arXiv++ Combinatorics

We prove that the recognition problem for algebraic matroids is undecidable. Explicitly, this means that there is no algorithm that takes as input a finite set $S$ and a function $r\colon\mathcal{P}(S) \to \mathbb{Z}_{\ge 0}$ (where $\mathcal{P}(S)$ is the power set) and decides whether there exists a pair of fields $F \subset K$, and a function $f\colon S \to K$, such that for all $A \subseteq S$: $\mathrm{tr.deg}_{K/F}(f(A)) = r(A)$. This problem is known to be decidable if the characteristic of the fields involved is constrained to be zero. We prove that it is undecidable if the characteristic is either left unspecified (in which case a realization over any characteristic is accepted) or fixed to be a prime $p$. The proof relies on Hrushovski--Zilber's Group Configuration Theorem and on the work of Evans and Hrushovski on "Projective Planes in Algebraically Closed Fields". We relate two different such projective planes, and eventually construct a reduction from the solvability of Diophantine equations over $\mathbb{F}_p(x)$ ($p$ prime) to algebraicity of matroids. Solvability of Diophantine equations over $\mathbb{F}_p(x)$ was proved to be undecidable by Pheidas for all $p > 2$, and later by Videla for $p=2$. A central part of our proof is a variant of the so-called Field Configuration Theorem.

We describe a construction that takes as input a graph and a basis for its first homology, and returns a triangulation of a 3-dimensional homology sphere. This makes precise an idea of M. Gromov and A. Nabutovski. The immediate application, essentially described by Gromov, is to translate problems about asymptotics of homology sphere triangulations to asymptotic counting problems for constant-degree graphs with "short" homology bases. We construct families of 3- sphere triangulations with dual graphs that are expanders, answering a relaxation of a question asked by G. Kalai. Our results also imply that if the number of d-dimensional triangulated homology spheres with n facets is superexponential in n for some d then the same holds for d = 3.

We prove that there is no algorithm to decide whether a given integer vector is in the closure of the entropic cone $\overline{Γ_{n}^{*}}$. Equivalently, there is no decision procedure to determine whether a given integer-valued function $h:\mathcal{P}(\{1,\ldots,n\})\rightarrow\mathbb{Z}_{\ge 0}$ is a pointwise limit of joint entropy functions. In other words, given such an $h$, it is undecidable whether for all $\varepsilon > 0$ there exists a finite probability space $(Ω,P)$ with random variables $X_{1},\ldots,X_{n}$ such that their joint entropy $H$ satisfies $\max_{I\subseteq\{1,\ldots,n\}}\left|H\left(X_{I}\right)-h\left(I\right)\right|<\varepsilon$. This settles the last open case in a sequence of related undecidability results proved by L. Kühne and the author, with applications in algorithmic information theory. The main new tool is a Desargues'-type theorem for almost entropic polymatroids.

This article studies two notions of generalized matroid representations motivated by algorithmic information theory and cryptographic secret sharing. The first (entropic representability) involves discrete random variables, while the second (almost-multilinear representability) deals with approximate subspace arrangements. In both cases, we prove that determining whether an input matroid has such a representation is undecidable. Consequently, the conditional independence implication problem is also undecidable, providing an independent answer to a question posed by Geiger and Pearl, recently resolved by Cheuk Ting Li. These problems are also closely related to characterizing achievable rates in network coding and constructing secret sharing schemes. For example, another corollary of our work is that deciding whether an access structure admits an ideal secret sharing scheme is undecidable. Our approach reduces undecidable problems from group theory to matroid representation problems. Specifically, we reduce the uniform word problem for finite groups to entropic representability and the word problem for sofic groups to almost-multilinear representability. A key part of this reduction involves modifying group presentations into forms where linear representations are generic in an appropriate sense when restricted to the generating set.

This paper compares skew-linear and multilinear matroid representations. These are matroids that are representable over division rings and (roughly speaking) invertible matrices, respectively. The main tool is the von Staudt construction, by which we translate our problems to algebra. After giving an exposition of a simple variant of the von Staudt construction we present the following results: $\bullet$ Undecidability of several matroid representation problems over division rings. $\bullet$ An example of a matroid with an infinite multilinear characteristic set, but which is not multilinear in characteristic $0$. $\bullet$ An example of a skew-linear matroid that is not multilinear.

We provide a new foundation for combinatorial commutative algebra and Stanley-Reisner theory using the partition complex introduced in [Adi18]. One of the main advantages is that it is entirely self-contained, using only a minimal knowledge of algebra and topology. On the other hand, we also develop new techniques and results using this approach. In particular, we provide - A novel, self-contained method of establishing Reisner's theorem and Schenzel's formula for Buchsbaum complexes. - A simple new way to establish Poincaré duality for face rings of manifolds, in much greater generality and precision than previous treatments. - A "master-theorem" to generalize several previous results concerning the Lefschetz theorem on subdivisions. - Proof for a conjecture of Kühnel concerning triangulated manifolds with boundary.

For a natural number $c$, a $c$-arrangement is an arrangement of dimension $c$ subspaces satisfying the following condition: the sum of any subset of the subspaces has dimension a multiple of $c$. Matroids arising as normalized rank functions of $c$-arrangements are also known as multilinear matroids. We prove that it is algorithmically undecidable whether there exists a $c$ such that a given matroid has a $c$-arrangement representation, or equivalently whether the matroid is multilinear. It follows that certain network coding problems are also undecidable. In the proof, we introduce a generalized Dowling geometry to encode an instance of the uniform word problem for finite groups in matroids of rank three. The $c$-arrangement condition gives rise to some difficulties and their resolution is the main part of the paper.