solution. We prove that SGE remains $\exists\mathbb{R}$-complete for edge-disjoint input graphs, that is, for collections of graphs without so-called public edges. As an intermediate result, we prove that it is $\exists\mathbb{R}$-complete to decide whether a directional walk without repeating edges is realizable. Here, a directional walk consists of a sequence of not-necessarily distinct vertices (a walk) and a function prescribing for each inner position whether the walk shall turn left or shall turn right. A directional walk is realizable, if there is an embedding of its vertices in the plane such that the embedded walk turns according to the given directions. Previously it was known that realization is $\exists\mathbb{R}$-complete to decide for directional walks repeating each edge at most 336 times. This answers two questions posed by Schaefer ["On the Complexity of Some Geometric Problems With Fixed Parameters", JGAA 2021].

A geophylogeny is a phylogenetic tree (or dendrogram) where each leaf (e.g. biological taxon) has an associated geographic location (site). To clearly visualize a geophylogeny, the tree is typically represented as a crossing-free drawing next to a map. The correspondence between the taxa and the sites is either shown with matching labels on the map (internal labeling) or with leaders that connect each site to the corresponding leaf of the tree (external labeling). In both cases, a good order of the leaves is paramount for understanding the association between sites and taxa. We define several quality measures for internal labeling and give an efficient algorithm for optimizing them. In contrast, minimizing the number of leader crossings in an external labeling is NP-hard. On the positive side, we show that crossing-free instances can be solved in polynomial time and give a fixed-parameter tractable (FPT) algorithm. Furthermore, optimal solutions can be found in a matter of seconds on realistic instances using integer linear programming. Finally, we provide several efficient heuristic algorithms and experimentally show them to be near optimal on real-world and synthetic instances.

A set $\mathcal{G}$ of planar graphs on the same number $n$ of vertices is called simultaneously embeddable if there exists a set $P$ of $n$ points in the plane such that every graph $G \in \mathcal{G}$ admits a (crossing-free) straight-line embedding with vertices placed at points of $P$. A conflict collection is a set of planar graphs of the same order with no simultaneous embedding. A well-known open problem from 2007 posed by Brass, Cenek, Duncan, Efrat, Erten, Ismailescu, Kobourov, Lubiw and Mitchell, asks whether there exists a conflict collection of size $2$. While this remains widely open, we give a short proof that for sufficiently large $n$ there exists a conflict collection consisting of at most $(3+o(1))\log_2(n)$ planar graphs on $n$ vertices. This constitutes a double-exponential improvement over the previously best known bound of $O(n\cdot 4^{n/11})$ for the same problem by Goenka, Semnani and Yip. Using our method we also provide a computer-free proof that there exists a conflict collection of size $30$, improving upon the previously smallest known conflict collection of size $49$ which was found using heavy computer assistance. While the construction by Goenka et al. was explicit, our construction of a conflict collection of size $O(\log n)$ is based on the probabilistic method and is thus only implicit. Motivated by this, for every large enough $n$ we give a different, fully explicit construction of a collection of less than $n^6$ planar $n$-vertex graphs with no simultaneous embedding.

Let $Ass_k(n)$ denote the simplicial complex of $(k+1)$-crossing-free subsets of edges in $\binom{n}{2}$. Here $k,n\in \mathbb{N}$ and $n\ge 2k+1$. It is conjectured that this simplicial complex is polytopal (Jonsson 2005). However, despite several recent advances, this is still an open problem. In this paper we attack this problem using as a vector configuration the rows of a rigidity matrix, namely, hyperconnectivity restricted to bipartite graphs. We see that in this way $Ass_k(n)$ can be realized as a polytope for $k=2$ and $n\le 10$, and as a fan for $k=2$ and $n\le 13$, and for $k=3$ and $n\le 11$. However, we also prove that the cases with $k\ge 3$ and $n\ge \max\{12,2k+4\}$ are not realizable in this way. We also give an algebraic interpretation of the rigidity matroid, relating it to a projection of determinantal varieties with implications in matrix completion, and prove the presence of a fan isomorphic to $Ass_{k-1}(n-2)$ in the tropicalization of that variety.

It is a longstanding conjecture that every simple drawing of a complete graph on $n \geq 3$ vertices contains a crossing-free Hamiltonian cycle. We strengthen this conjecture to "there exists a crossing-free Hamiltonian path between each pair of vertices" and show that this stronger conjecture holds for several classes of simple drawings, including strongly c-monotone drawings and cylindrical drawings. As a second main contribution, we give an overview on different classes of simple drawings and investigate inclusion relations between them up to weak isomorphism.

