arXiv++ Combinatorics

There is a fascinating array of interrelated questions studying which structures can be guaranteed in digraphs of large minimum out-degree. These often have intriguingly simple statements, yet seem surprisingly difficult to approach. A well-known example is Lichiardopol's conjecture (2014), stating that there exists a function $g:\mathbb{N}\rightarrow \mathbb{N}$ such that every digraph with minimum out-degree at least $g(k)$ contains $k$ vertex-disjoint directed cycles of distinct lengths. In this paper, building on earlier work of the second author, we confirm this conjecture in full generality. We also generalise this result to a weighted setting. Our proof uses and combines many ingredients from structural digraph theory such as butterfly minors, directed tangles, a directed analogue of the Tangle-Wall Theorem due to Robertson and Seymour as well as a local variant of the Directed Flat Wall Theorem due to Giannopoulou, Kawarabayashi, Kreutzer and Kwon. These techniques, which are somewhat atypical in the study of minimum degree conditions, may be of independent interest and may find further applications.

The well-known Bermond-Thomassen conjecture states that every digraph of minimum out-degree at least $2k-1$ contains $k$ vertex-disjoint directed cycles. Despite being posed in 1981, this conjecture remains unresolved for all $k \ge 4$. We prove a relaxation of this conjecture: every digraph $D$ of minimum out-degree at least $2k-1$ contains $k$ vertex-disjoint cycles, each of which either is directed or can be made directed by reversing one of its arcs. This bound is sharp and answers a question raised by Cames van Batenburg during the online workshop "Entropy Compression and Related Methods" in $2021$.

A famous conjecture of Erdős and Hajnal from 1969 states that for every integer $g\ge 4$ there exists a (smallest) function $f_g:\mathbb{N}\rightarrow \mathbb{N}$ such that every graph of chromatic number at least $f_g(k)$ contains a subgraph with chromatic number at least $k$ and girth at least $g$. So far, this has only been proved for $g=4$ by Rödl in 1977 and remains open for every $g\ge 5$. Rödl's elegant proof yields an upper bound on $f_4(k)$ which is a tower of $k$-s of height $Θ(k^2\log k)$, suggesting the problem of improving this enormous bound. We deduce a single-exponential bound $$f_4(k)\le e^{k^{3+o(1)}}$$ from OpenAI's recent lower bound on multicolor Ramsey numbers of triangles. Using a generalization of the latter result to multi-color Ramsey numbers of odd cycles from a companion paper, we show that for every odd $g\ge 5$ there is a function $h_g:\mathbb{N}\rightarrow \mathbb{N}$ growing at most as a power tower of height $\frac{g-3}{2}$ such that every graph of chromatic number at least $h_g(k)$ has a subgraph of chromatic number at least $k$ and odd-girth at least $g$. This proves a conjecture of Mohar and Wu from 2018.

In a recent breakthrough, OpenAI proved that the $k$-color Ramsey number of the triangle $C_3$ grows super-exponentially, more precisely, they proved that $R_k(C_3)\ge k^{k/3-o(k)}$. In this short note, we present a modification of their recursive construction that works for multicolor Ramsey numbers of fixed odd cycles. More precisely, for $p\ge 1$, let $\mathcal{O}_p=\{C_3,C_5,\ldots,C_{2p+1}\}$. We show that \[ R_k(\mathcal{O}_p)\ge (\log^{(p-1)}k)^{k/3-o(k)} \] for every fixed $p$, where $\log^{(p-1)}$ denotes the $(p-1)$-fold iterated logarithm. This immediately implies that for every fixed odd cycle, the multicolor Ramsey number is superexponential in the number of colors. The presented proof was found autonomously by ChatGPT 5.6 Pro/Sol.

Vizing's conjecture from 1963, considered by many the most important open problem in the field of graph domination, states that all graphs $G$ and $H$ satisfy $$γ(G\square H)\ge γ(G)γ(H),$$ where $γ$ denotes the domination number and $\square$ the Cartesian product. In a seminal result, Clark and Suen (2000) proved an approximate form of the conjecture, namely that $γ(G\square H)\ge \frac{1}{2}γ(G)γ(H)$ for all graphs $G$ and $H$. Despite several lower-order improvements of this bound and improvements for special classes of graphs $G$ and $H$, no absolute constant $c>\frac{1}{2}$ such that $γ(G\square H)\ge cγ(G)γ(H)$ for all graphs $G$ and $H$, has been known thus far. In this paper, we obtain the first constant-factor improvement of the Clark-Suen bound by proving that for all graphs $G$ and $H$, we have $$γ(G\square H)\ge cγ(G)γ(H),$$ where $$c=\frac{5+\sqrt{73}}{24}\approx 0.5643.$$ Along the way, we prove another lower bound on $γ(G\square H)$ which outperforms the above bound for many graphs.

