Papers by Robert Hickingbotham
31 paper(s) by this author
· All BibTeX
Induced Forest Minor Theorem for Graphs Without an Induced Star
Motivated by recent work on tree independence number, we study the path independence number of a graph $G$: the minimum integer $k$ such that there is a path decomposition of $G$ where each bag induces a graph with independence number at most $k$. We show that every graph excluding both an induced forest minor and an induced star has bounded path independence number. This characterises when a graph class that excludes an induced star has bounded path independence number while also partially resolving a conjecture of Dallard, Krnc, Kwon, Milani{č}, Munaro, Štorgel and Wiederrecht (2024). Furthermore, we show that graphs excluding both an apex-forest induced minor and an induced star have bounded tree independence number. As a consequence, for every fixed apex-forest $H$ and integer $t$, there is a polynomial-time algorithm to test whether a $K_{1,t}$-induced-subgraph-free graph contains $H$ as an induced minor. Moreover, it follows that the Maximum Weight Independent Set problem, as well as several other NP-hard problems, can be solved in polynomial-time on $K_{1,t}$-induced-subgraph-free graphs that exclude $H$ as an induced minor.
Optimal tree-decompositions with bags of bounded pathwidth
We show that every planar graph has a tree-decomposition with optimal width such that the subgraph induced by each bag has pathwidth at most 3. This bound is best possible, and for tree-decompositions that satisfy a certain minimality condition, we in fact give a precise description of the possible structures in each bag. Moreover, we show that the union of any $k$ bags has pathwidth $O(k)$. We also show that graphs excluding a fixed double-apex-forest minor have a tree-decomposition with optimal width such that the subgraph induced by each bag has bounded pathwidth. This includes graphs embeddable on any fixed surface. As a byproduct of our machinery, we give a new proof of the linear grid minor theorem for planar graphs.
An Induced $A$-Path Theorem
Given a graph $G$ and $\mathcal{A}\subseteq V(G)$, a classical theorem of Gallai (1964) states that for every positive integer $k$, the graph $G$ contains $k$ pairwise vertex-disjoint $\mathcal{A}$-paths, or a set $Z\subseteq V(G)$ of size at most $2(k-1)$ such that $G-Z$ contains no $\mathcal{A}$-paths. We generalise Gallai's theorem to the induced setting: We prove that $G$ contains $k$ pairwise anti-complete $\mathcal{A}$-paths, or a set $Z$ of size at most $78(k-1)$ such that, after removing the closed neighbourhood of $Z$, the resulting graph has no $\mathcal{A}$-path. Here, two paths are anti-complete if they are vertex disjoint and there is no edge in $G$ having one endpoint in each of them.
We further show that the bound $78(k-1)$ on the size of $Z$ can be reduced to $4(k-1)$ if one removes the balls of radius $4$ around the vertices of $Z$ (instead of radius $1$), which is within a factor $2$ of optimal. We also establish analogous results for long induced $\mathcal{A}$-paths.
Excluding a Forest Induced Minor
In the first paper of the Graph Minors series [JCTB '83], Robertson and Seymour proved the Forest Minor theorem: the $H$-minor-free graphs have bounded pathwidth if and only if $H$ is a forest. In recent years, considerable effort has been devoted to understanding the unavoidable induced substructures of graphs with large pathwidth or large treewidth. In this paper, we give an induced counterpart of the Forest Minor theorem: for any $t \geqslant 2$, the $K_{t,t}$-subgraph-free $H$-induced-minor-free graphs have bounded pathwidth if and only if $H$ belongs to a class $\mathcal F$ of forests, which we describe as the induced minors of two (very similar) infinite parameterized families. This constitutes a significant step toward classifying the graphs $H$ for which every weakly sparse $H$-induced-minor-free class has bounded treewidth. Our work builds on the theory of constellations developed in the Induced Subgraphs and Tree Decompositions series.
Induced Minors, Asymptotic Dimension, and Baker's Technique
Asymptotic dimension is a large-scale invariant of metric spaces that was introduced by Gromov (1993). We prove that every hereditary class of bounded-degree graphs that excludes some graph as a fat minor has asymptotic dimension at most $2$, which is optimal. This makes substantial progress on a question of Bonamy, Bousquet, Esperet, Groenland, Liu, Pirot, and Scott (J. Eur. Math. Soc. 2023).