A finite set $P$ of points in the plane is $n$-universal with respect to a class $\mathcal{C}$ of planar graphs if every $n$-vertex graph in $\mathcal{C}$ admits a crossing-free straight-line drawing with vertices at points of $P$. For the class of all planar graphs the best known upper bound on the size of a universal point set is quadratic and the best known lower bound is linear in $n$. Some classes of planar graphs are known to admit universal point sets of near linear size, however, there are no truly linear bounds for interesting classes beyond outerplanar graphs. In this paper, we show that there is a universal point set of size $2n-2$ for the class of bipartite planar graphs with $n$ vertices. The same point set is also universal for the class of $n$-vertex planar graphs of maximum degree $3$. The point set used for the results is what we call an exploding double chain, and we prove that this point set allows planar straight-line embeddings of many more planar graphs, namely of all subgraphs of planar graphs admitting a one-sided Hamiltonian cycle. The result for bipartite graphs also implies that every $n$-vertex plane graph has a $1$-bend drawing all whose bends and vertices are contained in a specific point set of size $4n-6$, this improves a bound of $6n-10$ for the same problem by Löffler and Tóth.

Let $Δ_k(n)$ denote the simplicial complex of $(k+1)$-crossing-free subsets of edges in $\binom{[n]}{2}$. Here $k,n\in \mathbb N$ and $n\ge 2k+1$. Jonsson (2003) proved that (neglecting the short edges that cannot be part of any $(k+1)$-crossing), $Δ_k(n)$ is a shellable sphere of dimension $k(n-2k-1)-1$, and conjectured it to be polytopal. The same result and question arose in the work of Knutson and Miller (2004) on subword complexes. Despite considerable effort, the only values of $(k,n)$ for which the conjecture is known to hold are $n\le 2k+3$ (Pilaud and Santos, 2012) and $(2,8)$ (Bokowski and Pilaud, 2009). Using ideas from rigidity theory and choosing points along the moment curve we realize $Δ_k(n)$ as a polytope for $(k,n)\in \{(2,9), (2,10) , (3,10)\}$. We also realize it as a simplicial fan for all $n\le 13$ and arbitrary $k$, except the pairs $(3,12)$ and $(3,13)$. Finally, we also show that for $k\ge 3$ and $n\ge 2k+6$ no choice of points can realize $Δ_k(n)$ via bar-and-joint rigidity with points along the moment curve or, more generally, via cofactor rigidity with arbitrary points in convex position.

A matchstick graph is a crossing-free unit-distance graph in the plane. Harborth (1981) proposed the problem of determining whether there exists a matchstick graph in which every vertex has degree exactly $5$. In 1982, Blokhuis gave a proof of non-existence. A shorter proof was found by Kurz and Pinchasi (2011) using a charging method. We combine their method with the isoperimetric inequality to show that there are $Ω(\sqrt{n})$ vertices in a matchstick graph on $n$ vertices that are of degree at most $4$, which is asymptotically tight.

The $k$-associahedron $Ass_k(n)$ is the simplicial complex of $(k+1)$-crossing-free subgraphs of the complete graph with vertices on a circle. Its facets are called $k$-triangulations. We explore the connection of $Ass_k(n)$ with the Pfaffian variety $Pf_k(n)\subset {\mathbb K}^{\binom{[n]}2}$ of antisymmetric matrices of rank $\le 2k$. First, we characterize the Gröbner cone $Grob_k(n)\subset{\mathbb R}^{\binom{[n]}2}$ producing as initial ideal of $I(Pf_k(n))$ the Stanley-Reisner ideal of $Ass_k(n)$ (that is, the monomial ideal generated by $(k+1)$-crossings). This implies that $k$-triangulations are bases in the algebraic matroid of $Pf_k(n)$, a matroid closely related to low-rank completion of antisymmetric matrices. We then look at the tropicalization of $Pf_k(n)$ and show that $Ass_k(n)$ embeds naturally as the intersection of $\operatorname{trop}(Pf_k(n))$ and $Grob_k(n)$, and is contained in the totally positive part $\operatorname{trop}^+( Pf_k(n))$ of it. We show that for $k=1$ and for each triangulation $T$ of the $n$-gon, the projection of this embedding of $Ass_k(n)$ to the $n-3$ coordinates corresponding to diagonals in $T$ gives a complete polytopal fan, realizing the associahedron. This fan is linearly isomorphic to the $\mathbf g$-vector fan of the cluster algebra of type $A$, shown to be polytopal by Hohlweg, Pilaud and Stella in (2018).

We introduce and study the problem of constructing geometric graphs that have few vertices and edges and that are universal for planar graphs or for some sub-class of planar graphs; a geometric graph is \emph{universal} for a class $\mathcal H$ of planar graphs if it contains an embedding, i.e., a crossing-free drawing, of every graph in $\mathcal H$. Our main result is that there exists a geometric graph with $n$ vertices and $O(n \log n)$ edges that is universal for $n$-vertex forests; this extends to the geometric setting a well-known graph-theoretic result by Chung and Graham, which states that there exists an $n$-vertex graph with $O(n \log n)$ edges that contains every $n$-vertex forest as a subgraph. Our $O(n \log n)$ bound on the number of edges cannot be improved, even if more than $n$ vertices are allowed. We also prove that, for every positive integer $h$, every $n$-vertex convex geometric graph that is universal for $n$-vertex outerplanar graphs has a near-quadratic number of edges, namely $Ω_h(n^{2-1/h})$; this almost matches the trivial $O(n^2)$ upper bound given by the $n$-vertex complete convex geometric graph. Finally, we prove that there exists an $n$-vertex convex geometric graph with $n$ vertices and $O(n \log n)$ edges that is universal for $n$-vertex caterpillars.

