arXiv++ Combinatorics

Given a graph $G$, its Hall ratio $ρ(G)=\max_{H\subseteq G}\frac{|V(H)|}{α(H)}$ forms a natural lower bound on its fractional chromatic number $χ_f(G)$. A recent line of research studied the fundamental question of whether $χ_f(G)$ can be bounded in terms of a (linear) function of $ρ(G)$. In a breakthrough-result, Dvořák, Ossona de Mendez and Wu gave a strong negative answer by proving the existence of graphs with bounded Hall ratio and arbitrarily large fractional chromatic number. In this paper, we solve two natural follow-up problems that were raised by Dvořák et al. The first problem concerns determining the growth of $g(n)$, defined as the maximum ratio $\frac{χ_f(G)}{ρ(G)}$ among all $n$-vertex graphs. Dvořák et al. obtained the bounds $Ω(\log\log n) \le g(n)\le O(\log n)$, leaving an exponential gap between the lower and upper bound. We almost fully resolve this problem by proving that the truth is close to the upper bound, i.e., $g(n)=(\log n)^{1-o(1)}$. The second problem posed by Dvořák et al. asks for the existence of graphs with bounded Hall ratio, arbitrarily large fractional chromatic number and such that every subgraph contains an independent set that touches a constant fraction of its edges. We affirmatively solve this second problem by showing that such graphs indeed exist.

In 1992, Erdős and Hajnal posed the following natural problem: Does there exist, for every $r\in \mathbb{N}$, an integer $F(r)$ such that every graph with chromatic number at least $F(r)$ contains $r$ edge-disjoint cycles on the same vertex set? We solve this problem in a strong form, by showing that there exist $n$-vertex graphs with fractional chromatic number $Ω\left(\frac{\log \log n}{\log \log \log n}\right)$ that do not even contain a $4$-regular subgraph. This implies that no such number $F(r)$ exists for $r\ge 2$. We show that assuming a conjecture of Harris, the bound on the fractional chromatic number in our result cannot be improved.

We present progress on three old conjectures about longest paths and cycles in graphs. The first pair of conjectures, due to Lovász from 1969 and Thomassen from 1978, respectively, states that all connected vertex-transitive graphs contain a Hamiltonian path, and that all sufficiently large such graphs even contain a Hamiltonian cycle. The third conjecture, due to Smith from 1984, states that for $r\ge 2$ in every $r$-connected graph any two longest cycles intersect in at least $r$ vertices. In this paper, we prove a new lemma about the intersection of longest cycles in a graph which can be used to improve the best known bounds towards all the aforementioned conjectures: First, we show that every connected vertex-transitive graph on $n\geq 3$ vertices contains a cycle (and hence path) of length at least $Ω(n^{13/21})$, improving on $Ω(n^{3/5})$ from [DeVos, \emph{arXiv:2302:04255}, 2023]. Second, we show that in every $r$-connected graph with $r\geq 2$, any two longest cycles meet in at least $Ω(r^{5/8})$ vertices, improving on $Ω(r^{3/5})$ from [Chen, Faudree and Gould, \emph{J. Combin. Theory, Ser.~ B}, 1998]. Our proof combines combinatorial arguments, computer-search and linear programming.

The cochromatic number $ζ(G)$ of a graph $G$ is the smallest number of colors in a vertex-coloring of $G$ such that every color class forms an independent set or a clique. In three papers written around 1990, Erdős, Gimbel and collaborators raised several open problems regarding the relationship of the chromatic and cochromatic number of a graph. In this short note, we address several of these problems, in particular -we disprove a conjecture of Erdős, Gimbel and Straight from 1988, -answer negatively a problem posed by Erdős and Gimbel in 1993, and -give positive evidence for a 1000\$--question of Erdős and Gimbel.