Lovász' famous Hamiltonicity conjecture (1969) states that every connected vertex-transitive graph has a Hamiltonian path. A stronger version of the conjecture, often attributed to Thomassen (1978), states that every sufficiently large such graph even has a Hamiltonian cycle. Despite the great amount of attention these conjectures have attracted over the past decades both in the combinatorial and algebraic communities, for more than 40 years the best known lower bound for the maximum length of a cycle (path) in a connected vertex-transitive graph of order $n$ remained of the form $Ω(\sqrt{n})$, due to Babai (1979). A series of recent works has successively improved the exponent in this lower bound further. In this paper, improving the previous state-of-the-art bound $Ω(n^{9/14})$ due to Norin et al.~(2025), we prove that every connected vertex-transitive graph of order $n$ contains a cycle of length at least $n^{2/3-o(1)}$. This hits a natural barrier for several existing approaches from previous work. Our proofs combine recent embedding techniques for paths in sublinear expanders, sublinear expander decompositions of almost-regular graphs, and several additional combinatorial ideas.

A "dominating $K_t$-model" in a graph $G$ is a sequence $(T_1,\dots,T_t)$ of pairwise vertex-disjoint connected subgraphs of $G$, such that whenever $1\leq i<j\leq t$ every vertex in $T_j$ has a neighbour in $T_i$. Replacing "every vertex in $T_j$" by "some vertex in $T_j$" retrieves the standard definition of $K_t$-model, which is equivalent to a $K_t$-minor in $G$. We prove that every graph with no dominating $K_5$-model is $4$-colourable. This generalises and is significantly stronger than the 4-colour theorem for planar graphs or for graphs with no $K_5$-minor. It also makes progress towards Hajós' conjecture on $K_5$-subdivisions in $5$-chromatic graphs.

Given a digraph $D$, let $c(D)$ denote the largest integer $k$ such that there exists a collection of $k$ openly disjoint cycles through a vertex, i.e., a collection of directed cycles $C_1,\ldots,C_k$ through a common vertex $v$ such that $C_1-v,\ldots,C_k-v$ are pairwise vertex-disjoint. The famous Caccetta-Häggkvist conjecture and its regular variant due to Behzad, Chartrand and Wall from 1970, have motivated the study of degree conditions forcing $c(D)$ to be large. Surprisingly, in 1985 Thomassen constructed digraphs of arbitrarily high minimum out- and in-degree such that $c(D)\le 2$. In 2005, Seymour asked whether in contrast every $r$-regular digraph satisfies $c(D)=r$, which would have implied the aforementioned conjecture of Behzad, Chartrand and Wall. In 2008, Mader answered this negatively for every $r\ge 8$, but conjectured that nevertheless the minimum value $c_r$ of $c(D)$ over all $r$-regular digraphs grows with $r$, i.e. $\lim_{r\rightarrow\infty}c_r=\infty$. In this paper, we prove Mader's conjecture in a strong form by showing that $c_r\ge \left\lceil\frac{3}{22} r\right\rceil$ for every $r\in \mathbb{N}$. We also show that $c_r\le 7\left\lceil \frac{r}{8}\right\rceil$, which improves the previous best upper bound $c_r\le r-Θ(\sqrt{r})$ due to Mader.

We prove that computing a shortest monotone path to the optimum of a linear program over a simple polytope is NP-hard, thus resolving a 2022 open question of De Loera, Kafer, and Sanità. As a consequence, finding a shortest sequence of pivots to an optimal basis with the simplex method is NP-hard. In fact, we show this is NP-hard already for fractional knapsack polytopes. By applying an additional polyhedral construction, we show that computing the diameter of a simple polytope is NP-hard, resolving a 2003 open problem by Kaibel and Pfetsch. Finally, on the positive side we show that every polytope has a small, simple extended formulation for which a linear length path may be found between any pair of vertices in polynomial time building upon a result of Kaibel and Kukharenko.

