arXiv++ Combinatorics

The overlap gap property (OGP) is a statement about the geometry of near-optimal solutions. Exhibiting OGP implies failure of a class of local algorithms; and has been observed to coincide with conjectured algorithmic limits in problems with statistical computational gap. We consider the Stochastic Block Model (SBM), where the graph has a planted partition with $k$ equal-size blocks which form the `communities', and where, for parameters $p>q$, vertices within the same community connect with probability $p$, while vertices in different communities connect with probability $q$, independently across pairs of vertices. Modularity--based clustering algorithms have become ubiquitous in applications. This article studies theoretical limits of local algorithms based on the modularity score on the SBM. We establish that modularity exhibits OGP on the SBM. This rules out a class of local algorithms based on modularity for recovery in the SBM, and shows slow mixing time for a related Markov Chain. Theoretically this is one of the few instances where OGP has been established for a `planted' model, as most such analyses to date consider the `null' model. As part of our analysis, we extend a result by Bickel and Chen 2009, who established that with high probability, the modularity optimal partition of SBM is $o(n)$ local moves away from the planted partition, where $n$ is the graph size. We show that, with high probability, any partition with modularity score sufficiently near the optimal value is close to the planted partition.

We prove that whenever $d=d(n)\to\infty$ and $n-d\to\infty$ as $n\to\infty$, then with high probability for any non-trivial initial colouring, the colour refinement algorithm distinguishes all vertices of the random regular graph $\mathcal{G}_{n,d}$. This, in particular, implies that with high probability $\mathcal{G}_{n,d}$ admits a canonical labelling computable in time $O(\min\{n^ω,nd^2+nd\log n\})$, where $ω<2.372$ is the matrix multiplication exponent.

Graph burning is a discrete-time process on graphs where vertices are sequentially activated and burning vertices cause their neighbours to burn over time. In this work, we focus on a dynamic setting in which the graph grows over time, and at each step we burn vertices in the growing grid $G_n = [-f(n),f(n)]^2$. We investigate the set of achievable burning densities for functions of the form $f(n)=\lceil cn^α\rceil$, where $α\ge 1$ and $c>0$. We show that for $α=1$, the set of achievable densities is $[1/(2c^2),1]$, for $1<α<3/2$, every density in $[0,1]$ is achievable, and for $α=3/2$, the set of achievable densities is $[0,(1+\sqrt{6}c)^{-2}]$.

For a graph $G = (V,E)$ and a subset $R \subseteq V$, we say that $R$ is \textit{multiset resolving} for $G$ if for every pair of vertices $v,w$, the \textit{multisets} $\{d(v,r): r \in R\}$ and $\{d(w,r):r \in R\}$ are distinct, where $d(x,y)$ is the graph distance between vertices $x$ and $y$. The \textit{multiset metric dimension} of $G$ is the size of a smallest set $R \subseteq V$ that is multiset resolving (or $\infty$ if no such set exists). This graph parameter was introduced by Simanjuntak, Siagian, and Vitrík in 2017~\cite{simanjuntak2017multiset}, and has since been studied for a variety of graph families. We prove bounds which hold with high probability for the multiset metric dimension of the binomial random graph $G(n,p)$ in the regime $d = (n-1)p = Θ(n^{x})$ for fixed $x \in (0,1)$.

The Sudoku number $s(G)$ of graph $G$ with chromatic number $χ(G)$ is the smallest partial $χ(G)$-colouring of $G$ that determines a unique $χ(G)$-colouring of the entire graph. We show that the Sudoku number of the random $3$-regular graph $\mathcal{G}_{n,3}$ satisfies $s(\mathcal{G}_{n,3}) \leq (1+o(1))\frac{n}{3}$ asymptotically almost surely. We prove this by analyzing an algorithm which $3$-colours $\mathcal{G}_{n,3}$ in a way that produces many locally forced vertices, i.e., vertices which see two distinct colours among their neighbours. The intricacies of the algorithm present some challenges for the analysis, and to overcome these we use a non-standard application of Wormald's differential equations method that incorporates tools from finite Markov chains.

