arXiv++ Combinatorics

We prove that the recognition problem for algebraic matroids is undecidable. Explicitly, this means that there is no algorithm that takes as input a finite set $S$ and a function $r\colon\mathcal{P}(S) \to \mathbb{Z}_{\ge 0}$ (where $\mathcal{P}(S)$ is the power set) and decides whether there exists a pair of fields $F \subset K$, and a function $f\colon S \to K$, such that for all $A \subseteq S$: $\mathrm{tr.deg}_{K/F}(f(A)) = r(A)$. This problem is known to be decidable if the characteristic of the fields involved is constrained to be zero. We prove that it is undecidable if the characteristic is either left unspecified (in which case a realization over any characteristic is accepted) or fixed to be a prime $p$. The proof relies on Hrushovski--Zilber's Group Configuration Theorem and on the work of Evans and Hrushovski on "Projective Planes in Algebraically Closed Fields". We relate two different such projective planes, and eventually construct a reduction from the solvability of Diophantine equations over $\mathbb{F}_p(x)$ ($p$ prime) to algebraicity of matroids. Solvability of Diophantine equations over $\mathbb{F}_p(x)$ was proved to be undecidable by Pheidas for all $p > 2$, and later by Videla for $p=2$. A central part of our proof is a variant of the so-called Field Configuration Theorem.

The conditional independence (CI) relation of a distribution in a max-linear Bayesian network depends on its weight matrix through the $C^\ast$-separation criterion. These CI~models, which we call maxoids, are compositional graphoids which are in general not representable by Gaussian random variables. We prove that every maxoid can be obtained from a transitively closed weighted DAG and show that the stratification of generic weight matrices by their maxoids yields a polyhedral~fan. We also use this connection to polyhedral geometry to develop an algorithm for solving the conditional independence implication problem for maxoids.

We analyze a combinatorial rule satisfied by the signs of principal minors of a real symmetric matrix. The sign patterns satisfying this rule are equivalent to uniform oriented Lagrangian matroids. We first discuss their structure and symmetries and then study their asymptotics, proving that almost all of them are not representable by real symmetric matrices. We offer several conjectures and experimental results concerning representable sign patterns and the topology of their representation spaces.

We introduce an algebraic concept of the frame for abstract conditional independence (CI) models, together with basic operations with respect to which such a frame should be closed: copying and marginalization. Three standard examples of such frames are (discrete) probabilistic CI structures, semi-graphoids and structural semi-graphoids. We concentrate on those frames which are closed under the operation of set-theoretical intersection because, for these, the respective families of CI models are lattices. This allows one to apply the results from lattice theory and formal concept analysis to describe such families in terms of implications among CI statements. The central concept of this paper is that of self-adhesivity defined in algebraic terms, which is a combinatorial reflection of the self-adhesivity concept studied earlier in context of polymatroids and information theory. The generalization also leads to a self-adhesivity operator defined on the hyper-level of CI frames. We answer some of the questions related to this approach and raise other open questions. The core of the paper is in computations. The combinatorial approach to computation might overcome some memory and space limitation of software packages based on polyhedral geometry, in particular, if SAT solvers are utilized. We characterize some basic CI families over 4 variables in terms of canonical implications among CI statements. We apply our method in information-theoretical context to the task of entropic region demarcation over 5 variables.

Selfadhesivity is a property of entropic polymatroids which guarantees that the polymatroid can be glued to an identical copy of itself along arbitrary restrictions such that the two pieces are independent given the common restriction. We show that positive definite matrices satisfy this condition as well and examine consequences for Gaussian conditional independence structures. New axioms of Gaussian CI are obtained by applying selfadhesivity to the previously known axioms of structural semigraphoids and orientable gaussoids.

The number of $n$-gaussoids is shown to be a double exponential function in $n$. The necessary bounds are achieved by studying construction methods for gaussoids that rely on prescribing $3$-minors and encoding the resulting combinatorial constraints in a suitable transitive graph. Various special classes of gaussoids arise from restricting the allowed $3$-minors.

A gaussoid is a combinatorial structure that encodes independence in probability and statistics, just like matroids encode independence in linear algebra. The gaussoid axioms of Lnenicka and Matús are equivalent to compatibility with certain quadratic relations among principal and almost-principal minors of a symmetric matrix. We develop the geometric theory of gaussoids, based on the Lagrangian Grassmannian and its symmetries. We introduce oriented gaussoids and valuated gaussoids, thus connecting to real and tropical geometry. We classify small realizable and non-realizable gaussoids. Positive gaussoids are as nice as positroids: they are all realizable via graphical models.