One of the most well-known conjectures concerning Hamiltonicity in graphs asserts that any sufficiently large connected vertex transitive graph contains a Hamilton cycle. In this form, it was first written down by Thomassen in 1978, inspired by a closely related conjecture due to Lovász from 1969. It has been attributed to several other authors in a survey on the topic by Witte and Gallian in 1984. The analogous question for vertex transitive digraphs has an even longer history, having been first considered by Rankin in 1946. It is arguably more natural from the group-theoretic perspective underlying this problem in both settings. Trotter and Erdős proved in 1978 that there are infinitely many connected vertex transitive digraphs which are not Hamiltonian. This left open the very natural question of how long a directed cycle one can guarantee in a connected vertex transitive digraph on $n$ vertices. In 1981, Alspach asked if the maximum perimeter gap (the gap between the circumference and the order of the digraph) is a growing function in $n$. We answer this question in the affirmative, showing that it grows at least as fast as $(1-o(1)) \ln n$. On the other hand, we prove that one can always find a directed cycle of length at least $Ω(n^{1/3})$, establishing the first lower bound growing with $n$, providing a directed analogue of a famous result of Babai from 1979 in the undirected setting.

The classic upper bound on the chromatic number of $d$-degenerate graphs is $d+1$, shown to be tight by complete graphs. A natural question is whether this bound remains tight if one forbids large cliques. Classic constructions of Tutte and Zykov from the early 50s show that there exist $d$-degenerate $(d+1)$-chromatic graphs that are triangle-free, however these constructions grow rapidly with $d$. Motivated by this and addressing a problem posed by the second author at the Oberwolfach Graph Theory workshop, we prove that the minimum order $f(d)$ of a $d$-degenerate triangle-free graph of chromatic number $d+1$ satisfies $e^{Ω(d)}\le f(d)\le e^{O(d^2\log d)}.$ The lower bound follows from a novel upper bound on the chromatic number of triangle-free graphs: Every triangle-free $d$-degenerate graph $G$ on $n \le e^{O(d)}$ vertices satisfies $$χ(G)\le O\left(\frac{d}{\log\left(d/\log n\right)}\right).$$ We extend this to a more general result about degenerate graphs with sparse neighborhoods, which has applications to many graph coloring problems: For example, we prove that every counterexample to Hadwiger's conjecture with parameter $t$ must have a complete bipartite subgraph with one exponentially large side ($K_{a,b}$ where $a=(\log t)^{1/2-o(1)}$ and $b=e^{t^{1-o(1)}}$) or a small and very dense subgraph (of order $\le t$ with $t^{2-o(1)}$ edges) in some neighborhood. For the upper bound on $f(d)$ we establish a surprising connection between $f(d)$ and the on-line-chromatic number $g(n)$ of $n$-vertex triangle-free graphs. We also give an asymptotic improvement of the previous best upper bound for $g(n)$ due to Lovász, Saks and Trotter from 1989. Along the way we disprove a generalization of Harris' fractional coloring conjecture to graphs of bounded clique number and raise numerous problems which open up interesting directions to explore for future research.

We prove that there exist graphs which do not contain $K_t$ as an odd minor and whose chromatic number is at least $(\frac 32-o(1))t$. This disproves, in a strong form, the odd Hadwiger conjecture of Gerards and Seymour from 1993.

A famous conjecture by Thomassen from 1983 asserts that for any given $k,g\in \mathbb{N}$ there exists some $d=d(k,g)\in \mathbb{N}$ such that every graph of minimum degree at least $d$ contains a subgraph of minimum degree at least $k$ and girth at least $g$. In this paper, we initiate the systematic study of the directed analogs of Thomassen's conjecture one obtains when replacing minimum degree by minimum out-degree. Concretely, we study which digraphs $F$ are avoidable in the sense that there exists $d_F:\mathbb{N}\rightarrow \mathbb{N}$ such that every digraph of minimum out-degree at least $d_F(k)$ contains an $F$-free subdigraph of minimum out-degree at least $k$. Among our main results, we show that all orientations of $C_3$ and $C_5$ are avoidable, while one-directed orientations of complete bipartite graphs and all oriented trees are not avoidable. This, in particular, shows that the most direct extension of Thomassen's conjecture to digraphs is false. We also fully characterize which digraphs are avoidable when restricting the setting to regular host digraphs. Finally, we raise numerous attractive open problems in the hope of sparking further progress.