The key to our proof is a notion inspired by Baker's technique (J. ACM 1994). We say that a graph class $\mathcal{G}$ has bounded Baker-treewidth if there exists a function $f \colon \mathbb{N} \to \mathbb{N}$ such that, for every graph $G\in \mathcal{G}$, there is a layering of $G$ such that the subgraph induced by the union of any $\ell$ consecutive layers has treewidth at most $f(\ell)$. We show that every class of bounded-degree graphs that excludes some graph as an induced minor has bounded Baker-treewidth. We discuss further applications of this result to clustered colouring and the design of linear-time approximate schemes.
Binary matroids and degree-boundedness for pivot-minors
We prove that for every bipartite graph $H$ and positive integer $s$, the class of $K_{s,s}$-subgraph-free graphs excluding $H$ as a pivot-minor has bounded average degree. Our proof relies on the announced binary matroid structure theorem of Geelen, Gerards, and Whittle.
Along the way, we also prove that every $K_{s,t}$-free bipartite circle graph with $s\le t$ has a vertex of degree at most $\max\{2s-2, t-1\}$ and provide examples showing that this is tight.
Coarse Balanced Separators and Tree-Decompositions
A classical result of Robertson and Seymour (1986) states that the treewidth of a graph is linearly tied to its separation number: the smallest integer $k$ such that, for every weighting of the vertices, the graph admits a balanced separator of size at most $k$. Motivated by recent progress on coarse treewidth, Abrishami, Czyżewska, Kluk, Pilipczuk, Pilipczuk, and Rzążewski (2025) conjectured a coarse analogue to this result: every graph that has a balanced separator consisting of a bounded number of balls of bounded radius is quasi-isometric to a graph with bounded treewidth. In this paper, we confirm their conjecture for $K_{t,t}$-induced-subgraph-free graphs when the separator consists of a bounded number of balls of radius $1$. In doing so, we bridge two important conjectures concerning the structure of graphs that exclude a planar graph as an induced minor.
Induced Minors and Region Intersection Graphs
We show that for any positive integers $g$ and $t$, there is a $K_{6}^{(1)}$-induced-minor-free graph of girth at least $g$ that is not a region intersection graph over the class of $K_t$-minor-free graphs. This answers in a strong form the recently raised question of whether for every graph $H$ there is a graph $H'$ such that $H$-induced-minor-free graphs are region intersection graphs over $H'$-minor-free graphs.
Quasi-isometries between graphs with variable edge lengths
This paper investigates quasi-isometries between graphs with variable edge lengths. A quasi-isometry is a mapping between metric spaces that approximately preserves distances, allowing for a bounded amount of additive and multiplicative distortion. Recently, Nguyen, Scott, and Seymour conjectured that, by appropriately adjusting the edge lengths of the target graph along with modifying the additive distortion constant, the multiplicative distortion factor could be eliminated. We disprove this conjecture.
Graphs that are quasi-isometric to graphs with bounded treewidth
In this paper, we characterise graphs that are quasi-isometric to graphs with bounded treewidth. Specifically, we prove that a graph is quasi-isometric to a graph with bounded treewidth if and only if it has a tree-decomposition where each bag consists of a bounded number of balls of bounded diameter. This result extends a characterisation by Berger and Seymour (2024) of graphs that are quasi-isometric to trees. Additionally, we characterise graphs that are quasi-isometric to graphs with bounded pathwidth and graphs that are quasi-isometric to graphs with bounded linewidth. As an application of these results, we show that graphs with bounded rank-width, graphs with bounded tree independence number, and graphs with bounded sim-width are quasi-isometric to graphs with bounded treewidth.
Treewidth, Hadwiger Number, and Induced Minors
Treewidth and Hadwiger number are two of the most important parameters in structural graph theory.
This paper studies graph classes in which large treewidth implies the existence of a large complete graph minor.
To formalise this, we say that a graph class $\mathcal{G}$ is (tw,had)-bounded if there is a function $f$ (called the (tw,had)-bounding function) such that tw$(G)$ $\leq$ $f$(had$(G)$) for every graph $G \in \mathcal{G}$.
