arXiv++ Combinatorics

We review the work of Dominic Welsh (1938-2023), tracing his remarkable influence through his theorems, expository writing, students, and interactions. He was particularly adept at bringing different fields together and fostering the development of mathematics and mathematicians. His contributions ranged widely across discrete mathematics over four main career phases: discrete probability, matroids and graphs, computational complexity, and Tutte-Whitney polynomials. We give particular emphasis to his work in matroid theory and Tutte-Whitney polynomials.

We raise some questions about graph polynomials, highlighting concepts and phenomena that may merit consideration in the development of a general theory. Our questions are mainly of three types: When do graph polynomials have reduction relations (simple linear recursions based on local operations), perhaps in a wider class of combinatorial objects? How many levels of reduction relations does a graph polynomial need in order to express it in terms of trivial base cases? For a graph polynomial, how are properties such as equivalence and factorisation reflected in the structure of a graph? We illustrate our discussion with a variety of graph polynomials and other invariants. This leads us to reflect on the historical origins of graph polynomials. We also introduce some new polynomials based on partial colourings of graphs and establish some of their basic properties.

Since the pioneering work of R. M. Foster in the 1930s, many graph repositories have been created to support research in graph theory. This survey reviews many of these graph repositories and summarises the scope and contents of each repository. We identify opportunities for the development of repositories that can be queried in more flexible ways.

A graph $G$ is a non-separating planar graph if there is a drawing $D$ of $G$ on the plane such that (1) no two edges cross each other in $D$ and (2) for any cycle $C$ in $D$, any two vertices not in $C$ are on the same side of $C$ in $D$. Non-separating planar graphs are closed under taking minors and are a subclass of planar graphs and a superclass of outerplanar graphs. In this paper, we show that a graph is a non-separating planar graph if and only if it does not contain $K_1 \cup K_4$ or $K_1 \cup K_{2,3}$ or $K_{1,1,3}$ as a minor. Furthermore, we provide a structural characterisation of this class of graphs. More specifically, we show that any maximal non-separating planar graph is either an outerplanar graph or a subgraph of a wheel or it can be obtained by subdividing some of the side-edges of the 1-skeleton of a triangular prism (two disjoint triangles linked by a perfect matching). Lastly, to demonstrate an application of non-separating planar graphs, we use the characterisation of non-separating planar graphs to prove that there are maximal linkless graphs with $3n-3$ edges which provides an answer to a question asked by Horst Sachs about the number of edges of linkless graphs in 1983.

Gordon and McMahon defined a two-variable greedoid polynomial $ f(G;t,z) $ for any greedoid $ G $. They studied greedoid polynomials for greedoids associated with rooted graphs and rooted digraphs. They proved that greedoid polynomials of rooted digraphs have the multiplicative direct sum property. In addition, these polynomials are divisible by $ 1 + z $ under certain conditions. We compute the greedoid polynomials for all rooted digraphs up to order six. A greedoid polynomial $ f(D) $ of a rooted digraph $ D $ of order $ n $ GM-factorises if $ f(D) = f(G) \cdot f(H) $ such that $ G $ and $ H $ are rooted digraphs of order at most $ n $ and $ f(G),f(H) \ne 1 $. We study the GM-factorability of greedoid polynomials of rooted digraphs, particularly those that are not divisible by $ 1 + z $. We give some examples and an infinite family of rooted digraphs that are not direct sums but their greedoid polynomials GM-factorise.

An alternating dimap is an orientably embedded Eulerian directed graph where the edges incident with each vertex are directed inwards and outwards alternately. Three reduction operations for alternating dimaps were investigated by Farr. A minor of an alternating dimap can be obtained by reducing some of its edges using the reduction operations. Unlike classical minor operations, these reduction operations do not commute in general. A Tutte invariant for alternating dimaps is a function $ P $ defined on every alternating dimap and taking values in a field such that $ P $ is invariant under isomorphism and obeys a linear recurrence relation involving reduction operations. It is well known that if a graph $ G $ is planar, then the Tutte polynomial $ T $ satisfies $ T(G;x,y)=T(G^{*};y,x) $. We note an analogous relation for the extended Tutte invariants for alternating dimaps introduced by Farr. We then characterise the Tutte invariant for alternating dimaps of genus zero under several conditions. As a result of the non-commutativity of the reduction operations, the recursions based on them cannot always be satisfied. We investigate the properties of alternating dimaps of genus zero that are required in order to obtain a well defined Tutte invariant. Some excluded minor characterisations for these alternating dimaps are also given.

The topological containment problem is known to be polynomial-time solvable for any fixed pattern graph $H$, but good characterisations have been found for only a handful of non-trivial pattern graphs. The complete graph on five vertices, $K_5$, is one pattern graph for which a characterisation has not been found. The discovery of such a characterisation would be of particular interest, due to the Hajós Conjecture. One step towards this may be to find a good characterisation of graphs that do not topologically contain the simpler pattern graph $K_5^-$, obtained by removing a single edge from $K_5$. This paper makes progress towards achieving this, by showing that every 4-connected graph must contain a $K_5^-$-subdivision.

We introduce and analyse an extension of the disjunctive sum operation on some classical impartial games. Whereas the disjunctive sum describes positions formed from independent subpositions, our operation combines positions that are not completely independent but interact only in a very restricted way. We extend the games Nim and Silver Dollar, played by moving counters along one-dimensional strips of cells, by joining several strips at their initial cell. We prove that, in certain cases, computing the Sprague-Grundy function can be simplified to that of a simpler game with at most two tokens in each strip. We give an algorithm that, for each Sprague-Grundy value g, computes the positions of two-token Star Nim whose Sprague-Grundy values are g. We establish that the sequence of differences of entries of these positions is ultimately additively periodic.

The subgraph homeomorphism problem, SHP($H$), has been shown to be polynomial-time solvable for any fixed pattern graph $H$, but practical algorithms have been developed only for a few specific pattern graphs. Among these are the wheels with four, five, and six spokes. This paper examines the subgraph homeomorphism problem where the pattern graph is a wheel with seven spokes, and gives a result that describes graphs with no $W_{7}$-subdivision, showing how they can be built up, using certain operations, from smaller `pieces' that meet certain conditions. We also discuss algorithmic aspects of the problem.

Practical algorithms for solving the Subgraph Homeomorphism Problem are known for only a few small pattern graphs: among these are the wheel graphs with four, five, six, and seven spokes. The length and difficulty of the proofs leading to these algorithms increase greatly as the size of the pattern graph increases. Proving a result for the wheel with six spokes requires extensive case analysis on many small graphs, and even more such analysis is needed for the wheel with seven spokes. This paper describes algorithms and programs used to automate the generation and testing of the graphs that arise as cases in these proofs. The main algorithm given may be useful in a more general context, for developing other characterizations of SHP-related properties.