arXiv++ Combinatorics

A central open question in extremal design theory is Nash-Williams' Conjecture from 1970 that every triangle-divisible graph on $n$ vertices (for $n$ large enough) with minimum degree at least $0.75 n$ has a triangle decomposition. In this paper, we prove this conjecture in full. In 2016, Barber, Kühn, Lo, and Osthus proved that if the fractional relaxation of Nash-Williams' Conjecture holds for minimum degree $cn$ for some constant $c\ge 0.75$, then Nash-Williams' Conjecture holds for any constant $c' > c$. The previously best-known bound on the fractional relaxation was due to Delcourt and Postle from 2021 with $c= \frac{7+\sqrt{21}}{14} \approx 0.82733$. This bound on the fractional relaxation has grown in importance over the years as it has been directly tied to bounds for a number of other problems in extremal design theory. This paper consists of three parts. In Part I, our first main result is a proof of the Fractional Nash-Williams' Conjecture: if $G$ is a graph on $n$ vertices with minimum degree at least $\frac{3n}{4}$, then $G$ has a fractional triangle decomposition. In Part II, our second main result is a Fractional Stability Theorem for Nash-Williams' Conjecture: if a graph $G$ on $n$ vertices has minimum degree close to $\frac{3n}{4}$ but no fractional $K_3$-decomposition, then $G$ is close (in edit distance) to the join of two $\frac{n}{4}$-regular graphs each on $\frac{n}{2}$ vertices. We use this to prove that if a triangle-divisible graph $G$ on $n$ vertices has minimum degree close to $\frac{3n}{4}$ but no $K_3$-decomposition, then $G$ is close (in edit distance) to the join of two $\frac{n}{4}$-regular graphs each on $\frac{n}{2}$ vertices. In Part III, our final main result is a proof of Nash-Williams' Conjecture in full.

In 2014, Keevash famously proved the existence of $(n,q,r)$-Steiner systems as part of settling the Existence Conjecture of Combinatorial Designs (dating from the mid-1800s). In 2020, Glock, Kühn, and Osthus conjectured a minimum degree generalization: specifically that minimum $(r-1)$-degree at least $(1-\frac{C}{q^{r-1}})n$ suffices to guarantee that every sufficiently large $K_q^r$-divisible $r$-uniform hypergraph on $n$ vertices admits a $K_q^r$-decomposition (where $C$ is a constant that is allowed to depend on $r$ but not $q$). The best-known progress on this conjecture is from the second proof of the Existence Conjecture by Glock, Kühn, Lo, and Osthus in 2016 who showed that $(1-\frac{C}{q^{2r}})n$ suffices. The fractional relaxation of the conjecture is crucial to improving the bound; for that, only the slightly better bound of $(1-\frac{C}{q^{2r-1}})n$ was known due to Barber, Kühn, Lo, Montgomery, and Osthus from 2017. Our main result is to prove that $(1-\frac{C}{q^{r-1+o(1)}})n$ suffices for the fractional relaxation. Combined with the work of R{ö}dl, Schacht, Siggers, and Tokushige from 2007, this also shows that such hypergraphs admit approximate $K_q^r$-decompositions.

A central open question in extremal design theory is Nash-Williams' Conjecture from 1970 that every $K_3$-divisible graph on $n$ vertices (for $n$ large enough) with minimum degree at least $3n/4$ has a $K_3$-decomposition. A folklore generalization of Nash-Williams' Conjecture extends this to all $q\ge 4$ by positing that every $K_q$-divisible graph on $n$ vertices (for $n$ large enough) with minimum degree at least $\left(1-\frac{1}{q+1}\right)n$ has a $K_q$-decomposition. We disprove this conjecture for all $q\ge 4$; namely, we show that for each $q\ge 4$, there exists $c > 1$ such that there exist infinitely many $K_q$-divisible graphs $G$ with minimum degree at least $\left(1-\frac{1}{c\cdot(q+1)}\right)v(G)$ and no $K_q$-decomposition; indeed we construct them admitting no fractional $K_q$-decomposition thus disproving the fractional relaxation of this conjecture. Our result also disproves the more general partite version. Indeed, we even show the folklore conjecture is off by a multiplicative factor by showing that for every $\varepsilon > 0$ and every large enough integer $q$, there exist infinitely many $K_q$-divisible graphs $G$ with minimum degree at least $\bigg(1-\frac{1}{\left(\frac{1+\sqrt{2}}{2}-\varepsilon\right)\cdot (q+1)}\bigg)v(G)$ with no (fractional) $K_q$-decomposition.