We characterise (tw,had)-bounded graph classes as those that exclude some planar graph as an induced minor, and use this characterisation to show that every proper vertex-minor-closed class is (tw,had)-bounded. Furthermore, we demonstrate that any (tw,had)-bounded graph class has a (tw,had)-bounding function in O(had$(G)^9$polylog(had$(G)$)). Our bound comes from the bound for the Grid Minor Theorem given by Chuzhoy and Tan, and any quantitative improvement to their result will lead directly to an improvement to our result.
More strongly, we conjecture that every (tw,had)-bounded graph class has a linear (tw,had)-bounding function.
In support of this conjecture, we show that it holds for the class of outer-string graphs, and for a natural generalisation of outer-string graphs: intersection graphs of strings rooted at the boundary of a fixed surface. We also verify our conjecture for low-rank perturbations of circle graphs, which is an important step towards verifying it for all proper vertex-minor-closed classes.
Fat minors cannot be thinned (by quasi-isometries)
We disprove the conjecture of Georgakopoulos and Papasoglu that a length space (or graph) with no $K$-fat $H$ minor is quasi-isometric to a graph with no $H$ minor. Our counterexample is furthermore not quasi-isometric to a graph with no 2-fat $H$ minor or a length space with no $H$ minor. On the other hand, we show that the following weakening holds: any graph with no $K$-fat $H$ minor is quasi-isometric to a graph with no $3$-fat $H$ minor.
Defective and Clustered Colouring of Graphs with Given Girth
The defective chromatic number of a graph class $\mathcal{G}$ is the minimum integer $k$ such that for some integer $d$, every graph in $\mathcal{G}$ is $k$-colourable such that each monochromatic component has maximum degree at most $d$. Similarly, the clustered chromatic number of a graph class $\mathcal{G}$ is the minimum integer $k$ such that for some integer $c$, every graph in $\mathcal{G}$ is $k$-colourable such that each monochromatic component has at most $c$ vertices. This paper determines or establishes bounds on the defective and clustered chromatic numbers of graphs with given girth in minor-closed classes defined by the following parameters: Hadwiger number, treewidth, pathwidth, treedepth, circumference, and feedback vertex number. One striking result is that for any integer $k$, for the class of triangle-free graphs with treewidth $k$, the defective chromatic number, clustered chromatic number and chromatic number are all equal. The same result holds for graphs with treedepth $k$, and generalises for graphs with no $K_p$ subgraph.
Cop-width, flip-width and strong colouring numbers
Published in Discrete Mathematics & Theoretical Computer Science, vol. 27:2, Graph Theory (May 7, 2025) dmtcs:14976
• View Publication
• BIB
Cop-width and flip-width are new families of graph parameters introduced by Toruńczyk (2023) that generalise treewidth, degeneracy, generalised colouring numbers, clique-width and twin-width. In this paper, we bound the cop-width and flip-width of a graph by its strong colouring numbers. In particular, we show that for every $r\in \mathbb{N}$, every graph $G$ has $\text{copwidth}_r(G)\leq \text{scol}_{4r}(G)$. This implies that every class of graphs with linear strong colouring numbers has linear cop-width and linear flip-width. We use this result to deduce improved bounds for cop-width and flip-width for various sparse graph classes.
Clustered Colouring of Odd-$H$-Minor-Free Graphs
The clustered chromatic number of a graph class $\mathcal{G}$ is the minimum integer $c$ such that every graph $G\in\mathcal{G}$ has a $c$-colouring where each monochromatic component in $G$ has bounded size. We study the clustered chromatic number of graph classes $\mathcal{G}_H^{\text{odd}}$ defined by excluding a graph $H$ as an odd-minor. How does the structure of $H$ relate to the clustered chromatic number of $\mathcal{G}_H^{\text{odd}}$? We adapt a proof method of Norin, Scott, Seymour and Wood (2019) to show that the clustered chromatic number of $\mathcal{G}_H^{\text{odd}}$ is tied to the tree-depth of $H$.