Circuit augmentation schemes are a family of combinatorial algorithms for linear programming that generalize the simplex method. To solve the linear program, they construct a so-called monotone circuit walk: They start at an initial vertex of the feasible region and traverse a discrete sequence of points on the boundary, while moving along certain allowed directions (circuits) and improving the objective function at each step until reaching an optimum. Since the existence of short circuit walks has been conjectured (Circuit Diameter Conjecture), several works have investigated how well one can efficiently approximate shortest monotone circuit walks towards an optimum. A first result addressing this question was given by De Loera, Kafer, and Sanità [SIAM J. Opt., 2022], who showed that given as input an LP and the starting vertex, finding a $2$-approximation for this problem is NP-hard. Cardinal and the third author [Math. Prog. 2023] gave a stronger lower bound assuming the exponential time hypothesis, showing that even an approximation factor of $O(\frac{\log m}{\log \log m})$ is intractable for LPs defined by $m$ inequalities. Both of these results were based on reductions from highly degenerate polytopes in combinatorial optimization with high dimension. In this paper, we significantly strengthen the aforementioned hardness results by showing that for every fixed $\varepsilon>0$ approximating the problem on polygons with $m$ edges to within a factor of $O(m^{1-\varepsilon})$ is NP-hard. This result is essentially best-possible, as it cannot be improved beyond $o(m)$. In particular, this implies hardness for simple polytopes and in fixed dimension.

Criticality is a fundamental notion in graph theory that has been studied continually since its introduction in the early 50s by Dirac. A graph is called $k$-vertex-critical ($k$-edge-critical) if it is $k$-chromatic but removing any vertex (edge) lowers the chromatic number to $k-1$. A set of edges in a graph is called critical if its removal reduces the chromatic number of the graph. In 1970, Dirac conjectured a rather strong distinction between the notions of vertex- and edge-criticality, namely that for every $k\ge 4$ there exists a $k$-vertex-critical graph that does not have any critical edges. This conjecture was proved for $k\ge 5$ by Jensen in 2002 and remains open only for $k=4$. A much stronger version of Dirac's conjecture was proposed by Erdős in 1985: Let $k\ge 4$ be fixed, and let $f_k(n)$ denote the largest integer such that there exists a $k$-vertex-critical graph of order $n$ in which no set of at most $f_k(n)$ edges is critical. Is it true that $f_k(n)\rightarrow \infty$ for $n\rightarrow \infty$? Strengthening previous partial results, we solve this problem affirmatively for all $k>4$, proving that $$f_k(n)=Ω(n^{1/3}).$$ This leaves only the case $k=4$ open. We also show that a stronger lower bound of order $\sqrt{n}$ holds along an infinite sequence of numbers $n$. Finally, we provide a first non-trivial upper bound on the functions $f_k$ by proving that $$f_k(n)=O\left(\frac{n}{(\log n)^{Ω(1)}}\right)$$ for every $k\ge 4$. Our proof of the lower bound on $f_k(n)$ involves an intricate analysis of the structure of proper colorings of a modification of an earlier construction due to Jensen, combined with a gluing operation that creates new vertex-critical graphs without small critical edge sets from given such graphs. The upper bound is obtained using a variant of Szemerédi's regularity lemma due to Conlon and Fox.

There are many intriguing questions in extremal graph theory that are well-understood in the undirected setting and yet remain elusive for digraphs. A natural instance of such a problem was recently studied by Hons, Klimošová, Kucheriya, Mikšaník, Tkadlec and Tyomkyn: What are the digraphs that have to appear as a subgraph in all digraphs of sufficiently large minimum out-degree? Hons et al. showed that all such digraphs must be oriented forests with a specific structure, and conjectured that vice-versa all oriented forests with this specific structure appear in any digraph of sufficiently large minimum out-degree. In this paper, we confirm their conjecture.

Motivated by an old question of Gallai (1966) on the intersection of longest paths in a graph and the well-known conjectures of Lovász (1969) and Thomassen (1978) on the maximum length of paths and cycles in vertex-transitive graphs, we present improved bounds for the parameters $\mathrm{lpt}(G)$ and $\mathrm{lct}(G)$, defined as the minimum size of a set of vertices in a graph $G$ hitting all longest paths (cycles, respectively). First, we show that every connected graph $G$ on $n$ vertices satisfies $\mathrm{lpt}(G)\le \sqrt{8n}$, and $\mathrm{lct}(G)\le \sqrt{8n}$ if $G$ is additionally $2$-connected. This improves a sequence of earlier bounds for these problems, with the previous state of the art being $O(n^{2/3})$. Second, we show that every connected graph $G$ satisfies $\mathrm{lpt}(G)\le O(\ell^{5/9})$, where $\ell$ denotes the maximum length of a path in $G$. As an immediate application of this latter bound, we present further progress towards Lovász' and Thomassen's conjectures: We show that every connected vertex-transitive graph of order $n$ contains a cycle (and path) of length $Ω(n^{9/14})$. This improves the previous best bound of the form $Ω(n^{13/21})$. Interestingly, our proofs make use of several concepts and results from structural graph theory, such as a result of Robertson and Seymour (1990) on transactions in societies and Tutte's $2$-separator theorem.