We study the stable matching problem under the random matching model where the preferences of the doctors and hospitals are sampled uniformly and independently at random. In a balanced market with $n$ doctors and $n$ hospitals, the doctor-proposal deferred-acceptance algorithm gives doctors an expected rank of order $\log n$ for their partners and hospitals an expected rank of order $\frac{n}{\log n}$ for their partners. This situation is reversed in an unbalanced market with $n+1$ doctors and $n$ hospitals, a phenomenon known as the short-side advantage. The current proofs of this fact are indirect, counter-intuitively being based upon analyzing the hospital-proposal deferred-acceptance algorithm. In this paper we provide a direct proof of the short-side advantage, explicitly analyzing the doctor-proposal deferred-acceptance algorithm. Our proof sheds light on how and why the phenomenon arises.

Hopping forcing is a single player combinatorial game in which the player is presented a graph on $n$ vertices, some of which are initially blue with the remaining vertices being white. In each round $t$, a blue vertex $v$ with all neighbours blue may hop and colour a white vertex blue in the second neighbourhood, provided that $v$ has not performed a hop in the previous $t-1$ rounds. The objective of the game is to eventually colour every vertex blue by repeatedly applying the hopping forcing rule. Subsequently, for a given graph $G$, the hopping forcing number is the minimum number of initial blue vertices that are required to achieve the objective. In this paper, we study the hopping forcing number for random $d$-regular graphs. Specifically, we aim to derive asymptotic upper and lower bounds for the hopping forcing number for various values of $d \geq 2$.

The semi-random hypergraph process is a natural generalisation of the semi-random graph process, which can be thought of as a one player game. For fixed $r < s$, starting with an empty hypergraph on $n$ vertices, in each round a set of $r$ vertices $U$ is presented to the player independently and uniformly at random. The player then selects a set of $s-r$ vertices $V$ and adds the hyperedge $U \cup V$ to the $s$-uniform hypergraph. For a fixed (monotone) increasing graph property, the player's objective is to force the graph to satisfy this property with high probability in as few rounds as possible. We focus on the case where the player's objective is to construct a subgraph isomorphic to an arbitrary, fixed hypergraph $H$. In the case $r=1$ the threshold for the number of rounds required was already known in terms of the degeneracy of $H$. In the case $2 \le r < s$, we give upper and lower bounds on this threshold for general $H$, and find further improved upper bounds for cliques in particular. We identify cases where the upper and lower bounds match. We also demonstrate that the lower bounds are not always tight by finding exact thresholds for various paths and cycles.

Let $\mathcal{T}$ be a Galton-Watson tree with a given offspring distribution $ξ$, where $ξ$ is a $Z_{\geq 0}$-valued random variable with $E[ξ] = 1$ and $0 < σ^{2}:=Var[ξ] < \infty$. For $n \geq 1$, let $T_{n}$ be the tree $\mathcal{T}$ conditioned to have $n$ vertices. In this paper we investigate $b(T_n)$, the burning number of $T_n$. Our main result shows that asymptotically almost surely $b(T_n)$ is of the order of $n^{1/3}$.

We study the 2-offer semirandom 3-uniform hypergraph model on $n$ vertices. At each step, we are presented with 2 uniformly random vertices. We choose any other vertex, thus creating a hyperedge of size 3. We show a strategy that constructs a perfect matching, and another that constructs a loose Hamilton cycle, both succeeding asymptotically almost surely within $Θ(n)$ steps. Both results extend to $s$-uniform hypergraphs. The challenges with hypergraphs, and our methods, are qualitatively different from what has been seen for semirandom graphs. Much of our analysis is done on an auxiliary graph that is a uniform $k$-out subgraph of a random bipartite graph, and this tool may be useful in other contexts.

