arXiv++ Combinatorics

A key theme in modern extremal combinatorics is the study of classical combinatorial theorems relative to sparse subsets of their natural settings. Here we describe some of the recent progress in this area and state a number of problems that remain open and pressing.

Green's popular difference theorem says that for every \(\varepsilon>0\), all sufficiently large primes \(p\), and every set \(A\subseteq\mathbb F_p\) of density \(α\), there exists a nonzero \(d\in\mathbb F_p\) such that \[ \mathbb E_{x\in\mathbb F_p} 1_A(x)1_A(x+d)1_A(x+2d) \geq α^3-\varepsilon. \] We show that a stronger simultaneous popular difference phenomenon holds for polynomial configurations. Namely, if $\mathcal P=\{P_1,\dots,P_k\} \subset \mathbb Z[t]$ is a fixed collection of linearly independent polynomials with zero constant terms, we show that for every \(\varepsilon>0\), all sufficiently large primes \(p\), and every set \(A\subseteq\mathbb F_p\) of density \(α\), there exists a nonzero \(d\in\mathbb F_p\) such that \[ \mathbb E_{x\in\mathbb F_p} 1_A(x) \prod_{i=1}^k 1_A\bigl(x+P_i(d)\bigr)^{ω_i} \geq α^{1+\sum_iω_i}-\varepsilon \] simultaneously for every \(ω=(ω_1,\dots,ω_k)\in\{0,1\}^k\). We also show that such simultaneous popular difference phenomena have sharp limitations by proving that for every sufficiently large prime \(p\), there is a constant \(c>0\) such that, for all sufficiently large \(n\), one can find a set \(A\subseteq\mathbb F_p^n\) of density \(1/2+o_n(1)\) satisfying \[ \max_{d\neq 0} \min\left\{ \mathbb E_{x\in\mathbb F_p^n} 1_A(x)1_A(x+d)1_A(x+2d), \mathbb E_{x\in\mathbb F_p^n} 1_A(x)1_A(x+2d)1_A(x+4d) \right\} \leq \frac18-c. \] That is, the strengthening of Green's result, in this case over $\mathbb F_p^n$ for $p$ fixed and $n$ tending to infinity, requiring that both \(d\) and \(2d\) are simultaneously popular differences for three-term arithmetic progressions is false.

In this note, we show how to adapt Tao's slice rank method to extend the Ellenberg--Gijswijt theorem on cap sets to the problem of forbidding arithmetic progressions with restricted differences. In particular, we show that if $q$ is an odd prime power, there is $\varepsilon_q>0$ such that if $S \subseteq \mathbb{F}_q$ with $0 \in S$ and $|S|>(q+1)/2$ and $A \subseteq \mathbb{F}_q^n$ contains no three-term arithmetic progression whose common difference is in $S^n$, then $|A| \leq q^{(1-\varepsilon_q)n}$.

A conjecture of Verstraëte states that for any fixed $\ell < k$ there exists a positive constant $c$ such that any $C_{2k}$-free graph $G$ contains a $C_{2\ell}$-free subgraph with at least $c |E(G)|$ edges. For $\ell = 2$, this conjecture was verified by Kühn and Osthus in 2004. We identify two counterexamples to this conjecture for $\ell = 4$ and $k=5$: the first comes from a recent construction of a dense $C_{10}$-free subgraph of the hypercube and the second from Wenger's construction for extremal $C_{10}$-free graphs.

We show that if $λ_1,\ldots,λ_k$ are algebraic numbers, then $$|A+λ_1\cdot A+\dots+λ_k\cdot A|\geq H(λ_1,\ldots,λ_k)|A|-o(|A|)$$ for all finite subsets $A$ of $\mathbb{C}$, where $H(λ_1,\ldots,λ_k)$ is an explicit constant that is best possible. The proof combines several ingredients, including a lower bound estimate on the measure of sums of linear transformations of compact sets in $\mathbb{R}^d$, a variant of Freiman's theorem tuned specifically to sums of dilates and the analysis of what we call lattice density, which succinctly captures how a subset of $\mathbb{Z}^d$ is arranged relative to a given flag of lattices. As an application, we revisit the study of sums of linear transformations of finite sets, in particular proving an asymptotically best possible lower bound for sums of two linear transformations.

We show that the set $Π^{(k)}$ of Turán densities of $k$-uniform hypergraphs has infinitely many accumulation points in $[0,1)$ for every $k \geq 3$. This extends an earlier result of ours showing that $Π^{(k)}$ has at least one such accumulation point.