Given a graph $G$ and an integer $d\ge 0$, its $d$-defective chromatic number $χ^d(G)$ is the smallest size of a partition of the vertices into parts inducing subgraphs with maximum degree at most $d$. Guo, Kang and Zwaneveld recently studied the relationship between the $d$-defective chromatic number of the $(d+1)$-fold (clique) blowup $G\boxtimes K_{d+1}$ of a graph $G$ and its ordinary chromatic number, and conjectured that $χ(G)=χ^d(G\boxtimes K_{d+1})$ for every graph $G$ and $d\ge 0$. In this note we disprove this conjecture by constructing graphs $G$ of arbitrarily large chromatic number such that $χ(G)\ge \frac{30}{29}χ^d(G\boxtimes K_{d+1})$ for infinitely many $d$. On the positive side, we show that the conjecture holds with a constant factor correction, namely $χ^d(G\boxtimes K_{d+1})\le χ(G)\le 2χ^d(G\boxtimes K_{d+1})$ for every graph $G$ and $d\ge 0$.

A dichotomous ordinal graph consists of an undirected graph with a partition of the edges into short and long edges. A geometric realization of a dichotomous ordinal graph $G$ in a metric space $X$ is a drawing of $G$ in $X$ in which every long edge is strictly longer than every short edge. We call a graph $G$ pandichotomous in $X$ if $G$ admits a geometric realization in $X$ for every partition of its edge set into short and long edges. We exhibit a very close relationship between the degeneracy of a graph $G$ and its pandichotomic Euclidean or spherical dimension, that is, the smallest dimension $k$ such that $G$ is pandichotomous in $\mathbb{R}^k$ or the sphere $\mathbb{S}^k$, respectively. First, every $d$-degenerate graph is pandichotomous in $\mathbb{R}^{d}$ and $\mathbb{S}^{d-1}$ and these bounds are tight for the sphere and for $\mathbb{R}^2$ and almost tight for $\mathbb{R}^d$, for $d\ge 3$. Second, every $n$-vertex graph that is pandichotomous in $\mathbb{R}^k$ has at most $μkn$ edges, for some absolute constant $μ<7.23$. This shows that the pandichotomic Euclidean dimension of any graph is linearly tied to its degeneracy and in the special cases $k\in \{1,2\}$ resolves open problems posed by Alam, Kobourov, Pupyrev, and Toeniskoetter. Further, we characterize which complete bipartite graphs are pandichotomous in $\mathbb{R}^2$: These are exactly the $K_{m,n}$ with $m\le 3$ or $m=4$ and $n\le 6$. For general bipartite graphs, we can guarantee realizations in $\mathbb{R}^2$ if the short or the long subgraph is constrained: namely if the short subgraph is outerplanar or a subgraph of a rectangular grid, or if the long subgraph forms a caterpillar.

We prove the following local strengthening of Shearer's classic bound on the independence number of triangle-free graphs: For every triangle-free graph $G$ there exists a probability distribution on its independent sets such that every vertex $v$ of $G$ is contained in a random independent set drawn from the distribution with probability $(1-o(1))\frac{\ln d(v)}{d(v)}$. This resolves the main conjecture raised by Kelly and Postle (2018) about fractional coloring with local demands, which in turn confirms a conjecture by Cames van Batenburg et al. (2018) stating that every $n$-vertex triangle-free graph has fractional chromatic number at most $(\sqrt{2}+o(1))\sqrt{\frac{n}{\ln(n)}}$. Addressing another conjecture posed by Cames van Batenburg et al., we also establish an analogous upper bound in terms of the number of edges. To prove these results we establish a more general technical theorem that works in a weighted setting. As a further application of this more general result, we obtain a new spectral upper bound on the fractional chromatic number of triangle-free graphs: We show that every triangle-free graph $G$ satisfies $χ_f(G)\le (1+o(1))\frac{ρ(G)}{\ln ρ(G)}$ where $ρ(G)$ denotes the spectral radius. This improves the bound implied by Wilf's classic spectral estimate for the chromatic number by a $\ln ρ(G)$ factor and makes progress towards a conjecture of Harris on fractional coloring of degenerate graphs.