The Artificial Benchmark for Community Detection (ABCD) graph is a random graph model with community structure and power-law distribution for both degrees and community sizes. The model generates graphs similar to the well-known LFR model but it is faster and can be investigated analytically. In this paper, we show that the ABCD model exhibits some interesting self-similar behaviour, namely, the degree distribution of ground-truth communities is asymptotically the same as the degree distribution of the whole graph (appropriately normalized based on their sizes). As a result, we can not only estimate the number of edges induced by each community but also the number of self-loops and multi-edges generated during the process. Understanding these quantities is important as (a) rewiring self-loops and multi-edges to keep the graph simple is an expensive part of the algorithm, and (b) every rewiring causes the underlying configuration models to deviate slightly from uniform simple graphs on their corresponding degree sequences.

We study information aggregation in networks when agents interact to learn a binary state of the world. Initially each agent privately observes an independent signal which is "correct" with probability $\frac{1}{2}+δ$ for some $δ> 0$. At each round, a node is selected uniformly at random to update their public opinion to match the majority of their neighbours (breaking ties in favour of their initial private signal). Our main result shows that for sparse and connected binomial random graphs $\mathcal G(n,p)$ the process stabilizes in a "correct" consensus in $\mathcal O(n\log^2 n/\log\log n)$ steps with high probability. In fact, when $\log n/n \ll p = o(1)$ the process terminates at time $\hat T = (1+o(1))n\log n$, where $\hat T$ is the first time when all nodes have been selected at least once. However, in dense binomial random graphs with $p=Ω(1)$, there is an information cascade where the process terminates in the "incorrect" consensus with probability bounded away from zero.

The semi-random graph process is a single player game in which the player is initially presented an empty graph on $n$ vertices. In each round, a vertex $u$ is presented to the player independently and uniformly at random. The player then adaptively selects a vertex $v$, and adds the edge $uv$ to the graph. For a fixed monotone graph property, the objective of the player is to force the graph to satisfy this property with high probability in as few rounds as possible. In this paper, we investigate the following three properties: containing a complete graph of order $k$, having the chromatic number at least $k$, and not having an independent set of size at least $k$.

In 1972 Tutte famously conjectured that every 4-edge-connected graph has a nowhere zero 3-flow; this is known to be equivalent to every 5-regular, 4-edge-connected graph having an edge orientation in which every in-degree is either 1 or 4. Jaeger conjectured a generalization of Tutte's conjecture, namely, that every $4p+1$-regular, $4p$-edge-connected graph has an edge orientation in which every in-degree is either $p$ or $3p+1$. Inspired by the work of Pralat and Wormald investigating $p=1$, for $p=2$ we show this holds asymptotically almost surely for random 9-regular graphs. It follows that the conjecture holds for almost all 9-regular, 8-edge-connected graphs. These results make use of the technical small subgraph conditioning method.

Given a graph $G=(V,E)$ on $n$ vertices and an assignment of colours to its edges, a set of edges $S \subseteq E$ is said to be rainbow if edges from $S$ have pairwise different colours assigned to them. In this paper, we investigate rainbow spanning trees in randomly coloured random $G_{k-out}$ graphs.

The semi-random graph process is a single player game in which the player is initially presented an empty graph on $n$ vertices. In each round, a vertex $u$ is presented to the player independently and uniformly at random. The player then adaptively selects a vertex $v$, and adds the edge $uv$ to the graph. For a fixed monotone graph property, the objective of the player is to force the graph to satisfy this property with high probability in as few rounds as possible. We focus on the problem of constructing a Hamiltonian cycle in as few rounds as possible. In particular, we present an adaptive strategy for the player which achieves it in $αn$ rounds, where $α< 2.01678$ is derived from the solution to some system of differential equations. We also show that the player cannot achieve the desired property in less than $βn$ rounds, where $β> 1.26575$. These results improve the previously best known bounds and, as a result, the gap between the upper and lower bounds is decreased from 1.39162 to 0.75102.