In 1847, Kirkman proved that there exists a Steiner triple system on $n$ vertices (equivalently a triangle decomposition of the edges of $K_n$) whenever $n$ satisfies the necessary divisibility conditions (namely $n\equiv 1,3 \mod 6$). In 1970, Nash-Williams conjectured that every graph $G$ on $n$ vertices with minimum degree at least $3n/4$ (for $n$ large enough and satisfying the necessary divisibility conditions) has a triangle decomposition. In 1973, Erdős conjectured that for each integer $g$, there exists a Steiner triple system on $n$ vertices with girth at least $g$ (provided that $n\equiv 1,3 \mod 6$ is large enough compared to the fixed $g$). In 2021, Glock, Kühn, and Osthus conjectured the common generalization of these two conjectures, dubbing it the ``Erdős meets Nash-Williams' Conjecture''. In this paper, we reduce the combined conjecture to the fractional relaxation of the Nash-Williams' Conjecture. Combined with the best known fractional bound of Delcourt and Postle, this proves the combined conjecture above when $G$ has minimum degree at least $0.82733n$. We note that our result generalizes the seminal work of Barber, Kühn, Lo, and Osthus on Nash-Williams' Conjecture and the resolution of Erdős' Conjecture by Kwan, Sah, Sawhney, and Simkin. Both previous proofs of those results used the method of iterative absorption. Our proof instead proceeds via the newly developed method of refined absorption (and hence provides new independent proofs of both results).

We codify a short self-contained proof of the existence of $K_q^r$-absorbers implicit in Keevash's original proof of the Existence Conjecture. Combining this with the work of the first and third authors in yields a proof of the Existence Conjecture for Combinatorial Designs that is not reliant on the construction of $K_q^r$-absorbers by Glock, Kühn, Lo, and Osthus.

A family of $r$ distinct sets $\{A_1,\ldots, A_r\}$ is an $r$-sunflower if for all $1 \leqslant i < j \leqslant r$ and $1 \leqslant i' < j' \leqslant r$, we have $A_i \cap A_j = A_{i'} \cap A_{j'}$. Erdős and Rado conjectured in 1960 that every family $\mathcal{H}$ of $\ell$-element sets of size at least $K(r)^\ell$ contains an $r$-sunflower, where $K(r)$ is some function that depends only on $r$. We prove that if $\mathcal{H}$ is a family of $\ell$-element sets of VC-dimension at most $d$ and $|\mathcal{H}| > (C r (\log d+\log^\ast \ell))^\ell$ for some absolute constant $C > 0$, then $\mathcal{H}$ contains an $r$-sunflower. This improves a recent result of Fox, Pach, and Suk. When $d=1$, we obtain a sharp bound, namely that $|\mathcal{H}| > (r-1)^\ell$ is sufficient. Along the way, we establish a strengthening of the Kahn-Kalai conjecture for set families of bounded VC-dimension, which is of independent interest.

The study of combinatorial designs has a rich history spanning nearly two centuries. In a recent breakthrough, the notorious Existence Conjecture for Combinatorial Designs dating back to the 1800s was proved in full by Keevash via the method of randomized algebraic constructions. Subsequently Glock, Kühn, Lo, and Osthus provided an alternate purely combinatorial proof of the Existence Conjecture via the method of iterative absorption. We introduce a novel method of refined absorption for designs; here as our first application of the method we provide a new alternate proof of the Existence Conjecture (assuming the existence of $K_q^r$-absorbers by Glock, Kühn, Lo, and Osthus).