An $\ell$-lift of a graph $G$ is any graph obtained by replacing every vertex of $G$ with an independent set of size $\ell$, and connecting every pair of two such independent sets that correspond to an edge in $G$ by a matching of size $\ell$. Graph lifts have found numerous interesting applications and connections to a variety of areas over the years. Of particular importance is the random graph model obtained by considering an $\ell$-lift of a graph sampled uniformly at random. This model was first introduced by Amit and Linial in 1999, and has been extensively investigated since. In this paper, we study the size of the largest topological clique in random lifts of complete graphs. In 2006, Drier and Linial raised the conjecture that almost all $\ell$-lifts of the complete graph on $n$ vertices contain a subdivision of a clique of order $Ω(n)$ as a subgraph provided $\ell$ is at least linear in $n$. We confirm their conjecture in a strong form by showing that for $\ell \ge (1+o(1))n$, one can almost surely find a subdivision of a clique of order $n$. We prove that this is tight by showing that for $\ell \le (1-o(1))n$, almost all $\ell$-lifts do not contain subdivisions of cliques of order $n$. Finally, for $2 \le \ell \ll n$, we show that almost all $\ell$-lifts of $K_n$ contain a subdivision of a clique on $(1-o(1))\sqrt{\frac{2n \ell}{1-1/\ell}}$ vertices and that this is tight up to the lower order term.

For a finite Abelian group $(Γ,+)$, let $n(Γ)$ denote the smallest positive integer $n$ such that for each labelling of the arcs of the complete digraph of order $n$ using elements from $Γ$, there exists a directed cycle such that the total sum of the arc-labels along the cycle equals $0$. Alon and Krivelevich initiated the study of the parameter $n(\cdot)$ on cyclic groups and proved that $n(\mathbb{Z}_q)=O(q\log q)$. Studying the prototypical case when $Γ=\mathbb{Z}_p^d$ is a power of a cyclic group of prime order, Letzter and Morrison recently showed that $n(\mathbb{Z}_p^d) \le O(pd(\log d)^2)$ and that $n(\mathbb{Z}_2^d)\le O(d \log d)$. They then posed the problem of proving an (asymptotically optimal) upper bound of $n(\mathbb{Z}_p^d)\le O(pd)$ for all primes $p$ and $d \in \mathbb{N}$. In this paper, we solve this problem for $p=2$ and improve their bound for all primes $p \ge 3$ by proving $n(\mathbb{Z}_2^d)\le 5d$ and $n(\mathbb{Z}_p^d)\le O(pd\log d)$. While the first bound determines $n(\mathbb{Z}_2^d)$ up to a multiplicative error of $5$, the second bound is tight up to a $\log d$ factor. Moreover, our result shows that a tight bound of $n(\mathbb{Z}_p^d)=Θ(pd)$ for arbitrary $p$ and $d$ would follow from a (strong form) of the well-known conjecture of Jaeger, Linial, Payan and Tarsi on additive bases in $\mathbb{Z}_p^d$. Along the way to proving these results, we establish a generalization of a hypergraph matching result by Haxell in a matroidal setting. Concretely, we obtain sufficient conditions for the existence of matchings in a hypergraph whose hyperedges are labelled by the elements of a matroid, with the property that the edges in the matching induce a basis of the matroid. We believe that these statements are of independent interest.

For a finite (not necessarily Abelian) group $(Γ,\cdot)$, let $n(Γ) \in \mathbb{N}$ denote the smallest positive integer $n$ such that for every labelling of the arcs of the complete digraph of order $n$ using elements from $Γ$, there exists a directed cycle such that the arc-labels along the cycle multiply to the identity. Alon and Krivelevich initiated the study of the parameter $n(\cdot)$ on cyclic groups and proved $n(\mathbb{Z}_q)=O(q \log q)$. This was later improved to a linear bound of $n(Γ)\le 8|Γ|$ for every finite Abelian group by Mészáros and the last author, and then further to $n(Γ)\le 2|Γ|-1$ for every non-trivial finite group independently by Berendsohn, Boyadzhiyska and Kozma as well as by Akrami, Alon, Chaudhury, Garg, Mehlhorn and Mehta. In this series of two papers we conclude this line of research by proving that $n(Γ)\le |Γ|+1$ for every finite group $(Γ,\cdot)$, which is the best possible such bound in terms of the group order and precisely determines the value of $n(Γ)$ for all cyclic groups as $n(\mathbb{Z}_q)=q+1$. In the present paper we prove the above result for all groups of odd order. The proof for groups of even order needs to overcome substantial additional obstacles and will be presented in the second part of this series.