Powers of planar graphs, product structure, and blocking partitions
We prove that the $k$-power of any planar graph $G$ is contained in $H\boxtimes P\boxtimes K_{f(Δ(G),k)}$ for some graph $H$ with bounded treewidth, some path $P$, and some function $f$. This resolves an open problem of Ossona de Mendez. In fact, we prove a more general result in terms of shallow minors that implies similar results for many `beyond planar' graph classes, without dependence on $Δ(G)$. For example, we prove that every $k$-planar graph is contained in $H\boxtimes P\boxtimes K_{f(k)}$ for some graph $H$ with bounded treewidth and some path $P$, and some function $f$. This resolves an open problem of Dujmović, Morin and Wood. We generalise all these results for graphs of bounded Euler genus, still with an absolute bound on the treewidth.
At the heart of our proof is the following new concept of independent interest. An $\ell$-blocking partition of a graph $G$ is a partition of $V(G)$ into connected sets such that every path of length greater than $\ell$ in $G$ contains at least two vertices in one part. We prove that for some constant $\ell \ge 1$ every graph of Euler genus $g$ has an $\ell$-blocking partition with parts of size bounded by a function of $Δ(G)$ and $g$. Motivated by this result, we study blocking partitions in their own right. We show that every graph $G$ has a $2$-blocking partition with parts of size bounded by a function of $Δ(G)$ and $\textrm{tw}(G)$. On the other hand, we show that 4-regular graphs do not have $\ell$-blocking partitions with bounded size parts.
The grid-minor theorem revisited
We prove that for every planar graph $X$ of treedepth $h$, there exists a positive integer $c$ such that for every $X$-minor-free graph $G$, there exists a graph $H$ of treewidth at most $f(h)$ such that $G$ is isomorphic to a subgraph of $H\boxtimes K_c$. This is a qualitative strengthening of the Grid-Minor Theorem of Robertson and Seymour (JCTB 1986), and treedepth is the optimal parameter in such a result. As an example application, we use this result to improve the upper bound for weak coloring numbers of graphs excluding a fixed graph as a minor.
The Excluded Tree Minor Theorem Revisited
Published in Combinatorics, Probability and Computing (2024), 33, pp. 85--90
• View Publication
• BIB
We prove that for every tree $T$ of radius $h$, there is an integer $c$ such that every $T$-minor-free graph is contained in $H\boxtimes K_c$ for some graph $H$ with pathwidth at most $2h-1$. This is a qualitative strengthening of the Excluded Tree Minor Theorem of Robertson and Seymour (GM I). We show that radius is the right parameter to consider in this setting, and $2h-1$ is the best possible bound.
Treewidth, Circle Graphs and Circular Drawings
Published
• View Publication
• BIB
A circle graph is an intersection graph of a set of chords of a circle. We describe the unavoidable induced subgraphs of circle graphs with large treewidth. This includes examples that are far from the `usual suspects'. Our results imply that treewidth and Hadwiger number are linearly tied on the class of circle graphs, and that the unavoidable induced subgraphs of a vertex-minor-closed class with large treewidth are the usual suspects if and only if the class has bounded rank-width. Using the same tools, we also study the treewidth of graphs $G$ that have a circular drawing whose crossing graph is well-behaved in some way. In this setting, we show that if the crossing graph is $K_t$-minor-free, then $G$ has treewidth at most $12t-23$ and has no $K_{2,4t}$-topological minor. On the other hand, we show that there are graphs with arbitrarily large Hadwiger number that have circular drawings whose crossing graphs are $2$-degenerate.
Product structure extension of the Alon--Seymour--Thomas theorem
Published in SIAM Journal on Discrete Mathematics, 38(3):2095--2107, 2024
• View Publication
• BIB
Alon, Seymour and Thomas [1990] proved that every $n$-vertex graph excluding $K_t$ as a minor has treewidth less than $t^{3/2}\sqrt{n}$. Illingworth, Scott and Wood [2022] recently refined this result by showing that every such graph is a subgraph of some graph with treewidth $t-2$, where each vertex is blown up by a complete graph of order $O(\sqrt{tn})$. Solving an open problem of Illingworth, Scott and Wood [2022], we prove that the treewidth bound can be reduced to $4$ while keeping blowups of order $O_t(\sqrt{n})$. As an extension of the Lipton--Tarjan theorem, in the case of planar graphs, we show that the treewidth can be further reduced to $2$, which is best possible. We generalise this result for $K_{3,t}$-minor-free graphs, with blowups of order $O(t\sqrt{n})$. This setting includes graphs embeddable on any fixed surface.