The Artificial Benchmark for Community Detection (ABCD) graph is a random graph model with community structure and power-law distribution for both degrees and community sizes. The model generates graphs with similar properties as the well-known LFR one, and its main parameter $ξ$ can be tuned to mimic its counterpart in the LFR model, the mixing parameter $μ$. In this paper, we investigate various theoretical asymptotic properties of the ABCD model. In particular, we analyze the modularity function, arguably, the most important graph property of networks in the context of community detection. Indeed, the modularity function is often used to measure the presence of community structure in networks. It is also used as a quality function in many community detection algorithms, including the widely used Louvain algorithm.

The semi-random graph process is a single player game in which the player is initially presented an empty graph on $n$ vertices. In each round, a vertex $u$ is presented to the player independently and uniformly at random. The player then adaptively selects a vertex $v$, and adds the edge $uv$ to the graph. For a fixed monotone graph property, the objective of the player is to force the graph to satisfy this property with high probability in as few rounds as possible. We focus on the problem of constructing a perfect matching in as few rounds as possible. In particular, we present an adaptive strategy for the player which achieves a perfect matching in $βn$ rounds, where the value of $β< 1.206$ is derived from a solution to some system of differential equations. This improves upon the previously best known upper bound of $(1+2/e+o(1)) \, n < 1.736 \, n$ rounds. We also improve the previously best lower bound of $(\ln 2 + o(1)) \, n > 0.693 \, n$ and show that the player cannot achieve the desired property in less than $αn$ rounds, where the value of $α> 0.932$ is derived from a solution to another system of differential equations. As a result, the gap between the upper and lower bounds is decreased roughly four times.

The semi-random graph process is a single-player game that begins with an empty graph on $n$ vertices. In each round, a vertex $u$ is presented to the player independently and uniformly at random. The player then adaptively selects a vertex $v$ and adds the edge $uv$ to the graph. For a fixed monotone graph property, the objective of the player is to force the graph to satisfy this property with high probability in as few rounds as possible. We focus on the problem of constructing a subgraph isomorphic to an arbitrary, fixed graph $G$. Let $ω= ω(n)$ be any function tending to infinity as $n \to \infty$. In (Omri Ben-Eliezer et al. "Semi-random graph process". In: Random Structures & Algorithms 56.3 (2020), pp. 648-675) it was proved that asymptotically almost surely one can construct $G$ in less than $n^{(d-1)/d} ω$ rounds where $d \ge 2$ is the degeneracy of $G$. It was also proved that the result is sharp for $G = K_{d+1}$, that is, asymptotically almost surely it takes at least $n^{(d-1)/d} / ω$ rounds to create $K_{d+1}$. Moreover, the authors conjectured that their general upper bound is sharp for all graphs $G$. We prove this conjecture here. We also consider a natural generalization of the process to $s$-uniform hypergraphs, the semi-random hypergraph process in which $r \ge 1$ vertices are presented at random, and the player then selects $s-r \ge 1$ vertices to form an edge of size~$s$. Our results for graphs easily generalize to hypergraphs when $r=1$; the threshold for constructing a fixed $s$-uniform hypergraph $G$ is, again, determined by the degeneracy of $G$. However, new challenges are mounting when $r \ge 2$; thresholds are not even known for complete hypergraphs. We provide bounds for this family and determine thresholds for some sparser hypergraphs.

The localization game is a two player combinatorial game played on a graph $G=(V,E)$. The cops choose a set of vertices $S_1 \subseteq V$ with $|S_1|=k$. The robber then chooses a vertex $v \in V$ whose location is hidden from the cops, but the cops learn the graph distance between the current position of the robber and the vertices in $S_1$. If this information is sufficient to locate the robber, the cops win immediately; otherwise the cops choose another set of vertices $S_2 \subseteq V$ with $|S_2|=k$, and the robber may move to a neighbouring vertex. The new distances are presented to the robber, and if the cops can deduce the new location of the robber based on all information they accumulated thus far, then they win; otherwise, a new round begins. If the robber has a strategy to avoid being captured, then she wins. The localization number is defined to be the smallest integer $k$ so that the cops win the game. In this paper we determine the localization number (up to poly-logarithmic factors) of the random geometric graph $G \in \mathcal G(n,r)$ slightly above the connectivity threshold.