The Circuit diameter of polytopes was introduced by Borgwardt, Finhold and Hemmecke as a fundamental tool for the study of circuit augmentation schemes for linear programming and for estimating combinatorial diameters. Determining the complexity of computing the circuit diameter of polytopes was posed as an open problem by Sanità as well as by Kafer, and was recently reiterated by Borgwardt, Grewe, Kafer, Lee and Sanità. In this paper, we solve this problem by showing that computing the circuit diameter of a polytope given in halfspace-description is strongly NP-hard. To prove this result, we show that computing the combinatorial diameter of the perfect matching polytope of a bipartite graph is NP-hard. This complements a result by Sanità (FOCS 2018) on the NP-hardness of computing the diameter of fractional matching polytopes and implies the new result that computing the diameter of a $\{0,1\}$-polytope is strongly NP-hard, which may be of independent interest. In our second main result, we give a precise graph-theoretic description of the monotone diameter of perfect matching polytopes and use this description to prove that computing the monotone (circuit) diameter of a given input polytope is strongly NP-hard as well.

A graph $G$ is said to be Ramsey for a tuple of graphs $(H_1,\dots,H_r)$ if every $r$-coloring of the edges of $G$ contains a monochromatic copy of $H_i$ in color $i$, for some $i$. A fundamental question at the intersection of Ramsey theory and the theory of random graphs is to determine the threshold at which the binomial random graph $G_{n,p}$ becomes a.a.s. Ramsey for a fixed tuple $(H_1,\dots,H_r)$, and a famous conjecture of Kohayakawa and Kreuter predicts this threshold. Earlier work of Mousset-Nenadov-Samotij, Bowtell-Hancock-Hyde, and Kuperwasser-Samotij-Wigderson has reduced this probabilistic problem to a deterministic graph decomposition conjecture. In this paper, we resolve this deterministic problem, thus proving the Kohayakawa-Kreuter conjecture. Along the way, we prove a number of novel graph decomposition results which may be of independent interest.

The Odd Hadwiger's conjecture, formulated by Gerards and Seymour in 1995, is a substantial strengthening of Hadwiger's famous coloring conjecture from 1943. We investigate whether the hierarchy of topological lower bounds on the chromatic number, introduced by Matoušek and Ziegler (2003) and refined recently by Daneshpajouh and Meunier (2023), forms a potential avenue to a disproof of Hadwiger's conjecture or its odd-minor variant. In this direction, we prove that, in a very general sense, every graph $G$ that admits a topological lower bound of $t$ on its chromatic number, contains $K_{\lfloor t/2\rfloor +1}$ as an odd-minor. This solves a problem posed by Simonyi and Zsbán [European Journal of Combinatorics, 31(8), 2110--2119 (2010)]. We also prove that if for a graph $G$ the Dol'nikov-Kříž lower bound on the chromatic number (one of the lower bounds in the aforementioned hierarchy) attains a value of at least $t$, then $G$ contains $K_t$ as a minor. Finally, extending results by Simonyi and Zsbán, we show that the Odd Hadwiger's conjecture holds for Schrijver and Kneser graphs for any choice of the parameters. The latter are canonical examples of graphs for which topological lower bounds on the chromatic number are tight.

