arXiv++ Combinatorics

We determine the asymptotically best possible minimum vertex degree condition forcing a two-coloured $3$-graph to contain a colour-biased tight Hamilton cycle. This confirms a conjecture of Hàn, Lang, Marciano, Pavez-Signé, Sanhueza-Matamala, Treglown and Zárate-Guerén.

The renowned theorem of Dirac states that if $G$ is a graph with minimum degree at least $n/2$ then $G$ has a Hamilton cycle. A natural generalisation asks what properties of an edge-colouring of $G$ guarantee the existence of a properly edge-coloured Hamilton cycle in $G$. This concept can be further generalised as follows: an \emph{incompatibility system} for $G$ is a set~$\mathcal{F}$ of `forbidden' pairs of adjacent edges, that is, $\mathcal{F}\subseteq \{\{uv,vw\}\in \binom{E(G)}2\}$. A cycle in $G$ is then \emph{compatible} if no two of its edges form a pair in $\mathcal{F}$. The system $\mathcal{F}$ is called \emph{$μn$-bounded} if for all $v\in V(G)$ and $uv\in E(G)$, there are at most $μn$ pairs $\{uv,vw\}\in \mathcal{F}$. How small must $μ$ be to guarantee the existence of a compatible Hamilton cycle in $G$? Krivelevich, Lee and Sudakov showed that $μ=10^{-16}$ suffices (for $n$ large), while an example of Bollobás and Erdős shows that $μ\leq 1/4$ is necessary. We significantly reduce this gap for large graphs of minimum degree at least $(1/2+\varepsilon)n$, by showing that $μ=1/8$ suffices but $μ\leq 1/6$ is necessary for such graphs. In fact, we give more precise bounds which are functions of $δ(G)/n$.

In 2004, Kim and Vu conjectured that, when $d=ω(\log n)$, the random $d$-regular graph $G_d(n)$ can be sandwiched with high probability between two random binomial graphs $G(n,p)$ with edge probabilities asymptotically equal to $\frac{d}{n}$. That is, there should exist $p_*=(1-o(1))\frac{d}{n}$, $p^*=(1+o(1))\frac{d}{n}$ and a coupling $(G_*,G,G^*)$ such that $G_*\sim G(n,p_*)$, $G\sim G_d(n)$, $G^*\sim G(n,p^*)$, and $\mathbb{P}(G_*\subset G\subset G^*)=1-o(1)$. Known as the sandwich conjecture, such a coupling is desirable as it would allow properties of the random regular graph to be inferred from those of the more easily studied binomial random graph. The conjecture was recently shown to be true when $d\gg\log^4n$ by Gao, Isaev and McKay. In this paper, we prove the sandwich conjecture in full. We do so by analysing a natural coupling procedure introduced in earlier work by Gao, Isaev and McKay, which had only previously been done when $d\gg n/\sqrt{\log n}$.

A finite set $X$ in a Euclidean space $\mathbb{R}^d$ is called Ramsey if for every $k$ there exists an integer $n$ such that whenever $\mathbb{R}^n$ is coloured with $k$ colours, there is a monochromatic copy of $X$. Graham conjectured that all spherical sets are Ramsey, but progress on this conjecture has been slow. A key result of Kříž is that all sets that embed in sets that are acted on transitively by a soluble group are Ramsey. We show that for nearly all known examples of Ramsey sets the converse is true, with only two possible exceptions.