A conjecture of Verstraëte states that for any fixed $\ell < k$ there exists a positive constant $c$ such that any $C_{2k}$-free graph $G$ contains a $C_{2\ell}$-free subgraph with at least $c |E(G)|$ edges. For $\ell = 2$, this conjecture was verified by Kühn and Osthus. We show that $C_6$ and $C_{2k}$ satisfy the conjecture for all odd $k$, but observe that a recent construction of a dense $C_{10}$-free subgraph of the hypercube yields a counterexample to the conjecture for $C_8$ and $C_{10}$.

Given a graph $H$ and a natural number $n$, the extremal number $\mathrm{ex}(n, H)$ is the largest number of edges in an $n$-vertex graph containing no copy of $H$. In this paper, we obtain a general upper bound for the extremal number of generalised face-incidence graphs, a family which includes the standard face-incidence graphs of regular polytopes. This builds on and generalises work of Janzer and Sudakov, who obtained the same bound for hypercubes and bipartite Kneser graphs, and allows us to confirm a conjecture of Conlon and Lee on the extremal number of $K_{r,r}$-free bipartite graphs for certain incidence graphs. In their work, Janzer and Sudakov showed that such an upper bound on the extremal number holds whenever the graph $H$ satisfies a certain percolation property which captures an appropriate sequence of repeated applications of the Cauchy--Schwarz inequality, a property which they then verify for hypercubes and bipartite Kneser graphs. This percolation property bears close resemblance to a property that arose in earlier work of Conlon and Lee on weakly norming graphs. In this latter work, Conlon and Lee developed a method for controlling repeated applications of the Cauchy--Schwarz inequality based on the properties of reflection groups, which then allowed them to isolate a broad family of weakly norming graphs. Here, we develop this method further, casting it in a purely algebraic form that allows us not only to combine it with the Janzer--Sudakov result and obtain the desired result about the extremal number of incidence graphs, but also to simplify the proofs of both the Conlon--Lee result on weakly norming graphs and a related result of Coregliano.

We prove that a random Cayley graph on a group of order $N$ has clique number $O(\log N \log \log N)$ with high probability. This bound is best possible up to the constant factor for certain groups, including~$\mathbb{F}_2^n$, and improves the longstanding upper bound of $O(\log^2 N)$ due to Alon. Our proof does not make use of the underlying group structure and is purely combinatorial, with the key result being an essentially best possible upper bound for the number of subsets of given order that contain at most a given number of colors in a properly edge-colored complete graph. As a further application of this result, we study a conjecture of Alon stating that every group of order $N$ has a Cayley graph whose clique number and independence number are both $O(\log N)$, proving the conjecture for all abelian groups of order $N$ for almost all $N$. For finite vector spaces of order $N$ with characteristic congruent to $1 \pmod 4$, we prove the existence of a self-complementary Cayley graph on the vector space whose clique number and independence number are both at most $(2+o(1))\log N$. This matches the lower bound for Ramsey numbers coming from random graphs and solves, in a strong form, a problem of Alon and Orlitsky motivated by information theory.

A system of linear equations $L$ is said to be norming if a natural functional $t_L(\cdot)$ giving a weighted count for the set of solutions to the system can be used to define a norm on the space of real-valued functions on $\mathbb{F}_q^n$ for every $n>0$. For example, Gowers uniformity norms arise in this way. In this paper, we initiate the systematic study of norming linear systems by proving a range of necessary and sufficient conditions for a system to be norming. Some highlights include an isomorphism theorem for the functional $t_L(\cdot)$, a proof that any norming system must be variable-transitive and the classification of all norming systems of rank at most two.

A natural open problem in Ramsey theory is to determine those $3$-graphs $H$ for which the off-diagonal Ramsey number $r(H, K_n^{(3)})$ grows polynomially with $n$. We make substantial progress on this question by showing that if $H$ is tightly connected or has at most two tight components, then $r(H, K_n^{(3)})$ grows polynomially if and only if $H$ is contained in an iterated blowup of an edge.

For $p$ prime, $A \subseteq \mathbb{Z}/p\mathbb{Z}$ and $λ\in \mathbb{Z}$, the sum of dilates $A + λ\cdot A$ is defined by \[A + λ\cdot A = \{a + λa' : a, a' \in A\}.\] The basic problem on such sums of dilates asks for the minimum size of $|A + λ\cdot A|$ for given $λ$, $A$ of given density $α$, and $p$ tending to infinity. We investigate this problem for $α$ fixed and $λ$ tending to infinity, proving near-optimal bounds in this case.

We show that for every non-spherical set $X$ in $\mathbb{E}^d$, there exists a natural number $m$ and a red/blue-colouring of $\mathbb{E}^n$ for every $n$ such that there is no red copy of X and no blue progression of length $m$ with each consecutive point at distance $1$. This verifies a conjecture of Wu and the first author.