We show that the twin-width of every $n$-vertex $d$-regular graph is at most $n^{\frac{d-2}{2d-2}+o(1)}$ and that almost all $d$-regular graphs attain this bound. More generally, we obtain bounds on the twin-width of sparse Erdős-Renyi and regular random graphs, complementing the bounds in the denser regime due to Ahn, Chakraborti, Hendrey, Kim and Oum.

Base polytopes of polymatroids, also known as generalized permutohedra, are polytopes whose edges are parallel to a vector of the form $\mathbf{e}_i - \mathbf{e}_j$. We consider the following computational problem: Given two vertices of a generalized permutohedron $P$, find a shortest path between them on the skeleton of $P$. This captures many known flip distance problems, such as computing the minimum number of exchanges between two spanning trees of a graph, the rotation distance between binary search trees, the flip distance between acyclic orientations of a graph, or rectangulations of a square. We prove that this problem is $NP$-hard, even when restricted to very simple polymatroids in $\mathbb{R}^n$ defined by $O(n)$ inequalities. Assuming $P\not= NP$, this rules out the existence of an efficient simplex pivoting rule that performs a minimum number of nondegenerate pivoting steps to an optimal solution of a linear program, even when the latter defines a polymatroid. We also prove that the shortest path problem is inapproximable when the polymatroid is specified via an evaluation oracle for a corresponding submodular function, strengthening a recent result by Ito et al. (ICALP'23). More precisely, we prove the $APX$-hardness of the shortest path problem when the polymatroid is a hypergraphic polytope, whose vertices are in bijection with acyclic orientations of a given hypergraph. The shortest path problem then amounts to computing the flip distance between two acyclic orientations of a hypergraph. On the positive side, we provide a polynomial-time approximation algorithm for the problem of computing the flip distance between two acyclic orientations of a hypergraph, where the approximation factor is the maximum codegree of the hypergraph. Our result implies an exact polynomial-time algorithm for the flip distance between two acyclic orientations of any linear hypergraph.

Let $r$ be any positive integer. We prove that for every sufficiently large $k$ there exists a $k$-chromatic vertex-critical graph $G$ such that $χ(G-R)=k$ for every set $R \subseteq E(G)$ with $|R|\le r$. This partially solves a problem posed by Erdős in 1985, who asked whether the above statement holds for $k \ge 4$.

A tantalizing open problem, posed independently by Stiebitz in 1995 and by Alon in 2006, asks whether for every pair of integers $s,t \ge 1$ there exists a finite number $F(s,t)$ such that the vertex set of every digraph of minimum out-degree at least $F(s,t)$ can be partitioned into non-empty parts $A$ and $B$ such that the subdigraphs induced on $A$ and $B$ have minimum out-degree at least $s$ and $t$, respectively. In this short note, we prove that if $F(2,2)$ exists, then all the numbers $F(s,t)$ with $s,t\ge 1$ exist and satisfy $F(s,t)=Θ(s+t)$. In consequence, the problem of Alon and Stiebitz reduces to the case $s=t=2$. Moreover, the numbers $F(s,t)$ with $s,t \ge 2$ either all exist and grow linearly, or all of them do not exist.

We prove Menger-type results in which the obtained paths are pairwise non-adjacent, both for graphs of bounded maximum degree and, more generally, for graphs excluding a topological minor. We further show better bounds in the subcubic case, and in particular obtain a tight result for two paths using a computer-assisted proof.

The clustered chromatic number of a graph class $\mathcal{G}$ is the minimum integer $c$ such that every graph $G\in\mathcal{G}$ has a $c$-colouring where each monochromatic component in $G$ has bounded size. We study the clustered chromatic number of graph classes $\mathcal{G}_H^{\text{odd}}$ defined by excluding a graph $H$ as an odd-minor. How does the structure of $H$ relate to the clustered chromatic number of $\mathcal{G}_H^{\text{odd}}$? We adapt a proof method of Norin, Scott, Seymour and Wood (2019) to show that the clustered chromatic number of $\mathcal{G}_H^{\text{odd}}$ is tied to the tree-depth of $H$.