A classical result of Dirac says that every $n$-vertex graph with minimum degree at least $\frac{n}{2}$ contains a Hamilton cycle. A `discrepancy' version of Dirac's theorem was shown by Balogh--Csaba--Jing--Pluhár, Freschi--Hyde--Lada--Treglown, and Gishboliner--Krivelevich--Michaeli as follows. Every $r$-colouring of the edge set of every $n$-vertex graph with minimum degree at least $(\frac{1}{2} + \frac{1}{2r} + o(1))n$ contains a Hamilton cycle where one of the colours appears at least $(1+o(1))\frac{n}{r}$ times. In this paper, we generalize this result by asymptotically determining the maximum possible value $f_{r,α}(n)$ for every $α\in [\frac{1}{2}, 1]$ such that every $r$-colouring of the edge set of every $n$-vertex graph with minimum degree at least $αn$ contains a Hamilton cycle where one of the colours appears at least $f_{r,α}(n)$ times. In particular, we show that $f_{r,α}(n) = (1-o(1)) \min\{(2α- 1)n, \frac{2αn}{r}, \frac{2n}{r+1}\}$ for every $α\in [\frac{1}{2} + \frac{1}{2r}, 1]$. A graph $H$ is called an $α$-residual subgraph of a graph $G$ if $d_H(v)\ge αd_{G[V(H)]}(v)$ for every $v\in V(H)$. Extending Dirac's theorem in the setting of random graphs, Lee and Sudakov showed the following. The Erdős--Rényi random graph $G(n,p)$, with $p$ above the Hamiltonicity threshold, typically has the property that every $(\frac{1}{2} +o(1))$-residual spanning subgraph contains a Hamilton cycle. Motivated by this, we prove the following random version of our `discrepancy' result. The random graph $G \sim G(n,p)$, with $p$ above the Hamiltonicity threshold, typically satisfies that every $r$-colouring of the edge set of every $α$-residual spanning subgraph of $G$ contains a Hamilton cycle where one of the colours appears at least $f_{r,α}(n)$ times.

For an oriented graph $D$, the inversion of $X\subseteq V(D)$ in $D$ is the graph obtained by reversing the orientation of all arcs with both ends in $X$. The inversion number $\mathrm{inv}(D)$ is the minimum number of inversions needed to obtain an acyclic oriented graph. We show that the dijoin conjecture of Bang-Jensen, da Silva and Havet, that $\mathrm{inv}(D_1\rightarrow D_2)=\mathrm{inv}(D_1)+\mathrm{inv}(D_2)$, is true in the case where $\mathrm{inv}(D_1)=2$ and $\mathrm{inv}(D_2)$ is even. We also characterise the cases $\mathrm{inv}(D_1)=2$ and $\mathrm{inv}(D_2)$ odd, for which the conjecture does and does not hold. We then go on to show a similar result for n-joins, in doing so we prove a conjecture of Alon, Powierski, Savery, Scott and Wilmer. Our proofs build on the idea of tournament minimum rank, introduced by Behague, Johnston, Morrison and Ogden.

One of the earliest results in extremal graph theory, Mantel's theorem, states that the maximum number of edges in a triangle-free graph $G$ on $n$ vertices is $\lfloor n^2/4 \rfloor$. We investigate how this extremal bound is affected when $G$ is additionally required to contain a prescribed graph $\mathbb{P}$ as a subgraph. We establish general upper and lower bounds for this problem, which are tight in the exponent for random triangle-free graphs and graphs generated by the triangle-free process, when the size of $\mathbb{P}$ lies within certain ranges.

The semi-random hypergraph process is a natural generalisation of the semi-random graph process, which can be thought of as a one player game. For fixed $r < s$, starting with an empty hypergraph on $n$ vertices, in each round a set of $r$ vertices $U$ is presented to the player independently and uniformly at random. The player then selects a set of $s-r$ vertices $V$ and adds the hyperedge $U \cup V$ to the $s$-uniform hypergraph. For a fixed (monotone) increasing graph property, the player's objective is to force the graph to satisfy this property with high probability in as few rounds as possible. We focus on the case where the player's objective is to construct a subgraph isomorphic to an arbitrary, fixed hypergraph $H$. In the case $r=1$ the threshold for the number of rounds required was already known in terms of the degeneracy of $H$. In the case $2 \le r < s$, we give upper and lower bounds on this threshold for general $H$, and find further improved upper bounds for cliques in particular. We identify cases where the upper and lower bounds match. We also demonstrate that the lower bounds are not always tight by finding exact thresholds for various paths and cycles.

A subgraph of the $n$-dimensional hypercube is called 'layered' if it is a subgraph of a layer of some hypercube. In this paper we show that there exist subgraphs of the cube of arbitrarily large girth that are not layered. This answers a question of Axenovich, Martin and Winter. Perhaps surprisingly, these subgraphs may even be taken to be induced.