We prove the High Girth Existence Conjecture - the common generalization of the Existence Conjecture for Combinatorial Designs originating from the 1800s and Erdős' Conjecture from 1973 on the Existence of High Girth Steiner Triple Systems.

We prove that if $p\ge n^{-\frac{1}{3}+β}$ for some $β> 0$, then asymptotically almost surely the binomial random graph $G(n,p)$ has a $K_3$-packing containing all but at most $n + O(1)$ edges. Similarly, we prove that if $d \ge n^{\frac{2}{3}+β}$ for some $β> 0$ and $d$ is even, then asymptotically almost surely the random $d$-regular graph $G_{n,d}$ has a triangle decomposition provided $3 \mid d \cdot n$. We also show that $G(n,p)$ admits a fractional $K_3$-decomposition for such a value of $p$. We prove analogous versions for a $K_q$-packing of $G(n,p)$ with $p\ge n^{-\frac{1}{q+0.5}+β}$ and leave of $(q-2)n+O(1)$ edges, for $K_q$-decompositions of $G_{n,d}$ with $(q-1)~|~d$ and $d\ge n^{1-\frac{1}{q+0.5}+β}$ provided $q\mid d\cdot n$, and for fractional $K_q$-decompositions.

We prove that if $p \geq n^{-(q-6)/2}$, then asymptotically almost surely the binomial random $q$-uniform hypergraph $G^{(q)}(n,p)$ contains an $(n,q,2)$-Steiner system, provided $n$ satisfies the necessary divisibility conditions.

We study $k$-star decompositions, that is, partitions of the edge set into disjoint stars with $k$ edges, in the uniformly random $d$-regular graph model $\mathcal{G}_{n,d}$. Using the small subgraph conditioning method, we prove an existence result for such decompositions for all $d,k$ such that $d/2 < k \leq d/2 + \max\{1,\frac{1}{6}\log d\}$. More generally, we give a sufficient existence condition that can be checked numerically for any given values of $d$ and $k$. Complementary negative results are obtained using the independence ratio of random regular graphs. Our results establish an existence threshold for $k$-star decompositions in $\mathcal{G}_{n,d}$ for all $d\leq 100$ and $k > d/2$. For smaller values of $k$, the connection between $k$-star decompositions and $β$-orientations allows us to apply results of Thomassen (2012) and Lovász, Thomassen, Wu and Zhang (2013). We prove that random $d$-regular graphs satisfy their assumptions with high probability, thus establishing a.a.s. existence of $k$-star decompositions (i) when $2k^2+k\leq d$, and (ii) when $k$ is odd and $k < d/2$.

A $(p,q)$-coloring of a graph $G$ is an edge-coloring of $G$ such that every $p$-clique receives at least $q$ colors. In 1975, Erdős and Shelah introduced the generalized Ramsey number $f(n,p,q)$ which is the minimum number of colors needed in a $(p,q)$-coloring of $K_n$. In 1997, Erdős and Gyárfás showed that $f(n,p,q)$ is at most a constant times $n^{\frac{p-2}{\binom{p}{2} - q + 1}}$. Very recently the first author, Dudek, and English improved this bound by a factor of $\log n^{\frac{-1}{\binom{p}{2} - q + 1}} $ for all $q \le \frac{p^2 - 26p + 55}{4}$, and they ask if this improvement could hold for a wider range of $q$. We answer this in the affirmative for the entire non-integral regime, that is, for all integers $p, q$ with $p-2$ not divisible by $\binom{p}{2} - q + 1$. Furthermore, we provide a simultaneous three-way generalization as follows: where $p$-clique is replaced by any fixed graph $F$ (with $|V(F)|-2$ not divisible by $|E(F)| - q + 1$); to list coloring; and to $k$-uniform hypergraphs. Our results are a new application of the Forbidden Submatching Method of the second and fourth authors.

