arXiv++ Combinatorics

A simple graph is triangular if every edge is contained in a triangle. A sequence of integers is graphical if it is the degree sequence of a simple graph. Egan and Nikolayevsky recently conjectured that every graphical sequence whose terms are all at least 4 is the degree sequence of a triangular simple graph, and proved this in some special cases. In this paper we state and prove the analogous version of this conjecture for multigraphs.

One of the great pleasures of working with Imre Leader is to experience his infectious delight on encountering a compelling combinatorial problem. This collection of open problems in combinatorics has been put together by a subset of his former PhD students and students-of-students for the occasion of his 60th birthday. All of the contributors have been influenced (directly or indirectly) by Imre: his personality, enthusiasm and his approach to mathematics. The problems included cover many of the areas of combinatorial mathematics that Imre is most associated with: including extremal problems on graphs, set systems and permutations, and Ramsey theory. This is a personal selection of problems which we find intriguing and deserving of being better known. It is not intended to be systematic, or to consist of the most significant or difficult questions in any area. Rather, our main aim is to celebrate Imre and his mathematics and to hope that these problems will make him smile. We also hope this collection will be a useful resource for researchers in combinatorics and will stimulate some enjoyable collaborations and beautiful mathematics.

Given a $k$-graph $H$ a complete blow-up of $H$ is a $k$-graph $\hat{H}$ formed by replacing each $v\in V(H)$ by a non-empty vertex class $A_v$ and then inserting all edges between any $k$ vertex classes corresponding to an edge of $H$. Given a subgraph $G\subseteq \hat{H}$ and an edge $e\in E(H)$ we define the density $d_e(G)$ to be the proportion of edges present in $G$ between the classes corresponding to $e$. The density Turán problem for $H$ asks: determine the minimal value $d_{crit}(H)$ such that any subgraph $G\subseteq \hat{H}$ satisfying $d_e(G)> d_{crit}(H)$ for every $e\in E(H)$ contains a copy of $H$ as a transversal, i.e. a copy of $H$ meeting each vertex class of $\hat{H}$ exactly once. We give upper bounds for this hypergraph density Turán problem that generalise the known bounds for the case of graphs due to Csikvári and Nagy, [Combinatorics, Probability and Computing, 21(4):531-553, 2012] although our methods are different, employing an entropy compression argument.

We consider a generalisation of Kelly's conjecture which is due to Alspach, Mason, and Pullman from 1976. Kelly's conjecture states that every regular tournament has an edge decomposition into Hamilton cycles, and this was proved by Kühn and Osthus for large tournaments. The conjecture of Alspach, Mason, and Pullman asks for the minimum number of paths needed in a path decomposition of a general tournament $T$. There is a natural lower bound for this number in terms of the degree sequence of $T$ and it is conjectured that this bound is correct for tournaments of even order. Almost all cases of the conjecture are open and we prove many of them.

We show that for any set $S\subseteq \mathbb{Z}$, $|S|=4$ there exists a 3-coloring of $\mathbb{Z}$ in which every translate of $S$ receives all three colors. This implies that $S$ has a codensity of at most $1/3$, proving a conjecture of Newman [D. J. Newman, Complements of finite sets of integers, Michigan Math. J. 14 (1967) 481--486]. We also consider related questions in $\mathbb{Z}^d$, $d\geq 2$.

If G is a graph and H is a set of subgraphs of G, then an edge-coloring of G is called H-polychromatic if every graph from H gets all colors present in G on its edges. The H-polychromatic number of G, denoted poly_H(G), is the largest number of colors in an H-polychromatic coloring. In this paper, poly_H(G) is determined exactly when G is a complete graph and H is the family of all 1-factors. In addition poly_H(G) is found up to an additive constant term when G is a complete graph and H is the family of all 2-factors, or the family of all Hamiltonian cycles.

Given a subgraph G of the hypercube Q_n, a coloring of the edges of Q_n such that every embedding of G contains an edge of every color is called a G-polychromatic coloring. The maximum number of colors with which it is possible to G-polychromatically color the edges of any hypercube is called the polychromatic number of G. To determine polychromatic numbers, it is only necessary to consider a structured class of colorings, which we call simple. The main tool for finding upper bounds on polychromatic numbers is to translate the question of polychromatically coloring the hypercube so every embedding of a graph G contains every color into a question of coloring the 2-dimensional grid so that every so-called shape sequence corresponding to G contains every color. After surveying the tools for finding polychromatic numbers, we apply these techniques to find polychromatic numbers of a class of graphs called punctured hypercubes. We also consider the problem of finding polychromatic numbers in the setting where larger subcubes of the hypercube are colored. We exhibit two new constructions which show that this problem is not a straightforward generalization of the edge coloring problem.