For an oriented graph $D$ and a set $X\subseteq V(D)$, the inversion of $X$ in $D$ is the graph obtained from $D$ by reversing the orientation of each edge that has both endpoints in $X$. Define the inversion number of $D$, denoted $\mathrm{inv}(D)$, to be the minimum number of inversions required to obtain an acyclic oriented graph from $D$. The dijoin, denoted $D_1\rightarrow D_2$, of two oriented graphs $D_1$ and $D_2$ is constructed by taking vertex-disjoint copies of $D_1$ and $D_2$ and adding all edges from $D_1$ to $D_2$. We show that $\mathrm{inv}({D_1 \rightarrow D_2}) > \mathrm{inv}(D_1)$, for any oriented graphs $D_1$ and $D_2$ such that $\mathrm{inv}(D_1) = \mathrm{inv}(D_2) \ge 1$. This resolves a question of Aubian, Havet, Hörsch, Klingelhoefer, Nisse, Rambaud and Vermande. Our proof proceeds via a natural connection between the graph inversion number and the subgraph complementation number.

Let $H_1$ and $H_2$ be graphs. A graph $G$ has the constrained Ramsey property for $(H_1,H_2)$ if every edge-colouring of $G$ contains either a monochromatic copy of $H_1$ or a rainbow copy of $H_2$. Our main result gives a 0-statement for the constrained Ramsey property in $G(n,p)$ whenever $H_1 = K_{1,k}$ for some $k \ge 3$ and $H_2$ is not a forest. Along with previous work of Kohayakawa, Konstadinidis and Mota, this resolves the constrained Ramsey property for all non-trivial cases with the exception of $H_1 = K_{1,2}$, which is equivalent to the anti-Ramsey property for $H_2$. For a fixed graph $H$, we say that $G$ has the anti-Ramsey property for $H$ if any proper edge-colouring of $G$ contains a rainbow copy of $H$. We show that the 0-statement for the anti-Ramsey problem in $G(n,p)$ can be reduced to a (necessary) colouring statement, and use this to find the threshold for the anti-Ramsey property for some particular families of graphs.

For any fixed $d\geq1$ and subset $X$ of $\mathbb{N}^d$, let $r_X(n)$ be the maximum cardinality of a subset $A$ of $\{1,\dots,n\}^d$ which does not contain a subset of the form $\vec{b} + rX$ for $r>0$ and $\vec{b} \in \mathbb{R}^d$. Such a set $A$ is said to be \emph{$X$-free}. The Multidimensional Szemerédi Theorem of Furstenberg and Katznelson states that $r_X(n)=o(n^d)$. We show that, for $|X|\geq 3$ and infinitely many $n\in\mathbb{N}$, the number of $X$-free subsets of $\{1,\dots,n\}^d$ is at most $2^{O(r_X(n))}$. The proof involves using a known multidimensional extension of Behrend's construction to obtain a supersaturation theorem for copies of $X$ in dense subsets of $[n]^d$ for infinitely many values of $n$ and then applying the powerful hypergraph container lemma. Our result generalizes work of Balogh, Liu, and Sharifzadeh on $k$-AP-free sets and Kim on corner-free sets.

One of the great pleasures of working with Imre Leader is to experience his infectious delight on encountering a compelling combinatorial problem. This collection of open problems in combinatorics has been put together by a subset of his former PhD students and students-of-students for the occasion of his 60th birthday. All of the contributors have been influenced (directly or indirectly) by Imre: his personality, enthusiasm and his approach to mathematics. The problems included cover many of the areas of combinatorial mathematics that Imre is most associated with: including extremal problems on graphs, set systems and permutations, and Ramsey theory. This is a personal selection of problems which we find intriguing and deserving of being better known. It is not intended to be systematic, or to consist of the most significant or difficult questions in any area. Rather, our main aim is to celebrate Imre and his mathematics and to hope that these problems will make him smile. We also hope this collection will be a useful resource for researchers in combinatorics and will stimulate some enjoyable collaborations and beautiful mathematics.