We introduce the novel concepts of local and union book embeddings, and, as the corresponding graph parameters, the local page number ${\rm pn}_\ell(G)$ and the union page number ${\rm pn}_u(G)$. Both parameters are relaxations of the classical page number ${\rm pn}(G)$, and for every graph $G$ we have ${\rm pn}_\ell(G) \leq {\rm pn}_u(G) \leq {\rm pn}(G)$. While for ${\rm pn}(G)$ one minimizes the total number of pages in a book embedding of $G$, for ${\rm pn}_\ell(G)$ we instead minimize the number of pages incident to any one vertex, and for ${\rm pn}_u(G)$ we instead minimize the size of a partition of $G$ with each part being a vertex-disjoint union of crossing-free subgraphs. While ${\rm pn}_\ell(G)$ and ${\rm pn}_u(G)$ are always within a multiplicative factor of $4$, there is no bound on the classical page number ${\rm pn}(G)$ in terms of ${\rm pn}_\ell(G)$ or ${\rm pn}_u(G)$. We show that local and union page numbers are closer related to the graph's density, while for the classical page number the graph's global structure can play a much more decisive role. We introduce tools to investigate local and union book embeddings in exemplary considerations of the class of all planar graphs and the class of graphs of tree-width $k$. As an incentive to pursue research in this new direction, we offer a list of intriguing open problems.

We study the question whether a crossing-free 3D morph between two straight-line drawings of an $n$-vertex tree can be constructed consisting of a small number of linear morphing steps. We look both at the case in which the two given drawings are two-dimensional and at the one in which they are three-dimensional. In the former setting we prove that a crossing-free 3D morph always exists with $O(\log n)$ steps, while for the latter $Θ(n)$ steps are always sufficient and sometimes necessary.

Let $G$ be a multigraph with $n$ vertices and $e>4n$ edges, drawn in the plane such that any two parallel edges form a simple closed curve with at least one vertex in its interior and at least one vertex in its exterior. Pach and Tóth (A Crossing Lemma for Multigraphs, SoCG 2018) extended the Crossing Lemma of Ajtai et al. (Crossing-free subgraphs, North-Holland Mathematics Studies, 1982) and Leighton (Complexity issues in VLSI, Foundations of computing series, 1983) by showing that if no two adjacent edges cross and every pair of nonadjacent edges cross at most once, then the number of edge crossings in $G$ is at least $αe^3/n^2$, for a suitable constant $α>0$. The situation turns out to be quite different if nonparallel edges are allowed to cross any number of times. It is proved that in this case the number of crossings in $G$ is at least $αe^{2.5}/n^{1.5}$. The order of magnitude of this bound cannot be improved.

A topological graph is a graph drawn in the plane. A topological graph is $k$-plane, $k>0$, if each edge is crossed at most $k$ times. We study the problem of partitioning the edges of a $k$-plane graph such that each partite set forms a graph with a simpler structure. While this problem has been studied for $k=1$, we focus on optimal $2$-plane and $3$-plane graphs, which are $2$-plane and $3$-plane graphs with maximum density. We prove the following results. (i) It is not possible to partition the edges of a simple optimal $2$-plane graph into a $1$-plane graph and a forest, while (ii) an edge partition formed by a $1$-plane graph and two plane forests always exists and can be computed in linear time. (iii) We describe efficient algorithms to partition the edges of a simple optimal $2$-plane graph into a $1$-plane graph and a plane graph with maximum vertex degree $12$, or with maximum vertex degree $8$ if the optimal $2$-plane graph is such that its crossing-free edges form a graph with no separating triangles. (iv) We exhibit an infinite family of simple optimal $2$-plane graphs such that in any edge partition composed of a $1$-plane graph and a plane graph, the plane graph has maximum vertex degree at least $6$ and the $1$-plane graph has maximum vertex degree at least $12$. (v) We show that every optimal $3$-plane graph whose crossing-free edges form a biconnected graph can be decomposed, in linear time, into a $2$-plane graph and two plane forests.

We explore various techniques for counting the number of straight-edge crossing-free graphs that can be embedded on a planar point set. In particular, we derive a lower bound on the ratio of the number of such graphs with $m+1$ edges to the number of graphs with $m$ edges. We show how a relatively small improvement of this bound would improve existing bounds concerning numbers of plane graphs with a prescribed number of edges. Furthermore, we use a cross-graph charging scheme to derive lower bounds for the number of such graphs when the point set has few extreme points.