In 1972 Tutte famously conjectured that every 4-edge-connected graph has a nowhere zero 3-flow; this is known to be equivalent to every 5-regular, 4-edge-connected graph having an edge orientation in which every in-degree is either 1 or 4. Jaeger conjectured a generalization of Tutte's conjecture, namely, that every $4p+1$-regular, $4p$-edge-connected graph has an edge orientation in which every in-degree is either $p$ or $3p+1$. Inspired by the work of Pralat and Wormald investigating $p=1$, for $p=2$ we show this holds asymptotically almost surely for random 9-regular graphs. It follows that the conjecture holds for almost all 9-regular, 8-edge-connected graphs. These results make use of the technical small subgraph conditioning method.

Let $f^{(r)}(n;s,k)$ be the maximum number of edges of an $r$-uniform hypergraph on~$n$ vertices not containing a subgraph with $k$~edges and at most $s$~vertices. In 1973, Brown, Erdős and Sós conjectured that the limit $$\lim_{n\to \infty} n^{-2} f^{(3)}(n;k+2,k)$$ exists for all positive integers $k\ge 2$. They proved this for $k=2$. In 2019, Glock proved this for $k=3$ and determined the limit. Quite recently, Glock, Joos, Kim, Kühn, Lichev and Pikhurko proved this for $k=4$ and determined the limit; we combine their work with a new reduction to fully resolve the conjecture by proving that indeed the limit exists for all positive integers $k\ge 2$.

In 1973, Erdős conjectured the existence of high girth $(n,3,2)$-Steiner systems. Recently, Glock, Kühn, Lo, and Osthus and independently Bohman and Warnke proved the approximate version of Erdős' conjecture. Just this year, Kwan, Sah, Sawhney, and Simkin proved Erdős' conjecture. As for Steiner systems with more general parameters, Glock, Kühn, Lo, and Osthus conjectured the existence of high girth $(n,q,r)$-Steiner systems. We prove the approximate version of their conjecture. This result follows from our general main results which concern finding perfect or almost perfect matchings in a hypergraph $G$ avoiding a given set of submatchings (which we view as a hypergraph $H$ where $V(H)=E(G)$). Our first main result is a common generalization of the classical theorems of Pippenger (for finding an almost perfect matching) and Ajtai, Komlós, Pintz, Spencer, and Szemerédi (for finding an independent set in girth five hypergraphs). More generally, we prove this for coloring and even list coloring, and also generalize this further to when $H$ is a hypergraph with small codegrees (for which high girth designs is a specific instance). Indeed, the coloring version of our result even yields an almost partition of $K_n^r$ into approximate high girth $(n,q,r)$-Steiner systems. Our main results also imply the existence of a perfect matching in a bipartite hypergraph where the parts have slightly unbalanced degrees. This has a number of applications; for example, it proves the existence of $Δ$ pairwise disjoint list colorings in the setting of Kahn's theorem; it also proves asymptotic versions of various rainbow matching results in the sparse setting (where the number of times a color appears could be much smaller than the number of colors) and even the existence of many pairwise disjoint rainbow matchings in such circumstances.

In 1943, Hadwiger conjectured that every graph with no $K_t$ minor is $(t-1)$-colorable for every $t\ge 1$. In the 1980s, Kostochka and Thomason independently proved that every graph with no $K_t$ minor has average degree $O(t\sqrt{\log t})$ and hence is $O(t\sqrt{\log t})$-colorable. Recently, Norin, Song and the second author showed that every graph with no $K_t$ minor is $O(t(\log t)^β)$-colorable for every $β> 1/4$, making the first improvement on the order of magnitude of the $O(t\sqrt{\log t})$ bound. The first main result of this paper is that every graph with no $K_t$ minor is $O(t\log\log t)$-colorable. This is a corollary of our main technical result that the chromatic number of a $K_t$-minor-free graph is bounded by $O(t(1+f(G,t)))$ where $f(G,t)$ is the maximum of $\frac{χ(H)}{a}$ over all $a\ge \frac{t}{\sqrt{\log t}}$ and $K_a$-minor-free subgraphs $H$ of $G$ that are small (i.e. $O(a\log^4 a)$ vertices). This has a number of interesting corollaries. First as mentioned, using the current best-known bounds on coloring small $K_t$-minor-free graphs, we show that $K_t$-minor-free graphs are $O(t\log\log t)$-colorable. Second, it shows that proving Linear Hadwiger's Conjecture (that $K_t$-minor-free graphs are $O(t)$-colorable) reduces to proving it for small graphs. Third, we prove that $K_t$-minor-free graphs with clique number at most $\sqrt{\log t}/ (\log \log t)^2$ are $O(t)$-colorable. This implies our final corollary that Linear Hadwiger's Conjecture holds for $K_r$-free graphs for every fixed $r$. One key to proving the main theorem is a new standalone result that every $K_t$-minor-free graph of average degree $d=Ω(t)$ has a subgraph on $O(t \log^3 t)$ vertices with average degree $Ω(d)$.