Size-Ramsey numbers are a central notion in combinatorics and have been widely studied since their introduction by Erdős, Faudree, Rousseau and Schelp in 1978. Research has mainly focused on the size-Ramsey numbers of $n$-vertex graphs with constant maximum degree $Δ$. For example, graphs which also have constant treewidth are known to have linear size-Ramsey numbers. On the other extreme, the canonical examples of graphs of unbounded treewidth are the grid graphs, for which the best known bound has only very recently been improved from $O(n^{3/2})$ to $O(n^{5/4})$ by Conlon, Nenadov and Trujić. In this paper, we prove a common generalization of these results by establishing new bounds on the size-Ramsey numbers in terms of treewidth (which may grow as a function of $n$). As a special case, this yields a bound of $\tilde{O}(n^{3/2 - 1/2Δ})$ for proper minor-closed classes of graphs. In particular, this bound applies to planar graphs, addressing a question of Kamcev, Liebenau, Wood and Yepremyan. Our proof combines methods from structural graph theory and classic Ramsey-theoretic embedding techniques, taking advantage of the product structure exhibited by graphs with bounded treewidth.

Motivated by Hadwiger's conjecture, we study the problem of finding the densest possible $t$-vertex minor in graphs of average degree at least $t-1$. We show that if $G$ has average degree at least $t-1$, it contains a minor on $t$ vertices with at least $(\sqrt{2}-1-o(1))\binom{t}{2}$ edges. We show that this cannot be improved beyond $\left(\frac{3}{4}+o(1)\right)\binom{t}{2}$. Finally, for $t\leq 6$ we exactly determine the number of edges we are guaranteed to find in the densest $t$-vertex minor in graphs of average degree at least $t-1$.

A set $\mathcal{G}$ of planar graphs on the same number $n$ of vertices is called simultaneously embeddable if there exists a set $P$ of $n$ points in the plane such that every graph $G \in \mathcal{G}$ admits a (crossing-free) straight-line embedding with vertices placed at points of $P$. A conflict collection is a set of planar graphs of the same order with no simultaneous embedding. A well-known open problem from 2007 posed by Brass, Cenek, Duncan, Efrat, Erten, Ismailescu, Kobourov, Lubiw and Mitchell, asks whether there exists a conflict collection of size $2$. While this remains widely open, we give a short proof that for sufficiently large $n$ there exists a conflict collection consisting of at most $(3+o(1))\log_2(n)$ planar graphs on $n$ vertices. This constitutes a double-exponential improvement over the previously best known bound of $O(n\cdot 4^{n/11})$ for the same problem by Goenka, Semnani and Yip. Using our method we also provide a computer-free proof that there exists a conflict collection of size $30$, improving upon the previously smallest known conflict collection of size $49$ which was found using heavy computer assistance. While the construction by Goenka et al. was explicit, our construction of a conflict collection of size $O(\log n)$ is based on the probabilistic method and is thus only implicit. Motivated by this, for every large enough $n$ we give a different, fully explicit construction of a collection of less than $n^6$ planar $n$-vertex graphs with no simultaneous embedding.

Scott and Seymour conjectured the existence of a function $f \colon \mathbb{N} \to \mathbb{N}$ such that, for every graph $G$ and tournament $T$ on the same vertex set, $χ(G) \geqslant f(k)$ implies that $χ(G[N_T^+(v)]) \geqslant k$ for some vertex $v$. In this note we disprove this conjecture even if $v$ is replaced by a vertex set of size $\mathcal{O}(\log{\lvert V(G)\rvert})$. As a consequence, we answer in the negative a question of Harutyunyan, Le, Thomassé, and Wu concerning the corresponding statement where the graph $G$ is replaced by another tournament, and disprove a related conjecture of Nguyen, Scott, and Seymour. We also show that the setting where chromatic number is replaced by degeneracy exhibits a quite different behaviour.