Mantel's theorem says that among all triangle-free graphs of a given order the balanced complete bipartite graph is the unique graph of maximum size. We prove an analogue of this result for 3-graphs. Let $K_4^-=\{123,124,134\}$, $F_6=\{123,124,345,156\}$ and $\mathcal{F}=\{K_4^-,F_6\}$: for $n\neq 5$ the unique $\mathcal{F}$-free 3-graph of order $n$ and maximum size is the balanced complete tripartite 3-graph $S_3(n)$ (for $n=5$ it is $C_5^{(3)}=\{123,234,345,145,125\}$). This extends an old result of Bollobás that $S_3(n) $ is the unique 3-graph of maximum size with no copy of $K_4^-=\{123,124,134\}$ or $F_5=\{123,124,345\}$.

We prove a vertex domination conjecture of Erd\H os, Faudree, Gould, Gyárfás, Rousseau, and Schelp, that for every n-vertex complete graph with edges coloured using three colours there exists a set of at most three vertices which have at least 2n/3 neighbours in one of the colours. Our proof makes extensive use of the ideas presented in "A New Bound for the 2/3 Conjecture" by Král', Liu, Sereni, Whalen, and Yilma.

If we 2-color the vertices of a large hypercube what monochromatic substructures are we guaranteed to find? Call a set S of vertices from Q_d, the d-dimensional hypercube, Ramsey if any 2-coloring of the vertices of Q_n, for n sufficiently large, contains a monochromatic copy of S. Ramsey's theorem tells us that for any r \geq 1 every 2-coloring of a sufficiently large r-uniform hypergraph will contain a large monochromatic clique (a complete subhypergraph): hence any set of vertices from Q_d that all have the same weight is Ramsey. A natural question to ask is: which sets S corresponding to unions of cliques of different weights from Q_d are Ramsey? The answer to this question depends on the number of cliques involved. In particular we determine which unions of 2 or 3 cliques are Ramsey and then show, using a probabilistic argument, that any non-trivial union of 39 or more cliques of different weights cannot be Ramsey. A key tool is a lemma which reduces questions concerning monochromatic configurations in the hypercube to questions about monochromatic translates of sets of integers.

If $\mathcal{F}$ is a family of graphs then the Turán density of $\mathcal{F}$ is determined by the minimum chromatic number of the members of $\mathcal{F}$. The situation for Turán densities of 3-graphs is far more complex and still very unclear. Our aim in this paper is to present new exact Turán densities for individual and finite families of 3-graphs, in many cases we are also able to give corresponding stability results. As well as providing new examples of individual 3-graphs with Turán densities equal to 2/9,4/9,5/9 and 3/4 we also give examples of irrational Turán densities for finite families of 3-graphs, disproving a conjecture of Chung and Graham. (Pikhurko has independently disproved this conjecture by a very different method.) A central question in this area, known as Turán's problem, is to determine the Turán density of $K_4^{(3)}=\{123,124, 134, 234\}$. Turán conjectured that this should be 5/9. Razborov [On 3-hypergraphs with forbidden 4-vertex configurations, in SIAM J. Disc. Math. 24 (2010), 946-963] showed that if we consider the induced Turán problem forbidding $K_4^{(3)}$ and $E_1$, the 3-graph with 4 vertices and a single edge, then the Turán density is indeed 5/9. We give some new non-induced results of a similar nature, in particular we show that $π(K_4^{(3)},H)=5/9$ for a 3-graph $H$ satisfying $π(H)=3/4$. We end with a number of open questions focusing mainly on the topic of which values can occur as Turán densities. Our work is mainly computational, making use of Razborov's flag algebra framework. However all proofs are exact in the sense that they can be verified without the use of any floating point operations. Indeed all verifying computations use only integer operations, working either over $\mathbb{Q}$ or in the case of irrational Turán densities over an appropriate quadratic extension of $\mathbb{Q}$.