A graph $H$ is common if the limit as $n\to\infty$ of the minimum density of monochromatic labelled copies of $H$ in an edge colouring of $K_n$ with red and blue is attained by a sequence of quasirandom colourings. We apply an information-theoretic approach to show that certain graphs obtained from odd cycles and paths via gluing operations are common. In fact, for every pair $(H_1,H_2)$ of such graphs, there exists $p\in(0,1)$ such that an appropriate linear combination of red copies of $H_1$ and blue copies of $H_2$ is minimized by a quasirandom colouring in which $p\binom{n}{2}$ edges are red; such a pair $(H_1,H_2)$ is said to be $(p,1-p)$-common. Our approach exploits a strengthening of the common graph property for odd cycles that was recently proved using Schur convexity. We also exhibit a $(p,1-p)$-common pair $(H_1,H_2)$ such that $H_2$ is uncommon.

Given two non-empty graphs $H$ and $T$, write $H\succcurlyeq T$ to mean that $t(H,G)^{|E(T)|}\geq t(T,G)^{|E(H)|}$ for every graph $G$, where $t(\cdot,\cdot)$ is the homomorphism density function. We obtain various necessary and sufficient conditions for two trees $H$ and $T$ to satisfy $H\succcurlyeq T$ and determine all such pairs on at most 8 vertices. This extends results of Leontovich and Sidorenko from the 1980s and 90s. Our approach applies an information-theoretic technique to reduce the problem of showing that $H\succcurlyeq T$ for two forests $H$ and $T$ to solving a linear program of Kopparty and Rossman. We also characterize trees $H$ which satisfy $H\succcurlyeq S_k$ or $H\succcurlyeq P_4$, where $S_k$ is the $k$-vertex star and $P_4$ is the $4$-vertex path and resolve a problem of Csikvári and Lin.

A collection of families $(\mathcal{F}_{1}, \mathcal{F}_{2} , \cdots , \mathcal{F}_{k}) \in \mathcal{P}([n])^k$ is cross-Sperner if there is no pair $i \not= j$ for which some $F_i \in \mathcal{F}_i$ is comparable to some $F_j \in \mathcal{F}_j$. Two natural measures of the `size' of such a family are the sum $\sum_{i = 1}^k |\mathcal{F}_i|$ and the product $\prod_{i = 1}^k |\mathcal{F}_i|$. We prove new upper and lower bounds on both of these measures for general $n$ and $k \ge 2$ which improve considerably on the previous best bounds. In particular, we construct a rich family of counterexamples to a conjecture of Gerbner, Lemons, Palmer, Patkós, and Szécsi from 2011.

Given a graph $H$, we say that an edge-coloured graph $G$ is $H$-rainbow saturated if it does not contain a rainbow copy of $H$, but the addition of any non-edge in any colour creates a rainbow copy of $H$. The rainbow saturation number $\text{rsat}(n,H)$ is the minimum number of edges among all $H$-rainbow saturated edge-coloured graphs on $n$ vertices. We prove that for any non-empty graph $H$, the rainbow saturation number is linear in $n$, thus proving a conjecture of Girão, Lewis, and Popielarz. In addition, we also give an improved upper bound on the rainbow saturation number of the complete graph, disproving a second conjecture of Girão, Lewis, and Popielarz.

A graph $H$ is said to be common if the number of monochromatic labelled copies of $H$ in a red/blue edge colouring of a large complete graph is asymptotically minimized by a random colouring with an equal proportion of each colour. We extend this notion to an asymmetric setting. That is, we define a pair $(H_1,H_2)$ of graphs to be $(p,1-p)$-common if a particular linear combination of the density of $H_1$ in red and $H_2$ in blue is asymptotically minimized by a random colouring in which each edge is coloured red with probability $p$ and blue with probability $1-p$. We extend many of the results on common graphs to this asymmetric setting. In addition, we obtain several novel results for common pairs of graphs with no natural analogue in the symmetric setting. We also obtain new examples of common graphs in the classical sense and propose several open problems.