Given graphs $F$ and $H$, the generalized rainbow Turán number $\text{ex}(n,F,\text{rainbow-}H)$ is the maximum number of copies of $F$ in an $n$-vertex graph with a proper edge-coloring that contains no rainbow copy of $H$. B. Janzer determined the order of magnitude of $\text{ex}(n,C_s,\text{rainbow-}C_t)$ for all $s\geq 4$ and $t\geq 3$, and a recent result of O. Janzer implied that $\text{ex}(n,C_3,\text{rainbow-}C_{2k})=O(n^{1+1/k})$. We prove the corresponding upper bound for the remaining cases, showing that $\text{ex}(n,C_3,\text{rainbow-}C_{2k+1})=O(n^{1+1/k})$. This matches the known lower bound for $k$ even and is conjectured to be tight for $k$ odd.

The famous List Colouring Conjecture from the 1970s states that for every graph $G$ the chromatic index of $G$ is equal to its list chromatic index. In 1996 in a seminal paper, Kahn proved that the List Colouring Conjecture holds asymptotically. Our main result is a local generalization of Kahn's theorem. More precisely, we show that, for a graph $G$ with sufficiently large maximum degree $Δ$ and minimum degree $δ\geq \ln^{25} Δ$, the following holds: for every assignment of lists of colours to the edges of $G$, such that $|L(e)| \geq (1+o(1)) \cdot \max\left\{\rm{deg}(u),\rm{deg}(v)\right\}$ for each edge $e=uv$, there is an $L$-edge-colouring of $G$. Furthermore, Kahn showed that the List Colouring Conjecture holds asymptotically for linear, $k$-uniform hypergraphs, and recently Molloy generalized Kahn's original result to correspondence colouring as well as its hypergraph generalization. We prove local versions of all of these generalizations by showing a weighted version that simultaneously implies all of our results.

Partitioning the edges of a graph into edge disjoint triangles forms a triangle decomposition of the graph. A famous conjecture by Nash-Williams from 1970 asserts that any sufficiently large, triangle divisible graph on $n$ vertices with minimum degree at least $0.75 n$ admits a triangle decomposition. In the light of recent results, the fractional version of this problem is of central importance. A fractional triangle decomposition is an assignment of non-negative weights to each triangle in a graph such that the sum of the weights along each edge is precisely 1. We show that for any graph on $n$ vertices with minimum degree at least $0.827327 n$ admits a fractional triangle decomposition. Combined with results of Barber, Kühn, Lo, and Osthus, this implies that for every sufficiently large triangle divisible graph on $n$ vertices with minimum degree at least $0.82733 n$ admits a triangle decomposition.

Let $T$ be a tree on $n$ vertices and with maximum degree $Δ$. We show that for $k\geq Δ+1$ the Glauber dynamics for $k$-edge-colourings of $T$ mixes in polynomial time in $n$. The bound on the number of colours is best possible as the chain is not even ergodic for $k \leq Δ$. Our proof uses a recursive decomposition of the tree into subtrees; we bound the relaxation time of the original tree in terms of the relaxation time of its subtrees using block dynamics and chain comparison techniques. Of independent interest, we also introduce a monotonicity result for Glauber dynamics that simplifies our proof.