We show that for every integer $k\geq3$, the set of Turán densities of $k$-uniform hypergraphs has an accumulation point in $[0,1)$. In particular, $1/2$ is an accumulation point for the set of Turán densities of $3$-uniform hypergraphs.

Let $ES_{\ell}(n)$ be the minimum $N$ such that every $N$-element point set in the plane contains either $\ell$ collinear members or $n$ points in convex position. We prove that there is a constant $C>0$ such that, for each $\ell, n \ge 3$, $$ (3\ell - 1) \cdot 2^{n-5} < ES_{\ell}(n) < \ell^2 \cdot 2^{n+ C\sqrt{n\log n}}.$$ A similar extension of the well-known Erd\H os--Szekeres cups-caps theorem is also proved.

A graph $H$ is said to be positive if the homomorphism density $t_H(G)$ is non-negative for all weighted graphs $G$. The positive graph conjecture proposes a characterisation of such graphs, saying that a graph is positive if and only if it is symmetric, in the sense that it is formed by gluing two copies of some subgraph along an independent set. We prove several results relating to this conjecture. First, we make progress towards the conjecture itself by showing that any connected positive graph must have a vertex of even degree. We then make use of this result to identify some new counterexamples to the analogue of Sidorenko's conjecture for hypergraphs. In particular, we show that, for $r$ odd, every $r$-uniform tight cycle is a counterexample, generalising a recent result of Conlon, Lee and Sidorenko that dealt with the case $r=3$. Finally, we relate the positive graph conjecture to the emerging study of graph codes by showing that any positive graph has vanishing graph code density, thereby improving a result of Alon who proved the same result for symmetric graphs. Our proofs make use of a variety of tools and techniques, including the properties of independence polynomials, hypergraph quasirandomness and discrete Fourier analysis.

Answering a question of Erdős and Graham, we show that for each fixed positive rational number $x$ the number of ways to write $x$ as a sum of reciprocals of distinct positive integers each at most $n$ is $2^{(c_x + o(1))n}$ for an explicit constant $c_x$ increasing with $x$.

A fundamental problem in Ramsey theory is to determine the growth rate in terms of $n$ of the Ramsey number $r(H, K_n^{(3)})$ of a fixed $3$-uniform hypergraph $H$ versus the complete $3$-uniform hypergraph with $n$ vertices. We study this problem, proving two main results. First, we show that for a broad class of $H$, including links of odd cycles and tight cycles of length not divisible by three, $r(H, K_n^{(3)}) \ge 2^{Ω_H(n \log n)}$. This significantly generalizes and simplifies an earlier construction of Fox and He which handled the case of links of odd cycles and is sharp both in this case and for all but finitely many tight cycles of length not divisible by three. Second, disproving a folklore conjecture in the area, we show that there exists a linear hypergraph $H$ for which $r(H, K_n^{(3)})$ is superpolynomial in $n$. This provides the first example of a separation between $r(H,K_n^{(3)})$ and $r(H,K_{n,n,n}^{(3)})$, since the latter is known to be polynomial in $n$ when $H$ is linear.

We show that for every positive integer $k$ there are positive constants $C$ and $c$ such that if $A$ is a subset of $\{1, 2, \dots, n\}$ of size at least $C n^{1/k}$, then, for some $d \leq k-1$, the set of subset sums of $A$ contains a homogeneous $d$-dimensional generalized arithmetic progression of size at least $c|A|^{d+1}$. This strengthens a result of Szemerédi and Vu, who proved a similar statement without the homogeneity condition. As an application, we make progress on the Erdős--Straus non-averaging sets problem, showing that every subset $A$ of $\{1, 2, \dots, n\}$ of size at least $n^{\sqrt{2} - 1 + o(1)}$ contains an element which is the average of two or more other elements of $A$. This gives the first polynomial improvement on a result of Erdős and Sárközy from 1990.

A simplicial complex $H$ consists of a pair of sets $(V,E)$ where $V$ is a set of vertices and $E\subseteq\mathscr{P}(V)$ is a collection of subsets of $V$ closed under taking subsets. Given a simplicial complex $F$ and $n\in \mathbb N$, the extremal number $\text{ex}(n,F)$ is the maximum number of edges that a simplicial complex on $n$ vertices can have without containing a copy of $F$. We initiate the systematic study of extremal numbers in this context by asymptotically determining the extremal numbers of several natural simplicial complexes. In particular, we asymptotically determine the extremal number of a simplicial complex for which the extremal example has more than one incomplete layer.