We say that $α\in [0,1)$ is a jump for an integer $r\geq 2$ if there exists $c(α)>0$ such that for all $ε>0 $ and all $t\geq 1$ any $r$-graph with $n\geq n_0(α,ε,t)$ vertices and density at least $α+ε$ contains a subgraph on $t$ vertices of density at least $α+c$. The Erd\H os--Stone--Simonovits theorem implies that for $r=2$ every $α\in [0,1)$ is a jump. Erd\H os showed that for all $r\geq 3$, every $α\in [0,r!/r^r)$ is a jump. Moreover he made his famous "jumping constant conjecture" that for all $r\geq 3$, every $α\in [0,1)$ is a jump. Frankl and Rödl disproved this conjecture by giving a sequence of values of non-jumps for all $r\geq 3$. We use Razborov's flag algebra method to show that jumps exist for $r=3$ in the interval $[2/9,1)$. These are the first examples of jumps for any $r\geq 3$ in the interval $[r!/r^r,1)$. To be precise we show that for $r=3$ every $α\in [0.2299,0.2316)$ is a jump. We also give an improved upper bound for the Turán density of $K_4^-=\{123,124,134\}$: $π(K_4^-)\leq 0.2871$. This in turn implies that for $r=3$ every $α\in [0.2871,8/27)$ is a jump.

We determine the minimal density of triangles in a tripartite graph with prescribed edge densities. This extends a previous result of Bondy, Shen, Thomassé and Thomassen characterizing those edge densities guaranteeing the existence of a triangle in a tripartite graph. To be precise we show that a suitably weighted copy of the graph formed by deleting a certain 9-cycle from $K_{3,3,3}$ has minimal triangle density among all weighted tripartite graphs with prescribed edge densities.

Let $\mathcal{Q}_n$ be the $n$-dimensional hypercube: the graph with vertex set $\{0,1\}^n$ and edges between vertices that differ in exactly one coordinate. For $1\leq d\leq n$ and $F\subseteq \{0,1\}^d$ we say that $S\subseteq \{0,1\}^n$ is \emph{$F$-free} if every embedding $i:\{0,1\}^d\to \{0,1\}^n$ satisfies $i(F)\not\subseteq S$. We consider the question of how large $S\subseteq \{0,1\}^n$ can be if it is $F$-free. In particular we generalise the main prior result in this area, for $F=\{0,1\}^2$, due to E.A. Kostochka and prove a local stability result for the structure of near-extremal sets. We also show that the density required to guarantee an embedded copy of at least one of a family of forbidden configurations may be significantly lower than that required to ensure an embedded copy of any individual member of the family. Finally we show that any subset of the $n$-dimensional hypercube of positive density will contain exponentially many points from some embedded $d$-dimensional subcube if $n$ is sufficiently large.

For a graph G and integer r\geq 1 we denote the collection of independent r-sets of G by I^{(r)}(G). If v\in V(G) then I_v^{(r)}(G) is the collection of all independent r-sets containing v. A graph G, is said to be r-EKR, for r\geq 1, iff no intersecting family A\subseteq I^{(r)}(G) is larger than max_{v\in V(G)}|I^{(r)}_v(G)|. There are various graphs which are known to have this property: the empty graph of order n\geq 2r (this is the celebrated Erdos-Ko-Rado theorem), any disjoint union of at least r copies of K_t for t\geq 2, and any cycle. In this paper we show how these results can be extended to other classes of graphs via a compression proof technique. In particular we show that any disjoint union of at least r complete graphs, each of order at least two, is r-EKR. We also show that paths are r-EKR for all r\geq 1.

For a graph G and integer r \geq 1 we denote the family of independent r-sets of V(G) by I^{(r)}(G). A graph G is said to be r-EKR if no intersecting subfamily of I^{(r)}(G) is larger than the largest such family all of whose members contain some fixed v \in V(G). If this inequality is always strict, then G is said to be strictly r-EKR. We show that if a graph G is r-EKR then its lexicographic product with any complete graph is r-EKR. For any graph G, we define μ(G) to be the minimum size of a maximal independent vertex set. We conjecture that, if 1 \leq r \leq 1/2μ(G), then G is r-EKR, and if r<1/2μ(G), then G is strictly r-EKR. This is known to be true when G is an empty graph, a cycle, a path or the disjoint union of complete graphs. We show that it is also true when G is the disjoint union of a pair of complete multipartite graphs.

The Erdos-Ko-Rado theorem tells us how large an intersecting family of r-sets from an n-set can be, while results due to Lovasz and Tuza give bounds on the number of singletons that can occur as pairwise intersections of sets from such a family. We consider a natural generalization of these problems. Given an intersecting family of r-sets from an n-set and 1\leq k \leq r, how many k-sets can occur as pairwise intersections of sets from the family? For k=r and k=1 this reduces to the problems described above. We answer this question exactly for all values of k and r, when n is sufficiently large. We also characterize the extremal families.

We prove a conjecture due to Holroyd and Johnson that an analogue of the Erdos-Ko-Rado theorem holds for k-separated sets. In particular this determines the independence number of the vertex-critical subgraph of the Kneser graph identified by Schrijver, the collection of separated sets.